The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

And I love KA, but no way she'd make it to the end over the other girls. I mean, Emily could only beat all the other girls if all the elimination rounds were purely physical and based off of size.

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;389359]Wes losing to big easy wasnt a surprise Wes hasn't worked out in years and gave up, and you of all people should know that was a cheap move by Brad. KellyAnne beating Rachel was legit.[/QUOTE] Point is if someone asked.. who'd win an elimination between Brad/Landon, KellyAnne/Rachel, EZ/Wes... etc... most people would bet on the losers because they don't think of the gray areas on these shows. Just because someone has proven to be "superior" doesn't make them a for sure win. Not by a long shot. I post my list not thinking about who'd win or lose, just who I think would be interesting to watch in a particular theme.

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;389367]Lol no way Averey would make the final over Evelyn Rachel Sarah Camilla or Laurel. I love her but let's be realistic[/QUOTE] You haven't seen her compete though...

[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;389369]And I love KA, but no way she'd make it to the end over the other girls. I mean, [B]Emily could [B]only[/B] beat all the other girls if all the elimination rounds were purely physical and based off of size.[/B][/QUOTE] I doubt she'd see an elimination in a Duel. At least not with that cast. She's friends with a lot of the top girls (Camila, Laurel, Rachel, Sarah, Cooke) and could possibly work with them and the others would probably be too intimidated to call her out. Plus she could definitely win some challenges. And saying "only" is pretty bold. The one challenge we did see her do that wasn't physical or based on size was hall pass on Exes and she won by a fairly big margin. KellyAnne could win a few of those eliminations and catch a lucky break if Rachel, Emily, Evelyn, Laurel, and Cooke called each other out.

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;389311]I'm assuming this is a gay joke about Marlon & Derek[/QUOTE] Oops, it completely wasn't at all. They were on the next line and I completely looked over them.

[QUOTE=TeamLandon;389377]I doubt she'd see an elimination in a Duel. At least not with that cast. She's friends with a lot of the top girls (Camila, Laurel, Rachel, Sarah, Cooke) and could possibly work with them and the others would probably be too intimidated to call her out. Plus she could definitely win some challenges. And saying "only" is pretty bold. The one challenge we did see her do that wasn't physical or based on size was hall pass on Exes and she won by a fairly big margin. KellyAnne could win a few of those eliminations and catch a lucky break if Rachel, Emily, Evelyn, Laurel, and Cooke called each other out.[/QUOTE] I was mainly pointing her out, because otherwise I can't see Ev or Rachel losing an elimination round. Yeah, maybe a few, but with Laurel, Ev, Rachel, Camila, Sarah there? The first 3 being far better than her, it just seems unlikely. She was also facing Paula who was VERY scared of Emily and physical contact. Every other elimination round has 100% been physical. But see one of those would have to win in the end and survive and I can't buy Ev/Rachel losing to any of the other girls (assuming the top tier girls took the others out).

Lol I understand where all of u are coming from. But I was being realistic and how about if laurel lost a challenge and was eliminated by ev?!?! And Averey earned and skated her way to the finale?

[QUOTE=boncat23;389384]Lol I understand where all of u are coming from. But I was being realistic and how about if laurel lost a challenge and was eliminated by ev?!?! And Averey earned and skated her way to the finale?[/QUOTE] Aneesa and Svetlana (two unlikely candidates) made it to a Duel final... so Averey making it isn't unrealistic or far fetched at all. Especially since we haven't seen her compete.

[QUOTE=boncat23;389366]**THE DUEL 3** Men Cory Jay Jordan Marlon Derrick Zach Dustin Swift Knight Ty Johnny B. Brad Abram Darrell Women Ashlee K Nany Cooke Emily Laurel Cara Maria Averey Rachel Theresa Nia Ev Kelly Anne Sarah Camila Elimination: 1. Knight 2. Camila 3. Jay 4. Cara Maria 5. Swift 6. Nany 7. Brad 8. Theresa 9. Marlon 10.Rachel 11.Cory 12.Sarah 13.Abram 14.Laurel 15.Zach 16.Nia 17.Derrick 18.Cooke 19.Ty 20.Ashlee K. 21.Jordan 22.Ev Finale Random Pairs. Darrell & Kellyanne Johnny B & Averey Dustin & Emily 3'rd Place: Darrell & Kellyanne 2'nd Place: Dustin & Emily 1'st Place: Johnny B & Averey[/QUOTE] I don't think Johnny B would get first, especially considering how poorly he did on the last final he competed in. He (and sadly Averey) would more likely be third.

[QUOTE=boncat23;389366]**THE DUEL 3** Men Cory Jay Jordan Marlon Derrick Zach Dustin Swift Knight Ty Johnny B. Brad Abram Darrell Women Ashlee K Nany Cooke Emily Laurel Cara Maria Averey Rachel Theresa Nia Ev Kelly Anne Sarah Camila Elimination: 1. Knight 2. Camila 3. Jay 4. Cara Maria 5. Swift 6. Nany 7. Brad 8. Theresa 9. Marlon 10.Rachel 11.Cory 12.Sarah 13.Abram 14.Laurel 15.Zach 16.Nia 17.Derrick 18.Cooke 19.Ty 20.Ashlee K. 21.Jordan 22.Ev Finale Random Pairs. Darrell & Kellyanne Johnny B & Averey Dustin & Emily 3'rd Place: Darrell & Kellyanne 2'nd Place: Dustin & Emily 1'st Place: Johnny B & Averey[/QUOTE] I know it is a fantasy challenge thread and all but I don't see how Darrell would get last place out of Johnny and Dustin. And Averey making the final over Evelyn, Cooke, Laurel, Rachel, and Sarah seems pretty unrealistic to me. And Dustin making the final over Derrick, Abram, and Zach seems unrealistic as well. Dustin is good, don't get me wrong but the one challenge he shined on was probably the weakest guys cast of any challenge we've seen to date.

[QUOTE=El Scorcho;389390]I know it is a fantasy challenge thread and all but I don't see how Darrell would get last place out of Johnny and Dustin. And Averey making the final over Evelyn, Cooke, Laurel, Rachel, and Sarah seems pretty unrealistic to me. And Dustin making the final over Derrick, Abram, and Zach seems unrealistic as well. Dustin is good, don't get me wrong but the one challenge he shined on was probably the weakest guys cast of any challenge we've seen to date.[/QUOTE] We've only seen Dustin really compete on 1, I think he could take out Abram and Zach in a few elimination games. Derrick can be taken out by Darrell, Johnny, and a few others as well. Not unrealistic for him to not make a final. And if they competed in pairs then you have to take into account how a pair interact and communicate with one another in a final. Johnny B's really good with his partners in those areas, Dustin handled Trishelle pretty well on BOTSeasons final. And judging based on the 1 final she did, I'd say KellyAnne isn't as good as Emily in a final, could also lead to Darrell losing to Dustin.

[QUOTE=Youssarian;389378]Oops, it completely wasn't at all. They were on the next line and I completely looked over them.[/QUOTE] Oh lol my bad

[QUOTE=boncat23;389384]Lol I understand where all of u are coming from. But I was being realistic and how about if laurel lost a challenge and was eliminated by ev?!?! And Averey earned and skated her way to the finale?[/QUOTE] Evelyn & Laurel are way to smart to call each other out. They would pick someone like Ashley K or Nia who they know they could beat. And Camilla being the first girl sent home, yeah right everyone knows she's tough I cant see anyone calling her Rachel Laurel or Evelyn out.

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;389393]Evelyn & Laurel are way to smart to call each other out. They would pick someone like Ashley K or Nia who they know they could beat. And Camilla being the first girl sent home, yeah right everyone knows she's tough I cant see anyone calling her Rachel Laurel or Evelyn out.[/QUOTE] The way the duels tend to work are the rookies get thrown in and the don't call out the vets as they attempt to prove themselves by eliminating the weaker competition. This would allow the vets to go further in the game where they would have the advantage and probably would pick on the other girls instead of calling out each other and risking elimination.

Exactly so unless Averey won every mission or beat Evelyn Laurel and Rachel then theses no way she's winning. People would pick her or KA to go against in a heart beat over Laurel Rachel and Evelyn

[QUOTE=CTRoyLeeFAN;389394]The way the duels tend to work are the rookies get thrown in and the don't call out the vets as they attempt to prove themselves by eliminating the weaker competition. This would allow the vets to go further in the game where they would have the advantage and probably would pick on the other girls instead of calling out each other and risking elimination.[/QUOTE] On Duel 2 Evan and Landon got called out. And rookie Kim took out Ruthie(who some people here claim to be an "elite" player). So it's not ridiculous nor is it unrealistic.

I like Issac but it was idiotic of him to pick Landon. And we have been over this Kim out smarted Ruthie, no way in **** any of theses girls is outsmarting Evelyn

What I was also saying is that the Vets won't call each other out which is true and the stronger players usually win the Duel games. The only surprise eliminations were Kimberly performing well in Duels and Brad beating Landon, so that does show that we can predict to an extent that the stronger players will beat the rookies. The only surprise on the Duel was CT losing to Brad, and Beth and Aneesa losing to Svet.

[QUOTE=CTRoyLeeFAN;389398]What I was also saying is that the Vets won't call each other out which is true and the stronger players usually win the Duel games. The only surprise eliminations were Kimberly performing well in Duels and Brad beating Landon, so that does show that we can predict to an extent that the stronger players will beat the rookies. The only surprise on the Duel was CT losing to Brad, and Beth and Aneesa losing to Svet.[/QUOTE] Agreed. People are really just trying to create scenarios where Avery would make a final, let alone with Ev, Rachel, Laurel, Camila, Emily S, Sarah. Given how close a few of these females are, I think they'd definitely start by either calling the rookies out or the rookies calling the vets out and most likely losing.

I think Averey could make a final but not with that stacked a female cast

The Challenge: TBD Four teams of new schoolers lead by an old school male/female pairing. [COLOR="#FF0000"][B]Team Ace and Veronica:[/B] Leroy Preston Zach Averey LaToya Nia[/COLOR] [COLOR="#0000FF"][B]Team Derrick and Coral:[/B] Jordan Marlon Mike M Erika Laura Marie[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FFD700"][B]Team Darrell and Rachel:[/B] Andrew Johnny R Ryan L Ashley K Devyn Jonna[/COLOR] [COLOR="#808080"][B]Team CT and Tina:[/B] Josh Mike R Swift Ashlee Joi Nany[/COLOR]

Battle of the seasons 2 Location Barcelona Spain- final in Antarctica 4 teams make the final comment on who they will be [COLOR="#FF0000"]Portland[/COLOR] Averey Nia Johnny R Jordan [COLOR="#00FF00"]Key West[/COLOR] Paula Janelle Tyler Johnny [COLOR="#0000FF"]Brooklyn[/COLOR] Sarah Baya Scott Ryan [B]Fresh Meat 2[/B] Laurel Theresa Noor Pete [COLOR="#800080"]Las Vegas 2[/COLOR] Nany Cooke Dustin Leroy [COLOR="#00FFFF"]Ex-plosion[/COLOR] Arielle Jenna Corey Jay [COLOR="#008000"]Sydney[/COLOR] KellyAnne Trisha Cohutta Issac [COLOR="#000080"]St Thomas [/COLOR] LaToya Marie Trey Swift

The Challenge: Battle of the Exes 2 Location: Monaco ---> Final in Paris and the French Alps Teams: [COLOR="#4B0082"]Chet & Mandi[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FFFF00"]Cohutta & KellyAnne[/COLOR] [COLOR="#00FF00"]Danny & Melinda[/COLOR] [COLOR="#0000FF"]Dustin & Cooke[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FF8C00"]Eric & Devyn[/COLOR] [COLOR="#8B4513"]Johnny D & Casey[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FF0000"]Johnny R & Averey[/COLOR] [B][COLOR="#000000"]Jordan & Sarah[/COLOR][/B] [COLOR="#800000"]Knight & Jemmye[/COLOR] [COLOR="#808080"]Leroy & Theresa[/COLOR] [COLOR="#00FF00"]Robb & Marie[/COLOR] [COLOR="#000080"]Swift & LaToya[/COLOR] [COLOR="#006400"]Ty & Paula[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FF0000"]Zach & Jonna[/COLOR] Final Teams: [COLOR="#000000"][B]Winners- Jordan & Sarah[/B][/COLOR] 2nd- [COLOR="#FF0000"]Zach & Jonna[/COLOR] 3rd- [COLOR="#808080"]Leroy & Theresa[/COLOR] 4th- [COLOR="#FFFF00"]Cohutta & KellyAnne[/COLOR] Elimination Order: 1. [COLOR="#00FF00"]Robb & Marie[/COLOR] 2. [COLOR="#000080"]Swift & LaToya[/COLOR] 3. [COLOR="#800000"]Knight & Jemmye[/COLOR] 4. [COLOR="#FF0000"]Johnny R & Averey[/COLOR] 5. [COLOR="#FF8C00"]Eric & Devyn[/COLOR] 6. [COLOR="#4B0082"]Chet & Mandi[/COLOR] 7. [COLOR="#00FF00"]Danny & Melinda[/COLOR] 8. [COLOR="#006400"]Ty & Paula[/COLOR] 9. [COLOR="#8B4513"]Johnny D & Casey[/COLOR] 10. [COLOR="#0000FF"]Dustin & Cooke[/COLOR]

Can you put who faced who, it makes it easier to see how things go. Because I can't see Eric & Devyn or Danny & Melinda lasting so long

I could see Cohutta and Kellyanne winning it.

Best friends challenge Guy/Girl pairs Paula/Evan Trisha/Johnny B Tyler/Jenn Jonna/Frank Jemmye/Marlon Wes/Evenlyn Emilee/Derek Tori/Derek Brandon/Caramaria Melinda/Knight Emily/Jordan Derrick/Kina Brad/Svet Katie/Eric

[QUOTE=LurkerNoMore;389405]The Challenge: TBD Four teams of new schoolers lead by an old school male/female pairing. [COLOR="#FF0000"][B]Team Ace and Veronica:[/B] Leroy Preston Zach Averey LaToya Nia[/COLOR] [COLOR="#0000FF"][B]Team Derrick and Coral:[/B] Jordan Marlon Mike M Erika Laura Marie[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FFD700"][B]Team Darrell and Rachel:[/B] Andrew Johnny R Ryan L Ashley K Devyn Jonna[/COLOR] [COLOR="#808080"][B]Team CT and Tina:[/B] Josh Mike R Swift Ashlee Joi Nany[/COLOR][/QUOTE] wow this would be an interesting challenge!! i like it haha...

[QUOTE=JEKFAN;389426]Best friends challenge Guy/Girl pairs Paula/Evan Trisha/Johnny B Tyler/Jenn Jonna/Frank Jemmye/Marlon Wes/Evenlyn Emilee/Derek Tori/Derek Brandon/Caramaria Melinda/Knight Emily/Jordan Derrick/Kina Brad/Svet Katie/Eric[/QUOTE] I'd put Tyler & Paula instead of Evan & Paula because he's closer to her then Evan

The Challenge: Cutthroat II Bregenz, Austria [COLOR="#FF0000"][B]Red Team:[/B] CJ Darrell Frank R Zach M Zach N Ashley L Carley Joi Laura Sahar[/COLOR] [COLOR="#0000FF"][B]Blue Team:[/B] Derek M Eric P Jordan Knight Wes Cooke Heather Jenna Marie Nia [/COLOR] [COLOR="#808080"][B]Grey Team:[/B] Cohutta Frank S Isaac Jay Thomas Ashlee Ashley K Baya Hailey Jonna[/COLOR] I got really bored so I decided to add a visual. Cast doesn't look half bad in my opinion, but I'm sure many of you will think otherwise due to the lack of big names and heavy hitters. [ATTACH]3520[/ATTACH]

Honestly I like how much effort you put into it. But the cast isn't great