The Challenge: Generic Thread

So here's a question that was inspired by the discussion on Kellyanne/Susie in another thread. What challenger do you think is overated?

[QUOTE=Debut Album;438686]So here's a question that was inspired by the discussion on Kellyanne/Susie in another thread. What challenger do you think is overated?[/QUOTE] Naomi Carmen "Nany" González. Mckenzie is pretty overrated as well because of her oil wrestling "prowess".

For me I would say Cara Maria. The only time she's been good was on this past season. she's just been average or mediocre. all the other challenges she's been on. I'd also say Theresa.

[QUOTE=LurkerNoMore;438687]Naomi Carmen "Nany" González. Mckenzie is pretty overrated as well because of her oil wrestling "prowess".[/QUOTE] Her Real Name is Naomi? Didn't know that.

[QUOTE=Debut Album;438689]Her Real Name is Naomi? Didn't know that.[/QUOTE] Yup. RW: Back to Las Vegas had two Michaels, two Heathers, and two Naomis!

[QUOTE=Debut Album;438689]Her Real Name is Naomi? Didn't know that.[/QUOTE] Yeah she said that on her Real World season when she met Naomi. But I think Zach is overrated.

[QUOTE=Debut Album;438686]So here's a question that was inspired by the discussion on Kellyanne/Susie in another thread. What challenger do you think is overated?[/QUOTE] Hands down it's Mark.

[QUOTE=Debut Album;438686]So here's a question that was inspired by the discussion on Kellyanne/Susie in another thread. What challenger do you think is overated?[/QUOTE] Jordan, especially the way that he said "Laurel's one of the top girl competitors, I'm one of the top guy competitors, those forces need to come together". That made me cringe.

[QUOTE=LurkerNoMore;438687]Naomi Carmen "Nany" González. Mckenzie is pretty overrated as well because of her oil wrestling "prowess".[/QUOTE] Lurker let's be honest here you just don't like Nany, lol.

Part III: [url]https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BwzY4Qc6X5-BcDhsbG5KSURjd1U/edit?usp=sharing[/url] [url]https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BwzY4Qc6X5-BVE55dnRiZWpLYU0/edit?usp=sharing[/url]

I agree with Theresa, I was really confused when everyone was saying she was a threat last season. She may be tall and sort of athletic, but we've barely seen her do anything on the show, so it's like we just have to take her word on being good on long distance things. Do I think she has potential? Yes, but I don't think that she was a legitimate threat to either Laurel or Cara as of last season.

I agree lol Theresa have the body build and is tall most likely hav epotential...But as of this day after 5 seasons she hasn't proved anything other than she is descent. Other than beating Camila she hasn't done anything. I personally still rank Cara and Laurel over her, I will even rank Nany over her. It's my opinion.

[QUOTE=LurkerNoMore;438690]Yup. RW: Back to Las Vegas had two Michaels, two Heathers, and two Naomis![/QUOTE] Who was the other Micheal?

Really Nany>Theresa?! That's a new one!!

Dustin IMO is extremely overrated he's good but only when the cast is mostly rookies and bad competitors. Also people give him way to much credit for tying Zach in oil change.

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;438698]Who was the other Micheal?[/QUOTE] Michael Adam Royer

[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;438694]Lurker let's be honest here you just don't like Nany, lol.[/QUOTE] ;)

[QUOTE=TheBestBully;438692]Hands down it's Mark.[/QUOTE] I didn't even think of Mark, he definitely takes the cake.

I feel like Sarah is very overrated. She's never done anything to stand out and always gets praised like she's a beast.

[QUOTE=gamer73;438704]I feel like Sarah is very overrated. She's never done anything to stand out and always gets praised like she's a beast.[/QUOTE] Yeah, Sarah is someone I can't get behind just because she is so convinced of her own prowess along with other people saying how great she is. I do think she's good, but she seems to think she's just as good as Ev/Laurel/Emily which is just...not true lol.

[QUOTE=gamer73;438704]I feel like Sarah is very overrated. She's never done anything to stand out and always gets praised like she's a beast.[/QUOTE] [QUOTE=riggins;438705]Yeah, Sarah is someone I can't get behind just because she is so convinced of her own prowess along with other people saying how great she is. I do think she's good, but she seems to think she's just as good as Ev/Laurel/Emily which is just...not true lol.[/QUOTE] Sarah has her moments. She was arguably the best competitor on Seasons, the only time she's held back her team was on Cutthroat, and she's had a string of horrible teams and partners. She's just unlucky. Do I think she's elite? No. But is she a solid, well-rounded challenger? Absolutely.

out of the girls: Theresa out of the guys: Leroy, can Leroy do anything else good besides runnign people over? the only thin I've seen him do impressive invovles physical strength. is Leory good at endurance, or swimming, if he is can someone tell me.

I think Wes. He won 5 exiles on Fresh Meat, but got lucky on a few of them where the other team forgot their flags and had to run back. His team also had much less weight than any of their opponents. He won The Duel, and his victory over Derrick was very impressive, but he got to the end because the last 2 men's challenges were swimming and then he got lucky with the soccer face off for the head start. After the Duel he basically did nothing until Rivals 2, when CT carried him.

[QUOTE=Johnny Utah;438708]I think Wes. He won 5 exiles on Fresh Meat, but got lucky on a few of them where the other team forgot their flags and had to run back. His team also had much less weight than any of their opponents. He won The Duel, and his victory over Derrick was very impressive, but he got to the end because the last 2 men's challenges were swimming and then he got lucky with the soccer face off for the head start. After the Duel he basically did nothing until Rivals 2, when CT carried him.[/QUOTE] Actually wes is the reason him Kenny didn't got eliminated on the first Rivals lol I think he did great until The Duel , then descent until Rivals and then he stopped working out. Overrated: Leroy. Overrated: Theresa and Sarah.

I think people are giving Cara too much credit. She gave one good performance after SIX seasons of mediocrity with great partners too. I think Sarah is a great competitor. I can't remember a season she performed poorly, one of the best females on the Ruins, Cutthroat, and the best on Seasons. I would say Emily S and Leroy are overrated.

[QUOTE=PinkRose;438709]Actually wes is the reason him Kenny didn't got eliminated on the first Rivals lol I think he did great until The Duel , then descent until Rivals and then he stopped working out. Overrated: Leroy. Overrated: Theresa and Sarah.[/QUOTE] You're right he did carry Kenny on Rivals, until the final. Wes's attitude on the Ruins was just over the top.

[QUOTE=Debut Album;438678]LOL she was suppose to be on casts that are nonexistent in the challenge world. That's funny.[/QUOTE] And yet you're still talking about her.

[QUOTE=LurkerNoMore;438690]Yup. RW: Back to Las Vegas had two Michaels, two Heathers, and two Naomis![/QUOTE] It had two micheals? I know one was mike Mike but who was the other Mike?

[QUOTE=Debut Album;438714]It had two micheals? I know one was mike Mike but who was the other Mike?[/QUOTE] Adam's first name is Michael.

[QUOTE=LurkerNoMore;438703]I didn't even think of Mark, he definitely takes the cake.[/QUOTE] Yep. I didn't even think of him either. he's definitely #1 on my list. The guy really hasn't done all that much when it comes to these shows. I don't get why he's so beloved.