The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

13610 posts / 0 new
Last post

Season 31: Battle of the Exes III 

Cory & Jenny

Tony & Madison

Thomas & Jamie

Dione & Kailah

Dylan & Jenna

Danny & Melinda

Wes & KellyAnne

Robb & Marie

Nelson & Latoya

Laurel & Nicole

Ryan & Shane

Theo & Tyara

Brad & Tori

Zach & Ashlee

Hayden & Carolina

Leroy & Jemmye

 

Alt: Mike & Alicia

Bruno & Sylvia

For same sex teams eliminations will be individual with the same sex team picking 1 player to represent them.

 

This has always been my dream challenge, trying to keep it realistic as far as who would say yes and who would actually get cast.BATTLE OF THE SEASONS IIITeam XXX: Derrick Kosinski, Jordan Wisely, Jenna Compono, Tori DealTeam Invasion: Ashley Mitchell, Cory Wharton, Kailah Casillas, Nelson ThomasTeam Rivals: Johnny Bananas, Sarah Rice, Camila Nakagawa, Tony RainesTeam Bloodlines: Cara Maria Sorbello, Jamie Banks, TBD Bloodlines 2, TBD Bloodlines 2Team Duel: CT Tamburello, Wes Bergmann, Aneesa Ferreira, Svetlana if they can get her but most likely Rachel RobinsonTeam Fresh Meat: Symbolic team, all rookies. Filled with new kids I don’t know and don’t like so doesn’t matter to meTeam Inferno: Darrell Taylor, Veronica Portillo, Coral Smith, Landon LueckTeam Gauntlet: Alton Williams, Cara Zavaleta, Sarah Greyson, Frank Rossler (or Abe)Team Battle of the Sexes: Mark Long, Ruthie Alcaide, Shane Landrum, Genesis MossThis last one I would swap with Team Bloodlines if all the people are down but it has a 1% chance of happening lolTeam Cutthroat: Cara Maria Sorbello, Tori Hall, Brad Fiorenza, Abram Boise.

Rachel Robinson was not on The Duel 1.

 The Challenge battlegrounds location Spain contestants paired up based on who they beat in an Elimination GuysMarlon & LeroyCT & ShaneAbram & BradWes & JordanTyler & Derrick Gus & CMNelson & CoryBananas & MarkGirls Lolo & Ashley Marie & Tori or Tori & Marie Cara Maria & NiaJenn & Theresa Nicole & Amanda Kailah & Jenna Kelly Anne & Rachel Cooke & Nany    

Who is Gus? Who is CM? And when did Wes and Jordan ever face off in an elimination round?

Challenge 17 wrote:

 The Challenge battlegrounds location Spain contestants paired up based on who they beat in an Elimination GuysMarlon & LeroyCT & ShaneAbram & BradWes & JordanTyler & Derrick Gus & CMNelson & CoryBananas & MarkGirls Lolo & Ashley Marie & Tori or Tori & Marie Cara Maria & NiaJenn & Theresa Nicole & Amanda Kailah & Jenna Kelly Anne & Rachel Cooke & Nany    

Who is Gus? Who is CM? And when did Wes and Jordan ever face off in an elimination round?

Gus and CM Punk are from Champs vs Pros

gamerthekid wrote:

1. Violetta Millerman eliminated by Marie Roda (Hall Brawl)

Sis nobody asked for this.

Challenge 17 wrote:

 The Challenge battlegrounds location Spain contestants paired up based on who they beat in an Elimination GuysMarlon & LeroyCT & ShaneAbram & BradWes & JordanTyler & Derrick Gus & CMNelson & CoryBananas & MarkGirls Lolo & Ashley Marie & Tori or Tori & Marie Cara Maria & NiaJenn & Theresa Nicole & Amanda Kailah & Jenna Kelly Anne & Rachel Cooke & Nany    

Who is Gus? Who is CM? And when did Wes and Jordan ever face off in an elimination round?

Champs vs pros as the answer to both 

El Scorcho wrote:

Challenge 17 wrote: The Challenge battlegrounds location Spain contestants paired up based on who they beat in an Elimination GuysMarlon & LeroyCT & ShaneAbram & BradWes & JordanTyler & Derrick Gus & CMNelson & CoryBananas & MarkGirls Lolo & Ashley Marie & Tori or Tori & Marie Cara Maria & NiaJenn & Theresa Nicole & Amanda Kailah & Jenna Kelly Anne & Rachel Cooke & Nany    

Who is Gus? Who is CM? And when did Wes and Jordan ever face off in an elimination round?

Champs vs pros as the answer to both 

Never even watched it. Explains why I didn't know either one. Thanks tho.

The Challenge Battle of the shows

Location Thailand 

The Challenge

Bananas

CT

Dario

Derrick h

Tony

Vince

Zach

Anika

Ashley k

Camila

Cara Maria 

Christina 

Jemmye 

Jenna 

Nicole z

The world 

Alex (siesta key)

Anthwan (catfish)

Big cat( fantasy factory)

Cody (stranded)

Javi (teen mom)

Justin( crazy guy from catfish)

Rob dydek 

The Situation 

Chanel west coast 

Dee pimping (catfish)

Deena(jersey shore)

Farrah (teen mom)

Juliette( siestakey)

Jwow

Mhissy (catfish)

Nessa(girl cody)

 

Ugh... I wouldn't even mind The Situation lmaoo.

Rivals 4(Some are stretches)

Girls

Nicole Z and Sylvia

Madison and Violetta

Kailah and Jemmye

Coral and Cara Maria

Alicia and Taylor

Britni and Hannah

Tori Hall/Fiorenza and KellyAnne

Ashley M and Jamie L

Guys

Leroy and Marlon

Bananas and Devin

Shane Landrum and Cory Wharton

Nelson and Tony

John H and Stephen

Derrick K and Wes

Abe and Thomas

Anthony and Layton

Rivals 4(Some are stretches)GirlsNicole Z and SylviaMadison and ViolettaKailah and JemmyeCoral and Cara MariaAlicia and TaylorBritni and HannahTori Hall/Fiorenza and KellyAnneAshley M and Jamie LGuysLeroy and MarlonBananas and DevinShane Landrum and Cory WhartonNelson and TonyJohn H and StephenDerrick K and WesAbe and ThomasAnthony and Layton

I like it. Especially the Abe and Thomas team lmao

el_greco wrote:

Rivals 4(Some are stretches)GirlsNicole Z and SylviaMadison and ViolettaKailah and JemmyeCoral and Cara MariaAlicia and TaylorBritni and HannahTori Hall/Fiorenza and KellyAnneAshley M and Jamie LGuysLeroy and MarlonBananas and DevinShane Landrum and Cory WhartonNelson and TonyJohn H and StephenDerrick K and WesAbe and ThomasAnthony and Layton

I like it. Especially the Abe and Thomas team lmao

It's not my ideal cast but I think it's best possible considering what we already know

Tori & Kelly Anne?????

Tori & Kelly Anne?????

It’s because of Brad.

Tori would never!

The Challenge: Battle of the Eras
Location: Costa Rica

Format: There have always been "eras" of the challenge. From Real Worlders against Road Rulers, Veterans against Rookies, Champions against Challengers, Rivals against Rivals, Exes against Exes, Seasons against Seasons, this season The Challenge will bring all of that together in Season 31: The Battle of the Eras! Four teams of eight players will square off in the ultimate Fatal Four Way. The Legends (Season 1-18), proven players that were around during the “Real World/Road Rules” Challenge days, while not all are Challenge champions, they have graced our screens for decades. The Veterans (Season 19-25), players introduced to the game with the brand change to “The Challenge”. While some may be considered Champions or legends in many’s mind, they are not as nostalgic as their opponents. The Redshirts (26-30) are another group that shall not be taken lightly. Some are proven Veterans and some even Champions however, they have been over shadowed by their two previously mentioned opponents. Players on the Redshirt team were introduced into the game during the "Are You The One" era. Some have came runner up in previous seasons, while others have yet to make a final. And the Novices (Season 31). These players are at a severe disadvantage as they are players that have never been on a Challenge before, however, they are young, hungry, and eager to make their mark and prove that they are the new generation of the Challenge. Which Era will reign supreme and take home not only bragging rights, but their share of $500,000?
Each challenge, the Era that wins will be safe from elimination and vote another Era into the Battlegrounds. The Era that comes in last place will automatically go into elimination. The two Eras competing in the Battlegrounds will vote one guy and one girl from the their team to go into the Battlegrounds. The Battlegrounds is the elimination round this season where one male and female will win and stay in the game and the losing male and female will be eliminated and sent home.

As far as people on the Novice team,  if they are from AYTO or any RW season after Portland, I do not know much about them or anything at all.
I do not watch AYTO or RW, so the people on this team, I got from others on this site who cast them consistently on their fantasy casts.

Team Jerseys: 
Legends- Black
Veterans- Blue
Redshirts- Red
Novices- Green

Male Cast:
Brad (RW: San Diego 2004)- Legend (First Challenge- Season 9: Battle of the Sexes 2)
Cory (RW: Ex-Plosion)- Redshirt (First Challenge- Season 27: Battle of the Bloodlines)
Dione (RW: Go Big)- Novice (First Challenge- Season 31: Battle of the Eras)
Dustin (RW: Las Vegas 2011)- Veteran (First Challenge- Season 22: Battle of the Exes)
Dylan (RW: Go Big)- Novice (First Challenge- Season 31: Battle of the Eras)
Giovanni (AYTO 4)- Novice (First Challenge- Season 31: Battle of the Era)
Hunter (AYTO 3)- Redshirt (First Challenge- Season 29: Invasion of the Champions)
Jamie (Bloodlines)- Redshirt (First Challenge- Season 27: Battle of the Bloodlines)
Johnny "Bananas" (RW: Key West)- Legend (First Challenge- Season 13: The Duel)
Johnny (RW: Portland)- Veteran (First Challenge- Season 25: Free Agents)
Leroy (RW: Las Vegas 2011)- Veteran (First Challenge- Season 21: Rivals)
Mike (AYTO 3)- Novice (First Challenge- Season 31: Battle of the Eras)
Tony (RW: Skeletons)- Redshirt (First Challenge- Season 27: Battle of the Bloodlines)
Shane (RR: Campus Crawl)- Legend (First Challenge- Season 6: Battle of the Sexes)
Wes (RW: Austin)- Legend (First Challenge- Season 12: Fresh Meat)
Zach (RW: San Diego 2011)- Veteran (First Challenge- Season 23: Battle of the Seasons 2012)

Female Cast:
Alicia (AYTO 5)- Novice (First Challenge- Season 31: Battle of the Eras)
Aneesa (RW: Chicago)- Legend (First Challenge- Season 6: Battle of the Sexes)
Ashley K (RW: San Diego 2011)- Veteran (First Challenge- Season 23: Battle of the Seasons 2012)
Ashley M (RW: Ex-Plosion)- Redshirt (First Challenge- Season 28: Rivals III)
Averey (RW: Portland)- Redshirt (First Challenge- Season 26: Battle of the Exes II)
Jemmye (RW: New Orleans 2010)- Veteran (First Challenge- Season 23: Battle of the Seasons 2012)
Kailah (RW: Go Big)- Redshirt (First Challenge- Season 29: Invasion of the Champions)
Katrina (RW: Seattle 2016)- Novice (First Challenge- Season 31: Battle of the Eras)
KellyAnne (RW: Sydney)- Legend (First Challenge- Season 16: The Island)
Laurel (Fresh Meat II)- Veteran (First Challenge- Season 19: Fresh Meat II)
Madison (RW: Skeletons)- Novices (First Challenge- Season 31: Battle of the Eras)
Marie (RW: St. Thomas)- Veteran (First Challenge- Season 23: Battle of the Seasons 2012)
Nicole (RW: Skeletons)- Redshirt (First Challenge- Season 29: Invasion of the Champins)
Tori (RR: Viewer's Revenge)- Legend (First Challenge- Season 15: The Gauntlet III)
Veronica (RR: Semester at Sea)- Legend (First Challenge- Season 3: Challenge 2000)
Violetta (RW: Skeletons)- Novice (First Challenge- Season 31: Battle of the Eras)

I will upload the challenges and eliminations soon.
 

^I dig it.

^I dig it.

Thank you!

I dig it.

Rivals 4

Location Fiji

Freshmeat style voting, and a big twist,  redemption is back but with a redneckisland style. In redemption, the three teams Eliminated will compete as individuals in three way Elimination to see who is the new pairs, like say the teams are jamie & Kelly anne, Wes & Nany and Nate & Christina, Wes & Kelly Anne win so they rejoin the game as a,new pair.

Tony & Sylvia

Darrell & Kelly Anne 

Hunter & Kailah

Ammo & Jenna t

Brad & Svetlana

Frank & Nany

Jordan & Nia

Derrick & Beth

CT & Coral

Peter & Katrina

Ty & Katie 

Jason & Nicole 

Abram & Laurel 

Nelson & Ashley m

Gus & Lolo

Greg & Brianna 

The Challenge: Battle of The Exes 3

Location: Punta Cana, Dominican Republic - Final: Canada.

CAST:

Brad Fiorenza, KellyAnne Judd, Tori Fiorenza and Wes Bergmann

Alicia White, Andre Siermers, Edward Williams and Kam Williams

Averey Tressler, Johnny Devenanzio, Johnny Reilly and Nany Gonzalez

Abram Boise, Cara Maria Sorbello, Jamie Larson and Thomas Buell

Amanda Garcia, Mike Crescenzo, Morgan St. Pierre and Tori Deal

Anna Stack, Jenn Geoghan, Peter Romeo and Robbie Padovano

Cory Wharton, Camila Nakagawa, Dione Mariani and Kailah Casillas

Ashley Kelsey, Bruno Bettencourt, Jenna Compono and Zach Nichols

Asaf Goren, Francesa Duncan, Kaylen Zahara and Giovanni Rivera

Battle of the Seasons

 

With teams consisting of Runner-ups from past seasons of the challenge

 

Team Invasion:

Cory

Nelson

Camila

Nicole

 

Team Exes: (Hybrid of Exes 1 & 2)

Jay

Ty

Emily

Theresa

 

Team Free Agents:

Johnny 

Zach 

Devyn

Nany

 

Team Rivals II:

Frank

Marlon

Cooke

Jemmye

 

Team Rivals:

Leroy

Wes

Cara Maria

Jenn

 

Team Cutthroat:

Abram

Luke

Laurel

Sarah

 

Team Duel:

Brad

Mark

Aneesa

Brittni

 

Team Inferno III:

Alton

Bananas

Cara

Susie

 

Team Inferno II:

CT

Derrick

Tina

Veronica

 

Alternate Team:

 

Team Rivals III:

Devin

Vince

Cheyenne

Jenna

The Challenge Anchored 

Location South Africa 

contestants paired up based on who they beat in an Elimination 

Guys

Bananas & Isaac

CT & Nehemiah

Wes & Chet

Darrell & Danny

Landon & Dan

Jordan & Preston

Brad & Big Easy

Derrick & Davis

Girls 

Laurel & Jasmine 

Emily & Melinda

Cara Maria & Anastasia

Jenn & Collie

Beth & Montana 

Jenna & Larssia

Aneesa & Shauvon

Sarah & Katie

Season 31: Battle of the Seasons 3 (realistic)

 

M/F pairs like the original Seasons.

 

Kailah/Dylan (GBOGH)

Katrina/Theo (Bad Blood)

Averey/Marlon (Portland)

Sylvia/Tony (Skeletons)

Shane L/Kendall (Campus Crawl)

Tina/Abram (South Pacific)

Jamie L/Cory (Ex-Plosion)

Marie/Robb (St Thomas)

Brandon N/Cara Maria (Fresh Meat 2)

Jamie B/Nicole R (Bloodlines)

Kellyanne/Cohutta (Sydney)

Leroy/Heather (Las Vegas 2)

Britni/Nelson (AYTO3)

Tori/Asaf (AYTO4)

Adam Kuhn/Jacy (AYTO1)

Alicia/Michael H (AYTO5)

Briana/Layton (AYTO2)

 

And then the non-RW/RR/AYTO/FM we keep hearing about:

 

Cody/Makani (Stranded)

Deena/Ronnie (Jersey Shore)

2 from Teen Mom (Javi & ??)

Maybe ‘90s House, Fear Factor, Laguna Beach, Siesta Key, Flora Bama?

 

All possibilities, but obviously 42 people won’t be on a challenge.

 

Axe AYTO2, AYTO1, and AYTO4 (since Tori declined), or make them Alternates. Lose Teen Mom, and I don’t see a South Pacific team really coming together either. Jersey Shore can also leave.

The Challenge: Heroes vs Villains

Good Guys

Emily (The Real World: D.C.)

Tori (Are You The One? Season 4)

Averey (The Real World: Portland)

Jenna (Real World: Ex-plosion)

Devyn (The Real World: Brooklyn)

Ashley K (The Real World: San Diego 2)

Jill (The Challenge: Bloodlines)

Darrell (Road Rules: Campus Crawl)

Shane (Road Rules: Campus Crawl)

Marlon (The Real World: Portland)

Cory (Real World: Ex-plosion)

Derrick (Road Rules: X-treme)

Leroy (The Real World: Las Vegas 2)

Thomas (Real World: Ex-plosion)

Bad Asses

Violetta (Real World: Skeletons)

Sylvia (Real World: Skeletons)

Katrina (Real World Seattle: Bad Blood)

Kailah (Real World: Go Big or Go Home)

Ashley M (Real World: Ex-plosion)

Tyara (Real World Seattle: Bad Blood)

Amanda (Are You The One? Season 3)

Johnny (The Real World: Key West)

Abram (Road Rules: South Pacific)

Frank (The Real World: San Diego 2)

Devin (Are You The One? Season 3)

Tony (Real World: Skeletons)

Nelson (Are You The One? Season 3)

Dione (Real World: Go Big or Go Home)

Cutthroat 2
Location France 
40 contestants, 4 teams of 10, threeway eliminations
Red Team
Marlon 
Ashley m
Abram 
Tori 
Frank 
Aneesa
CJ
Beth 
Noor 
Theresa

Blue Team
Darrell 
Cooke
Shane
Amanda 
Mitch
Jenn
Mark 
Lolo
Robb 
Katrina
 

Green Team
Wes
Nia
Hunter 
Louise 
Leroy 
Nany
Greg 
Marie 
Brad
Kelly Anne
 

Purple Team
Derrick 
Kailah
Cory
Jill
Gus
Coral
Tony
Rachel 
Jordan 
Sylvia
 

Cutthroat 2

Green Team

Adam Kuhn - AYTO? 1
Alton Williams - RW: Las Vegas
Amanda Garcia - AYTO? 3
Averey Tressler - RW: Portland
Brad Fiorenza - RW: San Diego
Emily Schromm - RW: DC
Robb Schreiber - RW: St. Thomas
Shane Landrum - RR: Campus Crawl
Theresa Gonzalez - Fresh Meat 2
Veronica Portillo - RR: Semester at Sea

Orange Team

Aneesa Ferreira - RW: Chicago
Britni Thornton - AYTO? 3
CJ Koegel - RW: Cancun
Cara Maria Sorbello - Fresh Meat 2
Darrell Taylor - RR: Campus Crawl
Frank Sweeney - RW: San Diego 2
Hunter Barfield - AYTO? 3
Sarah Patterson - RW: Brooklyn
Tina Bridges - RR: South Pacific
Wes Bergmann - RW: Austin

Black Team

CT Tamburello - RW: Paris
Coral Smith - RW: Back to NY
Derrick Kosinski - RR: X-Treme
Dustin Zito - RW: Las Vegas 2
Jordan Wiseley - RW: Portland
KellyAnne Judd - RW: Sydney
Kendal Sheppard - RR: Campus Crawl
Laurel Stucky - Fresh Meat 2
Nelson Thomas - AYTO? 3
Tori Deal - AYTO? 4

CutThroat II

Lacation: Norway - Final: South Africa

Cast:

VETERANS

Brad Fiorenza

Darrell Taylor

Dustin Zito

Cory Wharton

Jordan Wiseley

Nelson Thomas

Amanda Garcia

Aneesa Ferreira

Averey Tressler

Kailah Casillas

Marie Roda

KellyAnne Judd

Challengers (One-Hit Wonders)

Anthony Bartolotte

Bruno Bettencourt

Marlon Williams

Michael Boise

Noor Jehangir

Pete Connolly

Ayiiia Elizarraras

Brittinie Sharrod

Svetlana Shusterman

Heather Cooke

Kendal Sheppard

Jill Tuttle

Rookies

Andre Siemers

Brian Williams

Jason Hill

John Humphrey

Layton Jones

Robbie Padovano

Alicia Wright

CeeJai Jenkins

Jamie Larson

Jenny Delich

Katrina Stack

Tyara Hooks

 

Exes 3

Keith and Alexis

Wes and KellyAnne

Kailah and Cory

Tony and Madison

Thomas and Cara Maria

Theo and Tyara

Robb and Marie

Devin and Kiki

John H and Julia

Bruno and Sylvia

Alicia and Mike Cerasani

Abram and Coral

Mike and Tori

Hunter and Ashley M

 
Fresh meat 3 
location Mozambique 
Marlon & Tyara

Frank & Jenny

Derrick & Ceejai

Wes & Joi

Darrell & Katrina 

Shane & Trisha

Nelson & Ashley l

Abram & Jamie

Cooke & Simon 

Jenn & Jason

Nia & Greg

Veronica & Mike m 

Beth & Brian

Kailah & Scott

Ashley m & Will(Hollywood)

Averey & Dylan

Pages