The Challenge: Cast Member Rankings

806 posts / 0 new
Last post
Good update. Chris and Cameron were awesome. Zach was too.
Love this idea!  I was planning on doing one for my Challenge document I've been working on.  Very hard to stay unbiased Smile
hey man i hate to tell you but Priscilla did not do well at ALL on her elimination in Battle of the Exes 2. she was the first one to fall, and she fell pretty early. however i guess her being above Simone is justified. so i agree with her ranking. and yes Nate is terrible lol. Even DummyBear and Tyrie performed better than he did Smile
Nick should be dead last the guys never seen a win in anything at all. At least JJ from AYTO won an exile haha even if it was by default I think ?. Either way he was way more noticeable than Nick from Hollywood. 
actually JJ did won two exiles. one from Dustin and Jessica Smile and he actually was the main reason why they won. and then he and Simone won the second by default. but there opponents would have been Knight and Jemmye. i agree JJ should be ranked higher.
I am enjoying these!
Nate/Prsicilla on Exes 1 has to be one of the dumbest casting decisions ever lmao
Nate/Prsicilla on Exes 1 has to be one of the dumbest casting decisions ever lmao
I did not even remember they were there so I think that sums it up. 
Nate/Prsicilla on Exes 1 has to be one of the dumbest casting decisions ever lmao
I think the only reason they were there was because they wanted some type of San Diego representation. Zach/Ashley were still together and Alex said no. 
Nate/Prsicilla on Exes 1 has to be one of the dumbest casting decisions ever lmao
I think the only reason they were there was because they wanted some type of San Diego representation. Zach/Ashley were still together and Alex said no. 
That makes sense but Dustin/Heather were still together too so they could've still let Zach/Ashley go on. Those two would've been a tougher team. I'm still mad about how Adam/Nany got dropped because those two as a team would be TV gold. 
Nate/Prsicilla on Exes 1 has to be one of the dumbest casting decisions ever lmao
I think the only reason they were there was because they wanted some type of San Diego representation. Zach/Ashley were still together and Alex said no. 
That makes sense but Dustin/Heather were still together too so they could've still let Zach/Ashley go on. Those two would've been a tougher team. I'm still mad about how Adam/Nany got dropped because those two as a team would be TV gold. 
And on top of that Brad and Tori were contacted for that challenge and they were together too so clearly the teams didn't really have to be actual exes to even be exes in their mind(as also evidenced by the teams that never dated but just simply hooked up)
Nate/Prsicilla on Exes 1 has to be one of the dumbest casting decisions ever lmao
I think the only reason they were there was because they wanted some type of San Diego representation. Zach/Ashley were still together and Alex said no. 
That makes sense but Dustin/Heather were still together too so they could've still let Zach/Ashley go on. Those two would've been a tougher team. I'm still mad about how Adam/Nany got dropped because those two as a team would be TV gold. 
And on top of that Brad and Tori were contacted for that challenge and they were together too so clearly the teams didn't really have to be actual exes to even be exes in their mind(as also evidenced by the teams that never dated but just simply hooked up)
I got my info from PR or some other realiable person on here. The reason they were fine with Heather/Dustin and Brad/Tori is because they had footage of those couples fighting and "breaking up" even if it was just for a minute. Zach/Ashley had nothing. 
They could have stretched it like bananas and nany
  Guys! I didn't forget about this. I haven't been near a computer really the last couple days. I'll have 3 updates today to make up for it. Starting right now! 95. Johnnie (Fresh Meat) Johnnie was a bit of a hothead and mostly I just remember him arguing with Tonya. He seemed like somebody who would return for a second challenge but nope. 95. Ashley K (Battle of the Seasons 2) Ashley won her first and only Challenge. That’s a big accomplishment but quite frankly, she was hardly even an entity that entire season. She was actually an above-average competitor and she had a short kinda sorta flirtation with CJ that was actually sort of cute, but overall she was just sort of…there. 94. David Broom (Battle of the Sexes, The Gauntlet) David will forever live on in RW infamy for “Come On Be My Baby Tonight” but his Challenge appearances basically consisted of being voted off in the first 3 episodes or so. He did have a little romance with Ayanna on BOTS, but wasn’t around long enough for more of an impression. 94. Shauvon (Duel 2, Ruins, Cutthroat) Shauvon had some rough Challenge experiences. She was essentially the catalyst for the CT/Adam bloodbath of Duel 2, she thought she popped her implant on the Ruins, and then she was just the perpetual quitter on Cutthroat. On top of all this, she was essentially the laughing stock or cast punching bag. Not much of a competitor, but I can’t say she wasn’t entertaining in her own trainwreck kind of way. 93. Jeremy (Inferno, Gauntlet 2) Jeremy is so nice. And so, so boring. His whole thing was “Everybody parties but I stay in because I care about the game!” How’d that work out for ya, Jer? 93. Brooke (Gauntlet 3, Duel 2) LOL Brooke is so crazy. Like, batshit insane. I love her. Remember when she became a lesbian and she got voted off and had the epic Jack/Rose Titanic goodbye with Evelyn? Good stuff. But, she was a lousy competitor and never made it past episode 3 so here she is. 92. Steve (Gauntlet) Steve! Our lone Asian male! Maybe he’s why there aren’t more tbh because ZzzZzz. He did create the system for Road Rules voting which became a controversy with the team at some points, but let’s be honest: we only remember him because Trishelle beat him in a puzzle. 92. Kat (Challenge 2000) Kat was great! She was just normal, good people. Plus, she was the only person who broke the world record for longest bungee jump! So she goes here. 91. Danny D (Gauntlet 2) I was so tempted to put Danny higher because even though he was only in a few episodes, man did he make them count. Plus, he gets points for “Most delusional cast member”. Remember when Alton like poked him with his pinky and Danny flew out of the Beach Brawl circle? And remember his hilarious over the top fight with Jodi? Honestly though, Danny had the best after show interview of all time. I still remember him spilling the beans that Jodi gave Adam L a blow job and Alton a handjob on the same night. I mostly remember because their censorship for blowjob was a picture of a blow dryer over Danny’s mouth and for handjob it was a picture of someone churning butter. 91. Colie (Inferno 3, Island) Colie was somebody who really agitated me on her season of the RW, but who I actually wanted to see more of on the challenges. She didn’t make too much of an impression though. She cried a lot, accused Ace of some stuff, and didn’t do so hot in the missions, but she was pretty self-aware and funny actually. I still wish her second challenge was a real one and not the Island, because ugh. What a terrible challenge. Alright! I'll have the next update up later today! Thanks again for reading! Any guesses on who's next? Or hopes?
  Guys! I didn't forget about this. I haven't been near a computer really the last couple days. I'll have 3 updates today to make up for it. Starting right now! 95. Johnnie (Fresh Meat) Johnnie was a bit of a hothead and mostly I just remember him arguing with Tonya. He seemed like somebody who would return for a second challenge but nope. 95. Ashley K (Battle of the Seasons 2) Ashley won her first and only Challenge. That’s a big accomplishment but quite frankly, she was hardly even an entity that entire season. She was actually an above-average competitor and she had a short kinda sorta flirtation with CJ that was actually sort of cute, but overall she was just sort of…there. 94. David Broom (Battle of the Sexes, The Gauntlet) David will forever live on in RW infamy for “Come On Be My Baby Tonight” but his Challenge appearances basically consisted of being voted off in the first 3 episodes or so. He did have a little romance with Ayanna on BOTS, but wasn’t around long enough for more of an impression. 94. Shauvon (Duel 2, Ruins, Cutthroat) Shauvon had some rough Challenge experiences. She was essentially the catalyst for the CT/Adam bloodbath of Duel 2, she thought she popped her implant on the Ruins, and then she was just the perpetual quitter on Cutthroat. On top of all this, she was essentially the laughing stock or cast punching bag. Not much of a competitor, but I can’t say she wasn’t entertaining in her own trainwreck kind of way. 93. Jeremy (Inferno, Gauntlet 2) Jeremy is so nice. And so, so boring. His whole thing was “Everybody parties but I stay in because I care about the game!” How’d that work out for ya, Jer? 93. Brooke (Gauntlet 3, Duel 2) LOL Brooke is so crazy. Like, batshit insane. I love her. Remember when she became a lesbian and she got voted off and had the epic Jack/Rose Titanic goodbye with Evelyn? Good stuff. But, she was a lousy competitor and never made it past episode 3 so here she is. 92. Steve (Gauntlet) Steve! Our lone Asian male! Maybe he’s why there aren’t more tbh because ZzzZzz. He did create the system for Road Rules voting which became a controversy with the team at some points, but let’s be honest: we only remember him because Trishelle beat him in a puzzle. 92. Kat (Challenge 2000) Kat was great! She was just normal, good people. Plus, she was the only person who broke the world record for longest bungee jump! So she goes here. 91. Danny D (Gauntlet 2) I was so tempted to put Danny higher because even though he was only in a few episodes, man did he make them count. Plus, he gets points for “Most delusional cast member”. Remember when Alton like poked him with his pinky and Danny flew out of the Beach Brawl circle? And remember his hilarious over the top fight with Jodi? Honestly though, Danny had the best after show interview of all time. I still remember him spilling the beans that Jodi gave Adam L a blow job and Alton a handjob on the same night. I mostly remember because their censorship for blowjob was a picture of a blow dryer over Danny’s mouth and for handjob it was a picture of someone churning butter. 91. Colie (Inferno 3, Island) Colie was somebody who really agitated me on her season of the RW, but who I actually wanted to see more of on the challenges. She didn’t make too much of an impression though. She cried a lot, accused Ace of some stuff, and didn’t do so hot in the missions, but she was pretty self-aware and funny actually. I still wish her second challenge was a real one and not the Island, because ugh. What a terrible challenge. Alright! I'll have the next update up later today! Thanks again for reading! Any guesses on who's next? Or hopes?
Great bios. Brooke and Danny were hilarious. I never saw Danny's aftershow interview, do you have the link? 
Danny vs Alton was just hilarious to watch lol especially how little effort Alton had to put in
Camilla/Cara Maria/Backpack/Evan/Kenny all out next please.
SHAUVY #teamshavoun
Shauvon was hilarious and entertaining on all of her challenge seasons. I'm surprised Shauvon hasn't come back because on one of the Cutthroat dailies, she was telling everyone that she's still interested in doing more challenges. 
Shavoun was entertaining and brought something on every show she did so she was a fun time.
When Nia gets #1
When Nia gets #1
LOL
Camilla/Cara Maria/Backpack/Evan/Kenny all out next please.
LOL
Ashley K being ranked lower than Shauvon, Brooke, Colie, Danny Dias is just ridiculous using any criteria.
Ashley K being ranked lower than Shauvon, Brooke, Colie, Danny Dias is just ridiculous using any criteria.
I think he's ranking her in terms of entertainment. Ashley is a good player but she's really boring. 
Ashley K being ranked lower than Shauvon, Brooke, Colie, Danny Dias is just ridiculous using any criteria.
I think he's ranking her in terms of entertainment. Ashley is a good player but she's really boring. 
Competition is part of the show and if it solely based on entertainment then it still doesn't make sense that people that are annoying as hell as higher.  Or why Jeremy would be higher--Steve too.
  90. Derek M (Gauntlet 3, Duel 2) Derek was pretty cool. Just a nice guy, drama-free. Sadly, that doesn’t make for compelling TV. He did hook up with Paula, but he was generally pretty lowkey. He was also somebody who I feel like looked like they should be a much competitor than he actually was. He almost lost to Big Easy on a pole climbing elimination! 90. Sam (Battle of the Seasons 2) Sam won her first and only Challenge, but she was consistently the weakest player. She spent her entire season being verbally attacked (and pushed) by teammates Frank and Zach. And she got caught in the crossfire of Marie and Derek, causing her to get shoved into a plant. She did not like that. 89. Vinny (Fresh Meat 2, Cutthroat, Battle of the Exes) Ugh, Vinny. He’s the worst. He was all bark and no bite. Just a loud, obnoxious, person. And he pulled down Mandi’s top which was uncool. Remember when he got fat? 89. Shavonda (Inferno 2) After her RW season, I expected Shavonda to do a few challenges. But, she only did one and really didn’t make much of a splash. However, she and Jamie gave us some pretty hilarious Tonya taunting during the Heart Rate Bungee mission. And then in her elimination there was this gem: Tonya “You can’t get into my head” Shavonda “I got into your head earlier today, didn’t I bitch?!” But then she quit. Good thing TJ wasn’t the host yet. However, she did it for a good reason and it actually worked out! 88. Adam Kuhn (Battle of the Exes 2) Of all the AYTO people, Adam probably brought the most to the show. Which is to say, not much. He seemed to think he was this awesome macho competitor, but…wasn’t. He liked to blame Brittany on everything that went wrong when in reality he never did much better. I mostly remember him getting massaged by Averey. 88. Mallory (Inferno) I love Mallory and quite frankly, I think she’d be a good competitor but sadly we didn’t get to see her do too much on this season. I wish she would have stood up for herself more because she let Coral make her decision to go into the Inferno. I did like her friendship with Christena but it sort of felt like a poor man’s Sarah/Rachel from the Gauntlet. 87. Jon (Battle of the Seasons, Inferno 2) Jon has the distinction of going home first on every challenge he’s been on, so there’s that. 87. Cynthia (Battle of the Sexes 2) Cynthia was cool as hell. She was a little older than the other girls on her team, but she rallied with the rookie girls. It didn’t really lead to anything but her voteoff caused some controversy on her team. It was pretty shitty but that’s mostly because she was cool. 86. Swift (Free Agents) Swift actually wasn’t all that interesting on his season, but he had some lowkey hilarious moments. Like, he thought he was this big genius or something and then Zach beat him at trivia and voted him out. I still remember him falling out of his confessional chair though. And his weird ass hats and scarves. So strange. 86. Rachel M (Inferno 3, Gauntlet 3) Oh, Rachel. Did you guys know she was in the military? I don’t know if you heard. This was apparently supposed to mean she was this elite athlete but she never showed that. She was always so shocked when the Veterans would not vote her into the Gauntlet or when they would save her because she thought she was amazing. She had the most epic elimination meltdown of all time though. Then she called Jenn a “chubby civilian girl” (again, in case you didn’t know she was in the military), which LOL okay Rachel. More to come!
Ashley K being ranked lower than Shauvon, Brooke, Colie, Danny Dias is just ridiculous using any criteria.
I think he's ranking her in terms of entertainment. Ashley is a good player but she's really boring. 
Competition is part of the show and if it solely based on entertainment then it still doesn't make sense that people that are annoying as hell as higher.
I'm basing it on entertainment, competition, and just overall how memorable the person. There are some people ranked higher solely based on competition and there are others ranked higher because I think they brought more to the show. Ashley has been on one Challenge and despite being a good competitor, she didn't make much of an impression IMO. Shauvon and Brooke added something to their seasons, for better or worse. It's the same reason people like Jo and Belou haven't been listed yet despite only being on a couple episodes. They made those episodes count.   Also, she's not technically ranked lower than Danny D. There's like 10 more girls than guys, so while he has a better number ranking, she has more people beat than he does. Also, she's not technically ranked lower than him because the guy/girl ratings are separate.
Yeah Rachel from Austin was so damn annoying on both challenges she was on. Every single time she brought up her time in the army talked a big game yet always sucked. I laughed so hard when Jenn beat her ass in the inferno!.
Ashley K being ranked lower than Shauvon, Brooke, Colie, Danny Dias is just ridiculous using any criteria.
I think he's ranking her in terms of entertainment. Ashley is a good player but she's really boring. 
Competition is part of the show and if it solely based on entertainment then it still doesn't make sense that people that are annoying as hell as higher.
I'm basing it on entertainment, competition, and just overall how memorable the person. There are some people ranked higher solely based on competition and there are others ranked higher because I think they brought more to the show. Ashley has been on one Challenge and despite being a good competitor, she didn't make much of an impression IMO. Shauvon and Brooke added something to their seasons, for better or worse. It's the same reason people like Jo and Belou haven't been listed yet despite only being on a couple episodes. They made those episodes count.   Also, she's not technically ranked lower than Danny D. There's like 10 more girls than guys, so while he has a better number ranking, she has more people beat than he does. Also, she's not technically ranked lower than him because the guy/girl ratings are separate.
We disagree...Ashley did far more on her season than Sam for example.  I did agree that Brooke added anything.  Shauvon quit twice I don't agree with Jo but I agree with Belou...to each their own
Swift should probably be in the 100s.

Pages