[QUOTE=rwdenverfan;217388]Cutthroat is the first challenge since FM II. Sydney and Sandy could both still be asked back. Evelyn wasn't asked back until the second challenge after FM 1 (Inferno 3). Ryan wasn't asked back until the third challenge after FM 1, either (Gauntlet III)[/QUOTE]
Also around the time Fresh Meat was airing, Linette did an interview and said she had been asked for the Duel but had to turn it down. I'm guessing she probably didn't get asked after that though.
[QUOTE=jr588;217528]Yep. Casey was her replacement.[/QUOTE]
**** what a ****-poor replacement. Too bad they couldn't have gotten someone with at least half of Evelyn's athletic ability.
[QUOTE=mph922;217602]Also around the time Fresh Meat was airing, Linette did an interview and said she had been asked for the Duel but had to turn it down. I'm guessing she probably didn't get asked after that though.[/QUOTE]
But what about the orther Fresh Meat 1 members? Like Chanda and Johnnie. I can see why they didnt ask Jessie back cause he was really super boring.
[QUOTE=Youssarian;217665]Though I liked her, Chanda was also extremely boring...she was a good competitor, but did absolutely nothing.[/QUOTE]
Plus I think she is a teacher or something.
With Shauvon quitting Cutthroat, and Katelynn/Brandon's DQ it continues the trend from Inferno 3 till Cutthroat of someone leaving the Challenge without being officially eliminated.
Inferno 3 - CT punches Davis DQed
Gauntlet 3 - Tyrie quits
Island - Dave quits
Duel 2- Adam/CT fight
Ruins - Tonya/Brad/Darrel Dqedm Shauvon Quits
Fresh Meat 2 - Katelynn/Brandon DQed
Cutthroat - Shauvon quits
Also if you don't count the Duel you can also add Gauntlet 2 and Fresh Meat
Gauntlet 2- Jo/Beth quit
FM- Coral/Evan injured.
[QUOTE=Entropy;218066]With Shauvon quitting Cutthroat, and Katelynn/Brandon's DQ it continues the trend from Inferno 3 till Cutthroat of someone leaving the Challenge without being officially eliminated.
Inferno 3 - CT punches Davis DQed
Gauntlet 3 - Tyrie quits
Island - Dave quits
Duel 2- Adam/CT fight
Ruins - Tonya/Brad/Darrel Dqedm Shauvon Quits
Fresh Meat 2 - Katelynn/Brandon DQed
Cutthroat - Shauvon quits
Also if you don't count the Duel you can also add Gauntlet 2 and Fresh Meat
Gauntlet 2- Jo/Beth quit
FM- Coral/Evan injured.[/QUOTE]
Didn't Tina get sent home for punching Beth in the face?
Yea, and on Extreme Challenge, Ayanna is DQed for hitting Christian, Emily & Puck quit on Battle of the Sexes 1, Piggy was sent home on Inferno 1 and Beth quits on Inferno 2. So really theres only been 4 challenges when someone didn't leave prematurely: 1st Challenge, Challenge 2000, Battle of the Seasons, Gauntlet.
[QUOTE=AEvans5;218069]Didn't Tina get sent home for punching Beth in the face?[/QUOTE]
That is correct! So the entire trend is from Gauntlet 2, till present lol
So the real list is
Battle of the Sexes 2: Steven kicked off for hitting Shane
Inferno 2: Beth quits
Gauntlet 2: Jo Quits
Fresh Meat: Coral and Evan DQed
Duel: Tina kicked off for hitting Beth
Inferno 3: CT kicked off for hitting Davis
Gauntlet 3: Tyrie quits
Island: Dave quits
Duel 2: CT and Adam kicked off for fight
The Ruins: Tonya/Darrel/Brad kicked off and Shauvon quit
Fresh Meat 2: Brandon and Katelynn DQed
Cutthroat: Shauvon quits
Basically every challenge from Battle of the Sexes 2 till now, someone has been eliminated in an informal way.
So battle of the seasons and gauntlet 1 were the only challenges where they voted people off that actually left when eliminated and not for quitting or fighting.
[QUOTE=rwrrfan;218079]So the real list is
Battle of the Sexes 2: Steven kicked off for hitting Shane
Inferno 2: Beth quits
Gauntlet 2: Jo Quits
Fresh Meat: Coral and Evan DQed
Duel: Tina kicked off for hitting Beth
Inferno 3: CT kicked off for hitting Davis
Gauntlet 3: Tyrie quits
Island: Dave quits
Duel 2: CT and Adam kicked off for fight
The Ruins: Tonya/Darrel/Brad kicked off and Shauvon quit
Fresh Meat 2: Brandon and Katelynn DQed
Cutthroat: Shauvon quits
Basically every challenge from Battle of the Sexes 2 till now, someone has been eliminated in an informal way.[/QUOTE]
Are we not counting Piggy leaving early on Inferno 1? They didn't show it, but she still was there and left and they brought in a replacement. Gauntlet 1, no one left early, Battle of the Sexes 1 had Puck and Emily.
Nah Piggy doesn't count as she wasnt actually visible apart from the random shots of the back of her head. I can't believe I forgot Coral's exit from Gauntlet 3.
[QUOTE=mph922;218086]Beth and Cameran essentially quit Gauntlet 2 as well.
Also, though it was edited to appeared differently, I think Cameran quit BOTS2 as well.[/QUOTE]
Cameran did basically quit both challenges but she said on Battle of the Sexes 2 that she would volunteer herself and if they lost, she would go home. On Gauntlet 2, I don't even think she tried to win. Jisella quit Gauntlet 2 also, right?
[QUOTE=Dash_Vegas!;213824]Yeah, I know it was really late so my brain was acting weird, lookin back on it, it does sound a little...
I guess I meant, every person he's every eliminated was from the LGBT community?
Sounds a little better. I know it was never intentional on his part tho.[/QUOTE]
Guess that makes 4 with Ty?
Hehehehe
Im kidding of course
So are we counting getting sent home from injuries as DQ's? I know technically Brandon was DQ'ed from FM 2, but I still think that was a BS call to prevent Katelynn from getting more injured.
[QUOTE=Moonpaw;218475]So are we counting getting sent home from injuries as DQ's? I know technically Brandon was DQ'ed from FM 2, but I still think that was a BS call to prevent Katelynn from getting more injured.[/QUOTE]
This is a tough one but you're right, Brandon was the given DQ excuse but like said before on here, there have been other instances of drinking alcohol before eliminations, so they pretty much used it as an excuse to A. not injure Katelynn more and B. make sure CJ and Sydney didn't get to see the Exile like they had planned.
But the point of the trend is that they didnt actually go into an elimination round, and seeing how CJ and Syd did on the puzzle when they went against Landon/Carley, Brandon/Katelynn may have had a shot lol.
[QUOTE=Entropy;218500]But the point of the trend is that they didnt actually go into an elimination round, and seeing how CJ and Syd did on the puzzle when they went against Landon/Carley, Brandon/Katelynn may have had a shot lol.[/QUOTE]
Yeah but that's probably where they brought Katelynn's injury into consideration. I mean, Jeff was healthy going into the Exile and came up with a bad injury. Imagine if Katelynn went in with a major injury, it'd either be a painful exit or a boring exit lol.
[QUOTE=Entropy;218500]But the point of the trend is that they didnt actually go into an elimination round, and seeing how CJ and Syd did on the puzzle when they went against Landon/Carley, Brandon/Katelynn may have had a shot lol.[/QUOTE]
Something about that whole thing seemed a little fishy to me. On the daily, Syndney said they were down there for only 20 minutes. And someone else on this board said CJ and Landon decided that CJ would throw it so Landon would go back, but also give him time to work through it and really get a feel for the Exile, should he need to go back--which is also why he stopped right before the finish line and wanted to make sure Landon was done.
Pages