AYTO on The Challenge: Discussion Thread

OMG you can turn it and twist it whatever you want, it still doesn't erase the fact than Nate did better than Tony...Plus Nate beat Cory Wharton who proved being a decent competitor, not Devin or Chet, so my point still stands...

By your logic Jenna is a better competitor than Kellyanne & Anessa....

Lemonade wrote:

Rivals 3 was such an odd season, it's like they pretty much handed Bananas the W

They did. That was obvious the minute we found out who his partner was & looking at the rest of the cast.

I need v123 to be unbanned, STAT. He needs to drag a couple******* and put y'all to shame with his logic.

like he would literally have you all hiding your heads and begging to be deleted.

I need v123 to be unbanned, STAT. He needs to drag a couple******* and put y'all to shame with his logic.like he would literally have you all hiding your heads and begging to be deleted.

***!!!! He's banned???

By your logic Jenna is a better competitor than Kellyanne & Anessa....

Like I wrote, statistically Nate DID better than Tony. I've never said he WAS actually better... that's the difference ! I clearly stated my point on statistics...  

hardbitten wrote:

I need v123 to be unbanned, STAT. He needs to drag a couple******* and put y'all to shame with his logic.like he would literally have you all hiding your heads and begging to be deleted.

***!!!! He's banned???

yes ;/

but are you really surprised? lmaoo

I need v123 to be unbanned, STAT.

I need v123 to be unbanned, STAT. He needs to drag a couple******* and put y'all to shame with his logic.like he would literally have you all hiding your heads and begging to be deleted.

Nate does "arm days" like a simpleton 

I need v123 to be unbanned, STAT. He needs to drag a couple******* and put y'all to shame with his logic.like he would literally have you all hiding your heads and begging to be deleted.

omg when did he get banned **** I needed him to drag at least one ***** on a VG

Aside from not jumping out of the plane and agreeing to place third on rivals, Nate really didn't bother me that much lol

*prepares to get jumped* 

hardbitten wrote:

I need v123 to be unbanned, STAT. He needs to drag a couple******* and put y'all to shame with his logic.like he would literally have you all hiding your heads and begging to be deleted.

omg when did he get banned **** I needed him to drag at least one ***** on a VG

Lol yeah I liked v123 :( 

What did he do that was so bad? Honestly have no idea what a person would need to do to be actually banned from returning to a open forum site smh

Aside from not jumping out of the plane and agreeing to place third on rivals, Nate really didn't bother me that much lol*prepares to get jumped* 

jumped???? Looool

Honestly I don't mind AYTO on the challenges now. Mainly because I feel like they've done a better job in casting them and they're actually being of some use to the show. There are some missteps(Brianna should've never came back and Britini and Anthony are both useless) But overall they're getting better with AYTO I feel like. 

Honestly I don't mind AYTO on the challenges now. Mainly because I feel like they've done a better job in casting them and they're actually being of some use to the show. There are some missteps(Brianna should've never came back and Britini and Anthony are both useless) But overall they're getting better with AYTO I feel like. 

When's John gonna get a call though because he's the only guy who hasnt debut yet who is worth a ****

Debut Album wrote:

Honestly I don't mind AYTO on the challenges now. Mainly because I feel like they've done a better job in casting them and they're actually being of some use to the show. There are some missteps(Brianna should've never came back and Britini and Anthony are both useless) But overall they're getting better with AYTO I feel like. 

When's John gonna get a call though because he's the only guy who hasnt debut yet who is worth a ****

What about Layton? He seems decent...Although he's from AYTO 2.

I'm ******* gone reading the first page of this. How things change... SHOOK.

I don't like AYTO on this show. They're unecessary and don't even do shit and don't have anything to do with this franchise at all.

Here's who I would like to see on Challenges from AYTO, keeping in mind that I have not seen Second Chances yet

Want to see

Chris Scali (1) / Devin Walker-Molaghan (3) / Asaf Goren (4) / John Humphrey (4) / Michael Halpern (5) (don't hate me **** I love him)

Jacy Rodriguez (1) / Shanley McIntee (1) / Ellie Puckett (2) / Jessica Andreatta (2) / Amanda Garcia (3) / Tori Deal (4) / Alicia Wright (5) / Gianna Hammer (5) / Hannah Fugazzi (5)

Wouldn't mind seeing

Adam Kuhn (1) / Ryan Malaty (1) / Layton Jones (2) / Hunter Barfield (3) / Giovanni Rivera (4) / Hayden Weaver (5) / Joey Amoia (5) / Tyler O'Brien (5)

Brittany Baldassari (1) / Simone Kelly (1) / Ashley Hall (2) / Christina LeBlanc (2) / Paris Eike (2) / Britni Thorton (3) / Melanie Velez (3) / Emma Sweigard (4) / Francesca Duncan (4) / Kaylen Zahara (4) / Carolina Duarte (5) / Kam Williams (5) / Tyranny Todd (5)

Again, keeping in mind I haven't seen Second Chances so I have no idea how they did in a competitive environment. There are also a ton of people who I liked on the show (i.e. Cheyenne, Kari, Victoria, John Moustis, etc.) who I just don't think would fit on a Challenge.

For me the biggest difference in casting from AYTO and RW is only the best options for the challenge from AYTO should be cast while I think everyone from RW deserves at least 1 chance on the challenge

People who havent debut yet but I WANT to see again...

Girls:

Paige(S1), Jacy(S1), Shanley(S1), Ellie(S2), Paris(S2), Julia(S4), Alicia(S5)

Guys: 

Scali(S1), Ethan(S1), Pratt(S2), Prosper(S4), John(S4)

What's good is that every person worth a **** from Season 3 has already made their debut, nobody else is really special

Michael Halpern NEEDS to debut. Such a huge daddy. He's tall as **** and gotten so big. 

Michael Halpern NEEDS to debut. Such a huge daddy. He's tall as **** and gotten so big. 

Yaaaaaaas ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ And Daddy Pratt too ❤️❤️

So far Devin/Amanda/Hunter/Nelson/Tori are the AYTO A-Listers for the challenge. All the others, meh. But I'm always welcome towards AYTO people. It's created a nice storyline having Ayto vs vets/real world. 

Shanley, Ellie, Paris, Melanie, Julia, Alicia

Layton, John H, Prosper, Michael, Mike C, Ozzy

Most necessary debuts

The Jacy Rodriguez

Have hopes that any or all of Clinton/Dimitri/Keith/Nurys/Jada/Keyana/Uche/Diandra/Geles are interesting enough to get Challenge spots.

I would say Michael obviously but I REFUSE to sit through some ******* Jenna/Michael "Barbie & Ken" vomit-inducing storyline so if she's gonna keep getting called, he can stay at home.

Julia and Ozzy both have the personalities of a brick wall so they can stay home. I don't get why everyone was obsessed with them on their seasons