The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

16758 posts / 0 new
Last post
Battle of the Seasons II (technically 3) Road Rules - Derrick, Mark, Rachel, Tori San Diego - Brad, Zach, Robin, Priscilla Explosion - Cory, Brian, Jenny, Ashley M Portland - Johnny, Marlon, Nia, Averey DC - Ty, Mike, Emily, Erika Sydney - Isaac, Dunbar, Kellyanne, Shauvon Key West - Johnny, Tyler, Paula, Janelle Philadelphia - Landon, MJ, Shavonda, Melanie
[B]THE CHALLENGE: DUEL III[/B] [B]Location:[/B] Algarve, Portugal [B]Format:[/B] Hopefully BMP would change the format but still keep the classic Duel Selection Order but also incorporate the draw of cards in the game. Like maybe whoever draws an elimination card that, 1st nominated person can only pick them instead of anyone but the winner like in prior Duels. Also, keep the missions teams, pairs, and individuals. Just a thought... [B]Cast[/B] (adding the numbers because I like them having numbered jerseys, its a cool touch) 01. Nany 02. Brad 03. KellyAnne 04. Johnny 05. Jamie 06. Mark 07. Nia 08. Cory 09. Averey 10. Zach 11. LaToya 12. Jordan 13. Jessica 14. Thomas 15. Ashlee 16. Knight 17. Jasmine 18. Darrell 19. Hailey 20. Frank 21. Ayiiia 22. Wes 23. Jenny 24. Cohutta 25. Sarah 26. Brian 27. Jemmye 28. Marlon 29. Camila 30. Dustin [B]Alternates[/B] Tyler (RW: Key West) & Tyrie (RW: Denver) Joi (RW: Portland) & Laura (RW: St. Thomas)
[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;399926][B]THE CHALLENGE: DUEL III[/B] [B]Location:[/B] Algarve, Portugal [B]Format:[/B] Hopefully BMP would change the format but still keep the classic Duel Selection Order but also incorporate the draw of cards in the game. Like maybe whoever draws an elimination card that, 1st nominated person can only pick them instead of anyone but the winner like in prior Duels. Also, keep the missions teams, pairs, and individuals. Just a thought... [B]Cast[/B] 01. Nany 02. Brad 03. KellyAnne 04. Johnny 05. Jamie 06. Mark 07. Nia 08. Cory 09. Averey 10. Zach 11. LaToya 12. Jordan 13. Jessica 14. Thomas 15. Ashlee 16. Knight 17. Jasmine 18. Darrell 19. Hailey 20. Frank 21. Ayiiia 22. Wes 23. Jenny 24. Cohutta 25. Sarah 26. Brian 27. Jemmye 28. Marlon 29. Camila 30. Dustin [B]Alternates[/B] Tyler (RW: Key West) & Tyrie (RW: Denver) Joi (RW: Portland) & Laura (RW: St. Thomas)[/QUOTE] This is free agents not the duel......
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;399928]This is free agents not the duel......[/QUOTE] I like the numbers on the jerseys which is why I added them...
[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;399932]I like the numbers on the jerseys which is why I added them...[/QUOTE] But the problem is it is free agents its not a duel everything about those rules are free agents not duel. Plus pretty weak girls cast IMO a duel 3 should have only good competitors
[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;399926][B]THE CHALLENGE: DUEL III[/B] [B]Location:[/B] Algarve, Portugal [B]Format:[/B] Hopefully BMP would change the format but still keep the classic Duel Selection Order but also incorporate the draw of cards in the game. Like maybe whoever draws an elimination card that, 1st nominated person can only pick them instead of anyone but the winner like in prior Duels. Also, keep the missions teams, pairs, and individuals. Just a thought... [B]Cast[/B] (adding the numbers because I like them having numbered jerseys, its a cool touch) 01. Nany 02. Brad 03. KellyAnne 04. Johnny 05. Jamie 06. Mark 07. Nia 08. Cory 09. Averey 10. Zach 11. LaToya 12. Jordan 13. Jessica 14. Thomas 15. Ashlee 16. Knight 17. Jasmine 18. Darrell 19. Hailey 20. Frank 21. Ayiiia 22. Wes 23. Jenny 24. Cohutta 25. Sarah 26. Brian 27. Jemmye 28. Marlon 29. Camila 30. Dustin [B]Alternates[/B] Tyler (RW: Key West) & Tyrie (RW: Denver) Joi (RW: Portland) & Laura (RW: St. Thomas)[/QUOTE] The female cast is awful for a duel
[QUOTE=kvm1977;399938]The female cast is awful for a duel[/QUOTE] Thank you lol but I like it. Its realistic too imo
Realistic doesn't have to mean weak especially for a duel 3
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;399941]Realistic doesn't have to mean weak especially for a duel 3[/QUOTE] Well I guess my definition of weak is different from yours... for a Duel 3
[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;399943]Well I guess my definition of weak is different from yours... for a Duel 3[/QUOTE] Well you clearly have a to low definition of weak, there are all only 3 girls PROVEN to be strong competitiors and they are KellyAnne Sarah and Camilla. The rest suck like jasmine & Ayyiia or just average like Nany. Or rookies who we have no clue about
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;399946]Well you clearly have a to low definition of weak, there are all only 3 girls PROVEN to be strong competitiors and they are KellyAnne Sarah and Camilla. The rest suck like jasmine & Ayyiia or just average like Nany. Or rookies who we have no clue about[/QUOTE] Well thats your opinion. To each his own I guess. That's why this thread is fantasy right?
[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;399950]Well thats your opinion. To each his own I guess. That's why this thread is fantasy right?[/QUOTE] 17 is providing valid information that you're dismissing You're allowed to make whatever cast you want but you can't claim that's a strong female cast...that's complete nonsense
[QUOTE=kvm1977;399951]17 is providing valid information that you're dismissing You're allowed to make whatever cast you want but you can't claim that's a strong female cast...that's complete nonsense[/QUOTE] I didn't say it was strong nor did I say it was weak. I'm just simply responding to what he's saying. I'm sorry I don't have a cast like this Ev (never gonna happen) Rachel (whatever already happened) Cooke (never doing a challenge again so...) Emily (I just don't care for her) Paula (preggo/done) Laurel (ugh) Sarah KellyAnne Camila Theresa Coral (like she come back) Cara Maria (bye!) Baya (like this will happen EVER 17) and whoever else you guys consider strong!
[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;399954]I didn't say it was strong nor did I say it was weak. I'm just simply responding to what he's saying. I'm sorry I don't have a cast like this Ev (never gonna happen) Rachel (whatever already happened) Cooke (never doing a challenge again so...) Emily (I just don't care for her) Paula (preggo/done) Laurel (ugh) Sarah KellyAnne Camila Theresa Coral (like she come back) Cara Maria (bye!) Baya (like this will happen EVER 17) and whoever else you guys consider strong![/QUOTE] Baya could happen, she was going to be on seasons but you don't care about anyone who doesn't cause drama. And NOBODY was saying stuff like Evelyn or Coral we are saying a more athletic cast for girls would be good like Sarah,KellyAnne Camilla,Aneesa, Rachel, Ruthie throw in some rookies that could do good like Ashlee and Averey and some pretty good eye candy like Jonna Nany and Ashley K maybe some over dramatic people you love like Jemmye(to go first of course) and maybe some rookies who want a second chance like Laura or Heather
[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;399954]I didn't say it was strong nor did I say it was weak. I'm just simply responding to what he's saying. I'm sorry I don't have a cast like this Ev (never gonna happen) Rachel (whatever already happened) Cooke (never doing a challenge again so...) Emily (I just don't care for her) Paula (preggo/done) Laurel (ugh) Sarah KellyAnne Camila Theresa Coral (like she come back) Cara Maria (bye!) Baya (like this will happen EVER 17) and whoever else you guys consider strong![/QUOTE] You don't need all of them but you need some of them if you're going to do a duel The first two duel were wasted because there was only one strong female. The whole point of a duel, in the mind of mosts, is to determine the best of the best.
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;399956]Baya could happen, she was going to be on seasons but you don't care about anyone who doesn't cause drama. And NOBODY was saying stuff like Evelyn or Coral we are saying a more athletic cast for girls would be good like Sarah,KellyAnne Camilla,Aneesa, Rachel, Ruthie throw in some rookies that could do good like Ashlee and Averey and some pretty good eye candy like Jonna Nany and Ashley K maybe some over dramatic people you love like Jemmye(to go first of course) and maybe some rookies who want a second chance like Laura or Heather[/QUOTE] Of course you add Jonna. And off all those girls you named I had 8 of them. There is nothing wrong with having Jessica and Nia. You would have too add some Ex-Plosion girls on it if it was season 26. Jasmine and Ayiiia are simply fillers and drama which YES I DO LIKE AS MANY OTHERS DO! Its reality tv for god sake not the olympic hun! Competition shows will always have weak players, just get over it. The Duel 3 is not the end all, it never as been. If you want STRONG and ALL competition, have an All Stars seasons then. Now let me and my little cast be child!
[QUOTE=kvm1977;399957]You don't need all of them but you need some of them if you're going to do a duel The first two duel were wasted because there was only one strong female. The whole point of a duel, in the mind of mosts, is to determine the best of the best.[/QUOTE] What was the last season you liked Battle of the Sexes or Extreme lol
The Duel 3 Cory(Ex-plosion) Dustin(Las Vegas 2) Zach(San Diego 2) Andrew(DC) Bronne(Cancun) Thomas(Ex-plosion) Scott(Brooklyn) Knight(New Orleans 2) Brian(Ex-plosion) Johnny(Portland) Trey(St Thomas) Leroy(las Vegas 2) Issac(Sydney) Ashley(DC) Jenny(Ex-plosion) Latoya(St Thomas) Avery(Portland) Emilee(Cancun) Devyn(Brooklyn) Ashley M(Ex-Plosion) Jessica(Portland) Ashlee(New Orleans 2) Nany(Las Vegas 2) Cooke(Las Vegas 2) Jamie(Ex-Plosion) Ashley(San Diego 2)
[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;399960]What was the last season you liked Battle of the Sexes or Extreme lol[/QUOTE] Doesn't even make sense. I hated Seasons and I thought Rivals 2 should have been a different format with that cast but I like Cutthroat, Rivals & Exes to some degree.
[QUOTE=Debut Album;399961]The Duel 3 Cory(Ex-plosion) Dustin(Las Vegas 2) Zach(San Diego 2) Andrew(DC) Bronne(Cancun) Thomas(Ex-plosion) Scott(Brooklyn) Knight(New Orleans 2) Brian(Ex-plosion) Johnny(Portland) Trey(St Thomas) Leroy(las Vegas 2) Issac(Sydney) Ashley(DC) Jenny(Ex-plosion) Latoya(St Thomas) Avery(Portland) Emilee(Cancun) Devyn(Brooklyn) Ashley M(Ex-Plosion) Jessica(Portland) Ashlee(New Orleans 2) Nany(Las Vegas 2) Cooke(Las Vegas 2) Jamie(Ex-Plosion) Ashley(San Diego 2)[/QUOTE] Cooke wins by a mile and I thought livwithpeace had a terrible girls cast
[QUOTE=kvm1977;399963]Doesn't even make sense. I hated Seasons and I thought Rivals 2 should have been a different format with that cast but I like Cutthroat, Rivals & Exes to some degree.[/QUOTE] I just asked because you didn't like either Duels. Most people at least liked the first.
[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;399965]I just asked because you didn't like either Duels. Most people at least liked the first.[/QUOTE] I didn't like the lack of competition on the female sides Jodi & Rachel were locks from the beginning.
After seeing Kina on the Gauntlet 2, I thought she would do better, Jodi never did anything on a previous season that made her a lock for me (i.e. Inferno 2) and it would have been interesting if Tina had stuck around and did some elimination rounds.
[QUOTE=TheInfuerno;399968]After seeing Kina on the Gauntlet 2, I thought she would do better, Jodi never did anything on a previous season that made her a lock for me (i.e. Inferno 2) and it would have been interesting if Tina had stuck around and did some elimination rounds.[/QUOTE] I personally thought Diem was gonna win.
[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;399969]I personally thought Diem was gonna win.[/QUOTE] Yes and had Diem been in the final with Rachel on Duel 2 she MIGHT have slid by her, her being a runner and all.
[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;399969]I personally thought Diem was gonna win.[/QUOTE] If Diem could reach a final in a duel she'd be a threat...much like Jonna...but they aren't likely to get there as they aren't women that will do well in many eliminations
[QUOTE=kvm1977;399971]If Diem could reach a final in a duel she'd be a threat...much like Jonna...but they aren't likely to get there as they aren't women that will do well in many eliminations[/QUOTE] Well she got a ****** elimination in the first duel against Aneesa but whatever, she did lose fairly to Brit in Duel 2. And yes I agree, she gets way too in her head in eliminations (i.e. Rivals 2)
[B]NEW CHALLENGE FORMAT[/B] Individual challenge 15 men and 15 women 11 missions. 11 eliminations. Final 4 on each side Missions will be either individual, teams, same-sex partners, or guy/girl partners Teams and partners will be selected by drawing cards with your team color on it (just to spice up politics) because the winners of thats days challenge will select 2 men and 2 women to compete in the elimination I'd like to call "The Chosen". On guy/girl partner challenges the winning team MUST come to an agreeable decision on 2 men and 2 women to send in to "The Chosen". So technically they are choosing 4 people to go in. DRAMA. On same-sex partner and individual challenges its simple, guys chose 2 girls and girls choose 2 guys and they don't have to be teammates. This to me is the only way to stay safe is to win! Plus people can still have alliances and it keeps things interesting with teams switching up every other mission. So that way it won't get so predictable as to who goes in. Thoughts?
[QUOTE=kvm1977;399971]If Diem could reach a final in a duel she'd be a threat...much like Jonna...but they aren't likely to get there as they aren't women that will do well in many eliminations[/QUOTE] I will agree to that. Diem just gets wayyyyyyy to in her head in eliminations. Still bummed she didn't win Exes.
[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;399980][B]NEW CHALLENGE FORMAT[/B] Individual challenge 15 men and 15 women 11 missions. 11 eliminations. Final 4 on each side Missions will be either individual, teams, same-sex partners, or guy/girl partners Teams and partners will be selected by drawing cards with your team color on it (just to spice up politics) because the winners of thats days challenge will select 2 men and 2 women to compete in the elimination I'd like to call "The Chosen". On guy/girl partner challenges the winning team MUST come to an agreeable decision on 2 men and 2 women to send in to "The Chosen". So technically they are choosing 4 people to go in. DRAMA. On same-sex partner and individual challenges its simple, guys chose 2 girls and girls choose 2 guys and they don't have to be teammates. This to me is the only way to stay safe is to win! Plus people can still have alliances and it keeps things interesting with teams switching up every other mission. So that way it won't get so predictable as to who goes in. Thoughts?[/QUOTE] I kinda like it

Pages