The Challenge: All Stars - Season 2 (Cast discussion)

2402 posts / 0 new
Last post

So Derek makes it onto the cast but Syrus didn't.  Syrus would have been WAY more interesting

 

I personally didnt want to add alternates until I was told filming had started and everyone tested negative or was approved....If I made another switch it's over that.

So you do the slow and steady approach instead of rushing hmmm sounds like a certain " spoiler " page can take notes 

Even though we kind of gave it away with the cast collage earlier lol

But we wanted to wait until we were told it started and that everyone was negative

Brandon being an alternate isn't too surprising. Syrus being one is surprising considering he had a decent amount of screen time last season. But I guess Beth and Alton not being on, hurt that.

So now that we have the full cast the favorites from greatest to least based on past performance:

Girls- Jodi, Kendal, Jonna, Sophia, Tina, Janelle, Ayanna, Katie, Jaz, Melinda, Leah, Casey

Guys- Darrel, Derrick, Brad, Tyler, Cohutta, LT, Nehemiah, MJ, Teck, Steve, Ryan, Derek

You really thought you could sneak Sophia so high 

So Derek makes it onto the cast but Syrus didn't.  Syrus would have been WAY more interesting

I think they want the gay guys to hookup lol

Cancun and The Quest has the most rep on this season right?  Steve, Katie, & Sophia / Derek, Jasmine, & Jonna.

Syrus sitting this one out isn't bad because next season we can have Beth back and Elka will join him for a mini Boston reunion <3 

So Derek makes it onto the cast but Syrus didn't.  Syrus would have been WAY more interesting

So he can get injured again? Nah we don't need him

So now that we have the full cast the favorites from greatest to least based on past performance:

Girls- Jodi, Kendal, Jonna, Sophia, Tina, Janelle, Ayanna, Katie, Jaz, Melinda, Leah, Casey

Guys- Darrel, Derrick, Brad, Tyler, Cohutta, LT, Nehemiah, MJ, Teck, Steve, Ryan, Derek

Jaz performance was better than Melinda's ?

 

So now that we have the full cast the favorites from greatest to least based on past performance:

Girls- Jodi, Kendal, Jonna, Sophia, Tina, Janelle, Ayanna, Katie, Jaz, Melinda, Leah, Casey

Guys- Darrel, Derrick, Brad, Tyler, Cohutta, LT, Nehemiah, MJ, Teck, Steve, Ryan, Derek

You really thought you could sneak Sophia so high 

Queen Sophia is batting 1000 on finals appearances! 1 for 1!

Tyler or Derek will be first boot 

 

So Derek makes it onto the cast but Syrus didn't.  Syrus would have been WAY more interesting

I think they want the gay guys to hookup lol

I mean they have 3 of them now right?

 

So Derek makes it onto the cast but Syrus didn't.  Syrus would have been WAY more interesting

I think they want the gay guys to hookup lol

LOL That's what I was just thinking.  I don't think Ryan and Derek have ever done a show together so I figured both would make it.

 

So now that we have the full cast the favorites from greatest to least based on past performance:

Girls- Jodi, Kendal, Jonna, Sophia, Tina, Janelle, Ayanna, Katie, Jaz, Melinda, Leah, Casey

Guys- Darrel, Derrick, Brad, Tyler, Cohutta, LT, Nehemiah, MJ, Teck, Steve, Ryan, Derek

Jaz performance was better than Melinda's ?

I should have done it by tiers.  Jaz and Melinda are interchangeable lol.

 

 

So Derek makes it onto the cast but Syrus didn't.  Syrus would have been WAY more interesting

I think they want the gay guys to hookup lol

I mean they have 3 of them now right?

Yeah but who is touching Tyler?

Honestly we didn't need Syrus flopping again and then having an excuse to pretend he doesn't suck. Still would have been better than many others. Brandon deserved a spot. Hopefully Tyler pulls a ****** from 37 and gets removed episode 1 and replaced by Brandon.

 

 

 

So Derek makes it onto the cast but Syrus didn't.  Syrus would have been WAY more interesting

I think they want the gay guys to hookup lol

I mean they have 3 of them now right?

Yeah but who is touching Tyler?

lol right I can't see anyone going against him 

Derek C is the only Latinx representation on either side, made sense to choose him over sy 

Didn't Ryan already reject Tyler on gauntlet 3

Pink - any fun facts during all of this you're willing to share on cast members that were either dropped or in the running but turned it down during this process??!!  I love hearing that stuff lol 

Pink - any fun facts during all of this you're willing to share on cast members that were either dropped or in the running but turned it down during this process??!!  I love hearing that stuff lol 

i would love to know why Svetlana pulled a G3 again

Pink - any fun facts during all of this you're willing to share on cast members that were either dropped or in the running but turned it down during this process??!!  I love hearing that stuff lol 

Same, even though sometimes it's heartbreaking like Lori lol.

Surprised Brandon and Syrus are alternates but happy with the choices.  Wonder who was an alternate before Svet dropped...

Didn't Ryan already reject Tyler on gauntlet 3

Maybe possible drama. If Derek and Ryan were to flirt, I'm sure Tyler would be very high school about it. But also, just bc they're gay doesn't mean they will flirt. Though I'm sure producers didn't think that through. Lol

 

Pink - any fun facts during all of this you're willing to share on cast members that were either dropped or in the running but turned it down during this process??!!  I love hearing that stuff lol 

Same, even though sometimes it's heartbreaking like Lori lol.

That one stings for sure lol   Yeah, usually it enraged me knowing 'what could have been' (I love that thread on this site by the way) but I also like to know if some of my favs were ever really in consideration (Elka, Anne, Veronica, etc) or if they were just names originally tossed around then moved on from. 

If there were to be a Real World vs Road Rules format, they would probably have to put Ryan on the Road Rules team and Casey on the Real World team in order for the teams to have a gender balance. 

Sophia <3

If there were to be a Real World vs Road Rules format, they would probably have to put Ryan on the Road Rules team and Casey on the Real World team in order for the teams to have a gender balance. 

There's still too many RW guys--MJ Brad, Cohutta, Teck, Derek, Tyler and Nehemiah.   Would need 6/6

Surprised Brandon and Syrus are alternates but happy with the choices.  Wonder who was an alternate before Svet dropped...

my guess would be maybe Melinda 

I am happy with the alternates chosen, also Ayanna is a fun surprise. Def a great update made the loss of Shauvon and Svetlanta easier 

Surprised Brandon and Syrus are alternates but happy with the choices.  Wonder who was an alternate before Svet dropped...

my guess would be maybe Melinda 

Maybe but I think we undervalue how much they wanted Melinda.  Of course, I'm shocked they wasted flying out Jemmyye to be an alternate.

Pages