American Idol

486 posts / 0 new
Last post
I think Elise should be there over all 4 of them, Skylar....not so much, she was very pitchy and didnt connect with any of her songs. She did too much.
[QUOTE=fabulous788;303927]From an outside viewer, that only watches occasionally, Hollie was the best last week in my opinion...[/QUOTE] I absolutely agree. I think she was the best the week before too. [QUOTE=TSPKM2;303928]I think Elise should be there over all 4 of them, Skylar....not so much, she was very pitchy and didnt connect with any of her songs. She did too much.[/QUOTE] Elise's singing was alright, but her personality SUCKED. It's not very often that I dislike a contestant on AI(Jacob from last season may be the only other one), but there was something about her that I couldn't stand!
What are you talking about? Elise kept it real.
This season started to slip away when Elise went home but it's completely farcical now. Hollie and Skylar had no business being in the Bottom 2 last week. Hollie goes home this week with either Joshua or Jessica joining him in the Bottom 2 (because someone has to and people are madly in love with WGWG5 for reasons I will never know). Dialidol had Skylar receiving the most telephone votes last week and WGWG5 the fewest. So that tells me either there is a massive trend away from people voting by phone, or there's some rigging going on.
[QUOTE=Aereas;303949]This season started to slip away when Elise went home but it's completely farcical now. Hollie and Skylar had no business being in the Bottom 2 last week. Hollie goes home this week with either Joshua or Jessica joining him in the Bottom 2 (because someone has to and people are madly in love with WGWG5 for reasons I will never know). Dialidol had Skylar receiving the most telephone votes last week and WGWG5 the fewest. So that tells me either there is a massive trend away from people voting by phone, or there's some rigging going on.[/QUOTE] DialIdol won't be reliable anymore because of everyone having 2 phone lines now.
It tracks both numbers for each contestant separately and combines them for a score but I still think the trend is moving away from dialing and either texting or voting online.
[QUOTE=Aereas;303981]It tracks both numbers for each contestant separately and combines them for a score but I still think the trend is moving away from dialing and either texting or voting online.[/QUOTE] Yes, but the addition of the second line makes it significantly less, or not at all, accurate. That said, I do agree that there are more people texting and voting online than ever before.
I'm guessing the teenie bopper girls are texting and voting online for Jessica and Phillip. Idk who is voting for Joshua....church people? old people? I would think they would be dialing, which I would think Hollie would get more votes than him, since she is better. I do think some rigging is going on in favor of Joshua.
I lost interest very fast this season. Maybe it's because I'm not a fan of any of the contestants or nobody stands out. Well, maybe Phillip and Jessica. I'm looking forward to The X Factor!
Jessica or Hollie should be the one going this week if it were up to just me :D Jessica's Dreamgirls song was very shouty the entire time, up until the end. It really bugs me that the judges and half of America loves her so much. Her personality still hasn't shone through in my opinion. Joshua killed his second song, best of the night!
I'm going to agree with Fab. Jessica or Hollie should go home. I think it will be Hollie.
Am I the only one that hated Joshua's 1st song? Unless you can REALLY sing it, don't even attempt Josh Groban. I only saw the 1st songs because I really don't care about any of these people enough to watch the 2nd hour. No Colton, no Skylar, no interest.
Josh did a whole lot more screamimg and shouting than Jessica did. I think Its gonna be a Diva show down between Josh and Jessica for the Final 2
[QUOTE=Seannnn;304179]Josh did a whole lot more screamimg and shouting than Jessica did. I think Its gonna be a Diva show down between Josh and Jessica for the Final 2[/QUOTE] Unfortunately I think you're right. I would rather have Holly or Philip win at this point. Jessica and especially Josh seem so full of themselves.
[QUOTE=RMD1;304187]Unfortunately I think you're right. I would rather have Holly or Philip win at this point. Jessica and especially Josh seem so full of themselves.[/QUOTE] Josh is so good though. That was the best rendition of "It's a Man's Man's Man's World" I've heard in a long while.
Hollie has been redeemed in my book. That is all.
Honestly I'm sick of Joshua and Jessica. They've been doing ballad after ballad since week one. It's really gotten old. The judges need to stop playing favorites, especially with Joshua! He and Jessica have shown NO PERSONALITY AT ALL! They're effing boring! This show needs a big shake up next year for me to come back.
[QUOTE=salt&vinegar;304212]Honestly I'm sick of Joshua and Jessica. They've been doing ballad after ballad since week one. It's really gotten old. The judges need to stop playing favorites, especially with Joshua! He and Jessica have shown NO PERSONALITY AT ALL! They're effing boring! This show needs a big shake up next year for me to come back.[/QUOTE] Is this real life? I can't believer you people are saying that they have no personality. That's just simply not true. And so what if they do ballad after ballad. The beauty of competition like this is that stick to what their good at. I mean I've yet to see you complain about the country singers, rock singers of the past. Its better than have ticks and tremors like Phillip Phillips whose only made this far because of his name. He offers nothin new. Even Hollie is better than him and thats saying a lot.
How in the hell did Phillip Phillips make it in the finale over Joshua? Really trifle man. He sucks to the tenth degree. Well at least Jessica will win cause if the curse is correct excluding Scotty the last few winners have had ****ty records and Lee should've never won.
[QUOTE=Nostalgic;305125]How in the hell did Phillip Phillips make it in the finale over Joshua? Really trifle man. He sucks to the tenth degree. Well at least Jessica will win cause if the curse is correct excluding Scotty the last few winners have had ****ty records and Lee should've never won.[/QUOTE] Such a shame Joshua didn't make it. I wanted him to win. I bet you anything Phillip ends up winning anyway.
Like I said before, FaB; even if Phillip does win it doesn't mean a damn thing if he can't sell a record. He's like the new Blake (the guy Jordin was up against).
I have a feeling Jessica will win. I think all the Joshua supporters will now support Jessica.
[QUOTE=gamer73;305129]I have a feeling Jessica will win. I think all the Joshua supporters will now support Jessica.[/QUOTE] I was a supporter of Joshua and will not jump on the Jessica train.
[QUOTE=Nostalgic;305128]Like I said before, FaB; even if Phillip does win it doesn't mean a damn thing if he can't sell a record. He's like the new Blake (the guy Jordin was up against).[/QUOTE] Honestly the only person that I think will sell records from this season is Colton, and POSSIBLY Skylar.
I really hope Jessica wins the show, if Phillip wins the show I am seriously done with idol he is a terrible singer and I cannot believe he's in the finale over Joshua. I am tired mediocre guys winning the show like Scotty, Lee, Kris and David cook. I feel the runner's up always get the win snatch just look at Adam Lambert and Crystal just to name some lately america has gotten the winner wrong I hope this does not happen next week.
I hate to say this, but NONE of these people are terrible singers. They wouldn't have made it on American Idol had they been terrible.
I agree none of the participants on idol are terrible singers but Phillip the person I said was a terrible singer cannot be compared to Jessica's, Joshua's, Hollies', or Colton's singing capacity.
I guess I am the only one who wants Phillip to win.
[QUOTE=RMD1;305157]I guess I am the only one who wants Phillip to win.[/QUOTE] Nope. I want him to win over Jessica, hands down.
Jessica 4 the win!!! :)

Pages