The Challenge: Cast Member Rankings

806 posts / 0 new
Last post
I just can't stand her. Sorry, not/sorry
Didn't you like Nany before? lol I was checking the Free Agents thread the other day on the cast bios and saw that you complimented her 
I totally did.  I did a complete 180 on her.  Her trashiness & loud mouth just became too  much for me.  She is NOT hot & feisty to me anymore!  :)  
I totally did.  I did a complete 180 on her.  Her trashiness & loud mouth just became too  much for me.  She is NOT hot & feisty to me anymore!  :)  
I don't necessarily mind her but my interest in her peaked during BOTS.
I really don't understand all the Nany hate. I mean she's not horrid in the least imo.
Agreed 100%.  vVry short shelf life for that girl.  I don't mind seeing her return though.  Everytime she loses it's like Christmas for me.  I think her Bananas affiliation is what really killed my interest in her.  All downhill from there.  
I totally did.  I did a complete 180 on her.  Her trashiness & loud mouth just became too  much for me.  She is NOT hot & feisty to me anymore!  :)
LMAO I was dying at your comment saying "What is not to like about Nany?" then on the Exes II thread, you said she was a cheap tramp lol
I am very fickle. 
I really don't understand all the Nany hate. I mean she's not horrid in the least imo.
I used to not be able to stand Wes on Austin, but by the first few eps of Fresh Meat I adored him.  Still love him to this day. Gauntlet 3 is up,  Junky!
Agreed 100%.  vVry short shelf life for that girl.  I don't mind seeing her return though.  Everytime she loses it's like Christmas for me.  I think her Bananas affiliation is what really killed my interest in her.  All downhill from there.  
I think she was faking it that time...or at least I hope she was.
I really don't understand all the Nany hate. I mean she's not horrid in the least imo.
yeah same and when asked why they ddin't like her, aside from bringing up her being slutty (which lol who isnt?), they mention she's cocky, yet couldn't give actual examples of it. The whole mocking of an injury was awful, but aside from that, she really wasn't nearly as awful as anybody made her seem.
Yaaaaaaassssss@ Cara and Camilla Being out. Eric I don't mind(and I think I'm like the only one that doesn't mind him too). For the next update Guesses. Ellen and Sarah(Campus Crawl) those are the only two that popped in my head. I'm thinking Robin/Aneesa/Tina. Those 3 are ones that did 5 shows without winning that come to my mind Last one I'm guessing Zach and Leroy.
i was thinking Frank.
I really don't understand all the Nany hate. I mean she's not horrid in the least imo.
yeah same and when asked why they ddin't like her, aside from bringing up her being slutty (which lol who isnt?), they mention she's cocky, yet couldn't give actual examples of it. The whole mocking of an injury was awful, but aside from that, she really wasn't nearly as awful as anybody made her seem.
I don't understand the cockiness either. She's never been that at all.
I really don't understand all the Nany hate. I mean she's not horrid in the least imo.
yeah same and when asked why they ddin't like her, aside from bringing up her being slutty (which lol who isnt?), they mention she's cocky, yet couldn't give actual examples of it. The whole mocking of an injury was awful, but aside from that, she really wasn't nearly as awful as anybody made her seem.
I don't understand the cockiness either. She's never been that at all.
One of the biggest reasons why I don't like her is her attitude. Use to love her until Exes2. Once she got with that asshole, it's like she turned into one. I'll give a example. During the Hall Brawl elimination when she was clapping and cheering when Wes got hurt. That was not necessary. Still gets me to this day when she was saying "sucks to suck." Lmfao!! Bitch, you lost twice in one season with the five time champ as a partner.
I really don't understand all the Nany hate. I mean she's not horrid in the least imo.
yeah same and when asked why they ddin't like her, aside from bringing up her being slutty (which lol who isnt?), they mention she's cocky, yet couldn't give actual examples of it. The whole mocking of an injury was awful, but aside from that, she really wasn't nearly as awful as anybody made her seem.
I don't understand the cockiness either. She's never been that at all.
  It's not necessarily her cockiness about her game, she just walks around thinking she's hot shit in general.  Like she's used to being fawned over.  It's sickening.
I really don't understand all the Nany hate. I mean she's not horrid in the least imo.
yeah same and when asked why they ddin't like her, aside from bringing up her being slutty (which lol who isnt?), they mention she's cocky, yet couldn't give actual examples of it. The whole mocking of an injury was awful, but aside from that, she really wasn't nearly as awful as anybody made her seem.
I don't understand the cockiness either. She's never been that at all.
She was cocky all throughout Exes 2 and a little bit on Free Agents. She's never done anything to back up that cockiness.
Can people bring up actual incidents where she was cocky then for either FA or Exes 2?
Can people bring up actual incidents where she was cocky then for either FA or Exes 2?
Well Exes 2 from the time her & Johnny got back in the house to the time they left again, you could take all of that as cockiness but her partner was even more cocky so it wasn't all her. -You could tell both of them thought they were sitting pretty & coasting to the final....Sarah had to remind them. -Her thinking she coud go toe-to-toe with Nia in an argument or fight.....Nia had to remind her. -Ms. Fail also had to remind her that for all the talking Nany did, she wasn't kicking nobody's ass in the elimination & if anything, got HER ass kicked (taking all those kicks & elbows to the face). There is nothing wrong with being confident but Nany definitely let her partner rub off on her during that time.   As far as Free Agents: I don't remember anything necessarily cocky but her fight with Camila made them both look like dumbasses. "I WILL FUCK YOU UP" and trying to "hop" over somebody acting like she was really going to hit Camila....It was like yeah, go sit down somewhere. But like Dylan76 said, it's not about her really being cocky, but (for me at least) she obviously thinks she's one of the biggest badasses to ever grace the show.  
A lot of that seems liek assumptions/perceptions of her than her actually saying/doing something that would make her arrogant. I mean is Nany supposed to sit back and let Nia scream in her face? There's nothing wrong with her standing up for herselfn when Nia was going after her. Talking? Idk, I remember her trash talking Theresa, but let's also remmeber everything Theresa did to Nany on Exes 2 if we're bringing her up. Also, eh a lot of people ahve stupid, drunken fights, I wouldn't be surprised if those happen frequently and just rightuflly aren't aired because they're irrelveant.
A lot of that seems liek assumptions/perceptions of her than her actually saying/doing something that would make her arrogant. I mean is Nany supposed to sit back and let Nia scream in her face? There's nothing wrong with her standing up for herselfn when Nia was going after her. Talking? Idk, I remember her trash talking Theresa, but let's also remmeber everything Theresa did to Nany on Exes 2 if we're bringing her up. Also, eh a lot of people ahve stupid, drunken fights, I wouldn't be surprised if those happen frequently and just rightuflly aren't aired because they're irrelveant.
Well I mean you don't have to assume they thought they were coasting to the final because you could definitely tell...you could look at Johnny's bitchfit over being thrown in to see that & she thought the same with her talking about how she was gonna look like a idiot cheering for Sarah, then 2 seconds later saying her name. It's like they really thought with Johnny's wins & Nany at least being able to keep up in a final that Sarah was in the wrong for not wanting them there. She should definitely stand up for herself but at the same time Nia was talking to Johnny at that point in time, Nany decided she wanted to jump in for whatever reason.
Yeah to be fair, I stopped watching those last two episodes. If I'm remembering correctly,Nia was the one being over the top with Nany by including her, in the rant aganst bananas like calling her and johnny "fucking losers" etc. Nany just stated that she never said she was a champion and it escalated from there.
Yeah to be fair, I stopped watching those last two episodes. If I'm remembering correctly,Nia was the one being over the top with Nany by including her, in the rant aganst bananas like calling her and johnny "fucking losers" etc. Nany just stated that she never said she was a champion and it escalated from there.
but she was still cocky about how she thought she would destroy Theresa in that last elimination.
Yeah to be fair, I stopped watching those last two episodes. If I'm remembering correctly,Nia was the one being over the top with Nany by including her, in the rant aganst bananas like calling her and johnny "fucking losers" etc. Nany just stated that she never said she was a champion and it escalated from there.
but she was still cocky about how she thought she would destroy Theresa in that last elimination.
Well how was she supposed to be? You gotta go in like that(well not exactly that but in a confident attitude) otherwise you've already been beaten and you might as well not even try.
Can people bring up actual incidents where she was cocky then for either FA or Exes 2?
Well Exes 2 from the time her & Johnny got back in the house to the time they left again, you could take all of that as cockiness but her partner was even more cocky so it wasn't all her. -You could tell both of them thought they were sitting pretty & coasting to the final....Sarah had to remind them. -Her thinking she coud go toe-to-toe with Nia in an argument or fight.....Nia had to remind her. -Ms. Fail also had to remind her that for all the talking Nany did, she wasn't kicking nobody's ass in the elimination & if anything, got HER ass kicked (taking all those kicks & elbows to the face). There is nothing wrong with being confident but Nany definitely let her partner rub off on her during that time.   As far as Free Agents: I don't remember anything necessarily cocky but her fight with Camila made them both look like dumbasses. "I WILL FUCK YOU UP" and trying to "hop" over somebody acting like she was really going to hit Camila....It was like yeah, go sit down somewhere. But like Dylan76 said, it's not about her really being cocky, but (for me at least) she obviously thinks she's one of the biggest badasses to ever grace the show.  
The bolded I agree with. That fight was so stupid and it was sad watching Nany act like she was really going to fight Camilla(Wish she would have though) And I agree that Backpack did rub off on her a bit on Exes 2 but it wasn't that bad. Nowhere near Backpack/Kenny/Paula on The Island bad.
I remember in their intro videos that Nany was acting very cocky because she had Bananas as a partner. Very bad look on her.
Yeah to be fair, I stopped watching those last two episodes. If I'm remembering correctly,Nia was the one being over the top with Nany by including her, in the rant aganst bananas like calling her and johnny "fucking losers" etc. Nany just stated that she never said she was a champion and it escalated from there.
but she was still cocky about how she thought she would destroy Theresa in that last elimination.
Well how was she supposed to be? You gotta go in like that(well not exactly that but in a confident attitude) otherwise you've already been beaten and you might as well not even try.
So when Laurel went against Jasmine should she have been cocky? Otherwise laurel would have lost.
Yeah to be fair, I stopped watching those last two episodes. If I'm remembering correctly,Nia was the one being over the top with Nany by including her, in the rant aganst bananas like calling her and johnny "fucking losers" etc. Nany just stated that she never said she was a champion and it escalated from there.
but she was still cocky about how she thought she would destroy Theresa in that last elimination.
Well how was she supposed to be? You gotta go in like that(well not exactly that but in a confident attitude) otherwise you've already been beaten and you might as well not even try.
So when Laurel went against Jasmine should she have been cocky? Otherwise laurel would have lost.
Not necessarily cocky but you always have to have a confident attitude regardless of who you go against so yes. Why Would Nany go up against Theresa with the attitude of her having no shot? I mean how was she supposed to act?
Yeah to be fair, I stopped watching those last two episodes. If I'm remembering correctly,Nia was the one being over the top with Nany by including her, in the rant aganst bananas like calling her and johnny "fucking losers" etc. Nany just stated that she never said she was a champion and it escalated from there.
but she was still cocky about how she thought she would destroy Theresa in that last elimination.
Well how was she supposed to be? You gotta go in like that(well not exactly that but in a confident attitude) otherwise you've already been beaten and you might as well not even try.
So when Laurel went against Jasmine should she have been cocky? Otherwise laurel would have lost.
Not necessarily cocky but you always have to have a confident attitude regardless of who you go against so yes. Why Would Nany go up against Theresa with the attitude of her having no shot? I mean how was she supposed to act?
Exactly and also correct me if I'm wrong but I don't even remember Nany saying anything about destorying Theresa or anything like that. I havn't watched it since it aired so I might be wrong but all I remember her saying was things like "this is what we've been waiting for" and "I have been wanting to get my hands on her". I don't see the cockiness and the examples given don't seem valid enough for me to see it. 
Great list

Pages