The Challenge: All Stars (Season 2) - Early Speculation

4618 posts / 0 new
Last post

The whole best two girls thing was so funny to me because it was like "who put a battery in her back"?

Honestly, I smirk every time I watch that season and she says it.  She may have been their third best girl at that point (her or Johanna because Rachel was awful and Tori/Jillian were better) but such a ridiculous thing to say.

And production making awful choices does not make it good tv? You have no point. Cast Melinda and watch her add absolutely nothing lol. Chodi will at least get the strong mom edit. 

I'm not saying production doesn't make horrible decisions.  The point is valid though that Melinda was far more relevant that you remember.  There's a lot of girls I'd take over Melinda and Jodi but neither is a shocking casting decision and both fit the show.  I'm not going to get Coral, Mallory, Elka, Genesis, Irulan, Julie, Holly S and Susie like I want so I'm okay with Jodi and even Melinda because at least they're old schoolers (Melinda borderline) that we haven't seen in a decade or longer.   Well, I guess 9 years for Melinda but still

 

Lol CT was definitely not their golden boy back then so you trying to reiterate his name does nothing for me.

I also don't remember stats "per episode" of confessionals wayyyy back from Gauntlet 3 but if she did kudos to her? You have a link to back this up or did you keep it in a spreadsheet?

Also if true KTSE as an argument in the future when it's used against you.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1pCP1I6_BdeuyoF_QhxQA7hVXyTj8vJh0FuE826WUT-0/htmlview

People can use any facts against me in an argument. CT had a lot of drama on G3 (Coral and Diem) so I'm personally surprised that he didn't get more air time. 

no I meant for Gauntlet 3 confessional count lol. And you definitely didn't make that lmao.

Its not necessarily if it's factual, it's what said facts you deem more important than others

All this debating over Melinda?

Lol CT was definitely not their golden boy back then so you trying to reiterate his name does nothing for me.

I also don't remember stats "per episode" of confessionals wayyyy back from Gauntlet 3 but if she did kudos to her? You have a link to back this up or did you keep it in a spreadsheet?

Also if true KTSE as an argument in the future when it's used against you.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1pCP1I6_BdeuyoF_QhxQA7hVXyTj8vJh0FuE826WUT-0/htmlview

People can use any facts against me in an argument. CT had a lot of drama on G3 (Coral and Diem) so I'm personally surprised that he didn't get more air time. 

no I meant for Gauntlet 3 confessional count lol. And you definitely didn't make that lmao.

Its not necessarily if it's factual, it's what said facts you deem more important than others

What are you talking about?  On the link there's tabs for all seasons.  And you're right I didn't make that--as I said someone posted it here.  I'm not crazy enough to count confessionals.

What facts do you have?   I'm seeing you giving opinions

All this debating over Melinda?

I think it's actually about people being delusional that we're getting better women which we aren't

All this debating over Melinda?

all because me and one other person said we would like to see Melinda back on all stars LMAO

a confessional does not mean they impacted the episode or brought anything to it. Tf LMAOO

The Austin girls are some of the biggest bores to ever (dis)grace the challenge. Lacey is the only one I stan.

I can't stand Melinda's uncolored ***, Johanna the miserable ex-fiancé, nor Rachel M the chubby civilian 

a confessional does not mean they impacted the episode or brought anything to it. Tf LMAOO

You're right.  Confessionals are random--there's no logic behind who gets them

 

Lol CT was definitely not their golden boy back then so you trying to reiterate his name does nothing for me.

I also don't remember stats "per episode" of confessionals wayyyy back from Gauntlet 3 but if she did kudos to her? You have a link to back this up or did you keep it in a spreadsheet?

Also if true KTSE as an argument in the future when it's used against you.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1pCP1I6_BdeuyoF_QhxQA7hVXyTj8vJh0FuE826WUT-0/htmlview

People can use any facts against me in an argument. CT had a lot of drama on G3 (Coral and Diem) so I'm personally surprised that he didn't get more air time. 

no I meant for Gauntlet 3 confessional count lol. And you definitely didn't make that lmao.

Its not necessarily if it's factual, it's what said facts you deem more important than others

What are you talking about?  On the link there's tabs for all seasons.  And you're right I didn't make that--as I said someone posted it here.  I'm not crazy enough to count confessionals.

What facts do you have?   I'm seeing you giving opinions

oh I'll admit I barely looked. Facts that I find her boring? What? That's my opinion.

I meant when you argue with other people what facts you deem more important.

example, now I know going forward that confessional count is top priority for kvm going forward. Got it and noted

The Austin girls are some of the biggest bores to ever (dis)grace the challenge. Lacey is the only one I stan.

I can't stand Melinda's uncolored ***, Johanna the miserable ex-fiancé, nor Rachel M the chubby civilian 

thank you

 

The Austin girls are some of the biggest bores to ever (dis)grace the challenge. Lacey is the only one I stan.

I can't stand Melinda's uncolored ***, Johanna the miserable ex-fiancé, nor Rachel M the chubby civilian 

thank you

Woah, come on now. Johanna was always great, entertaining, and one of the prettiest to ever been on the show. Lets not disrespect her now.

oh I'll admit I barely looked. Facts that I find her boring? What? That's my opinion.

I meant when you argue with other people what facts you deem more important.

example, now I know going forward that confessional count is top priority for kvm going forward. Got it and noted

don't have a problem with you or anyone saying YOUR OPINION is that someone is boring.   We all care about different things.  For example, anyone that can compete isn't boring to me.  That's 100% fine but WE all need to be able to acknowledge when they add something even if you found that boring or didn't care about it.  Melinda added something--you just didn't care about it.  I didn't really care about it either but I can acknowledge it.   

Melinda shouldn't be a priority for casting but she wasn't invisible either.

Speaking of Austin, Lacey really should be on this. She was great on her one episode of Seasons, she deserved a return and it's a shame some of the clowns we got instead of her. 

 

 

The Austin girls are some of the biggest bores to ever (dis)grace the challenge. Lacey is the only one I stan.

I can't stand Melinda's uncolored ***, Johanna the miserable ex-fiancé, nor Rachel M the chubby civilian 

thank you

Woah, come on now. Johanna was always great, entertaining, and one of the prettiest to ever been on the show. Lets not disrespect her now.

"Well I did, and I could"

Hopefully we get an update today, so y'all can fight about something else 

Wait do you mean hooked melinda hooked up like a kiss? If so we gotta stop counting that lol

Speaking of Austin, Lacey really should be on this. She was great on her one episode of Seasons, she deserved a return and it's a shame some of the clowns we got instead of her. 

Lol at thinking lacy is a better challenge choice than jodi

 

Speaking of Austin, Lacey really should be on this. She was great on her one episode of Seasons, she deserved a return and it's a shame some of the clowns we got instead of her. 

Lol at thinking lacy is a better challenge choice than jodi

I don't care about the competitor aspect it has zero bearing on what makes a good season for. I watch actual sports with (mostly) fair and consistent rules for that. As a personality Chodi does nothing for me. I think Lacey's snark and wit is fun and hilarious. If this was America Ninja Warrior: Mom's Edition, I would love to see Chodi go for it.

wasn't danny and melinda like a iconic real world or reality tv couple back in the day? i think she deserves a spot sometime 

Wait do you mean hooked melinda hooked up like a kiss? If so we gotta stop counting that lol

No she had sex with Brandon and I'm not sure all the details with Ayiiia but apparently they were similar to Rachel/Jenn or Nicole/Melissa 

I think y'all think I have a way bigger issue with Chodi than I do being cast. My complaint when I saw her was "another boring name" not that she is like the worst and most awful choice. But SO FAR the list is boring names plus Tina, Jasmine, and Tyler. Which means the tryhards like Tyler and Jasmine will get lots of airtime while the others contribute not much. Chodi would be a good background character if the cast was solid. But there's 8 names, likely 16 more to be added with changes, so I might have different thoughts come departure day.

Lacy is just as boring..... she made like 2 little comments 

 

Wait do you mean hooked melinda hooked up like a kiss? If so we gotta stop counting that lol

No she had sex with Brandon and I'm not sure all the details with Ayiiia but apparently they were similar to Rachel/Jenn or Nicole/Melissa 

Wow Cutthroat really was lowkey the gayest season lol.

Melinda was cast because Austin was a popular RW season.  Melinda did NOTHING on the challenge.  That being said....there is nothing wrong with being a fan of hers.....but thinking she is interesting or dramatic is delusional.

Only Austin girl we need is Lacey!

The Austin girls are some of the biggest bores to ever (dis)grace the challenge. Lacey is the only one I stan.

I can't stand Melinda's uncolored ***, Johanna the miserable ex-fiancé, nor Rachel M the chubby civilian 

Melinda was cast because Austin was a popular RW season.  Melinda did NOTHING on the challenge.  That being said....there is nothing wrong with being a fan of hers.....but thinking she is interesting or dramatic is delusional.

Only Austin girl we need is Lacey!

Lacey got the chance on BOTS 2, what did she provide exactly besides 2 confessionals ? 

Speaking of Austin, Lacey really should be on this. She was great on her one episode of Seasons, she deserved a return and it's a shame some of the clowns we got instead of her. 

 

Melinda was cast because Austin was a popular RW season.  Melinda did NOTHING on the challenge.  That being said....there is nothing wrong with being a fan of hers.....but thinking she is interesting or dramatic is delusional.

Only Austin girl we need is Lacey!

Lacey got the chance on BOTS 2, what did she provide exactly besides 2 confessionals ? 

Nothing......us Lacey fans just love her!

TBH Johanna and Rachel both provided in their seasons.....I just dont want to see them lol

Soooo.   LACEY FOR THE WIN

Pages

Topic locked