[QUOTE=Morris1721;406836]You're right too an extent as well, if fighting isn't taken into consideration, Tyrie would've only been the first male sent home on Rivals 2 because on The inferno 3 it was CT and on Rivals it was Adam.[/QUOTE]
I actually wasn't taking fighting into account, lol. So I was wrong nonetheless. In my defense, I was thinking in terms of going home episode 1. Granted, on neither Inferno 3 nor Rivals 1 was Tyrie ELIGIBLE to go home episode 1 so by the logic that really counts, he is part of that unfortunate club.
[QUOTE=JayTee;406892]Tyrie, Dunbar, Nate, Preston, Big Easy and Nick: who's the worst one of them all? Lol.[/QUOTE]
Preston is an good runner. Some of the challenges (the running ones) will cater to him.
Dunbar.. well he's gotten far some challenges. He's not the worst out of the bunch.
To be fair to Nate, we only saw him once, although he did do a horrible job.
I don't remember Nick at all- um my bad?
So I guess it's between Big easy and Tyrie. I would have to say they are equally as bad. Although I don't remember Nick, so maybe he's the worst one ha ha
[QUOTE=JayTee;406892]Tyrie, Dunbar, Nate, Preston, Big Easy and Nick: who's the worst one of them all? Lol.[/QUOTE]
Tyrie and Big Easy Lol
It depends because Preston is a long distance runner and he is smart according to cast members, the only thing about him is that he is not good in missions at all that doesn't evolve those two things so getting on the final would be the problem.
Dunbar if he is in shape its not that bad.
[QUOTE=JayTee;406892]Tyrie, Dunbar, Nate, Preston, Big Easy and Nick: who's the worst one of them all? Lol.[/QUOTE]
I have to say Tyrie is the worst. Several episode 1 finishes and no wins. Not even a single final in six seasons. Tyrie's best ever finish was episode 5 in The Island.
I actually never put Dunbar at the bottom of the pack. The only time in his six challenges when he finished before episode 7 was when Tyrie was his partner. He even won once. His team was Brad, Tori, Tyler, and himself. None of those people are good enough that they could have carried Dunbar to a final win.
Nate only had the one challenge so we don't really know just how terrible he is but he seems pretty terrible.
Preston is an awful athlete overall (he's just so skinny) but he has a few advantages. He's tall and has great balance. Plus he's a pretty great runner so if he could ever make it to a final (maybe on a team) he'd do well there.
Big Easy also has a lousy record but he's had some impressive elimination rounds. AND he threw all of Gauntlet III into chaos but his entire team was afraid to face him in a gauntlet.
I don't even remember nick. He was only on like 2 episodes of his Real World season and 3 episodes between 2 challenges. So he's only been on 5 episodes on MTV total. Who the hell is this guy?
Tyrie has had extremely bad luck. Half of his challenges have been partner challenges (and he wasn't winning [B]anything[/B] with the ones he had) & one that he could've possibly won, he had to leave early. The Island was The Island lol so Inferno 3 was the only one where he can really blame himself. I think he could do well in something individual, like another Duel or Free Agents. Or of course another team challenge.
Nick was garbage. Got beat by Ryan (-_____-) on the Duel 2 & got tossed around for a bit by Wes on the Ruins. I would like to see him back to see if he's improved any though. They let Emilee come back, why not? lol
Preston...no clue why he shows up or why they think he contributes something to anything.
Nate was only on one & rookie hazing exists so he would need to come back.
Dunbar is just middle of the pack. Needed a team show to win one (may be the case w/ Tyrie)
Big Easy IMO is the worst
[QUOTE=Henchum;406897]I have to say Tyrie is the worst. Several episode 1 finishes and no wins. Not even a single final in six seasons. Tyrie's best ever finish was episode 5 in The Island.
I actually never put Dunbar at the bottom of the pack. The only time in his six challenges when he finished before episode 7 was when Tyrie was his partner. He even won once. His team was Brad, Tori, Tyler, and himself. None of those people are good enough that they could have carried Dunbar to a final win.
Nate only had the one challenge so we don't really know just how terrible he is but he seems pretty terrible.
Preston is an awful athlete overall (he's just so skinny) but he has a few advantages. He's tall and has great balance. Plus he's a pretty great runner so if he could ever make it to a final (maybe on a team) he'd do well there.
Big Easy also has a lousy record but he's had some impressive elimination rounds. AND he threw all of Gauntlet III into chaos but his entire team was afraid to face him in a gauntlet.
[B]I don't even remember nick. He was only on like 2 episodes of his Real World season and 3 episodes between 2 challenges. So he's only been on 5 episodes on MTV total. Who the hell is this guy?[/[/B]QUOTE]
THIS ps, sorry, ugh quote fail
[QUOTE=JayTee;406892]Tyrie, Dunbar, Nate, Preston, Big Easy and Nick: who's the worst one of them all? Lol.[/QUOTE]
Tyrie seems bad just because of his political game. Despite being on several challenges already, he always seems to get the post rookie treatment of being thrown into the eliminations after the token rookie teams. Competitor wise, he's pretty average.
Dunbar was never bad really. He puts himself in decent spots to make it to the finals and competes fine. You could say he drafted his team in Cutthroat and won the whole thing.
Preston's political game is pretty good. So far in Free Agent and in Rivals II, he put himself in a position where no one is gunning for him because they think he is weak. He may be weak, but if he can sneak to the end and pull off a win (who knows what the eliminations will be), I would consider that a good player.
Eric's pretty bad, pretty much an anchor for the whole team. Because of this it has been shown people are scared to throw people against him (Duel, Gauntlet3), but inevitably, he's not going to make any money.
Nick hasn't really been on these shows enough to make prove himself or make strong relationships with others. Can't really say.
I love how people respond to WOAT questions and how we all mostly agree.
Who are our six Candidates for worst female of all time?
Casey and Jasmine come to mind... Based on record, I'm tempted to say Aneesa even though she's a staple of the show...
[QUOTE=Graphik;406899]Tyrie has had extremely bad luck. Half of his challenges have been partner challenges (and he wasn't winning anything with the ones he had) & one that he could've possibly won, he had to leave early. I think he could do well in another Duel or Free Agents.[/QUOTE]
I still would think Dunbar and even Preston would be better than him on a final.
Tyrie was on the inferno 3, Gauntlet 3 (Quit for his reasons) and the Island. In none of those 3 challenge he shine once by himself the partner is an excuse for him. Davis/Jasmine were not that bad, I still think he was the weakest link on both teams. Dunbar is better than Tyrie but he did quit on him because he knew he wasn't making far with him as a partner and he was getting pay the same if he left week 1 or week 3.
I give Tyrie a ton of credit for getting in the kind of shape he was for Rivals 2 given where he's come from. He actually looks in shape...unlike Easy who just looks like a fat guy in a skinny body.
I personally find Nick Brown hilarious. He was on what? 4 episodes of the real world and 3 episodes of the challenge? I don't recall him ever doing any hosting work for MTV...but he still goes on Spring Break and introduces himself as an "MTV Personality"...guy hasn't been on TV in 6 years. But what can I say...it's a movement.
Imagine being that place that but one year ago got CT and Johnny Bananas to come out and host spring break but the next year they get Nick Brown and Jay from Explosion.
[QUOTE=Henchum;406903]I love how people respond to WOAT questions and how we all mostly agree.
Who are our six Candidates for worst female of all time?
Casey and Jasmine come to mind... Based on record, I'm tempted to say Aneesa even though she's a staple of the show...[/QUOTE]
I wouldnt put Jasmine in Casey level lol
Casey level would be Naomi, Brooke,Katelynn,Shouvan,Collie and even Emilee. Jasmine has proven to be better than those girls in missions, really hasn't never hold her team back except for seasons 2 in the running puzzle mission and the eating one that Cancun almost won both but didn't cause of her.
I would put ana on the Casey level but we haven't seen much of her.
[QUOTE=PinkRose;406909]I wouldnt put Jasmine in Casey level lol
Casey level would be Naomi, Brooke,Katelynn,Shouvan,Collie and even [B]Emilee[/B]. Jasmine has proven to be better than those girls in missions, really hasn't never hold her team back except for seasons 2 in the running puzzle mission and the eating one that Cancun almost won but didn't cause of her.
I would put ana on the Casey level but we haven't seen much of her.[/QUOTE]
Emilee Fitzpatrick is perfect and I will not have her or her beautiful face slandered this way. (I kid...but not really)
[QUOTE=PinkRose;406905]I still would think Dunbar and even Preston would be better than him on a final.
Tyrie was on the inferno 3, Gauntlet 3 (Quit for his reasons) and the Island. In none of those 3 challenge he shine once by himself the partner is an excuse for him. Davis/Jasmine were not that bad, I still think he was the weakest link on both teams. Dunbar is better than Tyrie but he did quit on him because he knew he wasn't making far with him as a partner and he was getting pay the same if he left week 1 or week 3.[/QUOTE]
Read my entire comment.
[QUOTE=auldx;406911]Agreed with everyone except Emilee. And maybe Naomi.[/QUOTE]
Naomi is worse than jasmine look at the missions they compete against each other, Jasmine out performed her even Leroy say it on his live streams back on exes that Naomi was horrible while Jasmine can hold her own and don't hold anyone back.
The only thing Emilee have for herself on this show is that she is good at puzzles, but I don't see her being good judging by we have saw and I don't see her being good in a final running the way she does.
[QUOTE=toenails;406912]How exactly did Dunbar quit on Tyrie? Did he just not try in the elimination round?[/QUOTE]
Rumor is that he didn't try and fall down on purpose because he was getting the pay if he leave first he just wanted the appearance check after finding out Tyrie was his "rivals"...I think either him, tyrie or another cast memebr said it on a podcast or something like that
[QUOTE=Graphik;406899]Tyrie has had extremely bad luck. Half of his challenges have been partner challenges (and he wasn't winning [B]anything[/B] with the ones he had) & one that he could've possibly won, he had to leave early. The Island was The Island lol so Inferno 3 was the only one where he can really blame himself. I think he could do well in something individual, like another Duel or Free Agents. Or of course another team challenge.
Nick was garbage. Got beat by Ryan (-_____-) on the Duel 2 & got tossed around for a bit by Wes on the Ruins. I would like to see him back to see if he's improved any though. They let Emilee come back, why not? lol
Preston...no clue why he shows up or why they think he contributes something to anything.
Nate was only on one & rookie hazing exists so he would need to come back.
Dunbar is just middle of the pack. Needed a team show to win one (may be the case w/ Tyrie)
Big Easy IMO is the worst[/QUOTE]
You seem to forget that Nick had his hand broken by big easy
Dunbar is decent. He's not amazing, but he definitely holds his own.
I agree with PinkRose about Jasmine. She really is NOT that bad.
Is Colie really that bad? I mean she wasn't good but I don't recall her being one of the worst.
What about Johanna and Rachel Moyal? Also Katie, as much as I adore her, is really not that good of a competitor. And Cameran and Jisela were pretty bad, too.
[QUOTE=Youssarian;406921]Dunbar is decent. He's not amazing, but he definitely holds his own.
I agree with PinkRose about Jasmine. She really is NOT that bad.
Is Colie really that bad? I mean she wasn't good but I don't recall her being one of the worst.
What about Johanna and Rachel Moyal? Also Katie, as much as I adore her, is really not that good of a competitor. And Cameran and Jisela were pretty bad, too.[/QUOTE]
Rachel wasn't bad, she had the second best girl time in the ladder race behind Evelyn
[QUOTE=JayTee;406926]So I guess we have it settled that 2 interesting facts are that Big Easy is the worst guy challenger and Casey is the worst girl challenger lol[/QUOTE]
I would say that the worst girl is hands down Shauvon. Casey has done some pretty impressive stuff, she has made it to a final, and has housed 5 elimination rounds in one season. I put probably 3 girls lower than Casey. Sure she has been scared to do certain challenges, but I just remember on The Gauntlet III in the Over the Edge challenge, she actually did it and didn't DQ. Shauvon could have never done that.
Shauvon has competed in 6 challenges throughout 3 seasons. She was a part of the losing team on her only challenge on The Duel 2, DQ'd on both challenges on The Ruins, did decent on the first challenge on Cutthroat, and she didn't compete in the 2nd or 3rd challenge that season.
Worst 5 girls in Challenge history:
1. Shauvon
2. Naomi
3. Brooke
4. Casey
5. Katie
[QUOTE=El Scorcho;406928]
Worst 5 girls in Challenge history:
1. Shauvon
2. Naomi
3. Brooke
4. Casey
5. Katie[/QUOTE]
Katie isn't great by any means, but I definitely wouldn't put her in the bottom 5 either. Katie came out of The Inferno a champion, and she definitely earned it by winning 2 elimination rounds. Nobody can say she skated all the way through or got carried by the rest of her team that season. There are many others who are worse than her IMO. I would put Katelynn, Devyn, or even McKenzie on this list before her.
[QUOTE=CHIblackhawk;406934]Katie isn't great by any means, but I definitely wouldn't put her in the bottom 5 either. Katie came out of The Inferno a champion, and she definitely earned it by winning 2 elimination rounds. Nobody can say she skated all the way through or got carried by the rest of her team that season. There are many others who are worse than her IMO. I would put Katelynn, Devyn, or even McKenzie on this list before her.[/QUOTE]
Okay fair enough. Replace Katie with Katelynn.
[QUOTE=EstimatedRoa;406902]Tyrie seems bad just because of his political game. Despite being on several challenges already, he always seems to get the post rookie treatment of being thrown into the eliminations after the token rookie teams. Competitor wise, he's pretty average.
Dunbar was never bad really. He puts himself in decent spots to make it to the finals and competes fine. You could say he drafted his team in Cutthroat and won the whole thing.
Preston's political game is pretty good. So far in Free Agent and in Rivals II, he put himself in a position where no one is gunning for him because they think he is weak. He may be weak, but if he can sneak to the end and pull off a win (who knows what the eliminations will be), I would consider that a good player.
Eric's pretty bad, pretty much an anchor for the whole team. Because of this it has been shown people are scared to throw people against him (Duel, Gauntlet3), but inevitably, he's not going to make any money.
Nick hasn't really been on these shows enough to make prove himself or make strong relationships with others. Can't really say.[/QUOTE]
Competitor wise I would say Tyrie is average, Dunbar is above average, and the other 3 are pretty poor. Eric is probably the worse competitor of all time.
A couple of guys I would throw in there who have been on multiple challenges are Danny and Ryan. I liked Danny in his season and he always looks pretty athletic, but he always seems to have no impact whether it's a mission or an elimination. I can't recall him winning any elimination round.
As for the girls, I would say Shavon and Casey are the worst.
[QUOTE=EstimatedRoa;406946]Competitor wise I would say Tyrie is average, Dunbar is above average, and the other 3 are pretty poor. Eric is probably the worse competitor of all time.
A couple of guys I would throw in there who have been on multiple challenges are Danny and Ryan. I liked Danny in his season and he always looks pretty athletic, but he always seems to have no impact whether it's a mission or an elimination. I can't recall him winning any elimination round.
As for the girls, I would say Shavon and Casey are the worst.[/QUOTE]
Ryan Kehoe? I actually think he's half decent.
Come on guys. Stop getting off topic. This is the Interesting Facts thread. I don't want any more threads to get locked. Head over here for this discussion [URL]http://vevmo.com/f266/the-challenge-generic-thread-6026/index1598.html#post406891[/URL]
Pages