The Challenge: What Ifs

1878 posts / 0 new
Last post
[QUOTE=VCR14;416517]What if Rivals 2 had been a Duel 3? Who do you think would have made it for the men and women if it was a final 5? I think it would have been: CT Wes Johnny Zach Frank Cooke Emily Aneesa Diem Paula[/QUOTE] Same for the guys, but my choice for the girls would be Cooke, Emily, Paula, Camila and maybe Theresa or Aneesa.
If it were Duel format unless Wes was winning every challenge he would be one of the first to get called out and I don't see him beating a lot of the guys there 1 on 1. I think it would've been: CT Johnny Frank Zach Leroy
[QUOTE=VCR14;416517]What if Rivals 2 had been a Duel 3? Who do you think would have made it for the men and women if it was a final 5? I think it would have been: CT Wes Johnny Zach Frank Cooke Emily Aneesa Diem Paula[/QUOTE] CT Johnny Zach Frank Jordan Emily Camila Cooke Aneesa Cara Maria/Theresa
As a Wes fan, he would have not made it. He has a huge target on his back and the fact that he doesn't workout anymore makes him an easy target. He would probably last a little bit and get killed in a physical elimination, but politics won't help you when someone calls you out. But I also believe Wes has mended and built many new relationships this past challenge because he lays low now and he hasn't been involved in MUCH of the drama, which will help him in future challenges.
[QUOTE=VCR14;416517]What if Rivals 2 had been a Duel 3? Who do you think would have made it for the men and women if it was a final 5? I think it would have been: CT Wes Johnny Zach Frank Cooke Emily Aneesa Diem Paula[/QUOTE] Zach and Emily would have won, IMO.
[QUOTE=TexasFight88;416941]Zach and Emily would have won, IMO.[/QUOTE] If the final challenge was the same, then I think Zach or CT could have won.
What if politics hadn't been taken out of the equation for the mission on Fresh Meat II and the usual winners pick/house vote was used to determine which teams went to exile? I would assume Kenny & Laurel would have chosen Landon & Carley to go in over any of the other teams from their alliance. Who from Kenny's alliance out of Jillian/Pete, Jenn/Noor, and Ryan/Theresa would have been selected in the house vote to be thrown into the final elimination assuming Landon/Carley were the winners pick?
[QUOTE=CHIblackhawk;417662]What if politics hadn't been taken out of the equation for the mission on Fresh Meat II and the usual winners pick/house vote was used to determine which teams went to exile? I would assume Kenny & Laurel would have chosen Landon & Carley to go in over any of the other teams from their alliance. Who from Kenny's alliance out of Jillian/Pete, Jenn/Noor, and Ryan/Theresa would have been selected in the house vote to be thrown into the final elimination assuming Landon/Carley were the winners pick?[/QUOTE] I would think Jillian & Pete would have been the best choice to take out Landon & Carley. Even though it would never happen. Kenny & Laurel won, they would have voted Landon & Carley into exile, then Jenn & Noor, Ryan & Theresa, and Jillian & Pete would vote on the 2nd team. Jenn and Ryan would never vote each other. Plus Jenn and Ryan probably both thought "Jillian & Pete have already been in twice, they already have the knowledge of what an exile is so they would be a stronger choice to take out Landon than we would." Landon & Carley would have DESTROYED Jillian & Pete in the blackout exile. So the final would have been: 1st- Landon & Carley 2nd- Kenny & Laurel 3rd- Jenn & Noor 4th- Ryan & THeresa
[QUOTE=El Scorcho;417683]I would think Jillian & Pete would have been the best choice to take out Landon & Carley. Even though it would never happen. Kenny & Laurel won, they would have voted Landon & Carley into exile, then Jenn & Noor, Ryan & Theresa, and Jillian & Pete would vote on the 2nd team. Jenn and Ryan would never vote each other. Plus Jenn and Ryan probably both thought "Jillian & Pete have already been in twice, they already have the knowledge of what an exile is so they would be a stronger choice to take out Landon than we would." Landon & Carley would have DESTROYED Jillian & Pete in the blackout exile. So the final would have been: 1st- Landon & Carley 2nd- Kenny & Laurel 3rd- Jenn & Noor 4th- Ryan & THeresa[/QUOTE] That would have been a good idea for Jenn/Ryan but Jenn would have never voted for Pete.
What instead of MJ & Nehemiah, CT and Adam were replaced by Wes & Darrell on the duel 2?
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;418607]What instead of MJ & Nehemiah, CT and Adam were replaced by Wes & Darrell on the duel 2?[/QUOTE] Evan would have shat out a castle from his ***. Brad wouldn't have made top 3. Darrell and Landon would have probably butt heads.
It frustrates me so much that CT and Darrell were on such an easy path to win a Challenge (on The Inferno 3 and The Ruins, respectively) and they threw it all away for some stupid physical violence.
[QUOTE=JayTee;418620]Evan would have shat out a castle from his ***. Brad wouldn't have made top 3. Darrell and Landon would have probably butt heads.[/QUOTE] Aren't Darrell and Landon good friends? I feel like they'd work together in the earlier stages of the game. Possibly in the later stages of the game, they could try to get each other out in order to win. But I don't really see them butting heads.
[QUOTE=toenails;418627]It frustrates me so much that CT and Darrell were on such an easy path to win a Challenge (on The Inferno 3 and The Ruins, respectively) and they threw it all away for some stupid physical violence.[/QUOTE] I definitely agree about Darrell, but CT was sent home in episode 1 before they even did the 1st mission. He probably would've had a great chance at getting to the end and winning, but this was nowhere near the guaranteed win Darrell had and lost.
[QUOTE=CHIblackhawk;418694]I definitely agree about Darrell, but CT was sent home in episode 1 before they even did the 1st mission. He probably would've had a great chance at getting to the end and winning, but this was nowhere near the guaranteed win Darrell had and lost.[/QUOTE] If CT had stayed on Inferno 3, I think his performance would have been the same as Inferno 2: he would win most of the life shields and the Good Guys would be too scared to call him into the inferno.
I've always wondered what if the Veterans on Gauntlet 3 would of sent in Big Easy to face Evan in the Gauntlet. If that were the case then I believe Evan wins that Gauntlet if it's Ball Brawl or Sliders and it turned out to be Sliders but Evan instead faced Johnny. If Big Easy would of been eliminated so many people on the Veterans would have gotten their 1st challenge win like CT, Evan, Brad, Adam, Diem, Paula, and Robin. Now granted CT, Evan, Brad, and Paula would go on to win their own Challenges and the wait made their wins much more special. But still Big Easy cost 7 people their 1st Challenge victory and killed the only chance for Adam, Diem, & Robin to ever get a Challenge win.
[QUOTE=GiggidyGoo90;418704]I've always wondered what if the Veterans on Gauntlet 3 would of sent in Big Easy to face Evan in the Gauntlet. If that were the case then I believe Evan wins that Gauntlet if it's Ball Brawl or Sliders and it turned out to be Sliders but Evan instead faced Johnny. If Big Easy would of been eliminated so many people on the Veterans would have gotten their 1st challenge win like CT, Evan, Brad, Adam, Diem, Paula, and Robin. Now granted CT, Evan, Brad, and Paula would go on to win their own Challenges and the wait made their wins much more special. But still Big Easy cost 7 people their 1st Challenge victory and killed the only chance for Adam, Diem, & Robin to ever get a Challenge win.[/QUOTE] Well what do you know..A Fresh Meater actually did something memorable and noteworthy.
[QUOTE=JEKFAN;418439]That would have been a good idea for Jenn/Ryan but Jenn would have never voted for Pete.[/QUOTE] Why? She had no problem voting Adam in on Rivals and she was banging him on that season too.
What if Brad didn't get into a fight with Darrell on a The Ruins? I mean no matter what Dunbar was going into the next Ruins against Johnny but would production give Johnny and Dunbar the Rag Doll elimination considering there would still be one more guys elimination round before the final and typically production likes the last elimination round to be something physical. But let's just say no matter what the Ruins elimination would of been between Johnny and Dunbar Johnny wins and that just leaves Brad as the last guy on the Challengers I think that he faces Darrell in the final Ruins even though the guys on the Champions told Darrell if he beats Cohutta he'll get a free ride to the final but I believe since Brad is close to Evan, Kenny, Johnny, and Derrick they'll put him against Darrell so if he wins he'll get Darrell's money.
[QUOTE=El Scorcho;418721]Why? She had no problem voting Adam in on Rivals and she was banging him on that season too.[/QUOTE] Jenn and Pete dated after the show for about a year, Adam and her were just a typical challenge couple
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;418727]Jenn and Pete dated after the show for about a year, Adam and her were just a typical challenge couple[/QUOTE] Jenn doesn't seem like someone who would vote based on emotions anyway. She is going to vote on what will get her further in the game. Obviously it would have been between Ryan/Theresa and Jillian/Pete.
What if instead of Nick Adam Casey and Shauvon, the challengers had CT,Tyler,Jenn, and Paula And the champions had Nehemiah and Abram instead of Evan & Kenny
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;419458]What if instead of Nick Adam Casey and Shauvon, the challengers had CT,Tyler,Jenn, and Paula And the champions had Nehemiah and Abram instead of Evan & Kenny[/QUOTE] If that happened, then it would have been real interesting. I say any team could have won.
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;419458]What if instead of Nick Adam Casey and Shauvon, the challengers had CT,Tyler,Jenn, and Paula And the champions had Nehemiah and Abram instead of Evan & Kenny[/QUOTE] The Champions wouldn't throw in Wes everytime, and if the challengers won they would put up Wes because he is smaller(height wise) but still a good competitor
Who would the final 3 dudes have been on The Duel 2 if CT was never DQ'd?
[QUOTE=El Scorcho;419520]Who would the final 3 dudes have been on The Duel 2 if CT was never DQ'd?[/QUOTE] Landon CT and either Mark or Evan
What if Mandi didn't listen to Wes and chose to have Jenn kicked out for shoving her? What would the final 4 look like
If Derrick had never done Battle of the Sexes 2 (in which he lasted like 2 episodes), he would have been on the Rookies team for The Gauntlet 2 with all of his fellow X-Treme castmates. Kina would have probably convinced Alton to never call out Derrick, and Derrick probably would have won that Challenge.
What if on Free Agents they kept the same eliminations in the original rotation and Jordan went up against Swift in the wall climbing mission? I think he might've lost due to his hand and due to Swift's ability to get things poppin'. 2 hands are basically essential for that type of elimination. and I also think that Theresa would have beaten Camila much faster in that type of elimination.
[QUOTE=toenails;419581]If Derrick had never done Battle of the Sexes 2 (in which he lasted like 2 episodes), he would have been on the Rookies team for The Gauntlet 2 with all of his fellow X-Treme castmates. Kina would have probably convinced Alton to never call out Derrick, and Derrick probably would have won that Challenge.[/QUOTE] Depends who you're bumping off the rookies team...Alton was never going to call out Landon or MJ...maybe if Derrick replaced MJ or Jamie but I think Alton would have called him out before Jamie, Landon or MJ. Remember Kina called out Jillian though the guys wanted her to go against Ibis. I don't think those 3 girls could have saved Derrick.

Pages