The Challenge: Generic Thread

69913 posts / 0 new
Last post

When will your faves?

jesus christ

When will your faves?

My Faves already been there and done that.

kvm1977 wrote:

 Women Top tier:  Holly Shand, Emily Bailey, Laurel Stucky, Evelyn Smith, Jodi Weatherton & Rachel Robinson.  Jodi & Rachel are borderline  

You forgot Legend Brooke Mitchell

No.

kvm1977 wrote:

 Women Top tier:  Holly Shand, Emily Bailey, Laurel Stucky, Evelyn Smith, Jodi Weatherton & Rachel Robinson.  Jodi & Rachel are borderline  

You forgot Legend Brooke Mitc****

I need more from her though I like what I've seen.  I don't think she's the athlete those girls are (especially Holly, Emily B, Laurel & Ev).  I mean, I don't even put Emily S on that level because she's strong as **** but not an elite athlete.  I have Ashley Mitc**** on the level of Jonna & Nany in part because of her size.  But she has room to be higher.  I don't think top tier.

Remember, I think there's about 20 tiers.  Emily S, Tori H, Cara M & Camila are second.  Coral, Veronica, Susie are third because of their strategic play.  It obviously isn't about people I like.  LOL

I feel like Holly Shand could still dominate the challenges 

I would have loved to have seen her on a duel.  She'd be the girl to call out Jodi or Evelyn just to see if she could beat them

Gucci Mane wrote:
When will your faves?

My Faves already been there and done that.

lmaooo

rwportland2 wrote:

I feel like Holly Shand could still dominate the challenges 

I would have loved to have seen her on a duel.  She'd be the girl to call out Jodi or Evelyn just to see if she could beat them

lol she would have  beat both of those manly women

I feel like Holly Shand could still dominate the challenges 

Holland for Champs vs Pros 2.

gamer73 wrote:

kvm1977 wrote: Women Top tier:  Holly Shand, Emily Bailey, Laurel Stucky, Evelyn Smith, Jodi Weatherton & Rachel Robinson.  Jodi & Rachel are borderline  

You forgot Legend Brooke Mitc****

I need more from her though I like what I've seen.  I don't think she's the athlete those girls are (especially Holly, Emily B, Laurel & Ev).  I mean, I don't even put Emily S on that level because she's strong as **** but not an elite athlete.  I have Ashley Mitc**** on the level of Jonna & Nany in part because of her size.  But she has room to be higher.  I don't think top tier.Remember, I think there's about 20 tiers.  Emily S, Tori H, Cara M & Camila are second.  Coral, Veronica, Susie are third because of their strategic play.  It obviously isn't about people I like.  LOL

thats a bit much.  Care to break them all down giving maybe 2-3 examples from each? I'm really curious about this.

If Ashley Mitchell was a lesbian or more masculine  then she would be ranked higher to fans #facts

kvm1977 wrote:

gamer73 wrote:

kvm1977 wrote: Women Top tier:  Holly Shand, Emily Bailey, Laurel Stucky, Evelyn Smith, Jodi Weatherton & Rachel Robinson.  Jodi & Rachel are borderline  

You forgot Legend Brooke Mitc****

I need more from her though I like what I've seen.  I don't think she's the athlete those girls are (especially Holly, Emily B, Laurel & Ev).  I mean, I don't even put Emily S on that level because she's strong as **** but not an elite athlete.  I have Ashley Mitc**** on the level of Jonna & Nany in part because of her size.  But she has room to be higher.  I don't think top tier.Remember, I think there's about 20 tiers.  Emily S, Tori H, Cara M & Camila are second.  Coral, Veronica, Susie are third because of their strategic play.  It obviously isn't about people I like.  LOL

thats a bit much.  Care to break them all down giving maybe 2-3 examples from each? I'm really curious about this.

Yeah, I can do that later this week.  There's a ton of tiers IMO because there's different levels of being bad and good.  Plus difrent things people excel at. Like as bad as Casey is she isn't as bad as Shauvon or Katelynn and while Devyn is a horrible competitor she's a very good strategist.  Ruthie's a great competitor but undersized and doesn't have a social game.  People like Mallory and Rachel B showed great potential but never got a chance to do multiple challenges so they're a bit of an unknown.  There's a ton 

20 tiers is a lot lol. What tier are Jonna/Nany/Ashley M on since you grouped them together? 

20 tiers is a lot lol. What tier are Jonna/Nany/Ashley M on since you grouped them together? 

Hopefully Tier 20. THEY ALL SUCK!

LOL Just kidding.

If Ashley Mitchell was a lesbian or more masculine  then she would be ranked higher to fans #facts

You're grasping for straws. I can't  tell if your obsession with placing Ashley in the "elite" group is a joke or not lol. I know you really like her, but sometimes I think you're blowing her up.

Tier 20: Casey, Shauvon, Brooke, Colie, Rachel Moyal, Sam, Emilee, Cameran (San Diego), Leah imo

Who is Rachel Moyal

Who is Rachel Moyal

The Army ***** from RW Austin.

Tier 20: Casey, Shauvon, Brooke, Colie, Rachel Moyal, Sam, Emilee, Cameran (San Diego), Leah imo

Colie, Shauvon and Leah as competitors <3 *******

hardbitten wrote:

Who is Rachel Moyal

The Army ***** from RW Austin.

I don't know her

I guess she's a local.

 Women Top tier:  Holly Shand, Emily Bailey, Laurel Stucky, Evelyn Smith, Jodi Weatherton & Rachel Robinson.  Jodi & Rachel are borderline  

LOVE me some Holly Shand but I don't think she's quite top tier. London Kat beat her in a wrestling match in Challenge 2000 who is at most a tier three. I would put Holly as a solid second tier and may add Ruthie, Ellen & Brittini to the top tier. If Emily Bailey is top tier then so are Ruthie & Ellen for always outperforming her on sexes and Britini  low key dominated alot of the Duel II. She even beat Rachel in that rope pulling mission.  

On second thought we'd really have to see more of Brittini to put her in top tier, like Kelley & evil Holly. Ellen should be top tier though for consistency alone.

Had Brittini done more she probably would've been near elite 

Had Brittini done more she probably would've been near elite 

And she was stick thin too. Landon helped but she definitely held her own. 

Ceej3 wrote:

Had Brittini done more she probably would've been near elite 

And she was stick thin too. Landon helped but she definitely held her own. 

Had Brittini done more she probably would've been near elite 

Same with Cooke.

Ceej3 wrote:

Had Brittini done more she probably would've been near elite 

Same with Cooke.

Cooke wouldn’t have been near elite, she would have been THE elite. Smile

KChallenge10 wrote:

Ceej3 wrote:Had Brittini done more she probably would've been near elite 

Same with Cooke.

Cooke wouldn’t have been near elite, she would have been THE elite. Smile

No.

It's actually not that hard to place some of the people who've only done 1-2 challenges in certain tiers because they've done more in 1 challenge (Cooke, Brittini, Svetlanta) than some have in 3 or 4 or 5. 

Here's how I would base it - I know some will disagree but this is based on overall performance skewing higher with athleticism.  Each group isn't in order,  that's too tough...and time consuming haha 

Tier 1 – Emily Bailey, Evelyn, Laurel, Emily Schrom, Rachel  - Top 5 for sure. 

Tier 2 – Cooke, Jodi,  Holly Shand, Cara Maria, Camila, Theresa, Sarah Rice , Paula, Jillian , Coral 

Tier 3  - Kelley , Ellen, Ruthie, Christena Pyle, Kendal, KellyAnne, Brittini,  Ashley Mitchell, Ruthie, Veronica , Jenna

Tier 4 – Kina, Aneesa, Beth, Tonya, Tina, Susie, Svetlana, Nany, Nia, Averey, Nicole Zanatta , Nicole Ramos, Tori, Jenn

Tier 5 –  Mandi, Cara Z, Irulan, Trishelle, Kim, Jonna, Marie, Lori,  Janelle,  Ashley K., Diem, Mallory , Robin, Elka, Julie

Tier 6 – Anne, Ayanna, Jasmine, Ibis, Sarah Greyson, Katie Doyle, Jessica, Amanda, Sylvia, Kailah, Jemmye, Christina LeBlanc

Tier 7 – Amaya, Arissa, Brittany, Casey, Colie, Devyn, Genesis, Jisela, Johanna, Sam McGinn, Simone, Melinda,

Tier 8 – Brooke, Cameran, Emilee, Katelynn, Latoya, Emilee, Leah, Montana, Naomi, Rachel M., Shauvon

 

It's actually not that hard to place some of the people who've only done 1-2 challenges in certain tiers because they've done more in 1 challenge (Cooke, Brittini, Svetlanta) than some have in 3 or 4 or 5. Here's how I would base it - I know some will disagree but this is based on overall performance skewing higher with athleticism.  Each group isn't in order,  that's too tough...and time consuming haha Tier 1 - Emily Bailey, Evelyn, Laurel, Emily Schrom, Rachel  - Top 5 for sure. Tier 2 - Cooke, Jodi,  Holly Shand, Cara Maria, Camila, Theresa, Sarah Rice , Paula, Jillian , Coral Tier 3  - Kelley , Ellen, Ruthie, Christena Pyle, Kendal, KellyAnne, Brittini,  Ashley Mitchell, Ruthie, Veronica , JennaTier 4 - Kina, Aneesa, Beth, Tonya, Tina, Susie, Svetlana, Nany, Nia, Averey, Nicole Zanatta , Nicole Ramos, Tori, JennTier 5 -  Mandi, Cara Z, Irulan, Trishelle, Kim, Jonna, Marie, Lori,  Janelle,  Ashley K., Diem, Mallory , Robin, Elka, JulieTier 6 - Anne, Ayanna, Jasmine, Ibis, Sarah Greyson, Katie Doyle, Jessica, Amanda, Sylvia, Kailah, Jemmye, Christina LeBlancTier 7 - Amaya, Arissa, Brittany, Casey, Colie, Devyn, Genesis, Jisela, Johanna, Sam McGinn, Simone, Melinda,Tier 8 - Brooke, Cameran, Emilee, Katelynn, Latoya, Emilee, Leah, Montana, Naomi, Rachel M., Shauvon 

Emilee deserves her own tier ****, biggest flop of the history of this show

challenge13 wrote:

It's actually not that hard to place some of the people who've only done 1-2 challenges in certain tiers because they've done more in 1 challenge (Cooke, Brittini, Svetlanta) than some have in 3 or 4 or 5. Here's how I would base it - I know some will disagree but this is based on overall performance skewing higher with athleticism.  Each group isn't in order,  that's too tough...and time consuming haha Tier 1 - Emily Bailey, Evelyn, Laurel, Emily Schrom, Rachel  - Top 5 for sure. Tier 2 - Cooke, Jodi,  Holly Shand, Cara Maria, Camila, Theresa, Sarah Rice , Paula, Jillian , Coral Tier 3  - Kelley , Ellen, Ruthie, Christena Pyle, Kendal, KellyAnne, Brittini,  Ashley Mitchell, Ruthie, Veronica , JennaTier 4 - Kina, Aneesa, Beth, Tonya, Tina, Susie, Svetlana, Nany, Nia, Averey, Nicole Zanatta , Nicole Ramos, Tori, JennTier 5 -  Mandi, Cara Z, Irulan, Trishelle, Kim, Jonna, Marie, Lori,  Janelle,  Ashley K., Diem, Mallory , Robin, Elka, JulieTier 6 - Anne, Ayanna, Jasmine, Ibis, Sarah Greyson, Katie Doyle, Jessica, Amanda, Sylvia, Kailah, Jemmye, Christina LeBlancTier 7 - Amaya, Arissa, Brittany, Casey, Colie, Devyn, Genesis, Jisela, Johanna, Sam McGinn, Simone, Melinda,Tier 8 - Brooke, Cameran, Emilee, Katelynn, Latoya, Emilee, Leah, Montana, Naomi, Rachel M., Shauvon 

Emilee deserves her own tier ****, biggest flop of the history of this show

my ***** Emilee still in Thailand waiting to get called into Invasion

It's actually not that hard to place some of the people who've only done 1-2 challenges in certain tiers because they've done more in 1 challenge (Cooke, Brittini, Svetlanta) than some have in 3 or 4 or 5. Here's how I would base it - I know some will disagree but this is based on overall performance skewing higher with athleticism.  Each group isn't in order,  that's too tough...and time consuming haha Tier 1 – Emily Bailey, Evelyn, Laurel, Emily Schrom, Rachel  - Top 5 for sure. Tier 2 – Cooke, Jodi,  Holly Shand, Cara Maria, Camila, Theresa, Sarah Rice , Paula, Jillian , Coral Tier 3  - Kelley , Ellen, Ruthie, Christena Pyle, Kendal, KellyAnne, Brittini,  Ashley Mitchell, Ruthie, Veronica , JennaTier 4 – Kina, Aneesa, Beth, Tonya, Tina, Susie, Svetlana, Nany, Nia, Averey, Nicole Zanatta , Nicole Ramos, Tori, JennTier 5 –  Mandi, Cara Z, Irulan, Trishelle, Kim, Jonna, Marie, Lori,  Janelle,  Ashley K., Diem, Mallory , Robin, Elka, JulieTier 6 – Anne, Ayanna, Jasmine, Ibis, Sarah Greyson, Katie Doyle, Jessica, Amanda, Sylvia, Kailah, Jemmye, Christina LeBlancTier 7 – Amaya, Arissa, Brittany, Casey, Colie, Devyn, Genesis, Jisela, Johanna, Sam McGinn, Simone, Melinda,Tier 8 – Brooke, Cameran, Emilee, Katelynn, Latoya, Emilee, Leah, Montana, Naomi, Rachel M., Shauvon 

  I agree with alot of that! I just don't get how so many people put Emily Bailey in a higher tier when Ruthie & Ellen consistently out performed her on Sexes. Emily never even won an ion and they had two apiece.

Pages