The Challenge: Generic Thread

69860 posts / 0 new
Last post

I love how we as a community all have Total Madness-Ride or Dies in our bottom half. We might not agree on much but at least we all have a little taste

CT, Darrell, Bananas, Leroy, JP, and Kim aren't needed at all

CT, Darrell, Bananas, Leroy, JP, and Kim aren't needed at all

You gotta have some casual favs. I'll take them all over the vacay losers. JP deserved a second chance. Kim is actually a gay guy who can compete which yall always ask for.

CT, Darrell, Bananas, Leroy, JP, and Kim aren't needed at all

No one is needed but they're realistic 

Another Battle of the seasons but call it Battle of the Shows.

They definitely need to do this theme. Who are we picking?

CT, Darrell, Bananas aren't needed at all

 its about what brings ratings, of course they all should be back

realistic cast next season 

johnny, jordan, horacio, jay, darrell, turbo, ct, kyle, josh, kelz, wes, yes, danny, nam, troy, cory, tony, steve 

tori, olivia, amber, michele, laurel, kailah, michaela, theresa, melissa, kiki, kaz, jodi, jonna, emily, sarah, angela, cara, alyssa 

We know 75% of who you all posted won't be on lol

 

Another Battle of the seasons but call it Battle of the Shows.

They definitely need to do this theme. Who are we picking?

Survivor - Jay, Turbo, Emanuel, Cody, Michele, Michaela, Natalie, Berna

Big Brother - Fessy, Hughie, Brett, Kyland, Angela, Esther, Da'Vonne, Minh-Ly

AYTO - Hunter, Devin, Asaf, Justin, Amanda, aMber, Tori, Shanley

Real World - Kailah, Zanatta, Averey, Nia, Tony, Jordan, Cohutta, Marlon

Which seasons do yall think had the best format?

Which seasons do yall think had the best format?

I liked the format of the exes seasons a lot. For a solo season I liked free agents. And for teams I like whichever ones don't have the stupid "team captain" stuff

Which seasons do yall think had the best format?

I like any season that is solid and continues the way it started. I prefer teams or pairs but hate it when they do a mid season twist.

Ideally I'd like another Cutthroat three team format. 

Which seasons do yall think had the best format?

I liked the format of the exes seasons a lot. For a solo season I liked free agents. And for teams I like whichever ones don't have the stupid "team captain" stuff

Free Agents would have been perfect if every non-winner was eligible to be voted in and for the draw.  Would have stopped people like Leroy from not trying.

JMO--Inferno 3 was the best team format (other team picks and that gender could save themselves), Exes was the best pair format (last goes in/winner picks the opponent) but best individual season is tough....the Duels would have been better if the winner just picked who went in then they picked someone), Free Agents see above so maybe Dirty X since they're was a lot of strategy involved.

Inferno 1

Battle of the Sexes 1

Final Reckoning (without a redemption house)

War of the Worlds

War of the Worlds 2 and The Ruins would have been a great format....if the teams were not so lopsided 

Inferno 1

Battle of the Sexes 1

Final Reckoning (without a redemption house)

War of the Worlds

War of the Worlds 2 and The Ruins would have been a great format....if the teams were not so lopsided 

You liked Inferno 1 more than Inferno 3?  I think the gender based life shields was a huge improvement but maybe I'm alone.  I3 was the worst of the 3 (mainly because the others might both be top 3 all time) but that change for 3 was good. 

I hated the gender based lifeshields of the Inferno 3 because it made it too easy for Susie to constantly win them. Her only competition each time was Paula.... that was kinda whack

I hated the gender based lifeshields of the Inferno 3 because it made it too easy for Susie to constantly win them. Her only competition each time was Paula.... that was kinda whack

So you just don't like Susie?   Evelyn won one--let's not pretend that team was stacked.

Last 10 seasons Ranked:

1. WOTW 2

2. WOTW1

3. Invasion

4. Dirty 30

5. Ride or Dies

6. Total Madness

7. Vendettas

8. Final Reckoning

9. Double Agents

10. Spies, Lies and Allies

 

I hated the gender based lifeshields of the Inferno 3 because it made it too easy for Susie to constantly win them. Her only competition each time was Paula.... that was kinda whack

So you just don't like Susie?   Evelyn won one--let's not pretend that team was stacked.

That and also because its just easier for people to throw the challenges for the nominated person to get the lifeshield. Less likelihood of a Kendal-Timmy crapshoot happening like what happened on the inferno 1

I hated the gender based lifeshields of the Inferno 3 because it made it too easy for Susie to constantly win them. Her only competition each time was Paula.... that was kinda whack

So you just don't like Susie?   Evelyn won one--let's not pretend that team was stacked.

That and also because its just easier for people to throw the challenges for the nominated person to get the lifeshield. Less likelihood of a Kendal-Timmy crapshoot happening like what happened on the inferno 1

Okay so it's really just anti-Susie which I respect you for acknowledging.  The only person that ever helped Susie win was Cara.  On The Inferno countless people threw it and it didn't work.   

 

I hated the gender based lifeshields of the Inferno 3 because it made it too easy for Susie to constantly win them. Her only competition each time was Paula.... that was kinda whack

So you just don't like Susie?   Evelyn won one--let's not pretend that team was stacked.

That and also because its just easier for people to throw the challenges for the nominated person to get the lifeshield. Less likelihood of a Kendal-Timmy crapshoot happening like what happened on the inferno 1

Okay so it's really just anti-Susie which I respect you for acknowledging.  The only person that ever helped Susie win was Cara.  On The Inferno countless people threw it and it didn't work.   

Yeah but it was lame because Susie's only competition was Paula since Cara was throwing everything, the chubby civilian was in and out, and Colie was one of the worst competitors ever. Each week was basically Susie vs. Paula (and I dislike both). Soooo lame 

I hated the gender based lifeshields of the Inferno 3 because it made it too easy for Susie to constantly win them. Her only competition each time was Paula.... that was kinda whack

So you just don't like Susie?   Evelyn won one--let's not pretend that team was stacked.

That and also because its just easier for people to throw the challenges for the nominated person to get the lifeshield. Less likelihood of a Kendal-Timmy crapshoot happening like what happened on the inferno 1

Okay so it's really just anti-Susie which I respect you for acknowledging.  The only person that ever helped Susie win was Cara.  On The Inferno countless people threw it and it didn't work.   

Yeah but it was lame because Susie's only competition was Paula since Cara was throwing everything, the chubby civilian was in and out, and Colie was one of the worst competitors ever. Each week was basically Susie vs. Paula (and I dislike both). Soooo lame 

Criticisms of the female cast on Inferno 3 is legit but the format itself was good.  Replace Colie with anyone who had a pulse and it's better.  

Which regulars do y'all think are the biggest problems and in what order?

  1. Devon-The absolute worst. He is such a poorman's Wes and his shtick is so tired.
  2. Josh-Taking him out and the spy theme automatically made this season 100x better. 
  3. Kasey-She puts zero effort into being entertaining, everything about her is stale and she will make it deep every time. She has zero made for tv qualities. The end game gets boring and you need big personalities. She's gotta go.
  4. Nelson-He's become a caricature of himself and it's no longer endearing and funny. It's annoying. The rehearsed Jessica Simpson dumb jokes aren't funny anymore, he's a grown man. They are embarrassing and pathetic. The "your boy" third person crap is unwatchable.
  5. Aneesa-It's the same storyline and she takes zero accountsbility. She used to at least be funny, she doesn't even bring good confessionals anymore. Twenty years of the same thing is enough.
  6. Nany-She hates doing these. She's miserable there and it translates. She's now just entitled without the mess, drama, hookups, and good looks. Take another break Nany and come back after Kasey cheats and your single.
  7. Tory-She's so cringe and tryhard. She only should return if she's going to face adversity and not have everything handed to her by production her friends.
  8. Fessy-He tries so hard to be a villain and can't pull it off. It's pathetic, his goofy BB persona was 100x more enjoyable. The only good reason to have him return is to watch him bash othee for sucking as he continously flops with his zero wins.

Kaycee is the biggest problem for me. I despise that waste of space, and if production got rid of her, Nany wouldn't come either so that's two birds with one stone.

Nelson is another problem for me. that man is beyond a character of himself at this point and it's embarrassing to watch. stop referring to the audience in your confessionals thinking you're hilarious. he has 2 brain cells and 0 authenticity.

Aneesa needs to take a long long long break. She's old, out of shape, and not funny at all. STAY HOME.

season 39 is going to be one of these white men winning (wes, jordan, ct, bananas or devin), or tori or kaycee for the women or someone from the vacation alliance. Were in the dark ages. 

A couple key production people need to leave. I won't say her name cause she knows she sucks and will threaten legal action, but without her it's salvageable. Bring back some key names from the Dirty 30 to WotW2, the good rookies from RoD and CBS Challenge and only Tory and Fessy from the vacation alliances and we can have a good season. They gotta bring drama back too though.

Ashley said on a podcast that she heard there's a new showrunner.. if true, I hope they shake things up

From worst to best

Kaycee

Josh

Devon

Tory

Nelson

Naneigh

Aneesa

Faysal

From worst to best

Kaycee

Aneesa

Naneigh

Nelson

Josh

Faysal

Devin

Tori

Josh is easily the worst of that group.  Looks like even production knows that. 

Pages