So since season 25 is over, I was just curious as to who the 25 biggest "stars" of the series are in other people's opinion. My list:
1. Coral RW:B2NY
2. Mike RW:B2NY
3. Beth RW:LA
4. Veronica RR:SAS
5. CT RW:Paris
6. Katie RR:The Quest
7. Tonya RW: Chicago
8. Wes RW:Austin
9. Johnny RW:Key West
10. Evan FM
11. Kenny FM
12. Paula RW:Key West
13. Rachel RR:Campus Crawl
14. Mark RR:First Adventure
15. Abram RR:South Pacific
16. Susie RR:Down Under
17. Laurel FM2
18. Diem FM
19. Derrick RR:X-treme
20. Timmy RR:USA2
21. Trishelle RW:Las Vegas
22. Julie RW:New Orleans
23. Darrell RR:Campus Crawl
24. Cara Maria FM2
25. Evelyn FM
Honorable Mentions:
* Kellyanne RW:Sydney
* Alton RW:Las Vegas
* Tina RR:South Pacific
* Kina RR:X-treme
* Theo RR:MVT
* Brad RW:San Diego
* Robin RW:San Diego
* Emily RR:USA2
[QUOTE=Youssarian;431807]Discussion in the Speculation thread has turned to Heather being an "upgrade" from Jessica for Dustin, and I'm curious as to why people thought that. Heather did not really shine in either of the challenges she competed in with Dustin, whereas Jessica has proved that she has a lot of fight and spirit (even with her sometimes-annoying personality). I think people are a little biased, but I want to hear from someone who thinks this way why Heather would be be a better partner for Dustin.[/QUOTE]
The dynamic between Heather & Dustin would be a lot more genuine & interesting compared to Jessica. Heather's pretty down-to-earth and not been one to play it up for the cameras, and I think she's a lot more competitive than we've seen from her. Jessica's cool, but it wouldn't be as good as seeing how Dustin & Heather unfold. Their relationship stretched across Las Vegas, Exes 1, and a whole other reality show. It has CT-Diem potential in carving out a pretty solid story surrounding them and the questions unanswered in why such a great couple couldn't last.
I'm cool with Jessica though, but I'd rather see Heather.
[QUOTE=Meelz;431947]The dynamic between Heather & Dustin would be a lot more genuine & interesting compared to Jessica. Heather's pretty down-to-earth and not been one to play it up for the cameras, and I think she's a lot more competitive than we've seen from her. Jessica's cool, but it wouldn't be as good as seeing how Dustin & Heather unfold. Their relationship stretched across Las Vegas, Exes 1, and a whole other reality show. It has CT-Diem potential in carving out a pretty solid story surrounding them and the questions unanswered in why such a great couple couldn't last.
I'm cool with Jessica though, but I'd rather see Heather.[/QUOTE]
From a story line perspective, I would [B]much[/B] rather see Heather paired with him than Jessica for all the reasons you just listed. I was just referring to people saying Heather is a better competitor.
In other news...
[img]http://vevmo.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=5825&d=1404693569[/img]
Ayiiia is STUNNING. She needs to make a return ASAP.
[QUOTE=Youssarian;431956]From a story line perspective, I would [B]much[/B] rather see Heather paired with him than Jessica for all the reasons you just listed. I was just referring to people saying Heather is a better competitor.
In other news...
[img]http://vevmo.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=5825&d=1404693569[/img]
Ayiiia is STUNNING. She needs to make a return ASAP.[/QUOTE]
Wow Ayiiia looks great in that picture.
[QUOTE=Youssarian;431956]From a story line perspective, I would [B]much[/B] rather see Heather paired with him than Jessica for all the reasons you just listed. I was just referring to people saying Heather is a better competitor.
In other news...
[img]http://vevmo.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=5825&d=1404693569[/img]
Ayiiia is STUNNING. She needs to make a return ASAP.[/QUOTE]
Wow Ayiiia looks great in that picture.
Just because you'd rather see Heather on this show than Jessica doesn't mean you can blindly say that Heather is a better competitor when Heather has shown is NOTHING and Jessica has won 4-5 missions and broke Cara Maria's finger.
Jessica has brought more to the Challenge than Heather ever has.
Never watched Cancun (or any RW) so my only exposure to Ayiiia is Cutthroat.
She didn't really do anything other than ***** about Cara Maria not pulling her weight in Bottleneck Stampede even when she finished first to save her own ***.
Although that being said she was inoffensive aside from that and looks like she would add more to a season than her Cancun counterparts.
[QUOTE=Youssarian;431956]From a story line perspective, I would [B]much[/B] rather see Heather paired with him than Jessica for all the reasons you just listed. I was just referring to people saying Heather is a better competitor.
In other news...
[img]http://vevmo.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=5825&d=1404693569[/img]
Ayiiia is STUNNING. She needs to make a return ASAP.[/QUOTE]
Why 3 i's HAHAHAHAHA
I too would like to see Dustin/Heather rather than Dustin/Jessica. I don't think they should repeat couples But I think These 2 should get another go considering they went out due to injury last time.
[QUOTE=LHarkins;431966]Never watched Cancun (or any RW) so my only exposure to Ayiiia is Cutthroat.
She didn't really do anything other than ***** about Cara Maria not pulling her weight in Bottleneck Stampede even when she finished first to save her own ***.
Although that being said she was inoffensive aside from that and looks like she would add more to a season than her Cancun counterparts.[/QUOTE]
Ayiiia Cancun and Ayiiia challenge Cutthroat was 2 totally different people.
Ayiiia was the center of Drama on the Cancun house, she was the outcast and had an argument with everyone living in that house.
[QUOTE=JayTee;431965]Just because you'd rather see Heather on this show than Jessica doesn't mean you can blindly say that Heather is a better competitor when Heather has shown is NOTHING and Jessica has won 4-5 missions and broke Cara Maria's finger.
Jessica has brought more to the Challenge than Heather ever has.[/QUOTE]
We [I]never[/I] agree, but I totally agree with you here, lol.
[QUOTE=LHarkins;431966]Never watched Cancun (or any RW) so my only exposure to Ayiiia is Cutthroat.
She didn't really do anything other than ***** about Cara Maria not pulling her weight in Bottleneck Stampede even when she finished first to save her own ***.
Although that being said she was inoffensive aside from that and looks like she would add more to a season than her Cancun counterparts.[/QUOTE]
Ayiiia was arguably the main focus and most dynamic character on Cancun. I'm actually extremely surprised that she hasn't been back since Cutthroat! I really hope they give her another chance.
[QUOTE=JayTee;431965]Just because you'd rather see Heather on this show than Jessica doesn't mean you can blindly say that Heather is a better competitor when Heather has shown is NOTHING and Jessica has won 4-5 missions and broke Cara Maria's finger.
Jessica has brought more to the Challenge than Heather ever has.[/QUOTE]
Is this intended for me? Heather is a better athlete--you have every right to disagree with that
I couldn't care less if I ever see Heather again
Jessica's wins had little to nothing to do with her athleticism. Let's be real
I'd rather see Heather than Jessica mostly because I prefer Heather.
Jessica is just not interesting to me at all. Heather's not that exciting herself but her and Dustin together is interesting IMO. I also think she has a ton of potential to do well in challenges. I'm bummed that they had to exit since Dustin sliced open his knee or whatever.
Plus, I can't stand Jessica's voice. Or most of what comes out of her mouth.
[QUOTE=kvm1977;431978]Is this intended for me? Heather is a better athlete--you have every right to disagree with that
I couldn't care less if I ever see Hetaher again
Jessica's wins had little to nothing to do with her athleticism. Let's be real[/QUOTE]
And Heathers 0 mission wins just adds to the fact that she hasn't shown us anything that could put her above Jessica. Even Emilee has done more than Heather Marter ever has.
[QUOTE=RubenJay05;431945]So since season 25 is over, I was just curious as to who the 25 biggest "stars" of the series are in other people's opinion. My list:
1. Coral RW:B2NY
2. Mike RW:B2NY
3. Beth RW:LA
4. Veronica RR:SAS
5. CT RW:Paris
6. Katie RR:The Quest
7. Tonya RW: Chicago
8. Wes RW:Austin
9. Johnny RW:Key West
10. Evan FM
11. Kenny FM
12. Paula RW:Key West
13. Rachel RR:Campus Crawl
14. Mark RR:First Adventure
15. Abram RR:South Pacific
16. Susie RR:Down Under
17. Laurel FM2
18. Diem FM
19. Derrick RR:X-treme
20. Timmy RR:USA2
21. Trishelle RW:Las Vegas
22. Julie RW:New Orleans
23. Darrell RR:Campus Crawl
24. Cara Maria FM2
25. Evelyn FM
Honorable Mentions:
* Kellyanne RW:Sydney
* Alton RW:Las Vegas
* Tina RR:South Pacific
* Kina RR:X-treme
* Theo RR:MVT
* Brad RW:San Diego
* Robin RW:San Diego
* Emily RR:USA2[/QUOTE]
Mine are:
1. CT (RW: Paris)
2. Diem (Fresh Meat)
3. Johnny Bananas (RW: Key West)
4. Kenny (Fresh Meat)
5. Coral (RW: Back to New York)
6. Wes (RW: Austin)
7. Mike "The Miz" (RW: Back to New York)
8. Paula (RW: Key West)
9. Veronica (RR: Campus Crawl)
10. Mark (RR: USA-The First Adventure)
11. Evan (Fresh Meat)
12. Rachel (RR: Campus Crawl)
13. Evelyn (Fresh Meat)
14. Derrick (RR: X-Treme)
15. Darrell (RR: Campus Crawl)
16. Cara Maria (Fresh Meat 2)
17. Abram (RR: South Pacific)
18. Brad (RW: San Diego)
19. Beth (RW: Los Angeles)
20. Alton (RW: Las Vegas)
21. Timmy (RR: USA-The Second Adventure)
22. Tonya (RW: Chicago)
23. Katie (RR: The Quest)
24. Laurel (Fresh Meat 2)
25. Theo (RR: Maximum Velocity Tour)
Honorable mentions:
Jenn (RW: Denver)
Robin (RW: San Diego)
Kina (RR: X-Treme)
Frank (RW: San Diego 2)
Sarah (RW: Brooklyn)
Aneesa (RW: Chicago)
Tina (RR: South Pacific)
Susie (RR: Down Under)
Zach (RW: San Diego 2)
Ruthie (RW: Hawaii)
Trishelle (RW: Las Vegas)
KellyAnne (RW: Sydney)
Julie (RW: New Orleans)
Nany (RW: Las Vegas 2)
[QUOTE=mph922;431961]Unpopular opinion here, but I think Ayiiia was the hottest on Cancun. I don't know what it is, but something about her man...[/QUOTE]
She was the hottest hands down, with Emilee close behind.
[QUOTE=JayTee;431982]And Heathers 0 mission wins just adds to the fact that she hasn't shown us anything that could put her above Jessica. Even Emilee has done more than Heather Marter ever has.[/QUOTE]
Put Heather on a season when they had "team" missions and then she'd probably have a win or two
Heather performed well consistently before Dustin got them removed...that's reality
LOL @ even mentioning Emilee's name. This is why I hate people in general. The average person has zero common sense
Well I mean Heather has only done 1 challenge where as Jessica has done 2. Jessica has had more of an opportunity to show what she can do. The same can't be said of Heather especially considering she had to leave early on because of Dustin's Injury.
I think we would have more of a gage of her abilities if she came back and lasted longer.
[QUOTE=JayTee;431982]And Heathers 0 mission wins just adds to the fact that she hasn't shown us anything that could put her above Jessica. Even Emilee has done more than Heather Marter ever has.[/QUOTE]
You're just crazy now, Emilee sucks
[QUOTE=kvm1977;431987]Put Heather on a season when they had "team" missions and then she'd probably have a win or two
Heather performed well consistently before Dustin got them removed...that's reality
LOL @ even mentioning Emilee's name. This is why I hate people in general. The average person has zero common sense[/QUOTE]
You mean in the TWO missions that happened before they were sent home? They were middle of the pack in both of them
[QUOTE=Nightwolf;431992]You mean in the TWO missions that happened before they were sent home? They were middle of the pack in both of them[/QUOTE]
Correct--she performed well on both
[QUOTE=kvm1977;431987]Put Heather on a season when they had "team" missions and then she'd probably have a win or two
Heather performed well consistently before Dustin got them removed...that's reality
LOL @ even mentioning Emilee's name. This is why I hate people in general. The average person has zero common sense[/QUOTE]
You're talking about common sense when you're saying someone who has shown us nothing is a better competitor over someone who did fairly well on her 2nd challenge. You're over here making ASSUMPTIONS rather than looking at the facts: Heather has done nothing on this show, Jessica has.
How about you get some common sense here lawyer.
[QUOTE=JayTee;431995]You're talking about common sense when you're saying someone who has shown us nothing is a better competitor over someone who did fairly well on her 2nd challenge. You're over here making ASSUMPTIONS rather than looking at the facts: Heather has done nothing on this show, Jessica has.
How about you get some common sense here lawyer.[/QUOTE]
This is like telling a toddler they need to go to bed.
Statistics mean nothing. Heather IS the better athlete. It takes 3 seconds for another athlete to see that.
[QUOTE=kvm1977;431989]So, you've never seen Jonna[/QUOTE]
Jonna is pretty, but nowhere near the other two in my opinion. She looked stuning on Rivals and Free Agents, but on BOTS, Rivals II and Cancun she was average in my opinion.
Apparently everyone should want Jessica over Ashlee as a partner because Ashlee hasn't been on a challenge therefore has never won a mission...this is all so freaking stupid there aren't even words.
Pages