[QUOTE=Nostalgic;433187]I don't blame them for once. Tyler and Tyrie are way more interesting and respectable than Dumbar. I hope Sahar is there too.[/QUOTE]
Tyrie is more interesting than Dunbar? Care to explain how?
[QUOTE=JayTee;433142]EXACTLY!
People are just blinded by Jessica's annoying personality that they give so much credit to a girl who can walk across a slippery beam. Just LOL.
I'm done arguing with the illogical people saying stuff based on emotions with this topic.[/QUOTE]
The logic "She's a black belt, she has to be good..." is so irritating. Do you know HOW many times we've heard "[INSERT NAME] plays [INSERT SPORT], they're going to be amazing!"
Here's some just off the top of my head:
Jasmine put on 10-15 pounds of muscle for Rivals, watch out!
Jonna won Endurance as a kid, she’s going to be a force to be reckon with.
Tyrie used to play college football, he’s going to be unstoppable.
Katelynn is a black belt, she’s going to get far in Fresh Meat 2!
Eric dropped a whole bunch of weight, he’ll be good this time.
Robb put on a lot of muscle, Rivals 2 should be a good Challenge for him.
McKenzie was a high school athlete, she’ll be a good addition to Battle of the Seasons.
Heather has a lot of potential, but can't say she is better than Jess based off of what we have seen. I want to say she played soccer growing up as well, but am not sure? The Jess hate is ridiculous though, she can be annoying, but **** some of you act like she has gone on a racist/homophobic tirade. Also, while Ayiiia looks great there, I thought Jessica looked amazing, as well.
Preach it brother! Glad to see logic still runs throughout this board.
All these collegiate football players and black belts and who's the won with the most challenge wins? Who's the one that crushes mountains like no other? Who's the one that never really played any sport in high school or college and instead drunk beers and did curls all the time at the gym? You're average ******* turned challenge legend Johnny Bananas.
The Challege is just a whole nother "sport" if you will. It will drain you physically and psychologically and lots of these kids that supposedly had so much potential just can't handle it.
Although I do give credit to the ones that can (Frank, Zach (kind of), Sarah, etc...)
[QUOTE=JayTee;433231]Preach it brother! Glad to see logic still runs throughout this board.
All these collegiate football players and black belts and who's the won with the most challenge wins? Who's the one that crushes mountains like no other? Who's the one that never really played any sport in high school or college and instead drunk beers and did curls all the time at the gym? You're average ******* turned challenge legend Johnny Bananas.[/QUOTE]
You make it difficult for me to tolerate Bananas, holy ****...
[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;433232]You make it difficult for me to tolerate Bananas, holy ****...[/QUOTE]
Just how the Heat and Lakers **** off a lot of people for being great!
[QUOTE=JayTee;433234]Just how the Heat and Lakers **** off a lot of people for being great![/QUOTE]
I do not get the refrnece, but no I do not dislike him for his success. I don't even dislike him anymore, but you are making me dislike him. Is that better?
[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;433235]I do not get the refrnece, but no I do not dislike him for his success. I don't even dislike him anymore, but you are making me dislike him. Is that better?[/QUOTE]
[url=http://news.mtv.ca/blogs/the-challenge/johnny-bananas-challenge-cronies-wish-him-a-semi-happy-30th-birthday-video/]Johnny Bananas? ?Challenge? Cronies Wish Him A Semi Happy 30th Birthday [Video] | MTV News[/url]
Classic Bananas.
We need The Island JB to make a come back!
[QUOTE=JayTee;433236][url=http://news.mtv.ca/blogs/the-challenge/johnny-bananas-challenge-cronies-wish-him-a-semi-happy-30th-birthday-video/]Johnny Bananas? ?Challenge? Cronies Wish Him A Semi Happy 30th Birthday [Video] | MTV News[/url]
Classic Bananas.
We need The Island JB to make a come back![/QUOTE]
Yes the guy who almost got voted out even when the guy standing asked to him was ASKING to be voted off. That was JB at his worst.
[QUOTE=thefinishlin;433227]The logic "She's a black belt, she has to be good..." is so irritating. Do you know HOW many times we've heard "[INSERT NAME] plays [INSERT SPORT], they're going to be amazing!"
Here's some just off the top of my head:
Jasmine put on 10-15 pounds of muscle for Rivals, watch out!
Jonna won Endurance as a kid, she’s going to be a force to be reckon with.
Tyrie used to play college football, he’s going to be unstoppable.
Katelynn is a black belt, she’s going to get far in Fresh Meat 2!
Eric dropped a whole bunch of weight, he’ll be good this time.
Robb put on a lot of muscle, Rivals 2 should be a good Challenge for him.
McKenzie was a high school athlete, she’ll be a good addition to Battle of the Seasons.[/QUOTE]
Look I love Heather. She will always be one of my favorite real worlders. I can't stand Jessica. However, we can't assume that Heather will be better or vice versa, bc neither have and probably never will compete in the same challenge.
[QUOTE=Coralfan;433240]Look I love Heather. She will always be one of my favorite real worlders. I can't stand Jessica. However, we can't assume that Heather will be better or vice versa, bc neither have and probably never will compete in the same challenge.[/QUOTE]
I like Heather a lot too. She's cute as **** and she's from New Jersey, relatively close to my town too! But I don't understand this Jess hate. Jess is cute too, granted she craves attention, but at least she doesn't act out like some of these other girls on this show (****o Camilla). Heather's biggest disadvantage is her height. She's tiny - really tiny. Five foot 3 with very little muscle on her. I may be underestimating her, but I say she'd be in the same tier as Ayiiia and Jonna [B]based on height alone.[/B]
[QUOTE=DarkFights;433192]You're kidding..right[/QUOTE]
Tonya,Trishelle, Robin are def. challenge legends. so idk why you wouldn't agree with them. The others I agree with.
[QUOTE=El Scorcho;433223]Tyrie is more interesting than Dunbar? Care to explain how?[/QUOTE]
LOL yeah Tyrie is actually one of the like 4 people that are actually less interesting than Dunbar.
[QUOTE=mph922;433260]LOL yeah Tyrie is actually one of the like 4 people that are actually less interesting than Dunbar.[/QUOTE]
I still think that Tyrie is more interesting than Brandon lol
[QUOTE=El Scorcho;433225]What was the list for?[/QUOTE]
The Top 25 Stars of The Challenge series, I don't believe that people who were on 1-3 challenges can be nomionated as a star quality
[QUOTE=DarkFights;433192]You're kidding..right[/QUOTE]
No I'm not. I think that the ones you bolded have star quality regardless of how many challenges they've been on.
[QUOTE=thefinishlin;433244]I like Heather a lot too. She's cute as **** and she's from New Jersey, relatively close to my town too! But I don't understand this Jess hate. Jess is cute too, granted she craves attention, but at least she doesn't act out like some of these other girls on this show (****o Camilla). Heather's biggest disadvantage is her height. She's tiny - really tiny. Five foot 3 with very little muscle on her. I may be underestimating her, but I say she'd be in the same tier as Ayiiia and Jonna [B]based on height alone.[/B][/QUOTE]
Double post
[QUOTE=Debut Album;433264]No I'm not. I think that the ones you bolded have star quality regardless of how many challenges they've been on.[/QUOTE]
Robin- the only memorable thing she has ever done is cry.
Tonya- seriously she's just a drunk mess.
Devyn- This one annoyed me, how can you put Devyn above alot of people (Camila, Paula, EVELYN....) WHAT HAS SHE DONE!!
Marie- She was a star on BOTS2 indeed but we are talking about the whole series
Dustin- He only shined on BOTS2 so it takes more to be on top 25 list.
Trishelle- actually after thinking about it she was a star
Jordan- I would of preferd if he was on "Honorable Mentions"
other than that i liked you're list but this is just my opinion
[QUOTE=rwrrfan1;433245]Tonya,Trishelle, Robin are def. challenge legends. so idk why you wouldn't agree with them. The others I agree with.[/QUOTE]
Trishelle; Yes
The other two not really
[QUOTE=DarkFights;433268]Trishelle; Yes
The other two not really[/QUOTE]
Tonya I can kind of see. She was a decent-ish competitor back in the day and the drama surrounding her (with the 3 "mean girls") was great TV.
Legend in terms of competitior wise? Nah.
In terms of memorability? Yes
[QUOTE=DarkFights;433267]Robin- the only memorable thing she has ever done is cry.
Tonya- seriously she's just a drunk mess.
Devyn- This one annoyed me, how can you put Devyn above alot of people ([B]Camila, Paula, EVELYN....) [/B]WHAT HAS SHE DONE!!
Marie- She was a star on BOTS2 indeed but we are talking about the whole series
Dustin- He only shined on BOTS2 so it takes more to be on top 25 list.
Tris****e- actually after thinking about it she was a star
Jordan- I would of preferd if he was on "Honorable Mentions"
other than that i liked you're list but this is just my opinion[/QUOTE]
But see In my opinion Those three you listed haven't done a **** thing and aren't star quality(Paula was good on her RW Season but the challenges? **** no) Camilla and Evelyn are both Useless and not entertaining or stars at all.
[QUOTE=Debut Album;433271]But see In my opinion Those three you listed haven't done a **** thing and aren't star quality(Paula was good on her RW Season but the challenges? **** no) Camilla and Evelyn are both Useless and not entertaining or stars at all.[/QUOTE]
Camila's drunk behaviour is less entertaining than Robin crying? or Tonya hooking up with randoms?
Ev was the star of the Island, she also made a memorable exit on The Ruins, her alliance on FM2 with Wes brought alot of controversy and her amazing performance each season is a plus to me I'm pretty sure that she IS a bigger star than Robin & Tonya
[QUOTE=DarkFights;433275]Camila's drunk behaviour is less entertaining than Robin crying? or Tonya hooking up with randoms?
Ev was the star of the Island, she also made a memorable exit on The Ruins, her alliance on FM2 with Wes brought alot of controversy and her amazing performance each season is a plus to me I'm pretty sure that she IS a bigger star than Robin & Tonya[/QUOTE]
Debut can't stand fresh meat/Camila and worships rookies so don't even bother trying to use logic.
[QUOTE=DarkFights;433275]Camila's drunk behaviour is less entertaining than Robin crying? or Tonya hooking up with randoms?
Ev was the star of the Island, she also made a memorable exit on The Ruins, her alliance on FM2 with Wes brought alot of controversy and her amazing performance each season is a plus to me I'm pretty sure that she IS a bigger star than Robin & Tonya[/QUOTE]
You're forgetting that Tonya had that spat with Robin Regarding Mark and Tonya and it ended up her throwing In Beth's clothes in the pool. That alone was more entertaining than anything Evelyn or Camilla has done.
And to be Honest Evelyn Deserved all the **** she got on The Island. Mainly because of how she was on The Gauntlet 3. And Camilla's stupid little freakouts are not entertaining to me IMO.
I don't see how me not finding them entertaining is wrong.
[QUOTE=toenails;433279]Devyn and Marie are bigger stars than Paula and Evelyn?... Hahahahaha thank you, I needed that laugh.[/QUOTE]
Devyn is funny And Marie was actually entertaining. can't say the same for Paula or Evelyn.
But that's my opinion of course.
[QUOTE=Debut Album;433284]You're forgetting that Tonya had that spat with Robin Regarding Mark and Tonya and it ended up her throwing In Beth's clothes in the pool. That alone was more entertaining than anything Evelyn or Camilla has done.
And to be Honest Evelyn Deserved all the **** she got on The Island. Mainly because of how she was on The Gauntlet 3. And Camilla's stupid little freakouts are not entertaining to me IMO.
I don't see how me not finding them entertaining is wrong.[/QUOTE]
Never said that you not finding them entertaining is wrong my whole point is that I couldn't understand how you believe Tonya, Robin, Dustin, Devyn & Marie are more entertaining than others
Pages