The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

I took the Gauntlet 2 cast and separated them onto teams as if it were an Inferno. Some of them are stretches, but I tried the best I could to separate everyone based on how they were edited in past shows. Let me know if you think anyone should be switched! Maybe I'll do a season summary for this fantasy cast as well. [center][COLOR="#FF0000"][B]BAD *****[/B] Adam Larson Danny Dias David Burns Derrick Kosinski Jamie Murray MJ Garrett Randy Barry Syrus Yarbrough Aneesa Ferreira Beth Stolarczyk Jillian Zoboroski Jisela Delgado Jo Rhodes Katie Doyle Kina Dean Susie Meister[/COLOR] [COLOR="#0000FF"][B]GOOD GUYS[/B] Ace Amerson Adam King Alton Williams Brad Fiorenza Jeremy Blossom Landon Lueck Mark Long Timmy Beggy Cameran Eubanks Cara Zavaleta Ibis Nieves Jodi Weatherton Julie Stoffer Montana McGlynn Robin Hibbard Ruthie Alcaide[/COLOR] [/center]

[QUOTE=JayTee;420032]Derek is fast and Marlon played D1 ball, I'm sure he'd be almost as fast as Zach. Too much weight? Do you know how much CT and Mark weigh and they still dominated that mission? Why not the wedding one? 1 decent sized guy and 1 6ft football player can dig and make their way through sand much faster than a guy and girl team unless Emily or Laurel is one that team. Why not the plane one? Go watch exes and tell me who was the anchor in all the waves: the girls. No girls on this cast can match up weight wise and strength wise to Marlon and Derek who aren't going to have a tough time speeding through the air and making their way towards the jet. Maybe if the guy pairs were skinny guys like Ryan K. it would be even, but Derek isn't that small and Marlon is kind of a big dude. It'll never happen.[/QUOTE] Mark came second to last and CT didn't do all that well. And they are combining weight together Marlon & Derek The wedding one because Marlon couldn't eat that cake and them running and carrying each other and already being tired would not work. The plane was strategy the teams who went sooner struggled and the teams who went last had a good strategy down. Marlon is not very coordinated either and Derek is kinda light he could get whisked away. I think it would happen JayTee!

[QUOTE=Youssarian;420037]I took the Gauntlet 2 cast and separated them onto teams as if it were an Inferno. Some of them are stretches, but I tried the best I could to separate everyone based on how they were edited in past shows. Let me know if you think anyone should be switched! Maybe I'll do a season summary for this fantasy cast as well. [center][COLOR="#FF0000"][B]BAD *****[/B] Adam Larson Danny Dias David Burns Derrick Kosinski Jamie Murray MJ Garrett Randy Barry Syrus Yarbrough Aneesa Ferreira Beth Stolarczyk Jillian Zoboroski Jisela Delgado Jo Rhodes Katie Doyle Kina Dean Susie Meister[/COLOR] [COLOR="#0000FF"][B]GOOD GUYS[/B] Ace Amerson Adam King Alton Williams Brad Fiorenza Jeremy Blossom Landon Lueck Mark Long Timmy Beggy Cameran Eubanks Cara Zavaleta Ibis Nieves Jodi Weatherton Julie Stoffer Montana McGlynn Robin Hibbard Ruthie Alcaide[/COLOR] [/center][/QUOTE] Both teams have a good chance at winning!

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;420040]Mark came second to last and CT didn't do all that well. And they are combining weight together Marlon & Derek The wedding one because Marlon couldn't eat that cake and them running and carrying each other and already being tired would not work. The plane was strategy the teams who went sooner struggled and the teams who went last had a good strategy down. Marlon is not very coordinated either and Derek is kinda light he could get whisked away. I think it would happen JayTee![/QUOTE] CT didn't do that well that's why him and Bananas were the last winners of the male heat? Why can't Marlon eat that cake? I'm sure Marlon could eat a lot more things than your average guy lol Strategy? It was mainly about weight. Bananas only lost being Camila was uncoordinated as ****. And Derek May be light for a guy, but he still weighs more and is stronger than Robin, Diem, Camila and Emily (the girls who did this mission) and also weighs more and is stronger than the whole female cast of this potential Exes 2 cast.

Omg what if they gave CT Shauvon as an Exes partner?!

[CENTER]Battle of the Sexes 3: [COLOR="#0000FF"]Males: CT Tamburello Frank Sweeney Robb Schreiber Trey Weatherholtz Johnny Reilly Cory Wharton Brian Williams Thomas Buell Johnny Bananas Jordan Wiseley Leroy Garrett Wes Bergmann Mark Long CJ Koegel Abram Boise Zach Nichols[/COLOR] [COLOR="#cc66cc"]Females: Cara Maria Sorbello Nia Moore Theresa Gonzalez Ashley Kelsey Laurel Stucky Evelyn Smith Camila Nakagawa Sarah Rice KellyAnne Judd Rachel Robinson Ruthie Alcaide Arielle Scott Jenny Delich Aneesa Ferreira Coral Smith Emily Schromm[/COLOR][/CENTER]

People paired up with someone they beat in an elimination, or someone who beat them. The theme of this Challenge can be something related to redemption or something like that... Thoughts on the cast? Predictions? [center][B]Abram Boise & Ty Ruff (Battle of the Exes)[/B] [img]http://i57.tinypic.com/fviidw.png[/img][img]http://i62.tinypic.com/111ouq9.png[/img] [B]Cohutta Grindstaff & Leroy Garrett (Free Agents)[/B] [img]http://i61.tinypic.com/snm3bq.png[/img][img]http://i61.tinypic.com/w024wj.png[/img] [B]Chet Cannon & Wes Bergmann (Ruins)[/B] [img]http://i58.tinypic.com/25qdpjd.png[/img][img]http://i58.tinypic.com/acxwky.png[/img] [B]CT Tamburello & Nehemiah Clark (Rivals)[/B] [img]http://i57.tinypic.com/2zexeom.png[/img][img]http://mtv.mtvnimages.com/onair/rwrr_challenge/rivals/photos/singles/promos/tyrie/281x211.jpg?quality=0.85[/img] [B]Dunbar Merrill & Johnny Bananas Devenanzio (Ruins)[/B] [img]http://i60.tinypic.com/23sfxvr.png[/img][img]http://i57.tinypic.com/15pl4zr.png[/img] [B]Dustin Zito & Trey Weatherholtz (Battle of the Seasons)[/B] [img]http://i58.tinypic.com/2dtdwdu.png[/img][img]http://i57.tinypic.com/2cmw3o0.png[/img] [B]Frank Roessler & Tyler Duckworth (Gauntlet 3)[/B] [img]http://mtv.mtvnimages.com/onair/gauntlet_III/images/flipbooks/cast/Men/Frank/crops/281x211.jpg?quality=0.85[/img][img]http://mtv.mtvnimages.com/onair/rwrr_challenge/rivals/photos/singles/promos/tyler/281x211_tyler.jpg?quality=0.85[/img] [B]Jordan Wiseley & Ryan Knight (Rivals 2)[/B] [img]http://i60.tinypic.com/nxvww7.png[/img][img]http://i57.tinypic.com/m8fn6q.png[/img] --- [B]Aneesa Ferreira & Camila Nakagawa (Rivals 2)[/B] [img]http://i58.tinypic.com/208bthu.png[/img][img]http://i60.tinypic.com/2u8udz5.png[/img] [B]Ashley Kelsey & Jonna Mannion (Battle of the Seasons)[/B] [img]http://i59.tinypic.com/290qw48.png[/img][img]http://i59.tinypic.com/14o7pmr.png[/img] [B]Beth Stolarczyk & Ruthie Alcaide (Gauntlet 2)[/B] [img]http://mtv.mtvnimages.com/onair/gauntlet_III/images/flipbooks/cast/Women/Beth/crops/281x211.jpg?quality=0.85[/img][img]http://mtv.mtvnimages.com/onair/rwrr_challenge_duel2/images/photos/Cast/Girls/ruthie/ruthie_flipbook/281x211.jpg?quality=0.85[/img] [B]Cara Maria Sorbello & LaToya Jackson (Free Agents)[/B] [img]http://i61.tinypic.com/o52wwg.png[/img][img]http://i61.tinypic.com/14kfpsg.png[/img] [B]Emily Schromm & Melinda Stolp (Cutthroat)[/B] [img]http://i62.tinypic.com/9t1xyr.png[/img][img]http://i62.tinypic.com/157otoo.png[/img] [B]Jemmye Carroll & Theresa Gonzalez (Rivals 2)[/B] [img]http://i60.tinypic.com/oqlun9.png[/img][img]http://i62.tinypic.com/5390qw.png[/img] [B]Laura Waller & Nany Gonzalez (Battle of the Seasons)[/B] [img]http://i59.tinypic.com/ms2j6a.png[/img][img]http://i60.tinypic.com/2lk4g08.png[/img] [B]McKenzie Coburn & Sarah Rice (Battle of the Seasons)[/B] [img]http://i61.tinypic.com/14jazut.png[/img][img]http://i60.tinypic.com/ivwt4j.png[/img][/center]

[QUOTE=Youssarian;420061]People paired up with someone they beat in an elimination, or someone who beat them. The theme of this Challenge can be something related to redemption or something like that... Thoughts on the cast? Predictions? [center][B]Abram Boise & Ty Ruff (Battle of the Exes)[/B] [img]http://i57.tinypic.com/fviidw.png[/img][img]http://i62.tinypic.com/111ouq9.png[/img] [B]Cohutta Grindstaff & Leroy Garrett (Free Agents)[/B] [img]http://i61.tinypic.com/snm3bq.png[/img][img]http://i61.tinypic.com/w024wj.png[/img] [B]Chet Cannon & Wes Bergmann (Ruins)[/B] [img]http://i58.tinypic.com/25qdpjd.png[/img][img]http://i58.tinypic.com/acxwky.png[/img] [B]CT Tamburello & Nehemiah Clark (Rivals)[/B] [img]http://i57.tinypic.com/2zexeom.png[/img][img]http://mtv.mtvnimages.com/onair/rwrr_challenge/rivals/photos/singles/promos/tyrie/281x211.jpg?quality=0.85[/img] [B]Dunbar Merrill & Johnny Bananas Devenanzio (Ruins)[/B] [img]http://i60.tinypic.com/23sfxvr.png[/img][img]http://i57.tinypic.com/15pl4zr.png[/img] [B]Dustin Zito & Trey Weatherholtz (Battle of the Seasons)[/B] [img]http://i58.tinypic.com/2dtdwdu.png[/img][img]http://i57.tinypic.com/2cmw3o0.png[/img] [B]Frank Roessler & Tyler Duckworth (Gauntlet 3)[/B] [img]http://mtv.mtvnimages.com/onair/gauntlet_III/images/flipbooks/cast/Men/Frank/crops/281x211.jpg?quality=0.85[/img][img]http://mtv.mtvnimages.com/onair/rwrr_challenge/rivals/photos/singles/promos/tyler/281x211_tyler.jpg?quality=0.85[/img] [B]Jordan Wiseley & Ryan Knight (Rivals 2)[/B] [img]http://i60.tinypic.com/nxvww7.png[/img][img]http://i57.tinypic.com/m8fn6q.png[/img] --- [B]Aneesa Ferreira & Camila Nakagawa (Rivals 2)[/B] [img]http://i58.tinypic.com/208bthu.png[/img][img]http://i60.tinypic.com/2u8udz5.png[/img] [B]Ashley Kelsey & Jonna Mannion (Battle of the Seasons)[/B] [img]http://i59.tinypic.com/290qw48.png[/img][img]http://i59.tinypic.com/14o7pmr.png[/img] [B]Beth Stolarczyk & Ruthie Alcaide (Gauntlet 2)[/B] [img]http://mtv.mtvnimages.com/onair/gauntlet_III/images/flipbooks/cast/Women/Beth/crops/281x211.jpg?quality=0.85[/img][img]http://mtv.mtvnimages.com/onair/rwrr_challenge_duel2/images/photos/Cast/Girls/ruthie/ruthie_flipbook/281x211.jpg?quality=0.85[/img] [B]Cara Maria Sorbello & LaToya Jackson (Free Agents)[/B] [img]http://i61.tinypic.com/o52wwg.png[/img][img]http://i61.tinypic.com/14kfpsg.png[/img] [B]Emily Schromm & Melinda Stolp (Cutthroat)[/B] [img]http://i62.tinypic.com/9t1xyr.png[/img][img]http://i62.tinypic.com/157otoo.png[/img] [B]Jemmye Carroll & Theresa Gonzalez (Rivals 2)[/B] [img]http://i60.tinypic.com/oqlun9.png[/img][img]http://i62.tinypic.com/5390qw.png[/img] [B]Laura Waller & Nany Gonzalez (Battle of the Seasons)[/B] [img]http://i59.tinypic.com/ms2j6a.png[/img][img]http://i60.tinypic.com/2lk4g08.png[/img] [B]McKenzie Coburn & Sarah Rice (Battle of the Seasons)[/B] [img]http://i61.tinypic.com/14jazut.png[/img][img]http://i60.tinypic.com/ivwt4j.png[/img][/center][/QUOTE] I'm in love with this, I love how random are the teams. For the girls, I say Aneesa/Camila, Beth/Ruthie and the other one I can't really say who, but my bets are on Jemmye/Theresa, Ashley K./Jonna and Emily/Melinda. For the guys, CT/Nehemiah, Frank/Tyler and Dunbar/Johnny.

[QUOTE=nevidcm;420064]I'm in love with this, I love how random are the teams. For the girls, I say Aneesa/Camila, Beth/Ruthie and the other one I can't really say who, but my bets are on Jemmye/Theresa, Ashley K./Jonna and Emily/Melinda. For the guys, CT/Nehemiah, Frank/Tyler and Dunbar/Johnny.[/QUOTE] Thank you! For your Battle of the Sexes cast - rocking cast on both sides, but strong guys will beat strong girls most of the time, so I think it could still be pretty lopsided. However, I can definitely see these girls pulling off more wins than the girls' teams in the past have. Either way, there's so many strong competitors on each team that every episode would be a surprise as to who would be eliminated.

Personally I'd put Sarah with Laurel and cara with Emily

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;420066]Personally I'd put Sarah with Laurel and cara with Emily[/QUOTE] I wanted to keep the teams fair and the competition pretty unpredictable, but I do see where you're coming from :)

[QUOTE=Youssarian;420061]People paired up with someone they beat in an elimination, or someone who beat them. The theme of this Challenge can be something related to redemption or something like that... Thoughts on the cast? Predictions? [center][B]Abram Boise & Ty Ruff (Battle of the Exes)[/B] [B]Cohutta Grindstaff & Leroy Garrett (Free Agents)[/B] [B]Chet Cannon & Wes Bergmann (Ruins)[/B] [B]CT Tamburello & Nehemiah Clark (Rivals)[/B] [B]Dunbar Merrill & Johnny Bananas Devenanzio (Ruins)[/B] [B]Dustin Zito & Trey Weatherholtz (Battle of the Seasons)[/B] [B]Frank Roessler & Tyler Duckworth (Gauntlet 3)[/B] [B]Jordan Wiseley & Ryan Knight (Rivals 2)[/B] --- [B]Aneesa Ferreira & Camila Nakagawa (Rivals 2)[/B] [B]Ashley Kelsey & Jonna Mannion (Battle of the Seasons)[/B] [B]Beth Stolarczyk & Ruthie Alcaide (Gauntlet 2)[/B] [B]Cara Maria Sorbello & LaToya Jackson (Free Agents)[/B] [B]Emily Schromm & Melinda Stolp (Cutthroat)[/B] [B]Jemmye Carroll & Theresa Gonzalez (Rivals 2)[/B] [B]Laura Waller & Nany Gonzalez (Battle of the Seasons)[/B] [B]McKenzie Coburn & Sarah Rice (Battle of the Seasons)[/B] [/QUOTE] I think CT/Nehemiah, Johnny/Dunbar, Wes/Chet, and Frank/Tyler would try to work together. Will they all make it to the final 4. Probably not. But I can see this happening. As for the girls, Emily/Melinda, Sarah/McKenzie, and Camila/Aneesa would probably work together. Great cast btw.

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;420066]Personally I'd put Sarah with Laurel and cara with Emily[/QUOTE] Why?

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;420181]Why?[/QUOTE] Because Sarah deserves the win........ and seeing two strong female teams go against each other in a final would be great

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;420342]Because Sarah deserves the win........ and seeing two strong female teams go against each other in a final would be great[/QUOTE] Exactly deserves so let her fight for it not be handed.

[QUOTE=Youssarian;420068]I wanted to keep the teams fair and the competition pretty unpredictable, but I do see where you're coming from :)[/QUOTE] I dislike that every strong competitior for the girls is paired with a anchor it just proves the flaw with partner challenges

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;420344]Exactly deserves so let her fight for it not be handed.[/QUOTE] No way she could win with McKenzie, and with that cast Aneesa is handed a win out of anyone

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;420345]I dislike that every strong competitior for the girls is paired with a anchor it just proves the flaw with partner challenges[/QUOTE] I don't think any of the girls are necessarily anchors. None of them are absolutely awful. McKenzie, Laura, Aneesa, Beth, LaToya, Melinda, Jemmye, and even both Ashley/Jonna all have their bad moments but have their good ones too. I do agree with you that this is the flaw with partner Challenges. However, I just feel it would be boring watching a Sarah/Laurel or Cara Maria/Emily steamroll the competition. This is, I feel, the most fair and balanced cast I could come up with using that format.

[QUOTE=Youssarian;420359]I don't think any of the girls are necessarily anchors. None of them are absolutely awful. McKenzie, Laura, Aneesa, Beth, LaToya, Melinda, Jemmye, and even both Ashley/Jonna all have their bad moments but have their good ones too. I do agree with you that this is the flaw with partner Challenges. However, I just feel it would be boring watching a Sarah/Laurel or Cara Maria/Emily steamroll the competition. This is, I feel, the most fair and balanced cast I could come up with using that format.[/QUOTE] Melinda sucks McKenzie sucks LaToya isn't good Laura isn't good. But if there's a very strong cast like I had for my last rivals 3 then its not boring

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;420362]Melinda sucks McKenzie sucks LaToya isn't good Laura isn't good. But if there's a very strong cast like I had for my last rivals 3 then its not boring[/QUOTE] Well there never will be a very strong cast which I'm fine with.

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;420363]Well there never will be a very strong cast which I'm fine with.[/QUOTE] That's because you don't care about competition which is clear from your love of Devyn

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;420366]That's because you don't care about competition which is clear from your love of Devyn[/QUOTE] I do but I also like entertainment aka reality tv not ESPN

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;420362]Melinda sucks McKenzie sucks LaToya isn't good Laura isn't good. But if there's a very strong cast like I had for my last rivals 3 then its not boring[/QUOTE] Honestly, coming up with a realistic girls' cast for this Challenge was very hard. A lot of girls were done already and I don't think Laurel is doing the next one. There's no Emilee or Jasmine, which I could have very easily put on the cast, so I thought that would appease some people.

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;420368]I do but I also like entertainment aka reality tv not ESPN[/QUOTE] Smh just because there is a strong cast doesn't mean its a boring one......

In the end, I felt that the cast I created was the most realistic, competitive, and entertaining one I could create using that format. I'm glad to discuss it with other people and I love getting feedback on the casts I create but I don't like going on endless debates. I don't think there's a perfect cast out there and every one will have disagreements, which sometimes makes things interesting and can lead to forming better casts in the future.

[QUOTE=Youssarian;420372]In the end, I felt that the cast I created was the most realistic, competitive, and entertaining one I could create using that format. I'm glad to discuss it with other people and I love getting feedback on the casts I create but I don't like going on endless debates. I don't think there's a perfect cast out there and every one will have disagreements, which sometimes makes things interesting and can lead to forming better casts in the future.[/QUOTE] Realistically that's the problem there's just to much weak girls because the strong ones don't want to come back sadly

[QUOTE=Youssarian;420369]Honestly, coming up with a realistic girls' cast for this Challenge was very hard. A lot of girls were done already and I don't think Laurel is doing the next one. There's no Emilee or Jasmine, which I could have very easily put on the cast, so I thought that would appease some people.[/QUOTE] You did good glenn coco **** Challenge17 only wants to see Sarah, Emily, Cara Maria, Rachel, Cooke, Ev, Jodi, Mallory, KellyAnne, and Kimberly.

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;420379]You did good glenn coco **** Challenge17 only wants to see Sarah, Emily, Cara Maria, Rachel, Cooke, Ev, Jodi, Mallory, KellyAnne, and Kimberly.[/QUOTE] C'mon Challenge 17... no Ruthie?! ;)

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;420362]Melinda sucks McKenzie sucks LaToya isn't good Laura isn't good. But if there's a very strong cast like I had for my last rivals 3 then its not boring[/QUOTE] Honestly, aside from Melinda (who I'd say is closer to average than sucking), I don't know that it's fair to say the other suck. IMO, McKenzie never showed that she sucked. She wasn't a beast or anything, but it seemed like people talked about she was performing poorly but nothing she actually did supported that. She beat Nany in a legitimate wrestling match, and didn't do anything to hold her team back on any of the other missions. She gassed out a bit in her elimination, but she wasn't terrible by any means. Same with Laura. I'd bet Laura is a better competitor than what we've seen. I don't really care much about her though so I don't remember how she did on her last challenge. Latoya probably isn't that great, but she's got fight. Just my opinion. I liked the idea and the cast! I think it's a cool concept. (I know this is fantasy, so no use debating it much. Just my two cents!)

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;420379]You did good glenn coco **** Challenge17 only wants to see Sarah, Emily, Cara Maria, Rachel, Cooke, Ev, Jodi, Mallory, KellyAnne, and Kimberly.[/QUOTE] Not true, I like Nany Averey Arielle(sadly never coming) LaToya, Hailey Diem Jenn Paula. Not everyone I like is a good competitor but I mostly like good competitors. And you forgot Laurel