The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

[QUOTE=kvm1977;380871]Best friends would create more drama than Rivals because with Rivals those best friends are on separate teams and therefore they create a natural alliance.[/QUOTE] oh wow! i never even thought of it like that! that would be a fun season!

Battle of the Teammates Teams of 4, where every member has been a teammate with every other member at some point on past challenges. Game format would be same as Battle of the Seasons 2 Team 1 (Gauntlet 2 - Team Rookies) Alton Williams Jodi Weatherton Kina Dean Landon Lueck Team 2 (Inferno 2 - Team Bad *****) Abram Boise Derrick Kosinski Rachel Robinson Veronica Portillo Team 3 (Cutthroat - Red Team) Brad Fiorenza Camila Nakagawa Tori Fiorenza Tyler Duckworth Team 4 (Gauntlet 3 - Team Veterans) Adam King CT Tamburello Coral Smith Diem Brown Team 5 (Inferno 3 - Team Good Guys) Ace Amerson Cara Zavaleta Johnny Devenanzio Susie Meister Team 6 (The Ruins - Team Challengers) Chet Cannon Cohutta Grindstaff KellyAnne Judd Sarah Rice Team 7 (BOTS 2 - Team St. Thomas) Laura Waller Marie Roda Robb Schreiber Trey Weatherholtz Team 8 (The Gauntlet - Team Road Rules) Darrell Taylor Katie Doyle Theo Von Tina Barta

[CENTER][U]Battle of the Seasons 2[/U] [/CENTER] in [I]Cape Town & Somerset West, South Africa[/I] [CENTER][B]MEN[/B] Brad Fiorenza, Real World: San Diego (2004) Brandon Nelson, Fresh Meat II Cohutta Grindstaff, Real World: Sydney Darrell Taylor, Road Rules: Campus Crawl Derrick Kosinski, Road Rules: X-Treme Dunbar Merrill, Real World: Sydney Dustin Zito, Real World: Las Vegas (2011) Frank Sweeney, Real World: San Diego (2011) Jay Gotti, Real World: San Francisco (2014) Johnny Devenanzio, Real World: Key West Johnny Riley, Real World: Portland Jordan Wiseley, Real World: Portland Leroy Garrett, Real World: Las Vegas (2011) Thomas Buell, Real World: San Francisco (2014) Tyler Duckworth, Real World: Key West Vinny Foti, Real World: Key West [B]WOMEN[/B] Ashli Robson, Real World: Sydney Averey Tressler, Real World: Portland Cara Maria Sorbello, Fresh Meat II Heather Cooke, Real World: Las Vegas (2011) Jamie Larson, Real World: San Francisco (2014) Jenna Compono, Real World: San Francisco (2014) KellyAnne Judd, Real World: Sydney Laurel Stucky, Fresh Meat II Naomi Defensor, Real World: Las Vegas (2011) Nia Moore, Real World: Portland Paula Meronek, Real World: Key West Rachel Robinson, Road Rules: Campus Crawl Robin Hibbard-Coulter, Real World: San Diego (2004) Sam McGinn, Real World: San Diego (2011) Svetlana Shusterman, Real World: Key West Veronica Portillo, Road Rules: Semester at Sea[/CENTER] [B][U][CENTER]Teams[/CENTER][/U][/B] [CENTER][COLOR="#ADD8E6"]Fresh Meat Brandon- Cara Maria- Laurel- Vinny[/COLOR] [COLOR="#B22222"]Key West Johnny- Paula- Svetlana- Tyler[/COLOR] [COLOR="#000080"]Las Vegas Cooke- Dustin- Naomi- Leroy[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FF0000"]Portland Averey- Johnny R.- Jordan- Nia[/COLOR] [COLOR="#0000FF"]Road Rules Darrell- Derrick- Rachel- Veronica[/COLOR] [COLOR="#808080"]San Diego Brad- Frank- Robin- Sam[/COLOR] [COLOR="#008000"]San Francisco Jamie- Jay- Jenna- Thomas[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FFFF00"]Sydney Ashli- Cohutta- Dunbar- KellyAnne[/COLOR] Whats your elimination order? [/CENTER]

alaska94--replace Diem with Beth and I love it

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;380989][CENTER][U]Battle of the Seasons 2[/U] [/CENTER] in [I]Cape Town & Somerset West, South Africa[/I] [CENTER][B]MEN[/B] Brad Fiorenza, Real World: San Diego (2004) Brandon Nelson, Fresh Meat II Cohutta Grindstaff, Real World: Sydney Darrell Taylor, Road Rules: Campus Crawl Derrick Kosinski, Road Rules: X-Treme Dunbar Merrill, Real World: Sydney Dustin Zito, Real World: Las Vegas (2011) Frank Sweeney, Real World: San Diego (2011) Jay Gotti, Real World: San Francisco (2014) Johnny Devenanzio, Real World: Key West Johnny Riley, Real World: Portland Jordan Wiseley, Real World: Portland Leroy Garrett, Real World: Las Vegas (2011) Thomas Buell, Real World: San Francisco (2014) Tyler Duckworth, Real World: Key West Vinny Foti, Real World: Key West [B]WOMEN[/B] Ashli Robson, Real World: Sydney Averey Tressler, Real World: Portland Cara Maria Sorbello, Fresh Meat II Heather Cooke, Real World: Las Vegas (2011) Jamie Larson, Real World: San Francisco (2014) Jenna Compono, Real World: San Francisco (2014) KellyAnne Judd, Real World: Sydney Laurel Stucky, Fresh Meat II Naomi Defensor, Real World: Las Vegas (2011) Nia Moore, Real World: Portland Paula Meronek, Real World: Key West Rachel Robinson, Road Rules: Campus Crawl Robin Hibbard-Coulter, Real World: San Diego (2004) Sam McGinn, Real World: San Diego (2011) Svetlana Shusterman, Real World: Key West Veronica Portillo, Road Rules: Semester at Sea[/CENTER] [B][U][CENTER]Teams[/CENTER][/U][/B] [CENTER][COLOR="#ADD8E6"]Fresh Meat Brandon- Cara Maria- Laurel- Vinny[/COLOR] [COLOR="#B22222"]Key West Johnny- Paula- Svetlana- Tyler[/COLOR] [COLOR="#000080"]Las Vegas Cooke- Dustin- Naomi- Leroy[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FF0000"]Portland Averey- Johnny R.- Jordan- Nia[/COLOR] [COLOR="#0000FF"]Road Rules Darrell- Derrick- Rachel- Veronica[/COLOR] [COLOR="#808080"]San Diego Brad- Frank- Robin- Sam[/COLOR] [COLOR="#008000"]San Francisco Jamie- Jay- Jenna- Thomas[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FFFF00"]Sydney Ashli- Cohutta- Dunbar- KellyAnne[/COLOR] Whats your elimination order? [/CENTER][/QUOTE] You gave every team a clear weak link aside from road rules

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;380991]You gave every team a clear weak link aside from road rules[/QUOTE] Who's the weak link on Key West...three of them have won multiple challenges and the other made a final in her only appearance.

My bad I didn't see key west

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;380991]You gave every team a clear weak link aside from road rules[/QUOTE] Well I mean Veronica could kinda be that weak link for Road Rules lol. She wasn't that great on The Ruins! Who is the weak link on Portland? Nia?

I hope Avery & Johnny R are good but I don't think they will be

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;381001]I hope Avery & Johnny R are good but I don't think they will be[/QUOTE] I couldn't pick Averey out of a lineup of 2 people but I was under the impression she was athletic.

She was a college volleyball player and I want her to do well but something is telling me she won't be

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;381009]She was a college volleyball player and I want her to do well but something is telling me she won't be[/QUOTE] I think if she was on a challenge like this with that team- Team Portland would have a HUGE chance! Buttttt they need to change the rules to 4 vs. 4 eliminations (Arenas) every 2 challenges. It could be 1. Power team challenge (Power team nominates one team, then the other teams cast one vote for another team.) 2. Life shield challenge (If your nominated and win the Life shield you are safe and get to pick another team but the Power Team to go in) Then the Arena is team of 4 vs. team of 4 and loser goes home (ALL OF THEM) Then repeat :)

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;381015]I think if she was on a challenge like this with that team- Team Portland would have a HUGE chance! Buttttt they need to change the rules to 4 vs. 4 eliminations (Arenas) every 2 challenges. It could be 1. Power team challenge (Power team nominates one team, then the other teams cast one vote for another team.) 2. Life shield challenge (If your nominated and win the Life shield you are safe and get to pick another team but the Power Team to go in) Then the Arena is team of 4 vs. team of 4 and loser goes home (ALL OF THEM) Then repeat :)[/QUOTE] An eight person elimination round just seems like a big ole mess to me...

[QUOTE=Youssarian;381018]An eight person elimination round just seems like a big ole mess to me...[/QUOTE] I agree

[QUOTE=Youssarian;381018]An eight person elimination round just seems like a big ole mess to me...[/QUOTE] If they did something like the Island or like on Survivor where they have an Immunity type challenge, it might be pretty cool!

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;380838]I like it, would eliminations be old vs new?[/QUOTE] Yes. Team vs Team.

[QUOTE=Youssarian;381018]An eight person elimination round just seems like a big ole mess to me...[/QUOTE] Not nessecarily it depends on the kind of elimination they do. Like maybe Buried Alive.

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;381031]Not nessecarily it depends on the kind of elimination they do. Like maybe Buried Alive.[/QUOTE] Sorry, I don't think it works. I'm still trying to picture TJ explaining that

And how would physical eliminations work if 8 people did it

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;381036]And how would physical eliminations work if 8 people did it[/QUOTE] Plenty of options. Royal Rumble type like on gauntlet 2, Rolling on a River like on Gauntlet 1, Dead Mans Drop like BOTSexes/Gauntlet.. plenty of cool ways to do it!

[QUOTE=kvm1977;381032]Sorry, I don't think it works. I'm still trying to picture TJ explaining that[/QUOTE] It could one male and female from each team is buried and the other male and female find them and then they all solve a puzzle! Its pretty simple!

[QUOTE=kvm1977;381032]Sorry, I don't think it works. I'm still trying to picture TJ explaining that[/QUOTE] He does a bad enough job already explaining the missions so I see your point

[QUOTE=challenge13;381047]He does a bad enough job already explaining the missions so I see your point[/QUOTE] They'd spend an entire day trying to film his 5 minute explanation of the challenge

[QUOTE=kvm1977;381049]They'd spend an entire day trying to film his 5 minute explanation of the challenge[/QUOTE] Really???? I don't think he does bad. I like him more than I liked Dave Mira! He was horrible!

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;381050]Really???? I don't think he does bad. I like him more than I liked Dave Mira! He was horrible![/QUOTE] I like TJ but, from the cast members, they do countless takes of him "explaining things" because he keeps screwing them up Nothing against TJ at all though I thought Moseley was slightly better. I still think they should convince Coral to be the host

[QUOTE=kvm1977;381051]I like TJ but, from the cast members, they do countless takes of him "explaining things" because he keeps screwing them up Nothing against TJ at all though I thought Moseley was slightly better. I still think they should convince Coral to be the host[/QUOTE] No! TJ is fine and Coral can host reunions!

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;381053]No! TJ is fine and Coral can host reunions![/QUOTE] I'm sorry--I'd love to see Coral call people out immediately following an elimination...maybe that's just me. TJ's good but give me someone that has done the show that will be brutally honest

I really want Coral to do the aftershows and reunions to call out people. Just re-watched the reunion of fresh meat 1 and she made Kenny look like little schoolboy.

I don't think a host of the actual show should call out people - it's their job to remain neutral and simply explain the rules, keep the show going, etc. Now, for a reunion show, get someone like Coral on there who will call everyone out.

[QUOTE=Youssarian;381103]I don't think a host of the actual show should call out people - it's their job to remain neutral and simply explain the rules, keep the show going, etc. Now, for a reunion show, get someone like Coral on there who will call everyone out.[/QUOTE] I disagree. I liked when TJ called out CT and Diem on Exes. I never feel as if TJ is picking side, but he just wants to see good competition. Remember when Evelyn lost in fresh meat 2? She deserved to be called out the way she acted.