Thread: Battle of the Seasons: Fresh Meat - Cara Maria, Eric, Brandon, Camila

Originally Posted by El Scorcho

Brandon is a ****** coward. He sits there and acts like he has been on 7 challenges, has a won, and doesn't deserve to go in. He beat Derek, JD, and Ty all of which were terrible competitors at the time, he got shut out by Derrick and was eliminated quick on Rivals. He hasn't paid his dues at all. He's a coward.

Well that escalated quickly...

If Brandon were on this team with a good male competitor, or even someone at the middle of the pack, then I would agree with you Scorcho. But that's not the case. Of three Arenas that have passed, Eric should have been in all 3 no questions asked. This 4th, upcoming Arena is when Brandon should have volunteered, had he not been sent home.

Originally Posted by El Scorcho

Brandon is a ****** coward. He sits there and acts like he has been on 7 challenges, has a won, and doesn't deserve to go in. He beat Derek, JD, and Ty all of which were terrible competitors at the time, he got shut out by Derrick and was eliminated quick on Rivals. He hasn't paid his dues at all. He's a coward.

His wins during Cutthroat weren't impressive but he did win them. Also, very few people are going to beat Derrick in anything that deal with wrestling.


Brandon did good during Rivals. Ty killed them in the elimination round. He beat Kenny & Wes the first time up the rope. Wes beat him the second. Those things happens.

He's not a great competitor but he's solid--far better than Eric

Eric should have gone into every elimination. He knows his team has no chance in a final with him on the team, so he should have gone in every time and the girls should have switched every time. I wonder if big easy was the only other guy they called or if they tried Vinny, Luke or Noor. Replace any of those guys with easy and they make the finals.

Originally Posted by ChallengeGod

Eric should have gone into every elimination. He knows his team has no chance in a final with him on the team, so he should have gone in every time and the girls should have switched every time. I wonder if big easy was the only other guy they called or if they tried Vinny, Luke or Noor. Replace any of those guys with easy and they make the finals.

I wouldn't go that far.
I think Noor would have given them a great chance to make the finals
Luke is probably 50/50--I do think he'd do well in elimination rounds
Vinny hasn't exactly been impressive to me but he's a better athlete than Eric so that would have helped them
I still don't think Camila or Cara Maria would ever win a mental or strategic elimination round with Brandon, Luke or Vinny--maybe Noor.

But at least they wouldn't have had to go into the first 3 elminations. And who knows maybe Camilla and Vinny could have been great together at puzzles haha.

Originally Posted by El Scorcho

Brandon is a ****** coward. He sits there and acts like he has been on 7 challenges, has a won, and doesn't deserve to go in. He beat Derek, JD, and Ty all of which were terrible competitors at the time, he got shut out by Derrick and was eliminated quick on Rivals. He hasn't paid his dues at all. He's a coward.

Bradon is not a coward...but his reasoning for not wanting to go in the Arena that episode was stupid...It doesn't matter what you did on past challenges..that doesn't mean you get a free pass from competing and plus there are only FOUR of you on this team and Eric is not going to go in every damn time (although he should).

But regardless he is still tolerable.