The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

Johnny (RW: Key West)- eliminated by the same guy twice in one season.

Beautiful

Because I'm bored lmao

REDEMTION ISLAND

Everyone was eliminated first on a previous challenge season (Not realistic nor do I think this will ever happen)
played like Free Agents

Thomas Buell (Battle of the Exes 2)
Chet Cannon (The Ruins, Free Agents)
Tyrie Ballard (The Inferno 3, Rivals, Rivals 2)
Dunbar Merrill (Rivals 2)
Wes Bergmann (Battle of the Seasons)
Nate Stodghill (Battle of the Exes)
Davis Mallory (Rivals)
Derek Chavez (Cutthroat)
Darrell Taylor (Fresh Meat 2)
Nick Brown (The Duel 2)
Abram Boise (The Island)
Alex Smith (The Guantlet 3)
Johnny Bananas (The Duel)
Danny Jamieson (Fresh Meat)
Ace Amerson (The Inferno)

Hailey Chivers (Battle of the Exes 2)
Jemmye Carroll (Free Agents)
Anastasia Miller (Rivals 2)
Jessica McCain (Rivals 2)
Lacey Buehler  (Battle of the Seasons)
Priscilla Mendez (Battle of the Exes)
Aneesa Ferriera (Rivals)
Robin Hibbard (Rivals)
Emilee Fitzpatrick (Cutthroat)
Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat 2)
Shauvon Torres  (The Duel 2)
Tonya Cooley (The Island)
Paula Meronek (The Duel)
Evelyn Smith (Fresh Meat)
Cameran Eubanks (The Inferno 2)
Trishelle Cannatella (The Inferno)

Thomas and Hailey weren't eliminated first on BOTE2.

He is probably including exile

Thomas and Hailey weren't eliminated first on BOTE2.

They were the first to be sent home.

Because I'm bored lmao

REDEMTION ISLAND

Everyone was eliminated first on a previous challenge season (Not realistic nor do I think this will ever happen)
played like Free Agents

Thomas Buell (Battle of the Exes 2)
Chet Cannon (The Ruins, Free Agents)
Tyrie Ballard (The Inferno 3, Rivals, Rivals 2)
Dunbar Merrill (Rivals 2)
Wes Bergmann (Battle of the Seasons)
Nate Stodghill (Battle of the Exes)
Davis Mallory (Rivals)
Derek Chavez (Cutthroat)
Darrell Taylor (Fresh Meat 2)
Nick Brown (The Duel 2)
Abram Boise (The Island)
Alex Smith (The Guantlet 3)
Johnny Bananas (The Duel)
Danny Jamieson (Fresh Meat)
Ace Amerson (The Inferno)

Hailey Chivers (Battle of the Exes 2)
Jemmye Carroll (Free Agents)
Anastasia Miller (Rivals 2)
Jessica McCain (Rivals 2)
Lacey Buehler  (Battle of the Seasons)
Priscilla Mendez (Battle of the Exes)
Aneesa Ferriera (Rivals)
Robin Hibbard (Rivals)
Emilee Fitzpatrick (Cutthroat)
Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat 2)
Shauvon Torres  (The Duel 2)
Tonya Cooley (The Island)
Paula Meronek (The Duel)
Evelyn Smith (Fresh Meat)
Cameran Eubanks (The Inferno 2)
Trishelle Cannatella (The Inferno)

Bananas Darrell and Wes and for girls Evelyn wins by a mile with Paula and cara maria in the final.

The Duel 3 (2016)

 

Chris "CT" Tamburello (Real World:Paris)

Brad Fiorenzia (Real World:San Diego)

Johnny "Bananas" Devenzio (Real World:Key West)

Leroy Garrett (Real World:Las Vegas 2)

Zach Nichols (Real World:San Diego)

Robb Shrieber (Real World:St.Thomas)

Marlon Williams (Real World:Portland)

Cory Wharton (Real World:Ex-Plosion)

Brian Williams Jr (Real World:Ex-Plosion)

Anthony Bartolette (AYTO?2)

Layton Jones (AYTO?2)

Bruno Bettencourt (Real World:Skeletons)

Jason Hill (Real World:Skeletons)

 

Trishelle Cannatella (Real World:Las Vegas)

KellyAnne Judd (Real World:Sydney)

Camila Nakagawa (Spring Break Challenge)

Nany Gonzalez (Real World:Las Vegas 2)

Marie Roda (Real World:St.Thomas)

LaToya Jackson (Real World:St.Thomas)

Nia Moore (Real World:Portland)

Averey Tressler (Real World: Portland)

Jamie Larson (Real World:Ex-Plosion)

Ashley Mitchell (Real World:Ex-Plosion)

Shanely McIntee (AYTO?)

Sylvia Elsrode (Real World:Skeletons)

Madison Walls (Real World:Skeletons)

Because I'm bored lmao

REDEMTION ISLAND

Everyone was eliminated first on a previous challenge season (Not realistic nor do I think this will ever happen)
played like Free Agents

Thomas Buell (Battle of the Exes 2)
Chet Cannon (The Ruins, Free Agents)
Tyrie Ballard (The Inferno 3, Rivals, Rivals 2)
Dunbar Merrill (Rivals 2)
Wes Bergmann (Battle of the Seasons)
Nate Stodghill (Battle of the Exes)
Davis Mallory (Rivals)
Derek Chavez (Cutthroat)
Darrell Taylor (Fresh Meat 2)
Nick Brown (The Duel 2)
Abram Boise (The Island)
Alex Smith (The Guantlet 3)
Johnny Bananas (The Duel)
Danny Jamieson (Fresh Meat)
Ace Amerson (The Inferno)

Hailey Chivers (Battle of the Exes 2)
Jemmye Carroll (Free Agents)
Anastasia Miller (Rivals 2)
Jessica McCain (Rivals 2)
Lacey Buehler  (Battle of the Seasons)
Priscilla Mendez (Battle of the Exes)
Aneesa Ferriera (Rivals)
Robin Hibbard (Rivals)
Emilee Fitzpatrick (Cutthroat)
Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat 2)
Shauvon Torres  (The Duel 2)
Tonya Cooley (The Island)
Paula Meronek (The Duel)
Evelyn Smith (Fresh Meat)
Cameran Eubanks (The Inferno 2)
Trishelle Cannatella (The Inferno)

Bananas Darrell and Wes and for girls Evelyn wins by a mile with Paula and cara maria in the final.

Darrell winning would be good.

Because I'm bored lmao REDEMTION ISLAND Everyone was eliminated first on a previous challenge season (Not realistic nor do I think this will ever happen) played like Free Agents Thomas Buell (Battle of the Exes 2) Chet Cannon (The Ruins, Free Agents) Tyrie Ballard (The Inferno 3, Rivals, Rivals 2) Dunbar Merrill (Rivals 2) Wes Bergmann (Battle of the Seasons) Nate Stodghill (Battle of the Exes) Davis Mallory (Rivals) Derek Chavez (Cutthroat) Darrell Taylor (Fresh Meat 2) Nick Brown (The Duel 2) Abram Boise (The Island) Alex Smith (The Guantlet 3) Johnny Bananas (The Duel) Danny Jamieson (Fresh Meat) Ace Amerson (The Inferno) Hailey Chivers (Battle of the Exes 2) Jemmye Carroll (Free Agents) Anastasia Miller (Rivals 2) Jessica McCain (Rivals 2) Lacey Buehler  (Battle of the Seasons) Priscilla Mendez (Battle of the Exes) Aneesa Ferriera (Rivals) Robin Hibbard (Rivals) Emilee Fitzpatrick (Cutthroat) Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat 2) Shauvon Torres  (The Duel 2) Tonya Cooley (The Island) Paula Meronek (The Duel) Evelyn Smith (Fresh Meat) Cameran Eubanks (The Inferno 2) Trishelle Cannatella (The Inferno)

Bananas Darrell and Wes and for girls Evelyn wins by a mile with Paula and cara maria in the final.

Depending on which Tonya shows up, she could take Paula's place.

Cutthroat 2
Location Italy
Red Team
Cory
Bananas
Robb
Tony
Zach
Averey
Emily
Coral
Kelly Anne
Violetta
Blue Team
Bruno
CT
Leroy
Trey
Johnny R
Aneesa
Cara Maria
Jenn
LaToya
Rachel
Green Team
Cohutta
Mark
Darrell
Jordan
Wes
Beth
Cooke
Nia
Nicole
Nany

The Challenge the Redemption
Location Italy
Anyone who has punched someone, gotten injured, quit a final, screwed over by a partner or just needs redemption gets another chance to prove themselves. Last place goes into the showdown and the winner picks the person to face them.
Frank
Joi
Darrell
Sarah
Greg
Cara Maria
Ryan L
Erika
Adam R
Beth
CT
Nia
Leroy
Heather
Wes
Cooke
Zach
Coral
Johnny R
Ashley M
Abram
Jenn
Brad
Trisha
Trey
Nany
Derrick
Averey

The Challenge the Redemption Location Italy Anyone who has punched someone, gotten injured, quit a final, screwed over by a partner or just needs redemption gets another chance to prove themselves. Last place goes into the showdown and the winner picks the person to face them. Frank Joi Darrell Sarah Greg Cara Maria Ryan L Erika Adam R Beth CT Nia Leroy Heather Wes Cooke Zach Coral Johnny R Ashley M Abram Jenn Brad Trisha Trey Nany Derrick Averey

This format is everything. So many of my favorite cast members. This challenge would be insane. 

I really don't care for this whole Redemption idea...

I'd rather see The Challenge: Revenge. A format that somehow incorporates  the idea of getting back at those who have done you wrong in the past. 

I really don't care for this whole Redemption idea...

I'd rather see The Challenge: Revenge. A format that somehow incorporates  the idea of getting back at those who have done you wrong in the past. 

Hmm how about this,
The challenge revenge,
A individual challenge with one hell of a twist,if your enemy wins, you go in the elimination round.
Like if Cara maria wins the mission , bananas automatically goes in the elimination, unless she decides to save him by throwing someone else in. That way the enemy will beg for forgiveness and there fate is completely in someone else's hands.

I really don't care for this whole Redemption idea...

I'd rather see The Challenge: Revenge. A format that somehow incorporates  the idea of getting back at those who have done you wrong in the past. 

Hmm how about this, The challenge revenge, A individual challenge with one hell of a twist,if your enemy wins, you go in the elimination round. Like if Cara maria wins the mission , bananas automatically goes in the elimination, unless she decides to save him by throwing someone else in. That way the enemy will beg for forgiveness and there fate is completely in someone else's hands.

I actually love that. If your enemy goes in and loses, then you have free reign to do whatever. 

It removes the need to ever do Rivals 3 or Co-ed Rivals. Because Revenge is much more broad and doesn't limit casting. Plus there is the social game element and a completely new and unknown layer to politics.

I really don't care for this whole Redemption idea...

I'd rather see The Challenge: Revenge. A format that somehow incorporates  the idea of getting back at those who have done you wrong in the past. 

Hmm how about this, The challenge revenge, A individual challenge with one hell of a twist,if your enemy wins, you go in the elimination round. Like if Cara maria wins the mission , bananas automatically goes in the elimination, unless she decides to save him by throwing someone else in. That way the enemy will beg for forgiveness and there fate is completely in someone else's hands.

I actually love that. If your enemy goes in and loses, then you have free reign to do whatever. 

It removes the need to ever do Rivals 3 or Co-ed Rivals. Because Revenge is much more broad and doesn't limit casting. Plus there is the social game element and a completely new and unknown layer to politics.

Thanks I do think it would be great for people to beg the one person they hate the most to save them. Plus whoever gets sent in instead of the enemy would be so mad and that could cause a lot of drama.

I really don't care for this whole Redemption idea...

I'd rather see The Challenge: Revenge. A format that somehow incorporates  the idea of getting back at those who have done you wrong in the past. 

Hmm how about this,
The challenge revenge,
A individual challenge with one hell of a twist,if your enemy wins, you go in the elimination round.
Like if Cara maria wins the mission , bananas automatically goes in the elimination, unless she decides to save him by throwing someone else in. That way the enemy will beg for forgiveness and there fate is completely in someone else's hands.

That's a bad *** idea for a challenge. I would prefer that over another Rivals challenge.

They seriously need to start either paying this site to use some ideas or bringing some of us in their office to discuss ideas smh that Revenge idea is GOLD.

I really don't care for this whole Redemption idea...

I'd rather see The Challenge: Revenge. A format that somehow incorporates  the idea of getting back at those who have done you wrong in the past. 

So Rivals 3?

I really don't care for this whole Redemption idea...

I'd rather see The Challenge: Revenge. A format that somehow incorporates  the idea of getting back at those who have done you wrong in the past. 

So Rivals 3?

No. With Rivals, you can't get revenge on your partner without ******* yourself over...

They seriously need to start either paying this site to use some ideas or bringing some of us in their office to discuss ideas smh that Revenge idea is GOLD.

But AYTO and Bloodlines though.

I really don't care for this whole Redemption idea...

I'd rather see The Challenge: Revenge. A format that somehow incorporates  the idea of getting back at those who have done you wrong in the past. 

So Rivals 3?

No. With Rivals, you can't get revenge on your partner without ******* yourself over...

Oh I see. That would be pretty cool. So would it be an individual challenge or what?

Oh I see. That would be pretty cool. So would it be an individual challenge or what?

That'd probably be the best route to take IMO.

They seriously need to start either paying this site to use some ideas or bringing some of us in their office to discuss ideas smh that Revenge idea is GOLD.

But AYTO and Bloodlines though.

My bad I forgot Mediocrity is the name of the game.

They seriously need to start either paying this site to use some ideas or bringing some of us in their office to discuss ideas smh that Revenge idea is GOLD.

But AYTO and Bloodlines though.

My bad I forgot Mediocrity is the name of the game.

Mediocrity would be too strong an accolade.

Thanks guys! I really like the idea myself but I still need to work the kinks out like how it would work for the sexes like should they be coed or same sex enemies .

The Gauntlet 4

 

Veterans

Cohutta Grindaff (Real World:Sydney)

Leroy Garrett (Real World:Las Vegas 2)

Dustin Zito (Real World:Las Vegas)

Preston Charles (Real World:New Orleans)

Zach Nichols (Real World:San Diego 2)

Trey Weatherholtz (Real World:St.Thomas)

Johnny Reilly (Real World:Portland)

KellyAnne Judd (Real World:Sydney)

Jonna Mannion (Real World:Cancun)

Camila Nakagawa (Spring Break Challenge)

Nany Gonzalez (Real World:Las Vegas 2)

Naomi Defensor (Real World:Las Vegas 2)

Jessica McCain (Real World:Las VEgas 2)

Nia Moore (Real World:Portland)

 

Rookies

Brandon Swift (Real World:St.Thomas)

Marlon Williams (Real World:Portland)

Adam Kuhn (Are You The One?)

Cory Wharton (Real World:Ex-Plosion)

Brian Williams Jr (Real World:Ex-Plosion)

Tony Raines (Real World:Skeletons)

Layton Jones (Are You The One?2)

Marie Roda (Real World:St.Thomas)

LaToya Jackson (Real World:St.Thomas)

Averey Tressler (Real World:Portland)

Shanely McIntee (Are You The One?)

Ashley Mitchell (Real World:Ex-Plosion)

Violetta Milerman (Real World:Skeletons)

Sylvia Elsrode (Real World:Skeletons)

Battle of the Sexes

Unlike previous Battle of the Sexes Guys and Girls won't be in competition with each other. There will be 4 teams ( 2 guy teams and 2 girl teams) both teams of each gender will face each other every challenge. Before each challenge all teams will nominate 2 team captains. If your team wins the Captains are safe and have to nominate someone else from your team to go into elimination. If you team loses the rest of the team has to decide between the 2 team Captains who goes into elimination in a public vote.

GUYS TEAMS:

Old School:
Cohutta (RW: Sydney)
Bananas (RW: Key West)
Darrell (RR: Campus Crawl)
Abram (RR: South Pacific)
Nehemiah  (RW: Austin)
Ace (RW: Paris)
Scott (RW: Brooklyn)
Mark (RR: First Adventure)

New School:
Pete  (Fresh Meat 2 )
Leroy (RW: Las Vegas 2)
Zach (RW: San Diego 2)
Trey (RW: St. Thomas)
Johnny (RW: Portland)
Adam (AYTO: Hawaii)
Cory (RW: Ex-Plosion)
Tony (RW: Skeletons)

GIRLS TEAMS: 

Old School:
KellyAnne (RW: Sydney)
Aneesa (RW: Chicago)
Kina (RR: X-Treme)
Beth (RW: Los Angeles)
Coral (RW: Back to New York)
Trishelle (RW: Las Vegas)
Veronica (RR: Semester at Sea)
Rachel (RR: Campus Crawl)

New School:
Cara Maria (Fresh Meat 2)
Emily (RW: D.C.)
Ayiiia (RW: Cancun)
Nany (RW: Las Vegas 2)
Marie (RW: St. Thomas)
Nia (RW: Portland)
Averey (RW: Portland)
Sylvia (RW: Skeletons)

Old School is New York - Brooklyn + Road Rules
New School is Cancun - Skeletons + AYTO

Battle of the Sexes Unlike previous Battle of the Sexes Guys and Girls won't be in competition with each other. There will be 4 teams ( 2 guy teams and 2 girl teams) both teams of each gender will face each other every challenge. Before each challenge all teams will nominate 2 team captains. If your team wins the Captains are safe and have to nominate someone else from your team to go into elimination. If you team loses the rest of the team has to decide between the 2 team Captains who goes into elimination in a public vote. GUYS TEAMS: Old School: Cohutta (RW: Sydney) Bananas (RW: Key West) Darrell (RR: Campus Crawl) Abram (RR: South Pacific) Nehemiah  (RW: Austin) Ace (RW: Paris) Scott (RW: Brooklyn) Mark (RR: First Adventure) New School: Pete  (Fresh Meat 2 ) Leroy (RW: Las Vegas 2) Zach (RW: San Diego 2) Trey (RW: St. Thomas) Johnny (RW: Portland) Adam (AYTO: Hawaii) Cory (RW: Ex-Plosion) Tony (RW: Skeletons) GIRLS TEAMS:  Old School: KellyAnne (RW: Sydney) Aneesa (RW: Chicago) Kina (RR: X-Treme) Beth (RW: Los Angeles) Coral (RW: Back to New York) Trishelle (RW: Las Vegas) Veronica (RR: Semester at Sea) Rachel (RR: Campus Crawl) New School: Cara Maria (Fresh Meat 2) Emily (RW: D.C.) Ayiiia (RW: Cancun) Nany (RW: Las Vegas 2) Marie (RW: St. Thomas) Nia (RW: Portland) Averey (RW: Portland) Sylvia (RW: Skeletons) Old School is New York - Brooklyn + Road Rules New School is Cancun - Skeletons + AYTO

I love this idea. I made a format like this years ago on this site around the time of Rivals or Exes I wanna say. If you scroll back forever you'll find it eventually. It would be cool if they did a challenge like this tho. 

Here is my cast:

Veteran Males: Black

CJ (RW: Cancun)

Cohutta (RW: Sydney)

Dustin (RW: Las Vegas 2011)

Johnny (RW: Portland)

Leroy (RW: Las Vegas 2011)

Trey (RW: St. Thomas)

Wes (RW: Austin)

Zach (RW: San Diego 2012)

 

Veteran Females: Red

Aneesa (RW: Chicago)

Camila (Spring Break Challenge)

Cara Maria (Fresh Meat II)

Emily (RW: D.C.)

Jonna (RW: Cancun)

KellyAnne (RW: Sydney)

Nany (RW: Las Vegas 2011)

Nia (RW: Portland)

 

Rookie Males: Gray

Adam (AYTO: Hawaii)

Brian (RW: Ex-Plosion)

Bruno (RW: Skeletons)

Cory (RW: Ex-Plosion)

Marlon (RW: Portland)

Swift (RW: St. Thomas)

Thomas (RW: Ex-Plosion)

Tony (RW: Skeletons)

 

Rookie Females: Blue

Ashley M. (RW: Ex-Plosion)

Averey (RW: Portland)

Brittany (AYTO: Hawaii)

LaToya (RW: St. Thomas)

Marie (RW: St. Thomas)

Sam (RW: San Diego 2012)

Sylvia (RW: Skeletons)

Violetta (RW: Skeletons)

Battle of the Seasons 3 (Realistic)

Team Old School - Abram, Darrell, Beth, Ruthie

ALL four of them stated that they are willing to come back to do a challenge. They would be a great team to watch. They're all memorable characters and have brought something to the show. 

Team Sydney - Cohutta, Isaac, Ashli, KellyAnne

They're all interested in coming back and I think this would be a fun team. 

Team Las Vegas - Dustin, Leroy, Cooke, Nany

They would be awesome in the challenges. 

Team St. Thomas - Robb, Trey, LaToya, Marie

It would be interesting to see how Robb/Marie would interract after their break up. The LaToya/Marie friendship would be awesome to watch. 

Team Portland - Johnny, Jordan, Averey, Nia

These four together = TV GOLD! Johnny/Averey hate each other and Jordan/Nia always fight. Johnny/Jordan are best friends while Averey/Nia are close. Their main storyline would be trying to work out their differences in order to win. 

Team Ex-Plosion - Cory, Thomas, Ashley M, Jamie

It would be interesting to see how Thomas/Jamie will interract after their break up. Ashley M and Jamie can't stand each other. Cory and Thomas have potential to be great. 

Team Skeletons - Bruno, Tony, Sylvia, Violetta

Bruno and Sylvia HATE each other so it'd be awesome seeing them on a team together. I think MTV could convince Bruno to do a challenge. Hopefully he pulls an Averey/Diem and agrees to come back on. Jason could be his alternate *****