[QUOTE=ellethevegan;327057]Okay I see.. what's Paula's excuse? What makes her best of the best?[/QUOTE]
I wouldn't necessarily include Paula. I think Paula would get destroyed by most people.
Emily, Evelyn, Laurel, Rachel, Aneesa, KellyAnne, Tori, Sarah, Camila, Theresa (I know she hasn't proven much but there's potential there IMO) and then 2 newbies Ashlee (NOLA2) and Cooke (Vegas 2) would probably be my ideal/dream cast for the women.
People like Coral aren't going to do an individual competition--it doesn't play to their strengths.
[QUOTE=kvm1977;327061]I wouldn't necessarily include Paula. I think Paula would get destroyed by most people.
Emily, Evelyn, Laurel, Rachel, Aneesa, KellyAnne, Tori, Sarah, Camila, Theresa (I know she hasn't proven much but there's potential there IMO) and then 2 newbies Ashlee (NOLA2) and Cooke (Vegas 2) would probably be my ideal/dream cast for the women.
People like Coral aren't going to do an individual competition--it doesn't play to their strengths.[/QUOTE]
I think Theresa has shown that she is very capable on many occasions so I agree that there is potential there.
-She steamrolled Jillian on Fresh Meat 2 in the log challenge. I don't think that Ryan and Theresa's domination over Jill and Pete was due to Ryan overpowering Pete.
-Fought off Jenn in the obstacle course and was the only female there to move more logs than her male partner(Ryan).
-Held her own in the exile while Ryan was the one that needed breaks.
Her partnership with Camila was cut short on Rivals but I think had they stayed, they would've been a force to be reckoned with.
I am interested in seeing what she has to offer as well.
[QUOTE=ellethevegan;327057]Okay I see.. what's Paula's excuse? What makes her best of the best?[/QUOTE]
Won Rivals, made 4 finals. She's not the greatest competitor ever but she deserves to be in a Duel 3.
[QUOTE=ChallengeGod;327086]Won Rivals, made 4 finals. She's not the greatest competitor ever but she deserves to be in a Duel 3.[/QUOTE]
Well she skated by on 2 of those challenges. In fact, she skates by on most and gets by due to her friends. She also won 1 challenge out of 9 definitely not good. I want a Best of the Best for the Duel 3 and Paula would definitely not make the cut.
[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;327088]Well she skated by on 2 of those challenges. In fact, she skates by on most and gets by due to her friends. She also won 1 challenge out of 9 definitely not good. I want a Best of the Best for the Duel 3 and Paula would definitely not make the cut.[/QUOTE]
Where did she skate by? Inferno 3 she was the best girl on the Good Guys team and beat Aneesa in an elimination, Gauntlet 3 she beat Katie, The Island she actually won a key and wasnt just handed one by winning a vote, and Rivals she and Ev dominated. She is definitely one of the best 13 active girls.
[QUOTE=ChallengeGod;327093]Where did she skate by? Inferno 3 she was the best girl on the Good Guys team and beat Aneesa in an elimination, Gauntlet 3 she beat Katie, The Island she actually won a key and wasnt just handed one by winning a vote, and Rivals she and Ev dominated. She is definitely one of the best 13 active girls.[/QUOTE]
Are you serious with the Island? Jenn and her partner helped Paula win to secure Jenn a spot in returning. In fact, was probably the worst girl there in that face-off. Yes, she defeated Katie, but at that point Katie was a joke of a competitor. Nothing to brag about. I'd say Ev, Rachel, Laurel, Emily, Kellyanne, Camila, Sarah, Diem, Tori, Kimberly are better than her. There is a reason why it took her 9 challenges and a partner like Ev to finally win.
[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;327100]Are you serious with the Island? Jenn and her partner helped Paula win to secure Jenn a spot in returning. In fact, was probably the worst girl there in that face-off. Yes, she defeated Katie, but at that point Katie was a joke of a competitor. Nothing to brag about. I'd say Ev, Rachel, Laurel, Emily, Kellyanne, Camila, Sarah, Diem, Tori, Kimberly are better than her. There is a reason why it took her 9 challenges and a partner like Ev to finally win.[/QUOTE]
But at least she won a key and was strong in alliance- Jenn and Robin were much less deserving to be in the finals than Paula. And she was 1 of 2 girls on the vets team that made the finals to go into an elimination, so she regarded by the rooks as one of the best 3 girls with Coral and Ev. And you only named 10 girls better than her, the duel has at least 13 people. Also it took Paula 8 challenges to win, not that it makes a difference.
[QUOTE=ChallengeGod;327102]But at least she won a key and was strong in alliance- Jenn and Robin were much less deserving to be in the finals than Paula. And she was 1 of 2 girls on the vets team that made the finals to go into an elimination, so she regarded by the rooks as one of the best 3 girls with Coral and Ev. And you only named 10 girls better than her, the duel has at least 13 people. Also it took Paula 8 challenges to win, not that it makes a difference.[/QUOTE]
I can list others if you'd like. It'd just be questionable since they are still new. My point still stands that it took Paula that long to win with an amazing partner. I'd much rather see CM, Nany, Marie, or Theresa in the Duel 3.
[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;327103]I can list others if you'd like. It'd just be questionable since they are still new. My point still stands that it took Paula that long to win with an amazing partner. I'd much rather see CM, Nany, Marie, or Theresa in the Duel 3.[/QUOTE]
So with your argument you're saying CT, Brad, Diem and Sarah shouldn't be included because they either haven't won yet or it took them forever to win. Winning a challenge takes a lot of luck, if Big Easy wouldn't have passed out on G3 she would have won on her 3rd challenge and her team barely lost on I3. Nehimiah and Dunbar are champions and CT still isn't. Just because you've won doesn't mean you're great, it's much more impressive to make 4 out of 9 finals than to say win 2 out of 9 times but only make the finals twice. And I would actually like you to name more because you actually only named 9 active since Ev is retired and it could also be argued that Kim isn't active and Paulas better than her.
[QUOTE=ChallengeGod;327104]So with your argument you're saying CT, Brad, Diem and Sarah shouldn't be included because they either haven't won yet or it took them forever to win. Winning a challenge takes a lot of luck, if Big Easy wouldn't have passed out on G3 she would have won on her 3rd challenge and her team barely lost on I3. Nehimiah and Dunbar are champions and CT still isn't. Just because you've won doesn't mean you're great, it's much more impressive to make 4 out of 9 finals than to say win 2 out of 9 times but only make the finals twice. And I would actually like you to name more because you actually only named 9 active since Ev is retired and it could also be argued that Kim isn't active and Paulas better than her.[/QUOTE]
Paula has really only been screwed that one time with Eric and on FM2 with Jeff. Every other time it was her fault.
If we are just talking about current girls then Paula would make the cut due to the fact that we don't have as many impressive ladies. I would still say Kim is better than Paula.
[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;327107]Paula has really only been screwed that one time with Eric and on FM2 with Jeff. Every other time it was her fault.
If we are just talking about current girls then Paula would make the cut due to the fact that we don't have as many impressive ladies. I would still say Kim is better than Paula.[/QUOTE]
So it was her fault she didn't win the Inferno 3? It was her fault she was on the ****ty boat on The Island? I'm not saying she was screwed those times, but it's not like she had anything to do with her team losing. She's had a lot of bad luck.
[QUOTE=ChallengeGod;327108]So it was her fault she didn't win the Inferno 3? It was her fault she was on the ****ty boat on The Island? I'm not saying she was screwed those times, but it's not like she had anything to do with her team losing. She's had a lot of bad luck.[/QUOTE]
It's not bad luck when you ally with Johnny and Kenny.
[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;327109]It's not bad luck when you ally with Johnny and Kenny.[/QUOTE]
What does that have to do with anything? She probably wouldn't even have made the finals of The Island without them and they helped her a lot on Rivals.
Inferno 4: Insiders vs Outsiders
Basically just have a team of JEK and people they usually align with against people that are usually against them or at least not with them. No chance of this being a real season at least for a while but a decent concept I think.
Insiders
Kenny
Bananas
Evan
Derrick
Mark
Dunbar
Abe
Tyler
Paula
Sarah
Jenn (if she came back)
Laurel
Camila
Cara Maria
Johanna (if she came back)
Robin
Outsiders
CT
Landon
Leroy
Nehimiah
Wes
Zach
Frank
Ty
Ev (if she came back)
Emily
Rachel
Tonya (I have a feeling she would be very motivated)
Susie (again if she came back)
Kelly Anne
Nany
Jonna
Maybe Townie can correct me if I am wrong, but it does seem that CT and Johnny+ Kenny are pretty good friends now. I do think that if CT does another challenge with one of them, he would join them.
[B][U]RW/RR Challenge: Extreme Elimination[/U][/B]
Only challengers who've been in a elimination round can participate in this challenge. The Aces team can only contain challengers who've won three or more elimination rounds and the Jokers team contain challengers who've only won two or less or nothing at all like Danny from RW: Austin who's 0-6 lol. Poor guy.
[B][U]Aces[/U][/B]
Alton (RW: Las Vegas)
Frank (RW: Las Vegas)
Brad (RW: San Diego)
Landon (RW: Philadelphia)
Wes (RW: Austin)
Derrick (RR: X-Treme)
Kenny (FM)
Aneesa (RW: Chicago)
Svetlana (RW: Key West)
Emily (RW: DC)
Susie (RR: Down Under)
Jillian (RR: X-Treme)
Casey (FM)
Laurel (FM2)
[B][U]Jokers[/U][/B]
Mike "The Miz" (RW: B2 New York)
Leroy (RW: B2 Las Vegas)
Zach (RW: B2 San Diego)
Mark (RR: First Adventure)
Theo (RR: MVT)
Abram (RR: South Pacific)
Pete (FM2)
Coral (RW: B2 New York)
Kelly-Anne (RW: Sydney)
Holly (RR: Latin America)
Rachel (RR: Campus Crawl)
Christina (RR: South Pacific)
Jodi (RR: X-Treme)
Carley (FM2)
This Challenge season I've come up with doesn't have a name yet, but the format would consist of a Contenders Vs. Pretenders. Basically the Contenders team would consistent of Challengers who've made it to finals, but never won one and the Pretenders team would consistent of Challengers who've never ever seen a final. Basically its almost like the Ruins, but without any Champions. It gives a bunch of people who haven't won before a chance to finally win one.
[B][U]Contenders[/U][/B]
CT (RW: Paris)
Adam (RW: Paris)
Ty (RW: DC)
Leroy (RW: B2 Las Vegas)
Dustin (RW: B2 Las Vegas)
Pete (FM2)
Ruthie (RW: Hawaii)
Jenn (RW: Denver)
Kelly-Anne (RW: Sydney)
Sarah (RW: Brooklyn)
Emily (RW: DC)
Laurel (FM2)
[B][U]Pretenders[/U][/B]
Danny (RW: Austin)
Tyrie (RW: Denver)
CJ (RW: Cancun)
Shane (RR: Campus Crawl)
Derek (RR: Viewers Revenge)
Brandon (FM2)
Beth (RW: Los Angeles)
Jemmye (RW: B2 New Orleans)
Nany (RW: B2 Las Vegas)
Marie (RW: St. Thomas)
Chanda (FM)
Theresa (FM2)
[QUOTE=ChallengeGod;327111]Inferno 4: Insiders vs Outsiders
Basically just have a team of JEK and people they usually align with against people that are usually against them or at least not with them. No chance of this being a real season at least for a while but a decent concept I think.
Susie (again if she came back)
[/QUOTE]
Susie's a tough call on this because Johnny hates her but she absolutely was aligned with Evan, Derrick & Kenny during Rivals. I'd have her with that group more than against it.
[QUOTE=ViewRam90;327123]Susie was not part of the Rivals cast.[/QUOTE]
Ruins not Rivals--not sure why I do that but I seem to always write Rivals when I mean Ruins
[QUOTE=GDInstall;327114]Maybe Townie can correct me if I am wrong, but it does seem that CT and Johnny+ Kenny are pretty good friends now. I do think that if CT does another challenge with one of them, he would join them.[/QUOTE]
True but I still think for the challenge I made he would still be on the Outsiders team.
[QUOTE=kvm1977;327122]Susie's a tough call on this because Johnny hates her but she absolutely was aligned with Evan, Derrick & Kenny during Rivals. I'd have her with that group more than against it.[/QUOTE]
Ya you could make a case either way for her. Thinking about it since it's called Insiders vs Outsiders and she's always been in the dominant alliance I might put her on the Insiders too.
Battle of the Champions
Basically the only rule is everyone on the cast has at least 1 challenge win before. You could do it Duel style, or split them up into 2 teams. One team of people with multiple wins, one team of people with just one win.
THE CHALLENGE: Battle Grounds
Old School vs New School
Format: Two teams one with competitors who have done 4 or more challenges they will be the Old School team vs the New School team who's competitors have been on 3 or less challenges. Before each mission each team will nominate 2 team captains 1 guy/1 girl the winning team captains will be safe from elimination and each individual team captain will have the only vote
on which guy or girl will go into elimination with the losing team captains. Also, each person will have they're own
personal bank accpunt like the Ruins and like the Ruins in the elimination round they're money is on the line.
Team Old School:
CT
Johnny
Brad
Derrick
Wes
Tyler
Abram
Dunbar
Rachel
Paula
Jenn
Tina
Coral
Robin
Melinda
Camilla
Team New School:
Leroy
Zach
Frank
Ty
CJ
Trey
Swift
Johnny (RW: Portland)
Laurel
Emily
Jonna
KellyAnne
Marie
Laura
Nany
Averey (RW: Portland)
I know I've posted this idea before a while ago but I've updated it.
Battle of the seasons 3
Derrick/Jillian RR Xtreme
Tori/Dan RR Viewers Revenge
Rachel/Darrell RR C.C.
Tina/Abe RR South Pacific
Evan/Diem Fresh Meat 1
Laurel/Noor Fresh Meat 2
KellyAnne/Dunbar RW Sydney
Wes/Melinda RW Austin
Sarah/Scott RW Brooklyn
Kim/Nick RW Hollywood
Ashlee/Eric RW NOLA
CJ/Emilee RW Cancun
Emily/Mike RW DC
Leeroy/H Cooke RW LV2
14 pairs with 3 pairs making it to the finals. No St. Thomas (low ratings) and no San Diego 2 (due to that being a hated season).
I don't really care about the cast as long as it is a good mix of rookies and vets, but how about something like this:
2 teams chosen school-yard style. The rules are not explained until after the draft is over.
Each day is either a male or female day (or if the cast is large enough, each day is both) the best performing male or female on the winning team chooses 2 people to go into the elimination round. But, they can choose any player of the same *** on either team, including themselves if they feel like being arrogant/stupid. The elimination may be 2 people from the losing team, 2 from the winning team or 1 of each. This way it is harder for an alliance to control the entire game, especially if there are an equal number of physical, endurance, mental and silly games. I also think it could potentially set up some great match-ups because logically you would either choose the best people from the opposite team (imagine if Laurel and Evelyn were on the same team) or you would choose the worst people from your own team (and the great question of who is better: Shauvon or Casey could be answered).
The order for each challenge is chosen by lots. Choosing the order gives too much power and allows one alliance to run away with the game.
Pages