[QUOTE=LivesToRun;38481]Perhaps David from Viewers Revenge.
He was on the speculated cast list at first?[/QUOTE]
And his name was our mistake. He should never have been on the list.
[quote=Dartagnan;38498]Okay good because I would have never wanted to see David.
I think we will be getting a lackluster replacement, somebody like Tyrie or Danny.[/quote]
David lost a lot of weight, not that it means anything for the challenge, haha, except another fit competitor. But I think it would have been interesting to see him.
And Ewww. :p
[QUOTE=Dartagnan;38498]Okay good because I would have never wanted to see David.
I think we will be getting a lackluster replacement, somebody like Tyrie or Danny.[/QUOTE]
:poo:
[QUOTE=Dartagnan;38513]Yes Melinda's Danny, and a big NO as well. Honestly, with the recent marriage I don't see him being the likely choice, but he is a possibility.[/QUOTE]
I would be interested to see if the marriage has changed him at all. It seemed like the pregnancy and engagement change Derrick a bit. And he does seem like a logical choice, but he talks a lot more game than he's worth.
[quote=hpkhg45;38517]I would be interested to see if the marriage has changed him at all. It seemed like the pregnancy and engagement change Derrick a bit. And he does seem like a logical choice, but he talks a lot more game than he's worth.[/quote]
Yeah, plus the fact that he is a big *****!
Just as long as it isn't him, Nehemiah, Johnny, Kenny, Dave, or anybody from Viewer's Revenge, I will be happy.
[QUOTE=Dartagnan;38518]Yeah, plus the fact that he is a big *****!
Just as long as it isn't him, Nehemiah, Johnny, Kenny, Dave, or anybody from Viewer's Revenge, I will be happy.[/QUOTE]
I like Nehemiah, I would be happy if was a replacement. But I doubt he would last long.
[quote=Dartagnan;38529]True Alton was good, but he proved he wasn't great on The Inferno 3 with his multiple DQ's and a sit-out.[/quote]
But on the Gauntlet 1 and 2 he kicked butt. And did well in every Gauntlet he was voted int
he's really awesome in eliminations. on inferno 3 he wasnt that good in challenges but he would've done well in the infernos. i think he could have taken out kenny or derrick in an inferno
[quote=dplayer18;38533]he's really awesome in eliminations. on inferno 3 he wasnt that good in challenges but he would've done well in the infernos. i think he could have taken out kenny or derrick in an inferno[/quote]
Agreed!
[QUOTE=ejborys22;38527]If it is Alton, the entire game would change. They guys will be shaking in their boots[/QUOTE]
Nope, he is much over rated. We've had this discussion here before. He was a disappointment to the other cast on Inferno 3. They expected to see a dominant Alton and he clearly was not that person. He may still have myth status to some fans, but he does not have it within the RW/RR family. Word spread quickly.
[quote=V1man;38547]Nope, he is much over rated. We've had this discussion here before. He was a disappointment to the other cast on Inferno 3. They expected to see a dominant Alton and he clearly was not that person. He may still have myth status to some fans, but he does not have it within the RW/RR family. Word spread quickly.[/quote]
I agree. The only time he was ever really good was the Gauntlet 2. Apparently word does spread fast.
And tj, I as well would like to see Joey, but if he is serious about being sober, I doubt he would go into a Challenge.
[quote=Dartagnan;38553]I agree. The only time he was ever really good was the Gauntlet 2. Apparently word does spread fast.
And tj, I as well would like to see Joey, but if he is serious about being sober, I doubt he would go into a Challenge.[/quote]
I know :( ...even the Danimal would be cool lol.
[QUOTE=Dartagnan;38553]I agree. The only time he was ever really good was the Gauntlet 2. Apparently word does spread fast.
And tj, I as well would like to see Joey, [B]but if he is serious about being sober,[/B] I doubt he would go into a Challenge.[/QUOTE]
Nor should he go because BMP creates the kind of environment where the social pressure to drink + other stuff is 1000X one's normal life.
I'm cool with MJ being one of the replacements. I did end up liking/caring about the Philadelphia cast overall, and while he wasn't my favorite in the cast or the most entertaining to me, it's good to have another cast member from that season, since they don't do many challenges and things like that. And I'll get to see him and Landon again and see if they still have a decent friendship. Plus I kind of agreed with his assessment of the whole Kina/Cara/Susie ordeal that challenge.
Plus I think MJ would be a part of the Katie/Mark/Landon group of people, since he was friends with them during G2. I would also be interested in seeing if MJ would do well in this type of format. He's a former college football player and very muscular, yet he didn't really stand out in G2 or G3. I think Landon, Alton, and Jamie had proven to be more stronger competitors than him (Jamie showed more in BOTS, but Landon and Alton were the top guys for the rookies in G2).
And since Alton was brought up, I really think I3 was just an off challenge for him for the most part. He was great in G1 and G2. He did have a good mission or two in I3, though. He is still one of the best male competitors to me, although he maybe slipped down a spot or two overall. And from some of the posts here I can tell I disagree with the latest group of challengers (FM and RW 17 +) or use some different kind of criteria to discern who I think is a good competitor (I pretty much go by missions). I'd love to see him on this challenge. What Alton has done in the past would blow someone like Kenny, Johnny, Dunbar, etc out of the water, IMO.
Others guys I wouldn't mind seeing as the other replacement: Abram, Darrell, Northern Trail Dan, Joey (would he do a challenge? True he should stay away from drinking situations), Cohutta (seems like such a nice guy), Jose, Zach, Karamo (not athletic, but could provide some drama for an episode or two), Frank, Malik (though he and Kevin vowed to not get caught up in the after the show life), Jamie, or Syrus. Some of these guys are good competitors, some could get involved drama or be fun, and some are just nice guys that I like or they don't irritate me. Some of them are a mixture of things. There are a couple of guys listed that don't seem likely, but I tried to keep in mind who might be willing to do a challenge based on the past or not hearing that they were done with challenges recently.
wow so much info i want to speculate on everything!!!! here is how i am imagining these scenarios:
with the whole adam/ct/issac thing, i am thinking that issac tried to be funny to ease tension, which made ct turn on him, but ct saved his violence for adam in the end. and if adam got sent home also, he must have equally been violent or out of line somehow. Maybe he was just tierd of ct **** that he threw the first punch?
I think kim chose robin for a duel(assuming she was the one who got to choose based on her being a rookie, and how the first duel played out). It was smart because she didnt choose exactly the weakest player, but i am a little worried about how this might effect kim later. will robins friends treat kim like an outcast, if they havent already?
I really wonder why did shauvon choose anessa?? Did anessa try to intimidate her like paula back in the original duel? i would assume anessa gave her attitude because shauvon just doesnt seem like the kinda chick she'd be down with, and anessa is one to tell you to your face.
I also wonder who was the punk that chose Davis for the duel. they lose cool points! Again, I am assuming Davis was chosen because besides Mr.Popular Ryan, Davis seems like an easy target. I just wish to see atleast a few unpredictable duels. I know nobody wants to risk money but PLEASE. I really thought that Nick was going to be the underdog this year :( but thats ok because my heart still wants brad to win
so who took brooke to the duel??? gosh i hope it wasnt kim because they seem to like to pick on one person usually. I hate when they do that, but it always seems to make the person stronger in the end...so, kim, if you are the one being picked on, I am already rooting for you. And its not exactly the smartest strategy to send a rookie in over and over because each time they win they lose that nervousness and gain their confidence and just might take you out next. im now thinking kim is going to stick around longer than some of my fav vets
ok and so last but not least: the 2nd male replacement. Wouldnt it be crazy if Eric N. came to play with Mark one last time? I hope not. I really hope it is NOT Tyler, or any guy from the island or G3 for that matter. Id like to see Theo, Shane, Dan, Will, Joey, Randy....
I guess it would be funny if it was dave Sky. He seems to have created a reputation for himself of not being able to back up his mouth. But since I havent seen actually anything from him besides him looking like a ***** in that fight on RW, part of me wants to reserve him the right to establish his credibility...because I am curious although I am not a fan of him.
ok guys sorry for my long post but i really wanted to share my thoughts because im just excited about this challenge. thanks for the info, this site is awesome.
Pages