The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

13610 posts / 0 new
Last post

If Rivals existed during the golden-era of the challenges (before Fresh Meat), when it seemed as though it was possible for anyone to be cast on a challenge - no matter how old it had been since their last appearance on TV:Rivals (6 male pairs, 6 female pairs, 6 male/female pairs)Rules: alternating challenges between the 3 types of pairs.4 pairs of each go home, 12 pairs total.2 male pairs/2 female pairs/2 male&female pairs make it to the final, one winner of each. 3 winning pairs total.Cast (with a brief explanation of rivalry):MalesTheo & Alton (Gauntlet 1: When Alton's girlfriend Irulan went home, Theo told Alton to help her pack her bags causing them to have a heated argument)Shane & Steven (BOTSexes 2: Steven slapped Shane during a challenge in which they were supposed to be silent and was sent home)Brad & Mike (Inferno 2: Mike gave Brad a wedgie as a joke but Brad got angry about it. The two were cool with each other afterwards but to me it seemed like Brad never fully got over it)Syrus & James (Extreme Challenge: At the end of a challenge, the two got into a heated argument and almost got into a physical altercation until Kameelah stopped them)Derrick & David (Gauntlet 2: Derrick wanted to face David in the last gauntlet but David refused to step up, causing Timmy to go in and for David to cheer Timmy on during the gauntlet and not hide the fact that he wanted Derrick to lose)Abram & Donnell (RR South Pacific: both got into a physical altercation on their season after disliking each other all season long)FemalesVeronica & Katie (Gauntlet 1/Inferno 1: Katie mistakenly accused Veronica of trying to get rid of her in the Gauntlet, so in the Inferno, Veronica went out of her way to get rid of her and the two got into an almost physical confrontation)Coral & Julie (Inferno 1: they hated each other on the Inferno and got into a heated argument)Tina & Tonya (BOTSexes 2/Inferno 2: got into an argument on BOTSexes 2 and their dislike for each other carried over to the Inferno 2)Kina & Cara (Gauntlet 2: they never clicked with each other and disliked each other the entire season until they faced off in a somewhat physical gauntlet)Rachel & Angela (BOTSexes 2: they never meshed well with each other causing Rachel to conspire with others on her team to get rid of Angela)Belou & Holly B (BOTSeasons: the two got into an argument after Holly criticized Belou as a mother during the hurricane lockdown and caused Belou to flip out on her and Chadwick)Male/FemaleNorman & Beth (BOTSeasons: they had a history of disliking each other causing Norman to want to get rid of her and he gave her the nickname of Osama 'Beth' Laden)Puck & Ellen (BOTSexes 1: they got into numerous arguments with each other, one of which caused Ellen to have a meltdown after Puck told her he was gonna kick her ass)CT & Leah (Inferno 1: CT felt like Leah was the weakest player on the team and didn't deserve to be in the final, ultimately causing them to argue all throughout Leah's inferno. Leah told CT she was gonna punch him when it all ended)Chadwick & Emily (BOTSeasons: Both disliked each other when Emily used Chadwick's own strategy to get rid of the team in 4th place right before the cut-off to be in the inner circle)Los & Piggy (Challenge 2000: They disliked each other most of the challenge and could not get along. If I remember correctly, they both also had issues and arguments regarding race, given that Piggy was of biracial or mixed race)Christian & Ayanna (Extreme Challenge: I forgot why, but Ayanna got kicked off of the challenge for physically attacking Christian. May have been a race-related thing as well)*sigh* this would've been an awesome cast.

Taking it back! Nice.

Challenge 30: Cutthroat 2- Past vs Present vs FuturePast:Mark Long (RR: First Adventure)Shane Landrum (RR: Campus Crawl)Alton Williams (RW: Las Vegas)Abram Boise (RR: South Pacific)Derrick Kosinski (RR: XTreme)Brad Fiorenza (RW: San Diego)Wes Bergmann (RW: Austin)Beth Stolarczyk (RW: Los Angeles)Veronica Portillo (RR: Semester at Sea)Aneesa Ferreira (RW: Chicago)Rachel Robinson (RR: Campus Crawl)Trishelle Cannatella (RW: Las Vegas)Cara Zavaletta (RR: South Pacific)Jenn Grijalva (RW: Denver) Present:Johnny Devanzio (RW: Key West)Zach Nichols (RW: San Diego 2)Jordan Wiseley (RW: Portland)Cory Wharton (RW: Explosion)Tony Raines (RW: Skeletons)Vince Gliatta (Battle of the Bloodlines)Nelson Thomas (Are You The One? Season 3)Camila Nakagawa (Spring Break Challenge)Nany Gonzalez (RW: Las Vegas 2)Marie Roda (RW: St. Thomas)Nia Moore (RW: Portland)Averey Tressler (RW: Portland)Ashley Mitchell (RW: Explosion)Amanda Garcia (Are You The One? Season 3) Future:Marlon Williams (RW: Portland)Brian Williams (RW: Explosion)Bruno Bettencourt (RW: Skeletons)Jason Hill (RW: Skeletons)Devin Walker (Are You The One? Season 3)Christopher Ammon (RW: Go Big or Go Home)Mike Crescenzo (Are You The One? Season 3 & RW: Seattle - Bad Blood)Ayiiia Elizarraras (RW: Cancun)Jenny Delich (RW: Explosion)Jamie Larson (RW: Explosion)Shanley McIntee (Are You The One?)Sylvia Elsrode (RW: Skeletons)Kailah Casillas (RW: Go Big or Go Home)Tyara Hooks (RW: Seattle - Bad Blood)

Are theygonna have a line of replacements for that Female present side after they all get kicked off for beating each others asses?

Exes 3back and gayer than ever. some kisses some hook ups some rumors etc.  Frank & JordanCT & ShaneBananas & TylerChris & DioneDustin & CamboyLandon & RyanRobbie & TheoDerek & Marlon Girls Laurel & SarahCara Maria & Nicole Jenna T & Kailah Jenn & Rachel Aneesa & EmilyHeather & NanyArielle & Ashley CCara & Susie 

Hilarious.

Challenge 17 wrote:

Exes 3back and gayer than ever. some kisses some hook ups some rumors etc.  Frank & JordanCT & ShaneBananas & TylerChris & DioneDustin & CamboyLandon & RyanRobbie & TheoDerek & Marlon Girls Laurel & SarahCara Maria & Nicole Jenna T & Kailah Jenn & Rachel Aneesa & EmilyHeather & NanyArielle & Ashley CCara & Susie 

Hilarious.

I have to say...Landon & Ryan as a team because Landon had a sex dream about him is hysterical--well done.  That's still weird to me but Landon handled it well

A lot of these confuse me (Frank & Jordan, who the fuck is Camboy?, when did Bananas & Tyler supposedly hook up or did Tyler have a crush on him), Heather M & Nany???did that really happen because if so that's awesome)

Landon deserves my ILM nickname "Closet"

Landon deserves my ILM nickname "Closet"

I know this was a running joke with the cast but I just don't buy it.  If he was really "in the closet" would he have told anyone about the Ryan dream?  I feel like he slept with  bunch of chicks including Tonya.  But he turned down Brittini--I don't know

wutzrenzi wrote:

Challenge 17 wrote:Exes 3back and gayer than ever. some kisses some hook ups some rumors etc.  Frank & JordanCT & ShaneBananas & TylerChris & DioneDustin & CamboyLandon & RyanRobbie & TheoDerek & Marlon Girls Laurel & SarahCara Maria & Nicole Jenna T & Kailah Jenn & Rachel Aneesa & EmilyHeather & NanyArielle & Ashley CCara & Susie 

Hilarious.

I have to say...Landon & Ryan as a team because Landon had a sex dream about him is hysterical--well done.  That's still weird to me but Landon handled it wellA lot of these confuse me (Frank & Jordan, who the fuck is Camboy?, when did Bananas & Tyler supposedly hook up or did Tyler have a crush on him), Heather M & Nany???did that really happen because if so that's awesome)

I think Heather and Nany def made out on their season

wutzrenzi wrote:

Challenge 17 wrote:Exes 3back and gayer than ever. some kisses some hook ups some rumors etc.  Frank & JordanCT & ShaneBananas & TylerChris & DioneDustin & CamboyLandon & RyanRobbie & TheoDerek & Marlon Girls Laurel & SarahCara Maria & Nicole Jenna T & Kailah Jenn & Rachel Aneesa & EmilyHeather & NanyArielle & Ashley CCara & Susie 

Hilarious.

I have to say...Landon & Ryan as a team because Landon had a sex dream about him is hysterical--well done.  That's still weird to me but Landon handled it wellA lot of these confuse me (Frank & Jordan, who the fuck is Camboy?, when did Bananas & Tyler supposedly hook up or did Tyler have a crush on him), Heather M & Nany???did that really happen because if so that's awesome)

camboy isn't a real person, just easier than saying someone from Dustin's gay porn days lol. Frank & Jordan and bananas & Tyler were rumored to have hooked up. Heather & Nany made out. I know nany is like Paula and super open to being with girls, i think she almost fucked aneesa in the shit they should have shown for rivals 2

Season 30: Cutthroat II

Captains are the 3 last place guys for the first Individual Challenge

Red Team:

Devin (Captain)

Jordan

Darrell

Leroy

Derrick H

Camila

Ashley

Veronica

Jemmye

Britni

 

Blue Team:

Chris (Captain)

CT

Bananas

Derrick K

Hunter

Cara Maria

Tori

Kailah

Marie

Alicia

 

Grey Team:

Shane (Captain)

Tony

Cory

Nelson

Dario

Jenna

Aneesa

Amanda

Latoya

Simone

Chris by Shane

Simone by Alicia

Elimination: In the Trenches

Devin by Dario

Amanda & Britni

Elimination: Wrecking Wall

Derrick H by Bananas

Alicia by Jemmye

Elimination: Oppenheimer

Hunter by Leroy

Kailah by Jemmye

Elimination: Tuk Tuk Bang Bang

Shane by Derrick K

Latoya by Tori

Elimination: Pole Wrestle

Dario by Jordan

Jemmye by Aneesa

Elimination: Bell Ringer

Nelson by Darrell

Jenna by Britni

Elimination: Pole Me Over

Bananas by Jordan

Britni by Marie

Elimination: Puzzle Pyramid

Tony by Leroy

Camila by Aneesa

Elimination: Balls In

1st Place: Red Team- Darrell, Jordan, Leroy, Ashley, and Veronica

2nd Place: Blue Team- CT, Derrick, Cara Maria, Marie, and Tori

3rd Place: Grey Team- Cory and Aneesa

Blue Team wins by a long shot.

The fuck is Shane R doing with his draft?

I dont think Jordan can beat Bananas in Pole Me Over coz Bananas is bigger and has more weight plus Jordan lacks 1 hand which you need in this elimination.

Damn that'd be a close race between red and blue.

I dont think Jordan can beat Bananas in Pole Me Over coz Bananas is bigger and has more weight plus Jordan lacks 1 hand which you need in this elimination.

oh no he eliminated Bananas in Puzzle Pyramid lol

We just don't give a fuck about spoilers anymore, huh?

Exes 3

Cory and Camilla

Tony and Ashley M.

Zach and Jenna

CT and Anastasia

Nate S. and Nicole

Jordan and Laurel

Alton and Sarah

Johnny R. And Nany

Nelson and Latoya

Thomas and Cara Maria

Robb and Marie

Bruno and Sylvia

Danny and Melinda

Wes and KellyAnne

 

 

 

 

 

 

GUISE I GOT IT: the best & biggest & most necessary cast of all time!

 

Battle of the Monikers

 

Ladies:

Ashlee F (RWNOLA2)

Ashley C (Ex-Plosion)

Ashley K (RWSD2)

Ashley M (Ex-Plosion)

Ashley L (RWDC)

Cara Maria (FM2)

Cara Z (RR South Pacific)

Cara K (RW Chicago)

Sarah R (Brooklyn)

Sarah G (Campus Crawl)

Tori D (AYTO4)

Tori F (RR Viewers’ Revenge)

Britni T (AYTO3)

Brittni S (Hollywood)

Brittany B (AYTO1)

Heather Cooke (RWLV2)

Heather M (RWLV2)

Naomi D (RWLV2)

Naomi “Nany” G (RWLV2)

Jenn G (Denver)

Jenn G (RW Bad Blood)

Jenna C (Ex-Plosion)

Jenna T (GBOGH)

Jenny D (Ex-Plosion)

Tyler (AYTO2)

Devyn (Brooklyn)

Jordan (Bad Blood)

 

Gentlemen:

Jordan (Portland)

Devin (AYTO3)

Tyler “Loves the” D (Key West)

Tyler (AYTO5)

Mike C (AYTO5)

Mike M (DC)

Michael H (AYTO5)

Michael R (RWLV2)

Shane R (Bloodlines)

Shane L (Campus Crawl)

Johnny D (Key West)

Johnny R (Portland)

Johnnie M (FM1)

Derrick H (AYTO5)

Derrick K (RR X-Treme)

Derek C (Cancun)

Derek M (RR Viewers’ Revenge)

Danny D (RR X-Treme)

Danny J (Austin)

Dan W (RR Viewers' Revenge)

Dan R (RW Miami)

Dan S (RR Northern Trail)

Brandon N (FM2)

Brandon T (AYTO2)

Theo V (RR Maximum Velocity)

Theo G (RW Chicago)

Theo K (Bad Blood)

 

Who am I missing though?

 

Whoops! Add Nicole Z (Skeletons) & Nicole R (Bloodlines) to the mix!

And Briana (Bloodlines) & Brianna (AYTO2)!

And Nate S (AYTO2) & Nate (RWSD2)!

And his roommate Frank S (RWSD2) & Frank R (RWLV)!

And CJ (Cancun) & CeeJai (GBOGH)!

Rivals 4 Nia and AvereyNany and TheresaKailah and MarieAmanda and CamilaLaurel and Cara MariaAneesa and KellyAnneCeejai and Jenna T.Ashley M and SimoneCory and NelsonBananas and WesShane and TonyThomas and VinceDevin and DarioDarrell and BradFrank and DustinZach and Jay 

did i miss something??? since when are kailah and marie rivals?

Ceej3 wrote:

Rivals 4 Nia and AvereyNany and TheresaKailah and MarieAmanda and CamilaLaurel and Cara MariaAneesa and KellyAnneCeejai and Jenna T.Ashley M and SimoneCory and NelsonBananas and WesShane and TonyThomas and VinceDevin and DarioDarrell and BradFrank and DustinZach and Jay 

did i miss something??? since when are kailah and marie rivals?

They didn't get along on Invasion though I think they're good now

Free Agents 2. 

Location-south Africa

prize $300,000 (one male & female $150,000 winner) 

30 contestants 

female- coral, Rachel, Veronica, Tina, Aneesa, anika, LaToya, Nia, ceejai, tyara, Simone, Nany, Camila, Ashley M, Kailah, Amanda 

male-Alton, CT, Derrick K, Wes, brad, Darrell, Nelson, Cory, Theo, Dean,  Dario, Hunter, Leroy, Dylan, 

We just don't give a fuck about spoilers anymore, huh?

lol forreal, but whatever.

I actually had a cast similar to s30 in my notes prior to the reveal. Wasn't ideal, just what I thought was realistic. It's such a coincidence...like I even had Veronica and Derrick returning .

Cutthroat 2.

Red Team

Swift(St Thomas)
Marlon(Portland)
Cory(Ex-plosion)
Jason(Skeletons)
Dione(Go Big or Go Home)

Madison(Skeletons)
Jamie(Ex-plosion)
Avery(Portland)
Sabrina(Go Big or Go Home)
Latoya(St Thomas)

Blue Team

Mike(Bad Blood)
Dustin(Las Vegas 2)
Thomas(Ex-plosion)
Tony(Skeletons)
Dylan(Go Big or Go Home)

Ceejai(Go Big or Go Home)
Katrina(Bad Blood)
Kailah(Go Big or Go Home)
Nicole(Skeletons)
Nia(Portland)

Gray Team

Robbie(Bad Blood)
Brian(Ex-plosion)
Jordan(Portland)
Trey(St Thomas)
CJ(Cancun)

Tyara(Bad Blood)
Marie(St Thomas)
Jenny(Ex-plosion)
Jonna(Cancun)
Ashley M(Ex-plosion)

The Challenge Fresh Meat 3

Rookies are paired with an alum thats only done 1 or 2 challenges

Devin & Shanley

Theo & Tya

Bruno & Arielle

Marlon & CeeJai

CJ & Jenny

Robb & Jamie

Noor & Tyranny

Hunter & Violetta

 

Averey & Connor

Marie & Brian

Sylvia & Jason

Kailah & Dylan

Nia & Edward

Ashley & Mike (Bad Blood)

Amanda & Dione

Cooke & Scali

The Challenge: Rivals 2.0

Same Rivals format  with a slight change. Pairs can also be made up of people that challenged each other 1-on-1 on past eliminations. 

Men:

Derrick & Wes (The Ruins)

Darrell & Cohutta (The Ruins)

Tony & Bruno (Invasion of the Champions)

Johnny & Leroy (Battle of the Exes 2)

Devin & Gio (Are You the One?)

Cory & Shane (Invasion of the Champions)

Abram & Brad (The Inferno 2)

Alternate: Theo & Kassius (Bad Blood)

Women:

Cara Maria & Nia (Free Agents)

Nany & Theresa (Battle of the Exes 2)

Amanda & Nicole (Invasion of the Champions)

Kailah & Marie (Invasion of the Champions)

Laurel & Aneesa (Free Agents)

Ashley & Jamie L (Real World: Ex-plosion)

Violetta & Madison (Real World: Skeletons)

Alternate: Jemmye & Latoya (Free Agents)
 

GUISE I GOT IT: the best & biggest & most necessary cast of all time! Battle of the Monikers Ladies:Ashlee F (RWNOLA2)Ashley C (Ex-Plosion)Ashley K (RWSD2)Ashley M (Ex-Plosion)Ashley L (RWDC)Cara Maria (FM2)Cara Z (RR South Pacific)Cara K (RW Chicago)Sarah R (Brooklyn)Sarah G (Campus Crawl)Tori D (AYTO4)Tori F (RR Viewers’ Revenge)Britni T (AYTO3)Brittni S (Hollywood)Brittany B (AYTO1)Heather Cooke (RWLV2)Heather M (RWLV2)Naomi D (RWLV2)Naomi “Nany” G (RWLV2)Jenn G (Denver)Jenn G (RW Bad Blood)Jenna C (Ex-Plosion)Jenna T (GBOGH)Jenny D (Ex-Plosion)Tyler (AYTO2)Devyn (Brooklyn)Jordan (Bad Blood) Gentlemen:Jordan (Portland)Devin (AYTO3)Tyler “Loves the” D (Key West)Tyler (AYTO5)Mike C (AYTO5)Mike M (DC)Michael H (AYTO5)Michael R (RWLV2)Shane R (Bloodlines)Shane L (Campus Crawl)Johnny D (Key West)Johnny R (Portland)Johnnie M (FM1)Derrick H (AYTO5)Derrick K (RR X-Treme)Derek C (Cancun)Derek M (RR Viewers’ Revenge)Danny D (RR X-Treme)Danny J (Austin)Dan W (RR Viewers' Revenge)Dan R (RW Miami)Dan S (RR Northern Trail)Brandon N (FM2)Brandon T (AYTO2)Theo V (RR Maximum Velocity)Theo G (RW Chicago)Theo K (Bad Blood) Who am I missing though? Whoops! Add Nicole Z (Skeletons) & Nicole R (Bloodlines) to the mix!And Briana (Bloodlines) & Brianna (AYTO2)!And Nate S (AYTO2) & Nate (RWSD2)!And his roommate Frank S (RWSD2) & Frank R (RWLV)!And CJ (Cancun) & CeeJai (GBOGH)!

Dre (Ayto 1) and Dre (Ayto 5)

The Challenge Fresh Meat 3Rookies are paired with an alum thats only done 1 or 2 challengesDevin & ShanleyTheo & TyaBruno & ArielleMarlon & CeeJaiCJ & JennyRobb & JamieNoor & TyrannyHunter & Violetta Averey & ConnorMarie & BrianSylvia & JasonKailah & DylanNia & EdwardAshley & Mike (Bad Blood)Amanda & DioneCooke & Scali

Cancelled--this would do worse than Seasons 2012

 

 

 

What they should do is film seasons 31 & 32 at the same time   Do a "Duel: All Stars" then a big team format with Real World vs. AYTO...even though I can't stand AYTO they're going to be on the cast so we might as well.  This would also create new winners (probably from Real World if we're being honest) and force people not to do every single season.  For example, Bananas would be on All Stars but not the team one so we'd finally get a much needed break.  Only concern would be getting enough people to make The Duel good enough. 

AshtonMartin wrote:

The Challenge Fresh Meat 3Rookies are paired with an alum thats only done 1 or 2 challengesDevin & ShanleyTheo & TyaBruno & ArielleMarlon & CeeJaiCJ & JennyRobb & JamieNoor & TyrannyHunter & Violetta Averey & ConnorMarie & BrianSylvia & JasonKailah & DylanNia & EdwardAshley & Mike (Bad Blood)Amanda & DioneCooke & Scali

Cancelled--this would do worse than Seasons 2012   

Thought this site would like Seasons. The majority don't like it.

kvm1977 wrote:

AshtonMartin wrote:The Challenge Fresh Meat 3Rookies are paired with an alum thats only done 1 or 2 challengesDevin & ShanleyTheo & TyaBruno & ArielleMarlon & CeeJaiCJ & JennyRobb & JamieNoor & TyrannyHunter & Violetta Averey & ConnorMarie & BrianSylvia & JasonKailah & DylanNia & EdwardAshley & Mike (Bad Blood)Amanda & DioneCooke & Scali

Cancelled--this would do worse than Seasons 2012   

Thought this site would like Seasons. The majority don't like it.

The problem with Seasons was the casting...which we can largely blame Dustin for.   There were too many rookie teams and the nightmare that was the Fresh Meat team--which included a Spring Breaker.  The eliminations were solid (aside from Balls Out) but the gameplay was poor. If we would have had Las Vegas, Austin,  Cancun, NOLA2, Vegas2, San Diego 2, with Brooklyn or Sydney (ideally Sydney) & either San Diego/Road Rules the masses on here would have been happy. 

messytessy wrote:

kvm1977 wrote:

AshtonMartin wrote:The Challenge Fresh Meat 3Rookies are paired with an alum thats only done 1 or 2 challengesDevin & ShanleyTheo & TyaBruno & ArielleMarlon & CeeJaiCJ & JennyRobb & JamieNoor & TyrannyHunter & Violetta Averey & ConnorMarie & BrianSylvia & JasonKailah & DylanNia & EdwardAshley & Mike (Bad Blood)Amanda & DioneCooke & Scali

Cancelled--this would do worse than Seasons 2012   

Thought this site would like Seasons. The majority don't like it.

The problem with Seasons was the casting...which we can largely blame Dustin for.   There were too many rookie teams and the nightmare that was the Fresh Meat team--which included a Spring Breaker.  The eliminations were solid (aside from Balls Out) but the gameplay was poor. If we would have had Las Vegas, Austin,  Cancun, NOLA2, Vegas2, San Diego 2, with Brooklyn or Sydney (ideally Sydney) & either San Diego/Road Rules the masses on here would have been happy. 

Um no. The only thing we can even begin to blame Dustin for is the 2 Vegas teams not panning out. And that was really Heather not wanting Dustin to be on a Team with Cooke given that she still had issues with her so really Dustin didn't do anything wrong.

Pages