The Challenge: What Could Have Been (SPOILERS)

166 posts / 0 new
Last post

kvm1977 wrote:

rwportland2 wrote:

justintime wrote:Averey and Joi should have made their debut on Free Agents over girls like Emilee and Jasmine, both are athletic and would have made the girls side more competitive. Averey has so much potential IMO. 

thats what sucked about Free Agents. I feel like that challenge was set up for Laurel and Johnny to win from the start. Better competition would have made that season from good to great.

I agree about Laurel (just like The Duels were set for Jodi & Rachel) but not John.   John battled hard to win that season.  If it was set up for anyone to win it I'd say CT.  Regarding Cooke--Cooke hasn't done anything to indicate she can beat Laurel.  But, yeah, maybe.  Averey and Joi--absolutely not.   Theresa and Cara were the biggest threats to Laurel and I'm not sure Cooke beats either of them in a final.

hold on, you realize Cooke/Cara were killing the rivals 2 final like they were wayyyy ahead of Emily/Paula until the eating portion. Don’t sleep on Cooke, her return>>>>

Way ahead is an exaggeration...having Cara as a #2 should have been a win for Cooke.  So but Cara > Paula at that point of the challenge.  Emily > Cooke.  I'm not even convinced Cara wouldn't beat Cooke.  I think Cooke is a great athlete and I'd love to see her again but I think she's overvalued around here based on what she actually did on Rivals 2 as opposed to what some believe she can do moving forward.  If Naomi doesn''t quit (for valid reason) we wouldn't have seen much of Cooke at all.

I can never seem to remember Emilee on any challenge she's on... Like I definitely completely forgot she was on free agents.

I can never seem to remember Emilee on any challenge she's on... Like I definitely completely forgot she was on free agents.

i think thats because she has never lasted more than the 2nd episode, shes the original latoya

Derrick & Ibis were confirmed for Invasion but production didn't I ise them 

Ibis is stil linterested in coming back!?!?!? Yes please...I need my x-treme cast back on the air!

King-lmh wrote:

Derrick & Ibis were confirmed for Invasion but production didn't I ise them 

Ibis is stil linterested in coming back!?!?!? Yes please...I need my x-treme cast back on the air!

hold on... did production know invasion was gonna be a flop of a season? Why else would they have champs like Zach/Ashley K when they could’ve had Derrick K/Ibis? 

Just reading through everything (thanks Yous)....I think I'm most disappointed that we never saw Patrick, that Irulan ever returned, that Kendal never returned, and that we had so many opportunites to see Katie, Landon & Ruthie again but haven't.  Averey accepting mutliple times and not being cast is highly disappointing given the people we've seen.  And if Darrell/Rachel were in for Exes 2 and not cast someone should be shot.  They would have gone after John and his crew so hard that Darell would have even worked with Wes

i agree with all of this 100% I was sad Patrick was never used...didn't realize he was interested after Sexes 2.

team road rules not being used in Seasons still pisses me off.

Psy4potato wrote:

King-lmh wrote:Derrick & Ibis were confirmed for Invasion but production didn't I ise them 

Ibis is stil linterested in coming back!?!?!? Yes please...I need my x-treme cast back on the air!

hold on... did production know invasion was gonna be a flop of a season? Why else would they have champs like Zach/Ashley K when they could’ve had Derrick K/Ibis? 

they clearly had Zach and Ashley K there because Jenna was gonna be there and they probably hoped it would create some sort of messy love triangle. 

Psy4potato wrote:

King-lmh wrote:Derrick & Ibis were confirmed for Invasion but production didn't I ise them 

Ibis is stil linterested in coming back!?!?!? Yes please...I need my x-treme cast back on the air!

hold on... did production know invasion was gonna be a flop of a season? Why else would they have champs like Zach/Ashley K when they could’ve had Derrick K/Ibis? 

lol I'd rather have Derrick/Ibis over Zach/Ashley any day.  But that's all just personal opinion. It was nice to see Ashley again. 

 

NMechling2 wrote:

Psy4potato wrote:

King-lmh wrote:Derrick & Ibis were confirmed for Invasion but production didn't I ise them 

Ibis is stil linterested in coming back!?!?!? Yes please...I need my x-treme cast back on the air!

hold on... did production know invasion was gonna be a flop of a season? Why else would they have champs like Zach/Ashley K when they could’ve had Derrick K/Ibis? 

lol I'd rather have Derrick/Ibis over Zach/Ashley any day.  But that's all just personal opinion. It was nice to see Ashley again.  

i agree with you lol but I see the point that it could’ve created a love triangle between Ashley k/Zach/jenna. Production is stupid if they actually though Ashley would get involved tho 

are you sure about Ibis?  Derrick yes but I thought our Buffalo Wild Wing allstar was considered.

are you sure about Ibis?  Derrick yes but I thought our Buffalo Wild Wing allstar was considered.

Yes, I agree. I was under the impression that it was Sam and Ibis was wishful thinking/the only other champion girl who wasn't definitely ruled out.

Yeah it was sam, the Ibis speculation is like the usual Tina speculation before every season because neither are active that oftenly on social media

I'm really upset at how they casted the females for Free Agents more than anything. 

Especially upset Susie declined, she is a true Challenge gem we don't get to see nearly enough. 

Along with Susie, they should've added Emily S, Cooke, Jenn G, Avery,   Joi, Evelyn, Sarah Rice, & Tina. With Laurel, Cara, Devyn, Theresa, Nia, & Nany that would've been an epic female lineup, no? 

Some of the legends in contention for Bloodlines II.

I'm really upset at how they casted the females for Free Agents more than anything. Especially upset Susie declined, she is a true Challenge gem we don't get to see nearly enough. Along with Susie, they should've added Emily S, Cooke, Jenn G, Avery,   Joi, Evelyn, Sarah Rice, & Tina. With Laurel, Cara, Devyn, Theresa, Nia, & Nany that would've been an epic female lineup, no? 

4 or 5 of those gems declined or are completely out of reality tv, i believe. So it's not like they didn't try. With the exception of Avery which I think they replaced her or didn't contact her.

Should I update for S31 when the cast departs or when the season is officially announced by mtv

Should I update for S31 when the cast departs or when the season is officially announced by mtv

Departure day Smile

I've been keeping a list of confirmed-by-the-spoiler-team close calls for season 31 as well.

I've been keeping a list of confirmed-by-the-spoiler-team close calls for season 31 as well.

Can you confirm if Alicia, Madison and Sylvia are on the final cast?

Youssarian wrote:

I've been keeping a list of confirmed-by-the-spoiler-team close calls for season 31 as well.

Can you confirm if Alicia, Madison and Sylvia are on the final cast?

1. This isn't the spoiler thread

2. If they knew/were able to say they will.

Brad/Cameran/Randy/RobinLandon/MJ/Shavonda/????Ashley/Emily/Josh/TyArissa/Frank and Cooke/LeroyActual BOTSeasons cast is SHOOK.

all of them plus the epic road Rules team...would have been amazing!!!!

If Nany won Free Agents instead of Laurel <3

Could you imagine how different Inferno 2 would have been with Melissa and Coral instead of Coral and Beth?

Melissa was not a strong competitor, she would have been sacrificed first, and possibly Robin would have beat her. With all the Beth drama gone, and Rachel not there to head the trifecta of V, R, and T the game may have been very different.

If Nany won Free Agents instead of Laurel <3

Going to update this within a day or so for season 31, I know a lot for what could've been but if you have any info let me know 

Keep it. It's probably a lot better than the final cast turned out to be lmao

Going to update this within a day or so for season 31, I know a lot for what could've been but if you have any info let me know 

just PM me tho

Keep it. It's probably a lot better than the final cast turned out to be lmao

lol it is 

Going to update this within a day or so for season 31, I know a lot for what could've been but if you have any info let me know 

lol based on some stuff I heard incredibly easy enraged but I look forward to being even more enraged! Thanks for updating! 

Going to update this within a day or so for season 31, I know a lot for what could've been but if you have any info let me know 

I'll PM you what I've gathered from the spoiler team's posts

Pages