The Challenge: Generic Thread

69811 posts / 0 new
Last post

I really thought Christina (AYTO) was gonna be a regular, she was a decent competitor and got into drama both seasons she did

Averey, Alicia, Christina

Alicia from AYTO is a good choice. I forgot about her cause I haven't been invested in the challenge as much. There was a good amount of hype around her after she was replaced on Dirty 30 but they haven't bothered with her since Vendettas. 

I really thought Christina (AYTO) was gonna be a regular, she was a decent competitor and got into drama both seasons she did

she was iconic in her 1 Bloodlines episode, but she was very boring and forgettable in Rivals 3 even though she made it really far. :/

Alicia from AYTO is a good choice. I forgot about her cause I haven't been invested in the challenge as much. There was a good amount of hype around her after she was replaced on Dirty 30 but they haven't bothered with her since Vendettas. 

I dont think she is made for the challenge. She is an amazing choice for dating show or something like real world/floribama/jersey shroe.

These 'Challenge react' videos would be a perfect way to introduce older challenge seasons or real world/road rules seasons to the current audience.

 

agreed. They showed Syrus recently in one. They could easily show more. 

I thought Danny was going to take the challenge by storm. Like literally be Wes but the all american pretty boy version

same. I thought Danny was going to be a huge force to reckoned with...boy was I wrong lol.   

I'll go old school for a sec:

They had their spot light but people I was surprised never got another call after their final season were Elka and Jodi. Both great competitors, usually brought some drama, an then not even an initial call after the Gauntlet and Duel for them. 

Can we please get Haley and Rhonda from Too Hot To Handle on The Challenge?

I thought Dustin (he was loved on RW), Nia (thought she was going to be a force + funny confessionals + drama), Theo (one of the only good casting choices on Bad Blood), Danny (they lowkey were trying to make him the face of MTV lolz). 

Trisha from Sydney, Cara & Keri from Chicago weren't on that list or Brynn from Vegas, Julie from New York. Cancel it. Katrina and Bryan would have been great additions though.

I thought dione waa going to be on as many seasons as possible but they cast ammo over him. Always a surprise to me

I thought dione waa going to be on as many seasons as possible but they cast ammo over him. Always a surprise to me

Ew. Why would they ever cast Dione? Kailah & Ceejay were the only 2 who deserved a spot from that season.

would've loved CeeJai and also Dylan. still bitter he was flown to Thailand as an alt for Invasion and never got a chance to be on the show. he easily could've been on Dirty 30 instead of Dario or Shane Raines (or either of the debuts, Ammo and Derrick H)

 

I thought dione waa going to be on as many seasons as possible but they cast ammo over him. Always a surprise to me

Ew. Why would they ever cast Dione? Kailah & Ceejay were the only 2 who deserved a spot from that season.

He was a frat boy adrenaline junkie type with no job tieing him down and who loved to party, He's exactly the type of person they'd cast imo. 

that list is actually fantastic. Katrina, Ashley L, Ashlee F, and Scott are all on my wish list. Katrina on Dirty 30 or Vendettas; Ashley L on Cutthroat; Ashlee F on Free Agents or Seasons 2 instead of McKenzie; Scott on The Ruins

That's a good *** list. I'm still salty that King Dylan Never got on the show. He could've easily had Anythony or Dario's spot. Wanted to see what Scott could do too.

Both Ashley's would've been good addition's IMO.

I thought dione waa going to be on as many seasons as possible but they cast ammo over him. Always a surprise to me

I swore he was going to be the new regular on the challenge because he was so wild but I'm so glad that didn't happen. He was annoying on RW and I felt like he thought he was a shoe-in for the challenge and used to shit on Kailah but now look lmao 

Ya'll are triggering me. So many RW potentials Sad

Queen was just too real for these **** & garbage *** MTV.

Not getting CeeJai is the biggest disappointment ever

Her and Kailah on Final Reckoning instead of Kayleigh? I would have been down.

Dione, Dylan, and  Ceejai should've gotten on the show.

Dione, Dylan, and  Ceejai should've gotten on the show.

Dione, Dylan, and  Ceejai should've gotten on the show.

Agreed, especially considering how bad Dirty 30 cast was aside from the bigger names. These 3 plus Kailah, Amanda, Ashley, Tony, Cory, Nelson, Hunter & Devin could have been a solid core post invasion, plus maybe a couple more skeletons & Bad Blood, there was just no need to have that tragic XXX rookie class. I'd have been happy to see anyone from skeletons, one of my favourite newer casts along with Portland. 

Ceejai should have been on that list. Would have loved to see Ari Fitz too.

Ya'll are triggering me. So many RW potentials

Hollywood and DC remain the most unrepresented seasons from that time. So much missed potential. Hollywood especially had the people to make the Challenge interesting. Plus I wanted to see more Ayiiia, and the other 4 of NOLA 2 all get a spot on the show before the culture had changed so much.

One-timers that should have definitely come back:

Briana,  Brittini, Ayiiia, Marlon, Averey (her Rivals 3 appearance barely counts), Cooke, Adam Royer (though it makes sense why they stopped calling him)

I legit forgot Marlon was only a one-timer.  It felt like we saw him a lot more than that.  He def needs to come back.  

I was always surprised Ryan Leslie never did this show even once.  I remember thinking he would be a lock.  

Pages