Thread: The Duel 2: Episode 9 - Discussion

Originally Posted by tjhallow

Yeah but to be fair, has Evelynn ever been in an elimination round against someone besides Casey? You can't compare them to each other. I have seen good things from both of them so this who vs. who isn't really fair. How can you put someone in the same league as Ev when we have never seen her truly compete against someone besides Casey? The Island doesn't count either..anyone could have beat Tyrie and I'm convinced anyone could have beaten Dan. Wasn't Dan the first one out in their eliminated round again KA and Johanna? Johnny and Kenny even said, their biggest threat was Rachel.

I'm not going to put her above Rachel yet or say one is better than the other because I haven't seen anything amazing from Ev.

This is just too much. I'm not sure if I'll be able to stop laughing anytime soon. Talk to almost anyone who has been on a challenge and they will tell you that Evelyn is the beast.

Originally Posted by V1man

This is just too much. I'm not sure if I'll be able to stop laughing anytime soon. Talk to almost anyone who has been on a challenge and they will tell you that Evelyn is the beast.

Well she is beast but I'm not saying to say she is better than Rachel.

Originally Posted by tjhallow

Well she is beast but I'm not saying to say she is better than Rachel.

I am, and I'll stake my reputation on it. (With respect to everyone's opinions, my views are not based on a TV show, on on real life. I'm not engaging in a dialogue on this with anyone, so don't bother to try.)

Originally Posted by V1man

I am, and I'll stake my reputation on it.

I respect your opinion, but we will just have to agree to disagree.

Woah, my opinion:

Rachel would beat anyone on this Challenge at this point. I do not think Aneesa is doing her dirty work. Rachel certainly wants it, but if you think about it, Aneesa would have ended up against Tori anyways.

As for her and Ev, I would put them in the same league, and they are equal. Just because we haven't seen Rachel in an elimination round, and Ev has only gone twice, once lost, and once against Casey.

I agree V1 that Ev is a beast. One thing I respect from her is, her commitment to the challenges. Aside from that wouldn't it be unfair to say Ev is better, without them competing agaisnt each other. Paula did beat Ev in some of the Gauntlet 3 missions, and Johanna was giving Ev a run for her money on the Island, on the last key challenge, and losing the life saver to Janelle and Tonya on Inferno 3. I don't think it's possible to compare the two, unless we have both of them compete in pole wrestle or an exile type of elimination. Now I won't deny this, the battle between both of them will be EPIC, probably better than Wes and Derricks Duel. Guys don't forget about the Hollys, the original Ev/Rachel LOL.