The Challenge: What Ifs

1878 posts / 0 new
Last post
[QUOTE=kvm1977;399921]Leroy would have seen an elimination round[/QUOTE] Yep that sounds about right. I can see Adam pissing people off to the point that he would get himself and Leroy sent into a Jungle.
[QUOTE=Debut Album;399931]Yep that sounds about right. I can see Adam pissing people off to the point that he would get himself and Leroy sent into a Jungle.[/QUOTE] Plus, JEK would have hoped they would beat CT/Adam before sending in Evan/Nehemiah
One I wonder is what if Evan came to play on Rivals? It was pretty much acknowledged by everyone that he was trying to go home the whole time, and basically was trying to just give Johnny and Kenny an extra vote in the beginning so they'd have a better shot at making it far. He was touring Egypt with his girlfriend pretty close to right up to when they left so he clearly wasn't training. I think we forget what a machine Evan was on every challenge he was on up until Rivals. Best guy on FM and the Ruins, and top two on the Duel and the Gauntlet 3. Derrick on his podcast said that he was the best athlete on the shows aside from CT and this is coming from a guy that did shows with Landon, Darrell, Theo, Mark, etc. I don't know if I AGREE with him...but he would know better than we do. Considering the shape Nehemiah was in, if Evan really came to play I may have bet on them.
What if Road Rules and/or DC were on Battle of the Seasons? Who thinks both of those teams would have been in the final?
What if Tina kept her cool and didn't punch Beth on The Duel? How well do you think she would have done? And which side of the alliances would she have chosen? I was sad that she did that cuz I really wanted to see how well she would do as an individual competitor.
[QUOTE=melm3;399958]What if Tina kept her cool and didn't punch Beth on The Duel? How well do you think she would have done? And which side of the alliances would she have chosen? I was sad that she did that cuz I really wanted to see how well she would do as an individual competitor.[/QUOTE] For some reason I could see her siding with the oddballs of Wes, Aneesa and Svet as opposed to with Kina, Jodi and Robin. I don't think many of the girls would call her out because like it or not I do think she had an intimidation factor, but had she been last in the line up, who knows how long she would've lasted!
What if there was no unhooking rule for push me on the duel?
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;399976]What if there was no unhooking rule for push me on the duel?[/QUOTE] CT wins the first duel
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;399976]What if there was no unhooking rule for push me on the duel?[/QUOTE] CT would have hands down won that challenge, Beth would have it made it farther but I'm sure somehow would have lost in some form or another
[QUOTE=kvm1977;399977]CT wins the first duel[/QUOTE] And Svetlana goes Home and Beth makes if further.
What if Brad didn't make a deal with the other team and sent in Casey instead of Brianna
[QUOTE=Debut Album;399931]Yep that sounds about right. I can see Adam pissing people off to the point that he would get himself and Leroy sent into a Jungle.[/QUOTE] I don't think so at all. I think the game would have went the same way. Leroy & Adam would have flown right under the radar and Johnny, Kenny, and Evan would have targetted CT over Adam. Davis & Tyrie and Brandon & Ty would have still been sent in by Kenny & Wes, Evan & Nehemiah would have still tried to take out CT & Adam, and the in Bombs Away challenge, Leroy still would have climbed the rope and been safe, resulting in CT & Adam facing Johnny & Tyler in the final Jungle.
[QUOTE=JL81790;399944]One I wonder is what if Evan came to play on Rivals? It was pretty much acknowledged by everyone that he was trying to go home the whole time, and basically was trying to just give Johnny and Kenny an extra vote in the beginning so they'd have a better shot at making it far. He was touring Egypt with his girlfriend pretty close to right up to when they left so he clearly wasn't training. I think we forget what a machine Evan was on every challenge he was on up until Rivals. Best guy on FM and the Ruins, and top two on the Duel and the Gauntlet 3. [B]Derrick on his podcast said that he was the best athlete on the shows aside from CT[/B] and this is coming from a guy that did shows with Landon, Darrell, Theo, Mark, etc. I don't know if I AGREE with him...but he would know better than we do. Considering the shape Nehemiah was in, if Evan really came to play I may have bet on them.[/QUOTE] Derrick said a lot of stupid **** on his podcast. He would always praise his guests on the podcast just because he was their guest. Like when he had Wes on with Nehemiah, he was praising Wes and saying that the hardest elimination round he was ever in was his with Wes on The Duel, then when he did a podcast with Kenny, Johnny, Mark or Evan, he would trash Wes. It just seemed like he would say a lot of stuff to avoid confrontation.
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;400072]What if Brad didn't make a deal with the other team and sent in Casey instead of Brianna[/QUOTE] Then Casey would have gone home... Come up with good What if questions. Not ones that are blantantly obvious.
[QUOTE=El Scorcho;400078]Then Casey would have gone home... Come up with good What if questions. Not ones that are blantantly obvious.[/QUOTE] The whole season would have changed IMO because the challengers had nobody throwing missions so I guess it isn't so obvious
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;400081]The whole season would have changed IMO because the challengers had nobody throwing missions so I guess it isn't so obvious[/QUOTE] The Challengers still weren't going to be winning missions. We can claim they would have been better though but pretty much nothing changes Now if we change the Challengers cast to include better people then maybe something changes...starting with CT
What if Paula and Jenn were on the challengers team instead of Casey and Shauvon? How much better would the challengers have been?
[QUOTE=CHIblackhawk;400114]What if Paula and Jenn were on the challengers team instead of Casey and Shauvon? How much better would the challengers have been?[/QUOTE] They would have been a lot better, enough to change the game. When Wes threw the first challenge the challengers would have won because Casey and Shauvon were horrible in that one. The challengers would put whoever Wes wants in because they don't want him to stop throwing and the champions would be distraught.
[QUOTE=CHIblackhawk;400114]What if Paula and Jenn were on the challengers team instead of Casey and Shauvon? How much better would the challengers have been?[/QUOTE] Also add CT for Nick and everything changes...that could have been a great challenge
[QUOTE=WesIsTheBest;400116]They would have been a lot better, enough to change the game. When Wes threw the first challenge the challengers would have won because Casey and Shauvon were horrible in that one. The challengers would put whoever Wes wants in because they don't want him to stop throwing and the champions would be distraught.[/QUOTE] The challengers still could have won that opening mission if they planned a little better. Having Casey be the first to climb up from the bottom of the rope was a terribly stupid idea. Wouldn't you want someone who knows what they're doing to go first and show everyone how it's done? I think the challengers would have taken that one if Casey was anywhere else on the rope since there would have been teammates at the top to pull her up. It would have been pretty much impossible for the champions to get around Wes throwing the mission if the challengers got 13 players to the top instead of 12.
I would also add Ruthie to the Challengers team. She vs. Ev would be great.
What if the Blue Team had to pick first(instead of last)in the draft on cuttrhroat?
What if Danny hadn't packed Melinda's luggage with his on Fresh Meat? Would him and Evelyn had won the exile, sending Wes and Casey home first? The entire season would have been completely different.
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;400081]The whole season would have changed IMO because the challengers had nobody throwing missions so I guess it isn't so obvious[/QUOTE] No its still pretty obvious. Whether Casey was throwing challenges or not, they would have not beat the Champions at anything. Maybe the fruits challenge, thats about it.
So what would happen if the challengers had Jenn CT Tyler Ruthie insted of Casey Nick Danny and Shavon.
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;400324]So what would happen if the challengers had Jenn CT Tyler Ruthie insted of Casey Nick Danny and Shavon.[/QUOTE] Well the challengers would have looked like this: Adam Brad Chet Cohutta CT Dunbar Tyler Brianna Diem Jenn KellyAnne Kimberly Ruthie Sarah Episode 1: Chet & Diem were eliminated by Wes & Tonya Episode 2: Tyler & Evelyn were eliminated by Wes & KellyAnne Episode 3: Adam & Brianna were eliminated by Syrus & Susie Episode 4: Dunbar & Katie were eliminated by Darrell & Sarah Episode 5: Wes & Ibis were eliminated by Cohutta & Kimberly Episode 6: Syrus & Veronica were eliminated by Cohutta & KellyAnne Episode 7: Cohutta & Johanna were eliminated by Darrell & Sarah Episode 8: Brad & Darrell were DQ'd Episode 9: Johnny & Kimberly were eliminated by CT & Susie Episode 10: Derrick & Ruthie or Jenn were eliminated by CT & Susie Final Challenge: Champions: Kenny, Evan, and Susie Challengers: CT, Jenn (or Ruthie), KellyAnne, and Sarah Still think the Champions would have won.
How do you guys think exes would have gone if Dustin never got injuried and Vinny never ripped Mandi's top off
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;400353]How do you guys think exes would have gone if Dustin never got injuried and Vinny never ripped Mandi's top off[/QUOTE] I also wonder how different Exes would have been if Adam & Nany didn't get dropped last second and the show actually began with a full cast.
[QUOTE=CHIblackhawk;400359]I also wonder how different Exes would have been if Adam & Nany didn't get dropped last second and the show actually began with a full cast.[/QUOTE] That would explain why there was only 13 instead of 14 I think they'd do okay but he'd get them thrown in by getting everyone mad
Here's a what if that would have changed the challenge for better and worse, what if instead of Evan and Kenny, Abram & Nehemiah were on the champions?

Pages