The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

16639 posts / 0 new
Last post

 

huge battle of the seasons.

 

edit: there were some seasons that I knew 0 people lmaoo

Battle of the Sexes III 

Location: Knysna, South Africa

 

Cast

Women

Alicia Wright- AYTO?: Cabarete

Ashley Mitchell- RW: Ex-Plosion

Aneesa Ferreira- RW: Chicago

Averey Tressler- RW: Portland

CeeJai Jenkins- RW: Go Big or Go Home

Coral Smith: RW: Back 2 New York

Emily Schromm- RW: Bad Blood

Jennifer Geoghan- RW: Bad Blood

Katrina Stack- RW: Bad Blood

Kim Glass- Champs vs Stars

LaToya Jackson- RW: St. Thomas

​Louise Hazel- Champs vs Pros

Marie Roda- RW: St. Thomas

Nia Moore- RW: Portland

Nicole Zanatta- RW: Skeletons

Nurys Mateo- AYTO?: New Orleans

Tori Deal- AYTO?: Maui

Tyara Hooks- RW: Bad Blood

Alternates: 

Symphony Taylor- AYTO?: Miami

Ellie Puckett- AYTO?: San Juan

Jenna Thomason- RW: Go Big or Go Home 

 

 

Male

Adam Kuhn- AYTO?: Hauai 

Ammo Hall- RW: Go Big or Go Home 

Brandon Nelson- Fresh Meat II

Cohutta Grindstaff- RW: Sydney

Connor Smith- AYTO?: Kona

Cory Wharton- RW: Ex-Plosion 

Dre Sinclair- AYTO?: Hauai

Dylan Moore- RW: Go Big or Go Home 

Frank Sweeney- RW: San Diego '11

Jason Hill- RW: Skeletons

Jordan Wiseley- RW: Portland

Kareem Fathalla- AYTO?: New Orleans

Kassius Bass- RW: Bad Blood 

Malcolm Drummer- AYTO?: New Orleans

Marlon Williams- RW: Bad Blood 

Michael Halpern- AYTO?: Cabarete

Nelson Thomas- AYTO?: Kona

Tony Raines- RW: Sskeletons

Alternates:

Dustin Zito- RW: Las Vegas '11

Damontez Perry- AYTO?: Miami

Tyler Salgado- AYTO?: Miami

 

 

Close Calls: Saint Lamar and Isaiah from AYTO?: Miami were originally cast but both dropped out. Tyler S was also on final cast but got moved to an alternate. Shane, CT, Darrell, and Bananas all declined this season. Symphony was on the cast but she was moved to an alternate. Violetta and Jenny accepted the calls and did tesring but were not on the final cast because of Louise and Kim. Sylvia, Veronica, Svetlana, Hannah (AYTO?: Kona), and Jonna declined this season. Tyranny did testing, but did not make final cast. Emilee received an availability call, but nothing further.

 

In a perfect world where MTV/BMP has their shit together......

The Challenge: New Blood

Location: Santorini, Greece

Challenge VeteransCT Tamburello (RW Paris)Wes Bergmann (RW Austin)Johnny Devananzio (RW Key West)Cory Wharton (RW Ex-Plosion)Mark Long (RR USA 1)Darrell Taylor (RR Campus Crawl)Abram Boise (RR South Pacific)Nelson Thomas (AYTO 3)Hunter Barfield (AYTO 3)Beth Stolarczyk-Ciriello (RW Los Angeles)Coral Smith (RW Back to New York)Nia Moore (RW Portland)Ashley Mitchell (RW Ex-Plosion)Kailah Casillas (RW Go Big or Go Home)Veronica Portillo (RR Semester at Sea)Laurel Stucky (Fresh Meat 2)Theresa Gonzalez (Fresh Meat 2)Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat 2)

New BloodGreg Halstead (RW Hollywood)Brian Williams (RW Ex-Plosion)Dylan Moore (RW Go Big or Go Home)John Humphrey (AYTO 4)Clinton Moxam (AYTO 6)Keith Klebacher (AYTO 6)Jessie Godderz (Big Brother 10 & 11)Devin Sheppard (Big Brother 16)Caleb Reynolds (Big Brother 16, Survivor: Kaoh Rong & Game Changers)CeeJai Jenkins (RW Go Big or Go Home)Tyara Hooks (RW Seattle: Bad Blood)Katrina Stack (RW Seattle: Bad Blood)Melanie Velez (AYTO 3)Nurys Mateo (AYTO 6)Alexis Eddy (AYTO 6)Sierra Dawn Thomas (Survivor: Worlds Apart & Game Changers)Cydney Gillion (Survivor: Kaoh Rong)Michaela Bradshaw (Survivor: Millennials v.s. Gen X & Game Changers)

AlternatesAlton Williams (RW Las Vegas)Zach Nichols (RW San Diego 2011)Aneesa Ferreira (RW Chicago)Sarah Rice (RW Brooklyn)Scott Herman (RW Brooklyn)Nick Starcevic (Big Brother 8 )Diandra Delgado (AYTO 6)Morgan McLeod (Survivor: Cagayan)

Team Challenge with double eliminations (4 choices of the type of elimination like on BOTSeasons 2). After about 10 people go home, it switches to same-sex pairs; 4 pairs of each sex in the final. Comments/scenarios are more than welcome. Smile

So 4th place doesn’t get any money? 

So 4th place doesn’t get any money? 

Correct.

Morgan would have these girls bothered in all the right ways!

Ceej3 wrote:

So 4th place doesn’t get any money? 

Correct.

Fun, I like the cast. The format is simple and to the point. Them going to same sex pairs is a nice twist without being contrived and over the top. You out here doing all of production’s work for free and they still can’t get a clue. 

Graphik wrote:

Ceej3 wrote:So 4th place doesn't get any money? 

Correct.

Fun, I like the cast. The format is simple and to the point. Them going to same sex pairs is a nice twist without being contrived and over the top. You out here doing all of production's work for free and they still can't get a clue. 

So ******* simple lmaoooooo give or take they can't get some of these people, it's still VERY much possible to create an A1 cast.

This is 3 spinoffs I hope they'd do.

Number 1

All-Stars vs Rookies

All-Stars

Ashley Kelsey

Ashley Mitchell

Coral Smith

Nany Gonzalez

Theresa Gonzalez

Abram Boise

Darrell Taylor

Nelson Thomas

Vince Gliatta

Wes Bergmann

 

Rookies

Ashley Lindley

CeeJai Jenkins

Jenny Delich

Katrina Stack

Tyara Hooks

Dean Bart-Plange

Dione Mariani

Dylan Moore

Jason Hill

Robbie Padovano

 

All-Stars vs Social Media Stars

All-Stars

Same as ASvR

 

Social Media Stars

Tabatha Robinson

Kim Kardashian

​Mari Takahashi

Wiintrr Blanco

Jenn Selter

Boonk

Dc Youngfly

King Bach

Jake Paul

Javi Marroquin

 

All-Stars vs Reality Stars

All-Stars

Same as ASvR

 

Reality Stars

Seven Craft

Michaela Bradshaw 

Vanessa Rousso

Morgan McLeod

Jorden Estis

Mo Saiidi 

John Gaines 

James Clemment

Tank D

Jason Roy

 

 

The Challenge: Element

 

32 players are brought in a put into teams based on the 4 elements of nature. They will compete in a daily challenge before each elimination. The Winning Team is safe and each gets $5,000 in there personal bank accounts. The Losing Team will be heading straight into The Forge. The Winners are also responsible for voting in 1 guy and 1 girl from the losing team. And have to pick which of the 2 remaining teams is protected that week. Then the selected team gets to send 1 guy and 1 girl from they’re team to go into to  The Forge.  

 

There will also be 4 Element based eliminations (similar to BOTS) and that will be selected by the protected team each week

 

Wind Team

 

(Invisible, Unpredictable, Manipulative)

 

Wes (RW: Austin)

Bananas (RW: Key West)

Alton (RW: Las Vegas

Cory (RW: Ex-Plosion)

Aneesa (RW: Chicago)

Veronica (RR: Semester at Sea)

Tyara (RW: Bad Blood)

Katrina (RW: Bad Blood)

 

 

Water Team

 

(Flexible, Calm, Goes with the flow)

 

Clinton (AYTO: Season 6)

Cohutta (RW: Sydney)

Shane (RR: Campus Crawl)

CJ (RW: Cancun)

Madison (RW: Skeletons)

Melanie (AYTO: Season 3)

Averey (RW: Portland)

KellyAnne (RW: Sydney)

 

 

Earth Team

 

(Predictable, Grounded, Stubborn)

 

Marlon (RW: Portland)

Hunter (AYTO: Season 3)

Darrell (RR: Campus Crawl)

Derrick (RR: X-Treme)

CeeJai (RW: Go Big or Go Home)

Coral (RW: Back to New York)

Cooke (RW: Las Vegas 2)

Jamie (RW: Ex-Plosion)

 

Fire Team

 

(Intense, Short Tempered, Passionate)

 

Tony (RW: Skeletons)

Nelson (AYTO: Season 3)

Frank (RW: San Diego 2)

Giovanni (AYTO: Season 4)

Kailah (RW: Go Big or Go Home)

Nia (RW: Portland)

Amanda (AYTO: Season 3)

Theresa (TC: Fresh Meat 2)

 

^I like this one.

The Challenge: Element 32 players are brought in a put into teams based on the 4 elements of nature. They will compete in a daily challenge before each elimination. The Winning Team is safe and each gets $5,000 in there personal bank accounts. The Losing Team will be heading straight into The Forge. The Winners are also responsible for voting in 1 guy and 1 girl from the losing team. And have to pick which of the 2 remaining teams is protected that week. Then the selected team gets to send 1 guy and 1 girl from they’re team to go into to  The Forge.   There will also be 4 Element based eliminations (similar to BOTS) and that will be selected by the protected team each week Wind Team (Invisible, Unpredictable, Manipulative) Wes (RW: Austin)Bananas (RW: Key West)Alton (RW: Las VegasCory (RW: Ex-Plosion)Aneesa (RW: Chicago)Veronica (RR: Semester at Sea)Tyara (RW: Bad Blood)Katrina (RW: Bad Blood)  Water Team (Flexible, Calm, Goes with the flow) Clinton (AYTO: Season 6)Cohutta (RW: Sydney)Shane (RR: Campus Crawl)CJ (RW: Cancun)Madison (RW: Skeletons)Melanie (AYTO: Season 3)Averey (RW: Portland)KellyAnne (RW: Sydney)  Earth Team (Predictable, Grounded, Stubborn) Marlon (RW: Portland)Hunter (AYTO: Season 3)Darrell (RR: Campus Crawl)Derrick (RR: X-Treme)CeeJai (RW: Go Big or Go Home)Coral (RW: Back to New York)Cooke (RW: Las Vegas 2)Jamie (RW: Ex-Plosion) Fire Team (Intense, Short Tempered, Passionate) Tony (RW: Skeletons)Nelson (AYTO: Season 3)Frank (RW: San Diego 2)Giovanni (AYTO: Season 4)Kailah (RW: Go Big or Go Home)Nia (RW: Portland)Amanda (AYTO: Season 3)Theresa (TC: Fresh Meat 2) 

I would def watch that!! I might make my own simulation of it

The Challenge:

Four teams divided by what region of America the contestant is from: The Northeast, South, Midwest, or The West. Went by the location listed as thier hometown in their original season bio.  Added alternates bc with these teams people are bound to DQ left and right. Not sure what the format would look like.

North East:

 

Chris "CT" Tamburello (Boston, Massachsetts)

Frank Sweeney (Canasota, New York)

Giovanni Rivera (Bridgeport, Connecticut)

Devin Walker-Molaghan (Northampton, Massachusetts)

Marie Roda (Staten Island, New York)

Susie Meister (Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania)

Nurys Mateo (Portland, Maine)

Alicia Wright (Howell, New Jersey)

 

Alternates: Raphy Medrano (Salem, Massachusetts), Brianna Taylor (Philadelphia, Pennsylvania)

 

Midwest:

 

Wes Bergman (Leawood, Kansas)

Zach Nichols (Brighton, Michigan)

Theo Bradley (Kankakee, Illinois)

John Humphrey (Norfolk, Nebraska)

Shanley McIntee (Indianapolis, Indiana)

Sylvia Elsrode (Kansas City, Missouri)

Theresa Gonzalez (Milwaukee, Wisconsin)

Cara Zalveta (Bowling Green, Ohio)

 

Alternate: Isaac Stout (Cleveland, Ohio), Jenny Delich (Kansas City, Missouri)

 

South:

 

Hunter Bartfield (Perry, Florida)

Nelson Thomas (San Marcos, Texas)

Shane Landrum (Chapel Hill, North Carolina)

Jason Hill (Fayetteville, North Carolina)

Kailah Casillas (Fort Meyer, Florida)

Ashley Mitchell (Morgantown, West Virginia)

CeeJai Jenkins (Atlanta, Georgia)

Jemmye Carroll (Starkville, Mississippi)

 

Alternates: Dustin Zito (Louisiana), Kellyanne Judd (Georgetown, Texas)

 

West:

 

Johnny Bananas Devenanzio (Fullerton, California)

Ryan Leslie(Tempe, Arizona)

Nehemiah Clark (Rancho Cucamonga, California)

Cory Wharton (Santa Monica, California)

Averey Tressler (Tempe, Arizona)

Carolina Duarte (Sammamish, Washington)

Jonna Mannion (Tempe, Arizona)

Sarah Rice Patterson (San Francisco, California)

 

Alternates: Chet Cannon (Salt Lake City, Utah), Ayiiia Elizarraras (San Diego, California)

 

I did not know Ashley M was from Morgantown WV I live close to there. 

The Challenge: Invasion of The Pros (Invasion 2)

Challengers

Chris "CT" Tamburello (RW Paris)Johnny "Bananas" Devananzio (RW Key West)Zach Nichols (RW San Diego 2011)Cory Wharton (RW Ex-Plosion)Mark Long (RR USA 1)Darrell Taylor (RR Campus Crawl)Shane Landrum (RR Campus Crawl)Abram Boise (RR South Pacific)Nelson Thomas (AYTO 3)Keith Klebacher (AYTO 6)Devin Shepherd (Big Brother 16)Caleb Reynolds (Big Brother 16, Survivor: Kaoh Rong & Game Changers)Heather Cooke (RW Las Vegas 2011)Nia Moore (RW Portland)Ashley Mitchell (RW Ex-Plosion)Nicole Zanatta (RW Skeletons)Kailah Casillas (RW Go Big or Go Home)CeeJai Jenkins (RW Go Big or Go Home)Veronica Portillo (RR Semester at Sea)Rachel Robinson (RR Campus Crawl)Laurel Stucky (Fresh Meat 2)Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat 2)Cydney Gillion (Survivor: Kaoh Rong)Michaela Bradshaw (Survivor: Milliennials v.s. Gen-X & Game Changers)

Pro Athletes

Gus Kenworthy (Professional Skier)

Terrell Owens (Former NFL Wide Receiver)
Anthony Joshua (Professional Boxer)
Sonny Bill Williams (Rugby Player & Former Boxer)

Rich Froning (Crossfit Athlete)

Lolo Jones (Professional Hurdler & Bobsledder)Louise Hazel (Professional Heptathlete)Kim Glass (Indoor Volleyball Player)Hope Solo (Professional Soccer Goalkeeper)Elisabeth Akinwale (Crossfit Athlete)

Gus <3.

That cast is perfect, tho Gus is ****** in anything physical vs those huge pro guys

That cast is perfect, tho Gus is ****** in anything physical vs those huge pro guys

The way o was thinking about doing it was that it would start out like that (maybe the first 2 elims) but would turn into Challenger v.s. Pro eliminations eventually..... I don't know lmao any way to get some lethal matchups period.

Louise <3

Louise <3

If they ever do something like this there would be blood and I would love it.

Louise <3

Hope solo <3

Gus <3.

Also this. Loved Gus too

The Challenge: Battlegrounds

Format: Pairs (Slightly Individual)

Location- South Africa

Host- TJ (let's be real, he's not going anywhere

Prize: $500k each person for 1st place. Nothing for the remaining players

Cast: I went with a cast that I can def see happening and threw in like 3-4 people who are up in the air about being on. I also wanted to have a diverse cast and have it where you're not sure how somethings are going to turn up right away. Yes I know some of the players are people from the past 3-4 seasons but I'm trying to be somewhat realistic as well. 

Girls:

Kellyanne

Aneesa

Coral

Tori (AYTO 4)

Kailah

Veronica

Cara Maria

Nicole Z

Laurel

Britni (AYTO 3)

Nany

Avery

Tina (Road Rules)

Theresa

Jenny (RW: Ex)

Robin

 

Guys:

Bananas 

Mark (RR)

Hunter

Brad

Johnny R

Cory

Derrick K

Darrell

CT

Wes

Nelson

Shane (RR)

Abram

Thomas (RW: Ex)

Brian (RW: Ex)

Cohutta

 

Rules: I am using some stuff from other shows since the challenge loves stealing some themes from other shows.

 

The cast arrives in South Africa ready to compete. They are brought to the house first and not told about the format or rules. They are at the house for about 3-4 days to get them to have fun and get to know each other. Maybe even have them strategize and speculate the format based on the cast that is there. They are finally brought to a location for their first challenge. The players will all compete individual in some type of endurance challenge. There will be 2 heats, girls heat and guys heat. The first 3 guys and first 3 girls to lose in the endurance challenge are eliminated from the game while the remaining 13 guys and girls will continue to start the real challenge. Those 26 players are there given another day or so to relax and speculate. 

 

They are then brought to another area where there is a large machine with balls in it, similar to a lotto machine for picking the winning numbers. Each ball has a players name on it that's still in the game. There are also 13 totems with 2 small platforms in front of them, one for a guy and one for a girl. These 2 platforms in front of the totem will be a pair for the challenge. This  entire competition will be played in guy/girl pairs and anyone can be a pair. Tj will turn the machine on and it will release a name. The first person who is released has to then pick a totem to stand at. Now TJ will release another name. That person will then choose an open spot of their sex. Now once a guy and girl are on the platforms for the same totem they are considered a pair. However when it's someone's turn to pick, if a pair is on the platforms for the same totem but that person picking wants the person of the opposite sex as their partner they can bump the same sex person off that totem. If you get bumped then you must pick an open spot that's available and you are not allowed to bump someone else if you get bumped. This may sound confusing but here's an example

 

1- Bananas picks spot 1

2- Kailah picks spot 2

3- Coral picks spot 3

4- CT picks spot 4

5- Cara Maria picks spot 4 and pairs with CT

6- Laurel takes spot 4 to get CT, bumps Cara Maria, and now Cara Maria has to take an open spot or partner up with a player who doesn't have a partner yet. 

 

This will continue till all 13 totems are filled. Pretty much the people who have their names drawn near the end have the best chance at getting the partner they want and the player who gets the last pick will automatically get whoever they want since they can't get bumped. This was taken from the show Endurance season 3. The players will be told by TJ these are their partners and that he will see them soon. The cast goes back to the house to do the usual, such as drunk, talk about the game, hook up, and ***** about their partners. 

 

The cast will then be brought to a location the next day. TJ will explain that they one more pair still needs to be formed for this game. The first eliminated 6 players will be brought back out to compete in another challenge to get back into the game. The guy and girl who win challenge will be pair # 14 while the other 4 players are officially eliminated from the game. The teams will now compete in their first challenge. However this challenge will. It have an elimination but more of twist. This challenge will be to see how the teams compete together. The team that wins the challenge will be given a big choice to make. They will have to pick two teams to swap partners. Once this challenge is over and the two teams are swapped the games will officially begin. 

 

Now I know there are a lot of twists so far but we haven't even gotten in to how the rules work. The team will be told that they will compete as pairs in a challenge. The team that gets last place will automatically be going into elimination. The winning team is safe and gets to choose another team to join the last place team in elimination. The elimination will be NOT be 2v2. The elimination will be guy vs guy and girl vs girl. The two winners of elimination will either be the same team or a new team depending on who wins. This will continue until another twist happens.

 

Once 8 pairs remain another bomb is dropped on them. By this point some pairs are probably dominating while others may hate each other. Tj will bring them to their next challenge. Once again this challenge will not have an elimination. The pairs will be told to split up with guys on one side and girls on the other. The teams will be competing for safety from a big twist. The pair that wins the challenge will be safe from the "shake up." The shake up will dissolve the remaining 7 pairs and they will have to make new pairs in some way. Now some players would love to switch partners at this time while others don't. Not everyone will need to compete in this safety challenge then. TJ will give each player 2 rocks, one black and one white. If a player wants to compete for safety they will need to pick a white rock while black represents the choice to not compete. Separating the players before revealing this will cause drama and conflict because they will be making their own choose if they don't want their partner anymore. Some players might want to keep their partner but the other person may not feel the same. Tj will make them on the count of 3 reveal the rock of their choice. For a team to compete in this challenge both players must pick a white rock which shows that they both wish to keep their partner. If any other combination is shown such as one white and one black or both black then that team will not be competing for safety and will automatically be involved in the "shake up." Once the winning team is declared in the challenge they will be safe and the other 14 players will take place in the totem picking again. It will be the same process as the first part and once the 7 teams are made they will continue on with the game.

 

The final will have 3 teams remaining. There will be 6 parts of the final. 3 parts will have them partnering up with another player of the opposite sex while the other 3 are individual. The girl and guy with the best time wins the whole thing.

 

I really like this idea because it keeps the casting easy since here is no theme to make pairs or teams. It's just 32 players wanting to win. What do you all think?

RW vs AYTO

Location: Greece

RW:

Robbie (BB)

Dylan (GBOGH)

Tony (Skeletons)

Jason (Skeletons)

Thomas (EXplosion)

Marlon (Portland)

Jordan (Portland)

Wes (Austin)

 

Katrina (BB)

Kailah (GBOGH)

Ceejai (GBOGH)

Sylvia (Skeletons)

Madison (Skeletons)

Ashley M (EXplosion)

Averey (Portland)

Marie (St. Thomas)

 

AYTO

Anthony (S2)

Hunter (S3)

Nelson (S3)

Devin (S3)

John H (S4)

Mike C (S5)

Clinton (S6)

Keith (S6)

 

Shanley (S1)

Ellie (S2)

Melanie (S3)

Julia (S4)

Tori (S4)

Alicia (S5)

Alexis (S6)

Nurys (S6)

 

Hope solo <3

she would kill

RW vs AYTOLocation: GreeceRW:Robbie (BB)Dylan (GBOGH)Tony (Skeletons)Jason (Skeletons)Thomas (EXplosion)Marlon (Portland)Jordan (Portland)Wes (Austin) Katrina (BB)Kailah (GBOGH)Ceejai (GBOGH)Sylvia (Skeletons)Madison (Skeletons)Ashley M (EXplosion)Averey (Portland)Marie (St. Thomas) AYTOAnthony (S2)Hunter (S3)Nelson (S3)Devin (S3)John H (S4)Mike C (S5)Clinton (S6)Keith (S6) Shanley (S1)Ellie (S2)Melanie (S3)Julia (S4)Tori (S4)Alicia (S5)Alexis (S6)Nurys (S6) 

would love this

InternationalFan wrote:

Hope solo <3

she would kill

Wasn't she charged and arrested for domestic violence several times?

challenge13 wrote:

InternationalFan wrote:Hope solo <3

she would kill

Wasn't she charged and arrested for domestic violence several times?

Wow ive never followed her personal life so i had no idea.

Lucy Bronze instead <3

Pages