The Challenge: Generic Thread

[QUOTE=Lola88;435380]I agree with this. Her appearance on Battle of the Sexes 1 is what gave her this overrated credit. Laurel Evelyn Emily Rachel Tonya imo are the top 5 female competitors. Camila Sarah Marie Paula Kelly Anne Cooke all get get honorable mentions with possible overtake in the future.[/QUOTE] Tonya? ***** I think the second group is largely a joke as well. Marie? KellyAnne? Seriously? See people like Holly S & Emily B for starters. Honestly, Tonya? Please

[QUOTE=Lola88;435380]I agree with this. Her appearance on Battle of the Sexes 1 is what gave her this overrated credit. Laurel Evelyn Emily Rachel [B]Tonya[/B] imo are the top 5 female competitors. Camila Sarah [B]Marie[/B] Paula Kelly Anne Cooke all get get honorable mentions with possible overtake in the future.[/QUOTE] You're kidding right ?

**** some people are so delusional in this thread. Marie top 5 female real world competitor just LOL i can't right now :highly_amused:

Ruthie is definitely a great competitor. Her performance on BOTSexes was obviously amazing, but she was also solid on Battle of the Sexes 2, considered the best girl on her team on Gauntlet 2, and won an individual challenge on the Duel 2. Her size is a hindrance (see her elimination against Beth), but she has a lot of fight. Despite Beth being like 3 times her size in Reverse Tug of War, Ruthie was able to use her strategy and ferocity to stall Beth and even make a tiny bit of progress for a couple of minutes before the inevitable happened (which was due to the size difference). Her loss to Kimberly is definitely a detractor, though.

Top Women: 1. Casey 2. Shauvon 3. Sarah G 4. Katie 5. Amaya

[QUOTE=Euroslavia;435390]Top Women: 1. Casey 2. Shauvon 3. Sarah G 4. Katie 5. Amaya[/QUOTE] Uh... you forgot Brooke.

[QUOTE=Youssarian;435391]Uh... you forgot Brooke.[/QUOTE] And Devyn.

[QUOTE=Youssarian;435389]Ruthie is definitely a great competitor. Her performance on BOTSexes was obviously amazing, but she was also solid on Battle of the Sexes 2, considered the best girl on her team on Gauntlet 2, and won an individual challenge on the Duel 2. Her size is a hindrance [B](see her elimination against Beth), [/B]but she has a lot of fight. Despite Beth being like 3 times her size in Reverse Tug of War, Ruthie was able to use her strategy and ferocity to stall Beth and even make a tiny bit of progress for a couple of minutes before the inevitable happened (which was due to the size difference). Her loss to Kimberly is definitely a detractor, though.[/QUOTE] That Was an awesome elimination. The Veterans Look on their faces afterwards was priceless.

Beth vs. Ruthie was a memorable elimination.

[QUOTE=Youssarian;435391]Uh... you forgot Brooke.[/QUOTE] Now now, Brooke is underrated. [SPOILER]:surprise:[/SPOILER]

[QUOTE=Youssarian;435389]Ruthie is definitely a great competitor. Her performance on BOTSexes was obviously amazing, but she was also solid on Battle of the Sexes 2, considered the best girl on her team on Gauntlet 2, and won an individual challenge on the Duel 2. Her size is a hindrance (see her elimination against Beth), but she has a lot of fight. Despite Beth being like 3 times her size in Reverse Tug of War, Ruthie was able to use her strategy and ferocity to stall Beth and even make a tiny bit of progress for a couple of minutes before the inevitable happened (which was due to the size difference). Her loss to Kimberly is definitely a detractor, though.[/QUOTE] The girls on her team were Robin, Aneesa, Katie, Montana, Beth, Jisela & Julie...... It's not that hard to be the best amongst those girls. Ruthie is overrated.

[QUOTE=TheKorean;435396]The girls on her team were Robin, Aneesa, Katie, Montana, Beth, Jisela & Julie...... It's not that hard to be the best amongst those girls. Ruthie is overrated.[/QUOTE] Ruthie may be slightly overrated but some are underrating her as well.

[QUOTE=kvm1977;435399]Ruthie may be slightly overrated but some are underrating her as well.[/QUOTE] I feel like if it weren't for her size, she'll be in at least the top 10 of all time. I hate challenges that caters to size, it's not fair. It's the same with Jasmine, the girl is small but has a lot of fire in her.

Ruthie dominated Sexes 1 and was even outperforming men on some missions. She did fine on her next two challenges, she even won the first individual Duel mission. She was outweighed by Beth and was outsmarted by Kim. She is at least top 6. Evelyn, Laurel, Rachel, Holly S, and Emily B would be my top 5. Veronica, Ruthie, Camila, Emily S, and I am still unsure who woukd be #10 for me.

[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;435403]Ruthie dominated Sexes 1 and was even outperforming men on some missions. She did fine on her next two challenges, she even won the first individual Duel mission. She was outweighed by Beth and was outsmarted by Kim. She is at least top 6. Evelyn, Laurel, Rachel, Holly S, and Emily B would be my top 5. Veronica, Ruthie, Camila, Emily S, and I am still unsure who woukd be #10 for me.[/QUOTE] What about Jodi for the #10 spot.

[QUOTE=nevidcm;435405]What about Jodi for the #10 spot.[/QUOTE] How did I forget Jodi?! She's probably #5 then.

[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;435406]How did I forget Jodi?! She's probably #5 then.[/QUOTE] I would swap Jodi for Emily B.

[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;435403]Evelyn, Laurel, Rachel, Holly S, and Emily B would be my top 5. Veronica, Ruthie, Camila, Emily S, and I am still unsure who woukd be #10 for me.[/QUOTE] Veronica's tough for me to place for many reasons. I think she's a better strategist than a competitor and if we're listing players Coral & Susie would easily be top 10 but as far as competitors go I think Evelyn, Laurel, Rachel, Holly S, Emily B, Emily S & Ruthie are all safely in the top 10. Jodi has an excellent case. I wish we saw Christena and Ellen once because I think they would have been right there.

[QUOTE=kvm1977;435412]Veronica's tough for me to place for many reasons. I think she's a better strategist than a competitor and if we're listing players Coral & Susie would easily be top 10 but as far as competitors go I think Evelyn, Laurel, Rachel, Holly S, Emily B, Emily S & Ruthie are all safely in the top 10. Jodi has an excellent case. I wish we saw Christena and Ellen once because I think they would have been right there.[/QUOTE] I think people forget she was a very good competitor. I agree on all of those being better than her except Emily S though.

[QUOTE=nevidcm;435402]I feel like if it weren't for her size, she'll be in at least the top 10 of all time. I hate challenges that caters to size, it's not fair. It's the same with Jasmine, the girl is small but has a lot of fire in her.[/QUOTE] Yup, her gassing out in that log mission on BOTS2 really showed us how much fire she has....

[QUOTE=Lola88;435380]I agree with this. Her appearance on Battle of the Sexes 1 is what gave her this overrated credit. Laurel Evelyn Emily Rachel Tonya imo are the top 5 female competitors. Camila Sarah Marie Paula Kelly Anne Cooke all get get honorable mentions with possible overtake in the future.[/QUOTE] Lol I love Kelly & Toyna but they are nowhere near top. And what the **** why'd you put Marie who didn't win a single mission?

[QUOTE=nevidcm;435411]I would swap Jodi for Emily B.[/QUOTE] I agree. I feel like it's Jodi's athletic ability.

[QUOTE=Debut Album;435346]I think Cara was Decent before Free Agents honestly.[/QUOTE] In what way?

Evelyn vs. Sarah G in Dead Mans Drop Brooke vs Casey in Ball Brawl I've seen a few people mention they wanted to see Linette back. What positive qualities do you think she possesses that could get her to a final?

[QUOTE=Euroslavia;435498]I've seen a few people mention they wanted to see Linette back. What positive qualities do you think she possesses that could get her to a final?[/QUOTE] Linette seemed athletic and laid back. She was good in water and won two missions with Shane.

[QUOTE=kvm1977;435507]Linette seemed athletic and laid back. She was good in water and won two missions with Shane.[/QUOTE] She also was incapable of carrying any weight at any point in time Even Johanna was able to do that

I'd rather see Aviv or Chanda for freshmeat girls over linette tbh

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;435517]I'd rather see Aviv or Chanda for freshmeat girls over linette tbh[/QUOTE] Agreed. Sadly, they didn't cause enough 'drama' during their challenge to be relevant in any future challenges. I think both of them could've been decent competitors. Aviv solved the puzzles for Darrell, right?

[QUOTE=ItalianBeats;435494]In what way?[/QUOTE] I take that back. She was weak as **** and only got to the end because of Abram. She sucked and should've went home.

Nahh Aviv is way better than Chanda, Aviv has a kick *** hot wheels collection.