The Real World Brooklyn Men

I like the male cast, but I get annoyed with JD.

I don't know, the only one that I really have a problem with so far is JD.

I honestly don't have a problem with any of them, I just don't like JD's behavior.

LOL I kind of over did it.....I was trying to get a point across, and I kind of over did it. I still stand by what I said, but I shouldn't jump the shark yet. Let's see if by the end of the season, I still view the guys that way.

Oh HELL. YOU HIT THE NAIL ON THE HEAD. The right term is *EVIL*. JD is evil. He has an evil spirit. AND, TO THINK that he came from an abusive family, he should know how he is hurting other people's feelings the way he felt with his family.

I have zero problems with the guys, but JD isn't making himself look very good. However, do we really know JD? No. Our opinions are coming from a few hours of editing on the RW. So, I'm not going to hate the dude, but based on the edit. It's not making him look good.

[quote=RW OG;49535]I have zero problems with the guys, but JD isn't making himself look very good. However, do we really know JD? No. Our opinions are coming from a few hours of editing on the RW. So, I'm not going to hate the dude, but based on the edit. It's not making him look good.[/quote] This is true.

I'm disappointed with the behavior of the guys. Ryan seems to be going through a "girls have cooties!" phase, Chet is judgmental, JD's vile, and Scott comes off as two-faced (talking smack about Devyn behind her back, but tripping over his words when it comes to confronting her [like in the orange juice Dailies clip]). They need to, for lack of a better term, "man up!" and stop acting so immaturely.

[QUOTE=producer88;49470]I actually like the whole cast in the beginning of the season, but after watching the episodes, and watching all the dailies, I have to say, this RW season has the most annoying male cast members ever. They remind of the RW Sydney girls actually. With their whole "guy code," and "girl code." It's sad that they have to behave like little middle school girls. I'm not bashing them or anything, but IMO they really are acting crazy. For example Scott- How can you even say Devyn is a friend the way you bash her. Even if it was a joke, you don't talk about friends like that, unless they are present, and know your joking. You just seem fake to me, and not real, because if your going to dislike Devyn, then why are you nice to her??? If I don't like someone, I'm going to let you know, not be fake about the situation. JD- I explain on the thread for episode 7, why I'm disgusted by him. Kate made me dislike him even more. Seriously I don't want to waste time on him no more. I truly believe his an evil person inside, and he basically got the other guys on his side, by getting into their heads. I had ex-friends that behave exactly as JD. He's truly a fake person. Chet/Ryan- There are still moments when I like both of them, but they need to mind their own business. Devyn wasn't going to even mention, the letter Ryan sent to Baya, to his girlfriend when she was visiting him. Chet never been in a serious relationship, so he shouldn't even give his own opinion, and what happen with the whole don't judge others, that's not part of the mormon beliefs. In all honesty, I still can't believe the men of this season are acting like if they are 12 year old girls. With the whole bashing people, pulling pranks on people you don't like. Being FAKE, and not talking about the problems or issue you have with a castmember as an adult. Worse male cast group ever on the RW (well I started watching RW since B2NY, but from that season to this season, worst male cast).[/QUOTE] I couldn't agree more. [url=http://www.DevynSimone.com]DevynSimone.com | The Official Website of Devyn Simone[/url]

I pretty much agree with the original poster - especially after watching some of the dailies. I think between vevmo, the comments of castmates and the dailies I've gotten a big lesson on the world of creative editing. I don't hate any of them and I know that at best I'm getting a two dimensional reading even including the extra information that I've gotten. nevertheless all of the women in the house have impressed me far more than the "men." I have to say I'm especially disappointed in Scott, I know he's written on here before and I hope that he comes back to provide his side of the story. But at least with the others despite their nasty girlish bi***ing I think it's safe to say they've at least been more honest about their feelings (or so it seems). The behavior from most of the guys has been pathetically predictable but I had such a different impression of Scott than the one I have now, I'm still majorly put off by his comments about wanting to hit a female in the house for something that wasn't even remotely his business. I think he is probably going to be the one that comes off looking the best in the end, but in my opinion he's shown the worst the sides of himself in the dailies. Surprisingly enough the one boy that I have the most respect for is Chet - which is not saying much by the way. Chet at least had the balls to say to people's faces a more sanitized version of what he has said behind their backs and on random occassions has shown a surprising amount of maturity. Ryan just needs to freakin grow up, I know that there are people who think he should get a free pass because of his military background. I'm sorry but that doesn't wash for me, particularly when he himself has implied on several occassions through interviews that he doesn't perceive his reactions or behavior to be correlated to traumatizing experiences in Iraq. He doesn't give himself any excuses, so I won't give him any either. I don't think he's a bad person at all, just young. JD, I've already said more than enough about him. Every show needs a villian I guess. For the record I don't think the women in the house are 100% perfect, but yeah for me this season SO FAR has probably about the least likeable entire cast of guys (though I've missed about 6 or 7 seasons). It is probably worth mentioning this is also the first time that I sought out information and formed my opinions outside of just watching the episodes though.

[QUOTE=Binary Solo;49782] It is probably worth mentioning this is also the first time that I sought out information and formed my opinions outside of just watching the episodes though.[/QUOTE] And we are all the richer for having you here.

Well none of the guys real bother me this season.

Scott is cool. The rest are immature as all hell. BTW, what is w the CHET hat? Where do you even get something like that?

As much as the model/ripped guy got attention on the show for looks, I think Ryan looks the best by a mile. Good face, still has a nice body with good... proportions. And frankly, he is the "cutest" guy on the show, if not the "hottest" Those noises reacting to the story from katelyn were great, just made him more endearing. Disagree? It's ok, everyone is allowed to be wrong! 2nd best looking is JD. He is VERY filled out, and so that earns him the second spot. 3rd is the bodybuilding guy (forgot his name) And fourth and last of course, is Chet. Must be rough.

I've always thought Ryan was very cute.

[quote=OtherPplsDrama;49849]I've always thought Ryan was very cute.[/quote] I have always agreed with this statement, proudly!!

[quote=OtherPplsDrama;49849]I've always thought Ryan was very cute.[/quote] I think Ryan is the cutest, too. Although I do have a soft spot for him.

I thought Chet was your man tj! :)

[quote=OtherPplsDrama;49876]I thought Chet was your man tj! :)[/quote] I like both of them but Ryan has one up on Chet, I think Ryan is a tad bit funnier.

Seeing the dailies, and the commercials on MTV for the next episode....I just know I'm going to hate all the guys officially, for the rest of the season (unless they man up, and apologize to the girls for being fake).

[quote=producer88;50095]Seeing the dailies, and the commercials on MTV for the next episode....I just know I'm going to hate all the guys officially, for the rest of the season (unless they man up, and apologize to the girls for being fake).[/quote] There is a preview for tonight's episode? The only preview I've seen was the one for the rest of the season. I looked at the MTV site and came up empty.

Yeah there was a preview on tv for tonight's episode. It's the one where JD breaks the table.

The season finally seems to be picking up, prob the 1st season ever without any cast hook ups. As far as castings.. Last season with "He who shall not be named" and Joey was the best... both of them were hilarious I was watching I think Episode 6 from Hollywood a few days ago, the one where Reva and Will get caught in the confessional, and "He who shall not be named" and Sarah have that big argument... definitely one of the greatest episodes ever

[quote=Julius;50307]The season finally seems to be picking up, prob the 1st season ever without any cast hook ups. [/quote] It may be the first one of the last several seasons, but several of the earlier seasons didn't have house hookups. I am still wondering if more happened on this season that we didn't see...

I can't really see anyone in this cast hooking up with each other(outside people I can see).

[quote=tybert7;49848]As much as the model/ripped guy got attention on the show for looks, I think Ryan looks the best by a mile. Good face, still has a nice body with good... proportions. And frankly, he is the "cutest" guy on the show, if not the "hottest" Those noises reacting to the story from katelyn were great, just made him more endearing. Disagree? It's ok, everyone is allowed to be wrong! 2nd best looking is JD. He is VERY filled out, and so that earns him the second spot. 3rd is the bodybuilding guy (forgot his name) And fourth and last of course, is Chet. Must be rough.[/quote] I have to say Scott is one of the hottest guys we have had on RR in a while and he seemed to have a really great personality to go with it. Sadly, we did not get anywhere near enough of him on the show. I do agree though that Ryan was adorable as well but Scott takes the cake for this season! :)

JD and Scott are my favorites by a mile. The girls are agrivating as hell! JD isn't evil, how can you call someone evil and you only seen them on a heavily edited television show? Ryan is the fakest one of them all! He talks the most crap about the girls but he acts so nice to their faces! And how is JD an evil person? Please tell me! He may have said some things that were disrespectful but so have all the other guys. JD just gets a bad edit, like Kim from Hollywood. But from what i heard from cast members JD isn't at all how they portrayed him on the show.

Janel, That has already been discussed to death.

No it hasn't, people just bashed JD but it hasn't been discussed with someone with my point of view.

[quote=janel6;70673]No it hasn't, people just bashed JD but it hasn't been discussed with someone with my point of view.[/quote] Not everyone here has bashed JD.