I recently read an article where someone ranked all the cast members from AS1,2,3 based on importance in the trilogy. Im curious what would be your guys top 5?
I recently read an article where someone ranked all the cast members from AS1,2,3 based on importance in the trilogy. Im curious what would be your guys top 5?
I agree with Jonna but definitely not the rest. I love Yes but he was a background character in both seasons. What did MJ bring except being Jonnas side piece which the casual fans couldnt even pick up on. Derrick K and Nehemiah just tried too hard for airtime so it rubbed me the wrong way because it gave major flagship vibes but I understand them on the list more than MJ.
Considering those on all 3 seasons, I think LT brought more. I definitely think Teck made both seasons he was there as well.
but I didnt read the article so I'm not sure how theyre determining importance, but my opinion is using the characteristics Wes listed in his tweet.
Jonna is clearly #1. Derrick-Nehemiah had the fake rivalry so I wouldn't have either. Yes is probably in the top 5 but he's not likeable.
Actually pick 5 is kind of difficult. Honestly, Veronica and Wes probably are top 5 despite only doing one of the seasons. And maybe Mark. I;d say Jonna-Veronica-Wes-Yes-Mark as 1-5. Jisela get an honorable mention even though I thought she was unbearable.
Honest opinion Jonna easily first then a combo of Yes, Nehemiah, Kendal, KellyAnnne Honorable mention could be any of Darrell, Teck, Mark, Brad, Ayanna
Mark, Nehemiah, & Derrick? What impact did they have besides making it inauthentic and unwatchable?
Mark had a huge impact and he's not unwatchable. Derrick and Nehemiah are but Mark, while slightly annoying, adds to the show and is why we have the show.
Seeing Mark on All Stars makes me wish he didn't "retire" after season 21 but he also is a john ally and he had too many as the shows went on anyway. I was always curious as to why he wasnt on more seasons before that anyway.
Mark Long. Without him, there would be no "All Stars.
Jonna Stephens (Mannion) Credit to her for winning back to back seasons after starting a family. She was a terrible competitor in previous Challenge seasons before All Stars.
KellyAnne Judd. Despite the entire "Tree House" being against her, she competed in the finals against younger competitors
Veronica Portillo. Credit to her for bringing true OG cred. Not one of my favorite cast members, however.
MJ. Garrett Kept his cool despite being continuously thrown in by Brad.
I love black excellence. Nehemiah starting the #KingsPalace, getting Derrick K booted early, then BEATING HIS *** in something HE should've kicked his *** in >>>>
I found that they all had their moments (pls give me more seasons!), but my ranking would be:
2>3>1
Hbu?
1>2>3
1 is the only one I have gone back & rewatched again. I am sort of wanting to rewatch 2 again as well but haven't yet. 3 I have no desire to ever watch again. Who would've thought that with the stacked cast 3 had that it would be the worst AS?
I recently read an article where someone ranked all the cast members from AS1,2,3 based on importance in the trilogy. Im curious what would be your guys top 5?
Please tell me they didnt rank Nehemiah at the top like Wes did lol.
Nehemiah was second
1. Yes
2. Kendal
3. Ayanna
4. Darrell
5. Jonna
For reference the original article had
5. Derrick K
4. MJ
3. Yes
2. Nehemiah
1. Jonna
Importance?
1: Jonna
2: Darrell
3: Nehemiah
4: Kendal
5: Yes
I agree with Jonna but definitely not the rest. I love Yes but he was a background character in both seasons. What did MJ bring except being Jonnas side piece which the casual fans couldnt even pick up on. Derrick K and Nehemiah just tried too hard for airtime so it rubbed me the wrong way because it gave major flagship vibes but I understand them on the list more than MJ.
Considering those on all 3 seasons, I think LT brought more. I definitely think Teck made both seasons he was there as well.
but I didnt read the article so I'm not sure how theyre determining importance, but my opinion is using the characteristics Wes listed in his tweet.
Jonna is clearly #1. Derrick-Nehemiah had the fake rivalry so I wouldn't have either. Yes is probably in the top 5 but he's not likeable.
Actually pick 5 is kind of difficult. Honestly, Veronica and Wes probably are top 5 despite only doing one of the seasons. And maybe Mark. I;d say Jonna-Veronica-Wes-Yes-Mark as 1-5. Jisela get an honorable mention even though I thought she was unbearable.
Honorable mention to Arissa, Veronica, Teck, Laterrian, Darrell, Jisela, and Casey!
For impact
5 Mark
4 Kendal
3 Nehemiah
2 Derrick
1 Jonna
for favorites
5 kellyanne
4 Veronica
3 Casey
2 Ayanna
1 Tina
Lavender you are out of the clique.
what did I do lol?
Mark, Nehemiah, & Derrick? What impact did they have besides making it inauthentic and unwatchable?
1. Jonna
2. Tina
3. Veronica
4. Kellyanne
5. Ayanna
omg I forgot kellyanne
Nm
Ok well maybe importance is a better word for what I meant @oldschooler
1. The godfather Mark long
2. Derrick
3. Nee-er-Mi-er
4. Mjdefender
5. Bald barbie
If we're naming Veronica in that might as well throw Kailahs name in there
Honest opinion Jonna easily first then a combo of Yes, Nehemiah, Kendal, KellyAnnne Honorable mention could be any of Darrell, Teck, Mark, Brad, Ayanna
Mark had a huge impact and he's not unwatchable. Derrick and Nehemiah are but Mark, while slightly annoying, adds to the show and is why we have the show.
Seeing Mark on All Stars makes me wish he didn't "retire" after season 21 but he also is a john ally and he had too many as the shows went on anyway. I was always curious as to why he wasnt on more seasons before that anyway.
I found that they all had their moments (pls give me more seasons!), but my ranking would be:
2>3>1
Hbu?
I found that they all had their moments (pls give me more seasons!), but my ranking would be:
2>3>1
Hbu?
Not putting Nehemiah in the top 5 is biased. Whether you like him or hate him, he was very important to each All Stars season.
Played an important role in making all 3 unwatchable.
Maybe I'm forgetting something--did he do anything on S3?
And if Nehemiah is in the top 5 then Derrick has to be as well and...yikes
I love black excellence. Nehemiah starting the #KingsPalace, getting Derrick K booted early, then BEATING HIS *** in something HE should've kicked his *** in >>>>
Legend Nehemiah.. you hate to see it!!
1>2>3
1 is the only one I have gone back & rewatched again. I am sort of wanting to rewatch 2 again as well but haven't yet. 3 I have no desire to ever watch again. Who would've thought that with the stacked cast 3 had that it would be the worst AS?
Pages