The Challenge: 41-WAY Too Early Pointless Speculation Thread

5701 posts / 0 new
Last post

 

 

daily prayer that if paramount drops mtv, peacock picks it up

Paramount aint doing good?

Very, very badly. 

https://www.avclub.com/paramount-reportedly-not-prioritizing-comedy-central-mtv

 i remember when the allstars trailers were posted online and had "millions of views" but had like 100 comments lol. The payola was real lmao

Oh trust if peacock picks up the challenge Skye and her lackeys are getting FIRED 

The challenge was such in a good place where they were doing the exes/rivals season back to back... the minute it turn to spies and explosions  it turned to shit.

They killed it after WOTW when they decided no more drama or fun moments, but extend the episodes and cast TERRIBLY with TERRIBLE formats and failure, after failure, after failure of seasons and spin-offs they still don't understand their mistakes. 

 

It was gross that ppl were thinking Amber was lying about her diagnosis tho

She's just VERY high-functoning. Plus doctors will disgnosis anyone these days and it's seen as "trendy". The different levels of the spectrum need different names though because it's really not right for Amber, Kyland, and others to be categorized along side those with serious struggles from the disability.

This is such a dumb take, there is a reason 'Aspergers' is no longer used, which was once a term used to call people high functioning. Whether or not there they are high functioning or not, it's still based on the same diagnostic criteria characterized in the dsm, and there are many ways people on various ends of the specturm can relate to eachother, even if those commonalities aren't picked up by neurotypicals. Being high functioning also presents unique struggles that they face as a RESULT of their autism not being taken seriously in schools, workplaces, etc.

It's not fair to have people like Amber and Kyland in the same category as people who are non-verbal and can never live independently. I stand by that.

So since love island 6 did amazing and it did because apparently most of the cast got millions of followers doing just one show while these challengers barely have a million after a million shows... would it be smart of them to throw the entire cast out completely and do a total new cast of 21-29 year olds only and build that class from here on out and add more young ppl season after season.

It's not fair to have people like Amber and Kyland in the same category as people who are non-verbal and can never live independently. I stand by that.

the 'category' is a clearly defined neurodevelopmental disorder, and creating more categories will cause further confusion and harm, and creating criteria for those new 'categories' would be difficult and redundant. the entire body of scientific literature disagrees with you

Oh trust if peacock picks up the challenge Skye and her lackeys are getting FIRED 

I will say it again, casting has not been the problem recently: casting only "sucked" for 39. All Stars 1-4, USA 1+2, and 40 all have great casts. The problem is the FORMATS of most of the shows and the inability to capture what makes exciting tv and reproduce it efficiently.

You give Season 40 a better format, it could've been legendary. Instead, we got the boring slog that we gor.

39 was not awful. The format was

So since love island 6 did amazing and it did because apparently most of the cast got millions of followers doing just one show while these challengers barely have a million after a million shows... would it be smart of them to throw the entire cast out completely and do a total new cast of 21-29 year olds only and build that class from here on out and add more young ppl season after season.

The "smart" thing would've been to develop a promising rookie class over the past 5 seasons instead of dumping 90% of all rookies, but I digress. It's too late now to add a bunch of 25 years olds to interact genuinely with a bunch of 38-45 year olds.

40 was garbage. No excuses. Bye! 

We need young blood ! A new TYB or something. Some people that'll come and be like "these old******* gotta leave." 

40 was garbage. No excuses. Bye! 

I havent watched since the first episode lol but really? I thought they had one of the best casts in awhile when the cast was revealed on vevmo since it had so many olschoolers back. Was season 40 really that bad?

Killa's rookie class for Era 5:

  • Kareem Fathalla
  • Rob Rausch
  • Bryton Constantine
  • Mark Jansen
  • Quintavius Burdette
  • Carrington Rodriguez
  • Zay Harayda
  • Tucker DesLauriers
  • Ty McDonald
  • Imani Ayan
  • Liv Walker
  • Kaylor Martin
  • Kirsten Elwin
  • Chelsie Baham
  • Tiffany Ervin
  • Makensy Manbeck
  •  

    It's not fair to have people like Amber and Kyland in the same category as people who are non-verbal and can never live independently. I stand by that.

    the 'category' is a clearly defined neurodevelopmental disorder, and creating more categories will cause further confusion and harm, and creating criteria for those new 'categories' would be difficult and redundant. the entire body of scientific literature disagrees with you

    We can respectfully agree to disagree. This is why people think Amber and Kyland are lying though. People won't take it seriously. It should be diagnosed with a different name because the way Amber would be "treated" or accommodated for it in school is very different than someone lower on the spectrum. "Scentific literature" is always changing so it's not reliable and is usually wrong. But anyway, I respect that you have a different opinion and I'm not judging/attacking your thoughts on the matter so no need to meltdown on me again. I enjoy hearing other perspectives.

    Hopefully the new young bucks are smarter. No shade to Cory, Nelson, and Hunter we've all seen how they played during the trilogy

    40 was garbage. No excuses. Bye! 

    41 will be too. Production isn't changing and they don't understand their flaws. Or they just don't care.

    Yall think the challenge gets past season 50?

    Makensy is a white Cayzzz who hates drama. Wawhoo having a brolic bring nothing but make it deep every season because of her size sounds sooo much fun. And I can't wait to see Kaylor cry for 6 episodes straight before she's finally eliminated. You love a spinless woman always in tears, huh?

    Hopefully the new young bucks are smarter. No shade to Cory, Nelson, and Hunter we've all seen how they played during the trilogy

    ehh hunter still won final reckoning title and being all the rigging that blatantly occured in our face on season 40 how do we really know they didn't rob nelson and cory of a win.

    Sportsman saying he wants entertaining TV but then throwing the word bully around when people target someone in a game for $1 million

    Step 1 in bringing good reality TV back is that fans need to understand that their behavior is what caused this genre shift in the first place... trying to cancel people and calling people bullies for getting into arguments is absolutely ridiculous 

    Makensy is a white Cayzzz who hates drama. Wawhoo having a brolic bring nothing but make it deep every season because of her size sounds sooo much fun. And I can't wait to see Kaylor cry for 6 episodes straight before she's finally eliminated. You love a spinless woman always in tears, huh?

    do you always b^itch and moan? It wouldn't kill you to crack a smile h^oe

    Yall think the challenge gets past season 50?

    Doubt it. They are headed back to their SLA ways and we saw the ratings drop under 200k without vets and with their international failed experiment so it'll just continue to drop.

     

    Makensy is a white Cayzzz who hates drama. Wawhoo having a brolic bring nothing but make it deep every season because of her size sounds sooo much fun. And I can't wait to see Kaylor cry for 6 episodes straight before she's finally eliminated. You love a spinless woman always in tears, huh?

    do you always b^itch and moan? It wouldn't kill you to crack a smile h^oe

    I wrote this with a smile. Where was I wrong? Don't try and deflect your trash opinions into a weak attack on me.

    Me, OldSchooler, and an unbiased mediator should overthrow Skye's casting team.

    OS you need to understand that your demands will never be met. You expect too much. 

    Yall think the challenge gets past season 50?

    No. It ends at 45 bet on it. The Hog and these re*ta rded producers are to blame.

    if they can squeeze in 2 flagships in a year then this shit can be officially done before 2030.. onto the next decade!

    So since love island 6 did amazing and it did because apparently most of the cast got millions of followers doing just one show while these challengers barely have a million after a million shows... would it be smart of them to throw the entire cast out completely and do a total new cast of 21-29 year olds only and build that class from here on out and add more young ppl season after season.

    they would never get rid of their regulars but Love island s6  is proof that reality tv isnt dead and can catch on quickly with the young by just clips on tiktok. But the way mtv reports any clips of their footage, that will never happen. (Also with how boring they edit it, there will be no scenes to go viral.) This franchise has such potential but as always, production squanders it. The people want drama!

     

    40 was garbage. No excuses. Bye! 

    I havent watched since the first episode lol but really? I thought they had one of the best casts in awhile when the cast was revealed on vevmo since it had so many olschoolers back. Was season 40 really that bad?

    40 isn't "bad". It's just boring. The format is lame so the season lacks drama and strategic gameplay. It's a 6/10.

    Pages