Scoreboard is lame. It's just going to prevent any drama and send in the bottom. The flops are usually the most entertaining. Protect the flops!
Back in Era 1 there would be little drama around voting. I think with the right cast it would be all drama in the current era
The women had plenty of drama but if the top 3 are voting in someone to against the bottom person there can be a ton of drama. How many times have we seen people like Laurel DQ--if someone good falls to the bottom there will get huge drama.
The drama around voting was literally what made the show great
From the very beginning I said what they should have done was
All-Stars-The Gauntlet, All-Stars-The Inferno, All Stars-The Duel, All Stars-The Ruins, All-Stars-Cutthroat, All-Stars-Battle of the Seasons, All-Stars-Free Agents, etc.
Hell, they could have even done an All Stars-Fresh Meat if they could have found enough RW/RR cast members that never did a season that wanted to. It was a missed opportunity
Hell, they could have even done an All Stars-Fresh Meat if they could have found enough RW/RR cast members that never did a season that wanted to. It was a missed opportunity
All Stars: Fresh Meat with old school vets paired up with RW/RR alum who never did a Challenge would CHANGE my life.
All Stars 6: Return to the Ruins (Champs vs Contenders
All Stars 7: Back to the Island (Island Format)
All Stars 8: Inferno (good guys vs bad as^ses
All Stars 9: Gauntlet (Ppl that were on previous all stars seasons vs first timers)
The Island could be fun with today's cast. The Island was awful because Johnny, Kenny created such a toxic environment. Leave Johnny, Dunbar, Kenny out.....cast strong women who are there to win
Has that ever worked? I mean, it was great to watch Tony go home and lose all his money but it hasn't actually worked with how it was intended
A scoreboard makes a lot of sense. The bottom person automatically goes in--the top 3 vote in their opponent from anyone else. It would actually force people to try which is one of the biggest issues with the show right now.
In my opinion, the funnest way for "personal bank accounts" (in a 28 person cast) to work would be assuming a $350k cash price (c'mon MTV bump this shit back up):
First challenge is individual and everyone gets from $1k (last place) to $7k (first place) depending on finish in $500 dollar increments - That's $52k for the men and $52k for the women: $104k total.
Team (Champs) vs Team (Contenders) from Episode 2 through Episode 8 - Winning the Daily nets your team $10k split evenly with everyone remaining - That's $174k total.
Winning an elimination nets you the losers prize pot.
You can buy your way out of elimination for $10k - if you keep getting sent in and think you're gonna lose - you can buy immunity for the round. $10k goes back into the final prize pot.
Individual challenge wins nets you $5k for the men and $5k for the women from Episode 9 to Episode 12. That's $216k total.
Episode 13 is start of the two part final, you make it here, you take home whatever you made so far.
Winning male and female of the final add $67k each (or more if someone bought elimination immunity) to their final bank account.
Benefits of this format:
Winning dailies and eliminations matters hugely. You can't just slide to the end or you're only guaranteed what your team won in dailies plus whatever you won on the first challenge.
Jealousy factor. Bigger purse = bigger target. But if you win enough times, you can buy immunity.
Plus this gets rid of "star talk" and moves it all to "the richest man/woman in the game" - which IMO is soooo much more interesting. Imagine you've won three eliminations and you're entering Episode 9 with $70k already in your account, just gotta get to the final to lock it up!
Hell, they could have even done an All Stars-Fresh Meat if they could have found enough RW/RR cast members that never did a season that wanted to. It was a missed opportunity
All Stars: Fresh Meat with old school vets paired up with RW/RR alum who never did a Challenge would CHANGE my life.
that would be the most epic version of all stars - I would love that
Has that ever worked? I mean, it was great to watch Tony go home and lose all his money but it hasn't actually worked with how it was intended
A scoreboard makes a lot of sense. The bottom person automatically goes in--the top 3 vote in their opponent from anyone else. It would actually force people to try which is one of the biggest issues with the show right now.
In my opinion, the funnest way for "personal bank accounts" (in a 28 person cast) to work would be assuming a $350k cash price (c'mon MTV bump this shit back up):
First challenge is individual and everyone gets from $1k (last place) to $7k (first place) depending on finish in $500 dollar increments - That's $52k for the men and $52k for the women: $104k total.
Team (Champs) vs Team (Contenders) from Episode 2 through Episode 8 - Winning the Daily nets your team $10k split evenly with everyone remaining - That's $174k total.
Winning an elimination nets you the losers prize pot.
You can buy your way out of elimination for $10k - if you keep getting sent in and think you're gonna lose - you can buy immunity for the round. $10k goes back into the final prize pot.
Individual challenge wins nets you $5k for the men and $5k for the women from Episode 9 to Episode 12. That's $216k total.
Episode 13 is start of the two part final, you make it here, you take home whatever you made so far.
Winning male and female of the final add $67k each (or more if someone bought elimination immunity) to their final bank account.
Benefits of this format:
Winning dailies and eliminations matters hugely. You can't just slide to the end or you're only guaranteed what your team won in dailies plus whatever you won on the first challenge.
Jealousy factor. Bigger purse = bigger target. But if you win enough times, you can buy immunity.
Plus this gets rid of "star talk" and moves it all to "the richest man/woman in the game" - which IMO is soooo much more interesting. Imagine you've won three eliminations and you're entering Episode 9 with $70k already in your account, just gotta get to the final to lock it up!
So...at that point they either go in every week or buy their way out of it until they're broke...
Honestly I don't hate it but they'd have to cast Jemmye or someone to explain it weekly.
So...at that point they either go in every week or buy their way out of it until they're broke...
Honestly I don't hate it but they'd have to cast Jemmye or someone to explain it weekly.
I think The Ruins' format is broken down fairly simply and it's easy to understand and those are also 42 minute episodes. With the first episode being a non-elimination, you can put a graphic scoreboard up as to where everyone is money-wise and then you can put their personal bank accounts in their confessionals and have a graphic update the leaderboards each week after the dailies and the male and female eliminations.
We need a season with money being a personal stake in the game again. Enough Joshes floating 2/3rds of the way through the season doing nothing. You wanna throw the same person over and over again? And they keep winning? Well, you just made them the richest person in the game after 3 eliminations and they can buy their way out of the next one!
So...at that point they either go in every week or buy their way out of it until they're broke...
Honestly I don't hate it but they'd have to cast Jemmye or someone to explain it weekly.
I think The Ruins' format is broken down fairly simply and it's easy to understand and those are also 42 minute episodes. With the first episode being a non-elimination, you can put a graphic scoreboard up as to where everyone is money-wise and then you can put their personal bank accounts in their confessionals and have a graphic update the leaderboards each week after the dailies and the male and female eliminations.
We need a season with money being a personal stake in the game again. Enough Joshes floating 2/3rds of the way through the season doing nothing. You wanna throw the same person over and over again? And they keep winning? Well, you just made them the richest person in the game after 3 eliminations and they can buy their way out of the next one!
The Ruins format didn't really work to be honest. See Cohutta--same thing would happen here or they'll spend money to avoid going back in which means they aren't exactly earning any.
The Ruins format didn't really work to be honest. See Cohutta--same thing would happen here or they'll spend money to avoid going back in which means they aren't exactly earning any.
If Cohutta would've managed to beat Darrell, he would've had 29k and would've been one daily challenge win from being able to sit out 1, 2, or 3 eliminations in my new format.
It's a gamble. The money in the pot makes it fun. If you've got an undersized guy like Cohutta who's won two or three eliminations and you see a headbanger against a Fessy/CT type, well you should've won the daily, so pay the $10k tax, put it in the final prize pot, and live to play another day.
I just feel like re-introducing personal bank accounts will make the game more cutthroat and exciting, you'll have people clammoring to get into elimination to take out a high earner to earn money, especially if the final is a nice win but not the only win.
The Ruins format didn't really work to be honest. See Cohutta--same thing would happen here or they'll spend money to avoid going back in which means they aren't exactly earning any.
If Cohutta would've managed to beat Darrell, he would've had 29k and would've been one daily challenge win from being able to sit out 1, 2, or 3 eliminations in my new format.
It's a gamble. The money in the pot makes it fun. If you've got an undersized guy like Cohutta who's won two or three eliminations and you see a headbanger against a Fessy/CT type, well you should've won the daily, so pay the $10k tax, put it in the final prize pot, and live to play another day.
I just feel like re-introducing personal bank accounts will make the game more cutthroat and exciting, you'll have people clammoring to get into elimination to take out a high earner to earn money, especially if the final is a nice win but not the only win.
People will still try to avoid elimination at all costs. The real money is still winning the final
The Ruins format didn't really work to be honest. See Cohutta--same thing would happen here or they'll spend money to avoid going back in which means they aren't exactly earning any.
If Cohutta would've managed to beat Darrell, he would've had 29k and would've been one daily challenge win from being able to sit out 1, 2, or 3 eliminations in my new format.
It's a gamble. The money in the pot makes it fun. If you've got an undersized guy like Cohutta who's won two or three eliminations and you see a headbanger against a Fessy/CT type, well you should've won the daily, so pay the $10k tax, put it in the final prize pot, and live to play another day.
I just feel like re-introducing personal bank accounts will make the game more cutthroat and exciting, you'll have people clammoring to get into elimination to take out a high earner to earn money, especially if the final is a nice win but not the only win.
People will still try to avoid elimination at all costs. The real money is still winning the final
I think you need to make some sort of mechanism to avoid going in over and over again. Like a Relic immunity for one round after 2 wins or my idea. The casuals on facebook are calling AS5 "one of the worst seasons ever" strictly because Steve and Adam keep getting voted in.
The Ruins format didn't really work to be honest. See Cohutta--same thing would happen here or they'll spend money to avoid going back in which means they aren't exactly earning any.
If Cohutta would've managed to beat Darrell, he would've had 29k and would've been one daily challenge win from being able to sit out 1, 2, or 3 eliminations in my new format.
It's a gamble. The money in the pot makes it fun. If you've got an undersized guy like Cohutta who's won two or three eliminations and you see a headbanger against a Fessy/CT type, well you should've won the daily, so pay the $10k tax, put it in the final prize pot, and live to play another day.
I just feel like re-introducing personal bank accounts will make the game more cutthroat and exciting, you'll have people clammoring to get into elimination to take out a high earner to earn money, especially if the final is a nice win but not the only win.
People will still try to avoid elimination at all costs. The real money is still winning the final
I think you need to make some sort of mechanism to avoid going in over and over again. Like a Relic immunity for one round after 2 wins or my idea. The casuals on facebook are calling AS5 "one of the worst seasons ever" strictly because Steve and Adam keep getting voted in.
I'm fine with the elimination winner being safe from the next elimination unless they finish last. That makes sense.
Steve and Adam don't even seem to care about going in so not sure why that's bothering anyone. It's also always been part it the show. People just don't usually keep winning.
seasons, sexes 1, sexes 2 say hello
gauntlet 1 and inferno 1 said hi too
Nobody wants the island format. Get out of here lol.
The women had plenty of drama but if the top 3 are voting in someone to against the bottom person there can be a ton of drama. How many times have we seen people like Laurel DQ--if someone good falls to the bottom there will get huge drama.
The drama around voting was literally what made the show great
From the very beginning I said what they should have done was
All-Stars-The Gauntlet, All-Stars-The Inferno, All Stars-The Duel, All Stars-The Ruins, All-Stars-Cutthroat, All-Stars-Battle of the Seasons, All-Stars-Free Agents, etc.
Hell, they could have even done an All Stars-Fresh Meat if they could have found enough RW/RR cast members that never did a season that wanted to. It was a missed opportunity
All Stars: Fresh Meat with old school vets paired up with RW/RR alum who never did a Challenge would CHANGE my life.
What life? All 19 short *** mf years of it? Tf.
The Island could be fun with today's cast. The Island was awful because Johnny, Kenny created such a toxic environment. Leave Johnny, Dunbar, Kenny out.....cast strong women who are there to win
No. It was stupid. The cast hated it. Next.
In my opinion, the funnest way for "personal bank accounts" (in a 28 person cast) to work would be assuming a $350k cash price (c'mon MTV bump this shit back up):
Benefits of this format:
Winning dailies and eliminations matters hugely. You can't just slide to the end or you're only guaranteed what your team won in dailies plus whatever you won on the first challenge.
Jealousy factor. Bigger purse = bigger target. But if you win enough times, you can buy immunity.
Plus this gets rid of "star talk" and moves it all to "the richest man/woman in the game" - which IMO is soooo much more interesting. Imagine you've won three eliminations and you're entering Episode 9 with $70k already in your account, just gotta get to the final to lock it up!
This. The island is legit the worst format in show history. I can't believe people are asking for it
it's not people. Sportsman is just a nostalgic lunatic.
lol agreed - island was by far the worse format ever. I wish that cast had a normal format.
that would be the most epic version of all stars - I would love that
I didn't propose The Island. Read again...oh wait, you can't read...
Awwww granny wants everyone around her to be old so that she can feel better about the fact that she's old herself. Lol. L. O. L.
What loser mod removed the cursing from my comment?
I did. Recognize your place and take a seat, lil maggot *** child.
So...at that point they either go in every week or buy their way out of it until they're broke...
Honestly I don't hate it but they'd have to cast Jemmye or someone to explain it weekly.
Well that's not very nice.
I think The Ruins' format is broken down fairly simply and it's easy to understand and those are also 42 minute episodes. With the first episode being a non-elimination, you can put a graphic scoreboard up as to where everyone is money-wise and then you can put their personal bank accounts in their confessionals and have a graphic update the leaderboards each week after the dailies and the male and female eliminations.
We need a season with money being a personal stake in the game again. Enough Joshes floating 2/3rds of the way through the season doing nothing. You wanna throw the same person over and over again? And they keep winning? Well, you just made them the richest person in the game after 3 eliminations and they can buy their way out of the next one!
The Ruins format didn't really work to be honest. See Cohutta--same thing would happen here or they'll spend money to avoid going back in which means they aren't exactly earning any.
If Cohutta would've managed to beat Darrell, he would've had 29k and would've been one daily challenge win from being able to sit out 1, 2, or 3 eliminations in my new format.
It's a gamble. The money in the pot makes it fun. If you've got an undersized guy like Cohutta who's won two or three eliminations and you see a headbanger against a Fessy/CT type, well you should've won the daily, so pay the $10k tax, put it in the final prize pot, and live to play another day.
I just feel like re-introducing personal bank accounts will make the game more cutthroat and exciting, you'll have people clammoring to get into elimination to take out a high earner to earn money, especially if the final is a nice win but not the only win.
Also bring back daily prizes - I want them to win motorcycles and trips to Greece again. Throw in an all you can eat Burger King feast too lol
People will still try to avoid elimination at all costs. The real money is still winning the final
I think you need to make some sort of mechanism to avoid going in over and over again. Like a Relic immunity for one round after 2 wins or my idea. The casuals on facebook are calling AS5 "one of the worst seasons ever" strictly because Steve and Adam keep getting voted in.
Not KVM thinking Melissa is a wasted spot LOL.
Melissa is there?
I'm fine with the elimination winner being safe from the next elimination unless they finish last. That makes sense.
Steve and Adam don't even seem to care about going in so not sure why that's bothering anyone. It's also always been part it the show. People just don't usually keep winning.
Pages