Survivor Fantasy casts

265 posts / 0 new
Last post
Survivor The Congo First vs second vs third Niari Tribe(1st place) Aras Fabio Tony Denise Kim Sophie Sangha Tribe(2nd ) Coach Woo Chase Sabrina Amanda Monica Malebo Tribe(3rd) Mick Terry Albert Chelsea Erin Kass
Survivor: Congo (All-Stars 2) Pataki Tribe: Stephen Fishbach Hayden Moss Malcolm Freberg Ethan Zohn Todd Herzog RC Saint-Amour Tina Wesson Baylor Wilson Corinne Kaplan Eliza Orlins Hotana Tribe: Vytas Baskauskas Colby Donaldson Spencer Bledsoe Jeremy Collins Chris Daugherty Kass McQuillen Brenda Lowe Ciera Eastin Abi-Maria Gomes Erinn Lobdell  
If an All Stars was to happen soon, here is the cast I would like to see. I kept it to people after HvV and who have only played once: Men: Reynold(Caramoan) Hayden(Blood vs Water) Vytas(Blood vs Water) Spencer(Cagayan) Troyzan(One World) Albert(South Pacific) Brad(Blood Vs Water) Ralph(Redemption Island) Woo(Cagayan) Marty(Nicaragua) Alternates: Pete(Philippines), Sash(Nicaragua) Women: Tasha(Cagayan) Abi Maria(Philippines) Jane(Nicaragua) Christine(South Pacific) Chelsea(One World) RC(Philippines) Ciera(Blood vs Water) Holly(Nicaragua) Sarah(Cagayan) Stephanie(Redemption Island) Alternates: Trish(Cagayan), Katie(Blood vs Water)   I know it's Cagayan and Blood vs Water heavy but those seasons had great casts in which a good chunk of them can be considered all stars IMO. of course If I included 3x players: Malcolm, Brenda, and Andrea would definitely be included.  
Survivor battle of the seasons Location ivory coast This probably wouldn't work but I think would be cool. Team Micronesia Erik Jason Alexis Natalie Team Gabon Ace Matty Cornnie Sugar Team Tocantins Coach JT Erin Taj Team Samoa Mick Russell Laura Shambo Team Nicaragua Chase Fabio Brenda Holly Team One world Jay Troyzan Chelsea Kim Team blood vs water Hayden Vytus Cierra Rachel Team Cagayan Spenser Woo Morgan Tasha
Survivor: All-Stars 2 Matang Tribe:  Ethan Zohn (Africa) Vytas Baskauskas (Blood vs. Water) Stephen Fishbach (Tocantins) Matty Whitmore (Gabon) Josh Canfield (San Juan del Sur) Kass McQuillen (Cagayan) Ciera Eastin (Blood vs. Water) Danielle DiLorenzo (Exile Island) RC Saint-Amour (Phillippines) Peih-Gee Law (China) Greta Tribe:  Rob Cesternino (The Amazon) Spencer Bledsoe (Cagayan) Malcolm Freberg (Phillippines) Shane Powers (Exile Island) Hayden Moss (Blood vs. Water) Abi-Maria Gomes (Phillippines) Baylor Wilson (San Juan del Sur) Eliza Orlins (Vanuatu) Natalie Bolton (Micronesia) Erinn Lobdell (Tocantins)
Survivor India All stars 2 Deccan Tribe Spenser Eddie Brad Wes Fabio Cierra Morgan Chelsea Brenda Tasha Chota Tribe Malcolm Woo Hayden Matty Vytus Kim Julie Andrea Corrine Shambo
Survivor Madagascar Champions vs challengers Alaotra Tribe(champions) Tony Fabio Tyson Ethan Aras Denise Kim Jenna Parvati Sophie Kinkony Tribe(challengers) Spenser Hayden Malcolm Woo Matty Tasha Morgan Brenda Corrine Chelsea
Survivor Peru Brains vs Brawn vs beauty Loreto Tribe(Brains) Russell Tony Yul Kim Cierra Sophie Piura Tribe(brawn) Brad Malcolm Terry Andrea Tasha Denise Junin Tribe(beauty) Fabio Hayden Jay Brenda Chelsea Parvati
Survivor Peru Brains vs Brawn vs beauty Loreto Tribe(Brains) Russell Tony Yul Kim Cierra Sophie Piura Tribe(brawn) Brad Malcolm Terry Andrea Tasha Denise Junin Tribe(beauty) Fabio Hayden Jay Brenda Chelsea Parvati
Nice cast, I really want to see another Brains vs. Brawns vs. Beauty. 
Survivor: Guam (Heroes vs. Villains) Heroes: Malcolm Freberg Spencer Bledsoe Jud "Fabio" Birza Hayden Moss Troyzan Robertson Ciera Eastin RC Saint-Amour Tasha Fox Kelley Wentworth Taj Johnson-George Villains: Brad Culpepper Shane Powers Pete Yurkowski John Rocker Reynold Toepfer Abi-Maria Gomes Kass McQuillen Stephanie Valencia Corinne Kaplan Natalie Bolton  
Survivor Peru Brains vs Brawn vs beauty Loreto Tribe(Brains) Russell Tony Yul Kim Cierra Sophie Piura Tribe(brawn) Brad Malcolm Terry Andrea Tasha Denise Junin Tribe(beauty) Fabio Hayden Jay Brenda Chelsea Parvati
Nice cast, I really want to see another Brains vs. Brawns vs. Beauty. 
Thanks, I was tempted to put James for brawn but I'm not a huge James fan. I want too see one also, I liked it a lot more then I thought I would.
Survivor: Guam (Heroes vs. Villains) Heroes: Malcolm Freberg Spencer Bledsoe Jud "Fabio" Birza Hayden Moss Troyzan Robertson Ciera Eastin RC Saint-Amour Tasha Fox Kelley Wentworth Taj Johnson-George Villains: Brad Culpepper Shane Powers Pete Yurkowski John Rocker Reynold Toepfer Abi-Maria Gomes Kass McQuillen Stephanie Valencia Corinne Kaplan Natalie Bolton  
Great cast, I feel like the teams are pretty even.
Survivor Peru Brains vs Brawn vs beauty Loreto Tribe(Brains) Russell Tony Yul Kim Cierra Sophie Piura Tribe(brawn) Brad Malcolm Terry Andrea Tasha Denise Junin Tribe(beauty) Fabio Hayden Jay Brenda Chelsea Parvati
Nice cast, I really want to see another Brains vs. Brawns vs. Beauty. 
Thanks, I was tempted to put James for brawn but I'm not a huge James fan. I want too see one also, I liked it a lot more then I thought I would.
Thank god you didn't, I can't stand him at all, especially after HvV.   
Survivor Peru Brains vs Brawn vs beauty Loreto Tribe(Brains) Russell Tony Yul Kim Cierra Sophie Piura Tribe(brawn) Brad Malcolm Terry Andrea Tasha Denise Junin Tribe(beauty) Fabio Hayden Jay Brenda Chelsea Parvati
Nice cast, I really want to see another Brains vs. Brawns vs. Beauty. 
Thanks, I was tempted to put James for brawn but I'm not a huge James fan. I want too see one also, I liked it a lot more then I thought I would.
Thank god you didn't, I can't stand him at all, especially after HvV.   
Yeah I hate him too but i thought about it for obvious reasons. also lurkernomore would kill me for this but I was thinking about putting Cochran for brains because he went to Harvard.
Good cast, aside from Russell being on brains.
Survivor Peru Brains vs Brawn vs beauty Loreto Tribe(Brains) Russell Tony Yul Kim Cierra Sophie Piura Tribe(brawn) Brad Malcolm Terry Andrea Tasha Denise Junin Tribe(beauty) Fabio Hayden Jay Brenda Chelsea Parvati
Nice cast, I really want to see another Brains vs. Brawns vs. Beauty. 
Thanks, I was tempted to put James for brawn but I'm not a huge James fan. I want too see one also, I liked it a lot more then I thought I would.
Thank god you didn't, I can't stand him at all, especially after HvV.   
Yeah I hate him too but i thought about it for obvious reasons. also lurkernomore would kill me for this but I was thinking about putting Cochran for brains because he went to Harvard.
Lol, I'm kinda indifferent towards Cochran tbh. 
Good cast, aside from Russell being on brains.
I put him there because I like Russell and hes very good at manipulation yes some choices he's made are bad but he knows how to get people to do his bidding.
Yeah I hate him too but i thought about it for obvious reasons. also lurkernomore would kill me for this but I was thinking about putting Cochran for brains because he went to Harvard.
Good cast, aside from Russell being on brains.
I put him there because I like Russell and hes very good at manipulation yes some choices he's made are bad but he knows how to get people to do his bidding.
  I think a lot of them are bad, but I guess this isn't the time or place to discuss it.
Nice cast, I really want to see another Brains vs. Brawns vs. Beauty. 
I do too, but for another all newbies season. I want to run the Brains tribe.
Nice cast, I really want to see another Brains vs. Brawns vs. Beauty. 
I do too, but for another all newbies season. I want to run the Brains tribe.
So what do you think of my cast?
Nice cast, I really want to see another Brains vs. Brawns vs. Beauty. 
I do too, but for another all newbies season. I want to run the Brains tribe.
So what do you think of my cast?
I like it, each tribe is pretty well balanced. Maybe too many winners on Brains, but it takes brains to win so that isn't a big deal at all.
Nice cast, I really want to see another Brains vs. Brawns vs. Beauty. 
I do too, but for another all newbies season. I want to run the Brains tribe.
So what do you think of my cast?
I like it, each tribe is pretty well balanced. Maybe too many winners on Brains, but it takes brains to win so that isn't a big deal at all.
Yeah I couldn't really think of many brains that haven't won.
So what do you think of my cast?
I like it, each tribe is pretty well balanced. Maybe too many winners on Brains, but it takes brains to win so that isn't a big deal at all.
Yeah I couldn't really think of many brains that haven't won.
Rob Cesternino would be a great pick. Heidi Strobel would also be a good choice, but she'd never return.
So what do you think of my cast?
I like it, each tribe is pretty well balanced. Maybe too many winners on Brains, but it takes brains to win so that isn't a big deal at all.
Yeah I couldn't really think of many brains that haven't won.
Rob Cesternino would be a great pick. Heidi Strobel would also be a good choice, but she'd never return.
Oh yeah I forgot about him.
Survivor Peru Brains vs Brawn vs beauty Loreto Tribe(Brains) Russell Tony Yul Kim Cierra Sophie Piura Tribe(brawn) Brad Malcolm Terry Andrea Tasha Denise Junin Tribe(beauty) Fabio Hayden Jay Brenda Chelsea Parvati
Nice cast, I really want to see another Brains vs. Brawns vs. Beauty. 
Thanks, I was tempted to put James for brawn but I'm not a huge James fan. I want too see one also, I liked it a lot more then I thought I would.
Its okay, James will not be back most likely. Though I haven't kept tabs on him, I remember after HvV, his leg had been giving trouble at the time of the reunion and that was almost a year after filming.
Survivor South Africa: Rebirth I chose 20 former players who IMO had potential to do well/become big in the game but got taken out fairly early. Obviously most are perjury with a few being first boots at the merge. Men: John Cody(Blood vs Water) Garrett Adelstein (Cagayan) Ace Gordon (Gabon) Coby Archa (Palau) Andrew Savage (Pearl Islands) Silas Gaither (Africa) Jonas Otsuji (One World) Brad Culpepper (Blood vs Water) Jim Rice (South Pacific) Johnathon Libby (Palau)   Alternative: JP Calderon (Cook Islands)   Women: Kelley Wentworth (San Juan del Sur) Sarah Lacina (Cagayan) Alexis Maxwell (Cagayan) Christine Shields (South Pacific) Roberta Saint Amour (Philippines) Stephanie Valencia (Redemption Island Amy O'hara (Guatemala) Val Collins (San Juan del Sur) Allie Pohevitz (Caramoan) Kristina Kell (Redemption Island)   Alternate: J'Tia Taylor (Cagayan)          
Survivor Mozambique tribes divided by race Not a huge fan of the idea but I think these tribes would be cool. Chilwa tribe(Asian Americans) Woo Jonas Ken Brenda Natalie Namuli tribe(African Americans) Jeremy Artis Tasha Sabrina Marissa Miombo Tribe(Caucasians) Spenser Wes Hayden Morgan Chelsea Delagoa Tribe(Hispanic Americans) Albert Marcus Abi Maria Allica Stephanie
Survivor: Madagascar (Rivals)   Rivals will be on opposing tribes, but will live in the same beach, kinda like One World.    Nubanho Tribe:  Terry Deitz (Aras) John Rocker (Jeremy) Tyson Apostol (Sierra) Shane Powers (Courtney) Bobby Jon Drinkard (Jamie) RC Saint-Amour (Abi) Marissa Peterson (Brad) Corinne Kaplan (Sugar) Eliza Orlins (Twila) Kass McQuillen (Tony)   Pitayo Tribe:  Brad Culpepper (Marissa) Jeremy Collins (Rocker) Shane Powers (Courtney) Aras Baskauskas (Terry) Jamie Newton (Bobby Jon) Sierra Reed (Tyson) Abi Maria Gomes (RC) Sugar Kiper (Corinne) Twila Tanner (Eliza) Courtney Marit (Shane)   Merged Tribe
Survivor: Madagascar (Rivals)   Rivals will be on opposing tribes, but will live in the same beach, kinda like One World.    Nubanho Tribe:  Terry Deitz (Aras) John Rocker (Jeremy) Tyson Apostol (Sierra) Shane Powers (Courtney) Bobby Jon Drinkard (Jamie) RC Saint-Amour (Abi) Marissa Peterson (Brad) Corinne Kaplan (Sugar) Eliza Orlins (Twila) Kass McQuillen (Tony)   Pitayo Tribe:  Brad Culpepper (Marissa) Jeremy Collins (Rocker) Shane Powers (Courtney) Aras Baskauskas (Terry) Jamie Newton (Bobby Jon) Sierra Reed (Tyson) Abi Maria Gomes (RC) Sugar Kiper (Corinne) Twila Tanner (Eliza) Courtney Marit (Shane)   Merged Tribe
Great idea and cast, what do you think of my cast?

Pages