The Challenge: Total Madness (Non-Spoilers Discussion Thread)

7850 posts / 0 new
Last post

Which Rookie do you think is going to flop if all made the cut?

There is always that one rookie that think he is the best and then when they actually do the show they flop

I think Jay or Billy. 

Unpopular opinion but.. I don’t think Bayleigh will be that great of a competitor. I can see her and Swaggy being the Danny/Melinda from FM and getting early boot.

Unpopular opinion but.. I don’t think Bayleigh will be that great of a competitor. I can see her and Swaggy being the Danny/Melinda from FM and getting early boot.

care to elaborate or is it just a gut feeling? They both are some of the more in shape and athletic rookies. Bayleigh in particular is tall and bigger for a challenge girl which usually equates to at least a decent showing 

I'm torn about Jay. On one hand, he's physically small and I think the second he goes into an individual elimination, he goes home. But he's competitive, and socially skilled, so I can see him flying under the radar/making enough friends not to be thrown in right away. In other words: his social game, not his physical game will determine his length of stay imo.

I still think it's crazy that they brought back Bananas and MELISSA for the final on Vendettas. Like, they were really pushing her like she was going to be a mainstay on the show after that season. I'm sure the fight with Kailah messed that up, but I hope she can redeem herself. 

PR is there an EOTB3 girl on this, I remember i seen a tweet about one being on and it sounded like they were irrel cause the gif on the tweet was cardi saying ‘what is the reason’

I feel like Jay is going far. I think he’ll perform well in dailies. He’s just got to avoid physical eliminations or he’s getting FLUNG

My rookie predictions from best to worst

  1. Kaycee
  2. Fessy
  3. Billy
  4. Bayleigh
  5. Jay
  6. Swaggy

 

Unpopular opinion but.. I don’t think Bayleigh will be that great of a competitor. I can see her and Swaggy being the Danny/Melinda from FM and getting early boot.

care to elaborate or is it just a gut feeling? They both are some of the more in shape and athletic rookies. Bayleigh in particular is tall and bigger for a challenge girl which usually equates to at least a decent showing 

I’m not even sure, honestly. I know Bayleigh is tall and athletic-ish, but I’m not sure she has the fight or “switch” to turn into a killer competitor, but I could be wrong. I just think she and Swaggy might get caught up in the cluster of relationship and the game and not be able to maneuver it the way Jordan and Tori or Paulie and CM do and will make themselves targets. And I can see Swaggy rubbing people the wrong way.

My rookie predictions from best to worst

  1. Kaycee
  2. Fessy
  3. Billy
  4. Bayleigh
  5. Jay
  6. Swaggy

Switch Jay and Billy and that’s my ranking.

My overall rank atm

Jordan

Wes

Bananas

CT

Cory

Rogan

Bear

Fessy

Kyle

Billy

Josh

Jay

Swaggy

 

 

Tori

Ashley

Jenny

Kaycee

Kailah

Jenna

Mattie

Nany

Dee

Aneesa

Melissa

Bayleigh

Big T

Idk why Swaggy is giving me strong Derrick Henry vibes

Swaggy is gonna say Hello and the house will erupt for no reason and target him.

 I'm not gonna be so quick to say KC & Fessy will deliver. Fessy could easily be another Victor. 

anon23423234ffs...
Anonymous's picture

My overall rank atm

Jordan

Wes

Bananas

CT

Cory

Rogan

Bear

Fessy

Kyle

Billy

Josh

Jay

Swaggy

 

 

Tori

Ashley

Jenny

Kaycee

Kailah

Jenna

Mattie

Nany

Dee

Aneesa

Melissa

Bayleigh

Big T

Jordan, Wes, Bananas, and CT as your top 4 guys? Are you serious?

It can go either way with Swaggy/Bay..I could see them being protected, I can see them getting targeted early, I can also see them proving themselves. It will be interesting to see how things go.

I never watched Survivor but I feel like Jay could be a Cohutta type: smaller, likeable, and decent until it's physical 

 

My overall rank atm

Jordan

Wes

Bananas

CT

Cory

Rogan

Bear

Fessy

Kyle

Billy

Josh

Jay

Swaggy

 

 

Tori

Ashley

Jenny

Kaycee

Kailah

Jenna

Mattie

Nany

Dee

Aneesa

Melissa

Bayleigh

Big T

Jordan, Wes, Bananas, and CT as your top 4 guys? Are you serious?

Thats just skill I personally don't care for any of them

I don't even know why people rank Nany above anyone at this point. We all know how the shit will end.

 

anon23423234ffs...
Anonymous's picture

 

 

My overall rank atm

Jordan

Wes

Bananas

CT

Cory

Rogan

Bear

Fessy

Kyle

Billy

Josh

Jay

Swaggy

 

 

Tori

Ashley

Jenny

Kaycee

Kailah

Jenna

Mattie

Nany

Dee

Aneesa

Melissa

Bayleigh

Big T

Jordan, Wes, Bananas, and CT as your top 4 guys? Are you serious?

Thats just skill I personally don't care for any of them

That makes sense. I can sadly see at least one of them making it to the end.

Idk why Swaggy is giving me strong Derrick Henry vibes

we all know why

I feel as if fessy will be a fish out of water kinda like victor on vendettas. I don't think he's meant for mtv.

Kaycee will be the rookie to watch. If you watch her football clips, she’s got crazy athleticism and she showed she’s good under pressure with all her Veto wins on B.B.

 

Idk why Swaggy is giving me strong Derrick Henry vibes

we all know why

oop 

 

My overall rank atm

Jordan

Wes

Bananas

CT

Cory

Rogan

Bear

Fessy

Kyle

Billy

Josh

Jay

Swaggy

 

 

Tori

Ashley

Jenny

Kaycee

Kailah

Jenna

Mattie

Nany

Dee

Aneesa

Melissa

Bayleigh

Big T

Jordan, Wes, Bananas, and CT as your top 4 guys? Are you serious?

With this cast who are you putting ahead of them?

anon23423234ffs...
Anonymous's picture

 

 

My overall rank atm

Jordan

Wes

Bananas

CT

Cory

Rogan

Bear

Fessy

Kyle

Billy

Josh

Jay

Swaggy

 

 

Tori

Ashley

Jenny

Kaycee

Kailah

Jenna

Mattie

Nany

Dee

Aneesa

Melissa

Bayleigh

Big T

Jordan, Wes, Bananas, and CT as your top 4 guys? Are you serious?

With this cast who are you putting ahead of them?

That's my mistake. I thought the ranking was based on how well he liked them, not their abilities.

It's tough to guess how well Jay will do tbh. His size will probably be an issue but as for everything else it's hard to compare the challenge and survivor since they are so different. Survivor you're playing on empty, and there's no endurance challenges anywhere close to the challenge for that reason. 

As for the big brother people, they all have athletic backgrounds right? They could do well but we've seen people with them flop. 

As for the big brother people, they all have athletic backgrounds right? They could do well but we've seen people with them flop. 

I know everyone does besides Bayleigh. Not sure about her athletic background.

But i mean, Idris is a boxer but he's been below average so far.

Pages