The Challenge: Generic Thread

69866 posts / 0 new
Last post

If you could pick the format for season 40 what would you pick?

either individual (for casting reasons) or a fresh meat/war of the worlds 1 type season with the rookies being from social media....

We need a speculation thread. It's been a while and that's the only part of the season I enjoy lol.

Yeah but then I'll be around a lot so win/lose 

 

We need a speculation thread. It's been a while and that's the only part of the season I enjoy lol.

Yeah but then I'll be around a lot so win/lose 

what do you think of my theme?

MTV vs CBS

 

We need a speculation thread. It's been a while and that's the only part of the season I enjoy lol.

Yeah but then I'll be around a lot so win/lose 

This place is dead. It could use some KVM chaos.

 

lowkey all u gotta do to win this show is be a white male. think about it, most white men who are regulars have won at some point. There are a few exceptions like Danny, Kyle, & Paulie but thats all I can think of, and I do think Paulie can eventually win if he does more seasons. People like Devin and Dunbar winning is strong evidence of this theory btw. I also can see Jay winning but idk cause hes spicy white so idk if production likes that.

Jay is Latino

Shane has done 8 seasons without even making a final, let alone winning. Cohutta also hasn't made a final in 5 (?) seasons

That's the point though, the black people worth a damn never really get a fair shot. Tacha, Priscilla, Kelz, Johnny, and Esther should all be back asap. Marlon should've been bought back, Eddie was robbed over a rumor,  they won't let Theo on the main show after two seasons, they blackballed Ashley Cain for whatever reason, Idris robbed, etc. It can go on and on. But we get others for 5 seasons of nothing. 

Lol @ Jay gingerbread *** being Latino

He's a white Latino but who gaf that boy is still white. Idc where from.

Also, Konquerer is right. I often think about what would've happened if Kam lost any of those eliminations on Vendettas. You really HAVE to be completely out there if you're a Black rookie to make a mark.

I'm sure Johnny M losing his elimination made him lose his callback.

He's a white Latino but who gaf that boy is still white. Idc where from.

Also, Konquerer is right. I often think about what would've happened if Kam lost any of those eliminations on Vendettas. You really HAVE to be completely out there if you're a Black rookie to make a mark.

I'm sure Johnny M losing his elimination made him lose his callback.

Brandon wouldn't have been on Rivals if he didn't win all those elims on Cutthroat tbh

 

 

We need a speculation thread. It's been a while and that's the only part of the season I enjoy lol.

Yeah but then I'll be around a lot so win/lose 

what do you think of my theme?

I'd like that for 41

For 40 I want all vets from different eras. Ideally individual with good payouts for everyone that makes the final. 

Cuthroat - Battle of the Eras

Or MTV vs CBS

Ooo I do like the battle of the eras idea

Players from all eras would be great!

Players from social media would be great!

Players from social media would be great!

But why on S40?   Shouldn't 40 be about the history of the show?

I mean, I wish 50 could be but then the "old" people now would be "way too old"

 

Players from social media would be great!

But why on S40?   Shouldn't 40 be about the history of the show?

I mean, I wish 50 could be but then the "old" people now would be "way too old"

I don't trust them to do it right...look at dirty 30 with Leroy, Jenna, Latoya etc...it's a nice concept but I just have no faith in them getting Coral, Alton, Beth and the like...maybe they'll surprise us though.

 

 

Players from social media would be great!

But why on S40?   Shouldn't 40 be about the history of the show?

I mean, I wish 50 could be but then the "old" people now would be "way too old"

I don't trust them to do it right...look at dirty 30 with Leroy, Jenna, Latoya etc...it's a nice concept but I just have no faith in them getting Coral, Alton, Beth and the like...maybe they'll surprise us though.

Do you have faith in them getting the right  people from social media?   

 

 

 

Players from social media would be great!

But why on S40?   Shouldn't 40 be about the history of the show?

I mean, I wish 50 could be but then the "old" people now would be "way too old"

I don't trust them to do it right...look at dirty 30 with Leroy, Jenna, Latoya etc...it's a nice concept but I just have no faith in them getting Coral, Alton, Beth and the like...maybe they'll surprise us though.

Do you have faith in them getting the right  people from social media?   

not necessarily, but I expect to know a few of them (mostly black models & personal trainers)

but yeah...let em do a big 40 like survivor tried to, and this theme can be on the back burner.

 

Players from social media would be great!

But why on S40?   Shouldn't 40 be about the history of the show?

I mean, I wish 50 could be but then the "old" people now would be "way too old"

They would still do the show even if they got to use walkers.

The day this show casts straight from social media is the day I'm done watching

The day this show casts straight from social media is the day I'm done watching

imo it's no worse than them casting from various international shows nobody in their target audience knows about or watched...

The day this show casts straight from social media is the day I'm done watching

Wasn't that Esther woman on  WOTW2 a social media person or was is just a small show?

Esther was from a YouTube talk show.

Her getting cast from that ate tho.

Updated Tier Ranking

If you could pick the format for season 40 what would you pick?

duel 

Top Tier: Inferno 2, The Ruins, Exes 2, Final Reckoning, and WOTW2

Good: The Gauntlet, The Inferno, The Duel, Rivals 1&2, BOTS2012, Free Agents, Invasion, and WOTW1

Average: Sexes 2, The Gauntlet 2&3, Fresh Meat 1&2, The Inferno 3, Rivals 3, Dirty 30, Vendettas, and BFANC

Not Good: The Duel 2, Cutthroat, Exes 1, Bloodlines, Total Madness, and SLA

Terrible: The Island, Double Agents, and Ride or Dies

Never seen: The first 6 seasons. 

AS2 Good, AS3 Average, AS1 Not Good

Updated Tier Ranking

watching Inferno 1 is a MUST. one of my faves. get on it!

 

Updated Tier Ranking

watching Inferno 1 is a MUST. one of my faves. get on it!

By far the greatest season. Probably my favorite season of any show ever outside of the Of Love franchise.

Both Infernos are in my top 3 favorite seasons! 

Pages