AYTO on The Challenge: Discussion Thread

1282 posts / 0 new
Last post

Still crazy to me that John from S4 was never in the mix for The Challenge. Seemed like the total package for the show

I used to not like any of the AYTO, but I'll take some of the interesting AYTO guys over Kyle, Floss, Josh, etc.

Still crazy to me that John from S4 was never in the mix for The Challenge. Seemed like the total package for the show

Seriously. Hot, athletic, insane... what more did they want?!

 

 

AYTO had really good people that could have become good additions to this show. Starting Season 1 with Shanley. However they first got cast as joke characters and that pretty much sealed the deal. Nelson, Amanda, Hunter, Kam, Devin, Tori were the only useful ones. And even they were edited as jokes or wannabee/overdramatic besides Tori or Kam. Production butt fumbeled this good idea. They are making the same mistake with BB or UK.

I'm probably the only one, but I think that Connor or Layton would have been great additions to The Challenge, in terms competition, hookups and drama (mainly Layton)

Layton would have been fine. Mike Cerasni or whatever, despite being boring, seemed like a decent competitor on Second Chances.

Prosper + John H. would have been Gods.

Mike Cerasani ❤️ 

What a waste Sad

Mike C was cute as ****. I felt like he and Alicia were a good team on that second chances thing. I wish he would've made it on the challenge. 

 

Dario was sexy as can be, boring or not.  Now we have... josh.

What does Josh have to do with it? Like our sole Latino man rep? shame...he's not cute at all.

Just making a point that we used to have sexy guys & now we have garbage.  Anytime is a good time to shit on josh.

 

 

Dario was sexy as can be, boring or not.  Now we have... josh.

What does Josh have to do with it? Like our sole Latino man rep? shame...he's not cute at all.

Just making a point that we used to have sexy guys & now we have garbage.  Anytime is a good time to **** on josh.

I like the way you think.

Lol y'all mad about Josh. How sad.

Lol y'all mad about Josh. How sad.

Y'all mad about us? How sadder.

Mike C, Andre and Tevin are cute and deserve challenge spots over boring *** Joss, Rogan and Kyle. 

Michael Halpern tho... the zaddy we missed out on

I remember us all being pressed over AYTO getting cast now we all wish it was still just them

Mike C, Andre and Tevin are cute and deserve challenge spots over boring *** Joss, Rogan and Kyle. 

I like them but they'd be boring af. 

 

Lol y'all mad about Josh. How sad.

Y'all mad about us? How sadder.

Who said I am mad?

 

 

Lol y'all mad about Josh. How sad.

Y'all mad about us? How sadder.

Who said I am mad?

Who said I'm mad? You said. So I'm saying you're mad. You see how it works?

Mike C, Andre and Tevin are cute and deserve challenge spots over boring *** Joss, Rogan and Kyle. 

100%

I will even take Nate these days, over most of the new guys.

 

 

Lol y'all mad about Josh. How sad.

Y'all mad about us? How sadder.

Who said I am mad?

Sad, mad, grasping at straws, useless opinions... all the same.

 

Mike C, Andre and Tevin are cute and deserve challenge spots over boring *** Joss, Rogan and Kyle. 

I like them but they'd be boring af. 

at least they're eye candy can't say the same for the latter three. ☕️

Y'all find Tevin cute? He look like he a second away from breaking in half 

Y'all find Tevin cute? He look like he a second away from breaking in half 

He's gorgeous as **** imo. I just hate his dumb *** haircut **** 

Prosper was a majorlly missed oppurtunity. he wasnt even on dirty 30 and his momentary presenance  suring the tori/derrick h segmanet was gold. I also think he would have been a capable competitor. 

Prosper was a majorlly missed oppurtunity. he wasnt even on dirty 30 and his momentary presenance  suring the tori/derrick h segmanet was gold. I also think he would have been a capable competitor. 

Gio/Prosper/John should've all been regulars by this point.

 

Prosper was a majorlly missed oppurtunity. he wasnt even on dirty 30 and his momentary presenance  suring the tori/derrick h segmanet was gold. I also think he would have been a capable competitor. 

Gio/Prosper/John should've all been regulars by this point.

 

Prosper was a majorlly missed oppurtunity. he wasnt even on dirty 30 and his momentary presenance  suring the tori/derrick h segmanet was gold. I also think he would have been a capable competitor. 

Gio/Prosper/John should've all been regulars by this point.

The Gio vs Jordan fight on Dirty 30 would've been insane

Queen Diandra robbed as well Sad

 

Prosper was a majorlly missed oppurtunity. he wasnt even on dirty 30 and his momentary presenance  suring the tori/derrick h segmanet was gold. I also think he would have been a capable competitor. 

Gio/Prosper/John should've all been regulars by this point.

Me realising...since when did so many people like AYTO on the Challenge. :o

I just think after this last part of the supposed trilogy, they can get a lot of MTV own people back that dont cost much and would absolutely do everything to get attention for upcoming season. Not saying UK people are bad (they brought it) but there impact are fading if they are keep getting cast with the same group of US guys.

I remember us all being pressed over AYTO getting cast now we all wish it was still just them

that was Pandora's box for this show. They opened up the casting and it was a downward spiral. I'd much prefer just another fresh meat with people who weren't already established on another show. That being said Tori and Kam were the only good things to come out of AYTO for the Challenge. Both are extremely cocky for never winning a challenge but they're good tv, I can give them that. 

 

 

Prosper was a majorlly missed oppurtunity. he wasnt even on dirty 30 and his momentary presenance  suring the tori/derrick h segmanet was gold. I also think he would have been a capable competitor. 

Gio/Prosper/John should've all been regulars by this point.

 

I remember us all being pressed over AYTO getting cast now we all wish it was still just them

that was Pandora's box for this show. They opened up the casting and it was a downward spiral. I'd much prefer just another fresh meat with people who weren't already established on another show. That being said Tori and Kam were the only good things to come out of AYTO for the Challenge. Both are extremely cocky for never winning a challenge but they're good tv, I can give them that. 

Then all this people need to send Jasmine from Real World Cancun some money because she was the reason they opened that pandora box. 

Little Jasmine had a huge impact on the direction this show went #Queen

Pages