The Challenge: Cast Member Rankings

806 posts / 0 new
Last post
Jordan is also impressive because he competes well with only one hand.
Am I the only one that gets irritated when people say Jordan only has one hand? Not directed at the author but just in general I've heard people say it multiple times. When I say someone has no hands I think of this:   Jordan at least has a palm and a thumb (not sure about the other fingers) so he still has a second hand that is somewhat viable.
Okay so I think the three that I'll be happy as hell to see gone are Kenny/Evan/Camilla..Or Maybe Camilla/Backpack/Cara Maria As for the other part..hm i'm guessing Emily(Second Adventure), Cara(South Pacific), and the last one I wanna Say Jonna but I think she was already eliminated. *looks back through thread* Yep Jonna was ranked so I'll guess Melinda in place of her.
I'm thinking Diem.
I feel like she would be higher but you could be right though.
Okay so I think the three that I'll be happy as hell to see gone are Kenny/Evan/Camilla..Or Maybe Camilla/Backpack/Cara Maria As for the other part..hm i'm guessing Emily(Second Adventure), Cara(South Pacific), and the last one I wanna Say Jonna but I think she was already eliminated. *looks back through thread* Yep Jonna was ranked so I'll guess Melinda in place of her.
I'm thinking Diem.
I feel like she would be higher but you could be right though.
Maybe Kina? She had a serious boyfriend on the show. 
Kina actually makes the most sense.  
Kina actually makes the most sense.  
She does actually. This point in the ranking would be perfect for her. Perhaps her and Melinda would be two of them since I doubt Melinda goes further than this.
Kina actually makes the most sense.  
She does actually. This point in the ranking would be perfect for her. Perhaps her and Melinda would be two of them since I doubt Melinda goes further than this.
I thought Melinda already made the list, but if she hasn't she's wayyyy too high.
MELINDA IS NOT APPEARED YET ?    that is ... something
I thought Melinda already appeared.  I'll have to double check. Edit:  Melinda was #81 That leaves us with the following who have had serious boyfriends:
  • Emily B.
  • Kina
  • Diem
  • Cara Maria
  • Cara Z.
I thought Melinda already appeared.  I'll have to double check. Edit:  Melinda was #81 That leaves us with the following who have had serious boyfriends:
  • Emily B.
  • Kina
  • Diem
  • Cara Maria
That means we'll be seeing Emily B, Kina and Cara Maria next. Diem is definitely going to rank higher than them. 
I forgot Cara Z.  So it is probably Emily, Kina, and Cara Z.  Although I could see Emily going higher and both Caras coming next.
I forgot Cara Z.  So it is probably Emily, Kina, and Cara Z.  Although I could see Emily going higher and both Caras coming next.
As much as I don't like her I'm expecting Cara Maria to be on the top 10. 
I forgot Cara Z.  So it is probably Emily, Kina, and Cara Z.  Although I could see Emily going higher and both Caras coming next.
As much as I don't like her I'm expecting Cara Maria to be on the top 10. 
I'm not sure she's done enough to impact the franchise to be in the top 10.  You could argue for Emily B. because she pioneered the cutthroat politics.
Nany being higher than than superwoman Emily is a joke
I thought Melinda already appeared.  I'll have to double check. Edit:  Melinda was #81 That leaves us with the following who have had serious boyfriends:
  • Emily B.
  • Kina
  • Diem
  • Cara Maria
  • Cara Z.
Oh Melinda was ranked? Must have missed her. So yeah it's probably Kina, Cara(South Pacific), and Emily(Second Adventure). But I think Cara might be in the next round and Emily would be higher given that she was really one of the first ones to really play the game cold-hearted and Cutthroat and that's more than CM's ever done.
Nany, even though I don't like her, 100% deserves to be above Emily B, Kina, and Emily S. She's wayyy more memorable than all of them combined IMO.  Random question, did Susie place yet?
Nany, even though I don't like her, 100% deserves to be above Emily B, Kina, and Emily S. She's wayyy more memorable than all of them combined IMO.  Random question, did Susie place yet?
No. Susie didn't place yet. She'll probably be in the next update or the one after.
Nany, even though I don't like her, 100% deserves to be above Emily B, Kina, and Emily S. She's wayyy more memorable than all of them combined IMO.  Random question, did Susie place yet?
LOL absolutely not.  If you remove Nany from The Challenge, the show is no different.  I'm not saying that to be mean it's just true.  She hasn't dominated a challenge like Emily S. nor has she transformed the way people vote like Emily B.  Nany and Kina are about the same imo.
Nany, even though I don't like her, 100% deserves to be above Emily B, Kina, and Emily S. She's wayyy more memorable than all of them combined IMO.  Random question, did Susie place yet?
LOL absolutely not.  If you remove Nany from The Challenge, the show is no different.  I'm not saying that to be mean it's just true.  She hasn't dominated a challenge like Emily S. nor has she transformed the way people vote like Emily B.  Nany and Kina are about the same imo.
Honestly. You can remove anyone from the show and it wouldn't change a thing so you can say that about anyone.
Nany, even though I don't like her, 100% deserves to be above Emily B, Kina, and Emily S. She's wayyy more memorable than all of them combined IMO.  Random question, did Susie place yet?
LOL absolutely not.  If you remove Nany from The Challenge, the show is no different.  I'm not saying that to be mean it's just true.  She hasn't dominated a challenge like Emily S. nor has she transformed the way people vote like Emily B.  Nany and Kina are about the same imo.
Nany has had a much bigger impact to the show than Emily's and Kina. Hands down. Nany is the current challenge star IMO and she is much more memorable than the Emily's and Kina. Emily is wallpaper for most of the seasons she's on, 0 personality, all brawn. Not entertaining at all.
You can say she has had a  bigger impact but you haven't explained how.
Nany, even though I don't like her, 100% deserves to be above Emily B, Kina, and Emily S. She's wayyy more memorable than all of them combined IMO.  Random question, did Susie place yet?
LOL absolutely not.  If you remove Nany from The Challenge, the show is no different.  I'm not saying that to be mean it's just true.  She hasn't dominated a challenge like Emily S. nor has she transformed the way people vote like Emily B.  Nany and Kina are about the same imo.
Honestly. You can remove anyone from the show and it wouldn't change a thing so you can say that about anyone.
Oh ok...then how did JEK ruin the show if that is true?
You can say she has had a  bigger impact but you haven't explained how.
As much as people will hate to read this Nany is essentially the Veronica of this era. Veronica was one of if not the biggest female name during her era and now Nany is that name. It's hard to look at it now because she is still doing challenges but for fans that just started watching the show a couple seasons ago Nany is the biggest female name on the challenge. She is always in some type of drama, hookup and competes well she deserves one of the highest rankings of the challengers still doing the show today. 
You can say she has had a  bigger impact but you haven't explained how.
As much as people will hate to read this Nany is essentially the Veronica of this era. Veronica was one of if not the biggest female name during her era and now Nany is that name. It's hard to look at it now because she is still doing challenges but for fans that just started watching the show a couple seasons ago Nany is the biggest female name on the challenge. She is always in some type of drama, hookup and competes well she deserves one of the highest rankings of the challengers still doing the show today. 
I wouldn't disagree with that.  I was actually thinking she is like a Veronica lite.  However, I don't think her track record is up to Veronica's level yet.  She has yet to control a challenge in the way that Veronica did.  Is being popular good enough to impact the series?
You can say she has had a  bigger impact but you haven't explained how.
As much as people will hate to read this Nany is essentially the Veronica of this era. Veronica was one of if not the biggest female name during her era and now Nany is that name. It's hard to look at it now because she is still doing challenges but for fans that just started watching the show a couple seasons ago Nany is the biggest female name on the challenge. She is always in some type of drama, hookup and competes well she deserves one of the highest rankings of the challengers still doing the show today. 
I wouldn't disagree with that.  I was actually thinking she is like a Veronica lite.  However, I don't think her track record is up to Veronica's level yet.  She has yet to control a challenge in the way that Veronica did.  Is being popular good enough to impact the series?
I think being one of the most popular cast members impacts the series is some way. You also have to remember during Veronicas challenges it was all teams so it was easier to control the girls side of your team especially because the guys on her team were usually the quiet drama free type. The Ruins she actually had guys on her team that ran things unlike she did her first few challenges and look where it got her. 
Nany, even though I don't like her, 100% deserves to be above Emily B, Kina, and Emily S. She's wayyy more memorable than all of them combined IMO.  Random question, did Susie place yet?
LOL absolutely not.  If you remove Nany from The Challenge, the show is no different.  I'm not saying that to be mean it's just true.  She hasn't dominated a challenge like Emily S. nor has she transformed the way people vote like Emily B.  Nany and Kina are about the same imo.
Honestly. You can remove anyone from the show and it wouldn't change a thing so you can say that about anyone.
Oh ok...then how did JEK ruin the show if that is true?
I'm talking about now not then( And actually I shouldn't say anyone either..I'd say alot of the people doing challenges now could be replaced and nothing would change).. And I've stated that Not just JEK ruined the show..It was also production as well(and I would say they fucked it up moreso than those three Idiots).
You can say she has had a  bigger impact but you haven't explained how.
As much as people will hate to read this Nany is essentially the Veronica of this era. Veronica was one of if not the biggest female name during her era and now Nany is that name. It's hard to look at it now because she is still doing challenges but for fans that just started watching the show a couple seasons ago Nany is the biggest female name on the challenge. She is always in some type of drama, hookup and competes well she deserves one of the highest rankings of the challengers still doing the show today. 
I wouldn't disagree with that.  I was actually thinking she is like a Veronica lite.  However, I don't think her track record is up to Veronica's level yet.  She has yet to control a challenge in the way that Veronica did.  Is being popular good enough to impact the series?
I think being one of the most popular cast members impacts the series is some way. You also have to remember during Veronicas challenges it was all teams so it was easier to control the girls side of your team especially because the guys on her team were usually the quiet drama free type. The Ruins she actually had guys on her team that ran things unlike she did her first few challenges and look where it got her. 
I think as far as ratings but not in any other area(unless said popular castmember is acutally entertaining and brings something to the show).
You can say she has had a  bigger impact but you haven't explained how.
As much as people will hate to read this Nany is essentially the Veronica of this era. Veronica was one of if not the biggest female name during her era and now Nany is that name. It's hard to look at it now because she is still doing challenges but for fans that just started watching the show a couple seasons ago Nany is the biggest female name on the challenge. She is always in some type of drama, hookup and competes well she deserves one of the highest rankings of the challengers still doing the show today. 
I would say she's more Tonya than Veronica
You can say she has had a  bigger impact but you haven't explained how.
As much as people will hate to read this Nany is essentially the Veronica of this era. Veronica was one of if not the biggest female name during her era and now Nany is that name. It's hard to look at it now because she is still doing challenges but for fans that just started watching the show a couple seasons ago Nany is the biggest female name on the challenge. She is always in some type of drama, hookup and competes well she deserves one of the highest rankings of the challengers still doing the show today. 
I wouldn't disagree with that.  I was actually thinking she is like a Veronica lite.  However, I don't think her track record is up to Veronica's level yet.  She has yet to control a challenge in the way that Veronica did.  Is being popular good enough to impact the series?
Her rivalry with Theresa dominated and took control of an entire sotryline for Exes 2. Her fight with Frank was the biggest part of Seasons 2. Her controversial hook up with both Johnny and Cohutta. She's TV Gold and is so much more important than Kina, Emily, and Emily S in regards to their impact to the show. If Nany wasn't on these show there'd be a huge decrease of entertainment. 
You can say she has had a  bigger impact but you haven't explained how.
As much as people will hate to read this Nany is essentially the Veronica of this era. Veronica was one of if not the biggest female name during her era and now Nany is that name. It's hard to look at it now because she is still doing challenges but for fans that just started watching the show a couple seasons ago Nany is the biggest female name on the challenge. She is always in some type of drama, hookup and competes well she deserves one of the highest rankings of the challengers still doing the show today. 
I would say she's more Tonya than Veronica
Yeah. Nany seems more like a less crazy and more likable Tonya.
You can say she has had a  bigger impact but you haven't explained how.
As much as people will hate to read this Nany is essentially the Veronica of this era. Veronica was one of if not the biggest female name during her era and now Nany is that name. It's hard to look at it now because she is still doing challenges but for fans that just started watching the show a couple seasons ago Nany is the biggest female name on the challenge. She is always in some type of drama, hookup and competes well she deserves one of the highest rankings of the challengers still doing the show today. 
I wouldn't disagree with that.  I was actually thinking she is like a Veronica lite.  However, I don't think her track record is up to Veronica's level yet.  She has yet to control a challenge in the way that Veronica did.  Is being popular good enough to impact the series?
Her rivalry with Theresa dominated and took control of an entire sotryline for Exes 2. Her fight with Frank was the biggest part of Seasons 2. Her controversial hook up with both Johnny and Cohutta. She's TV Gold and is so much more important than Kina, Emily, and Emily S in regards to their impact to the show. If Nany wasn't on these show there'd be a huge decrease of entertainment. 
this. you don't have to manipulate people to be important.

Pages