Thread: The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

CutThroat 2 with a TWIST!
Team Old School or Past (Challengers before Fresh Meat 1)
Mike "The Miz" (RW: B2 New York)
CT (RW: Paris)
Brad (RW: San Diego)
Abram (RR: South Pacific)
Derrick (RR: X-Treme)
Beth (RW: Los Angeles)
Coral (RW: B2 New York)
Robin (RW: San Diego)
Veronica (RR: Semester at Sea)
Rachel (RR: Campus Crawl)

Team Middle School or Present (Challengers between Fresh Meat 1-Ruins)
Wes (RW: Austin)
Johnny (RW: Key West)
Dunbar (RW: Sydney)
Evan (FM)
Kenny (FM)
Paula (RW: Key West)
Jenn (RW: Denver)
Sarah (RW: Brooklyn)
Ev (FM)
Diem (FM)

Team New School or Future (Challengers after Fresh Meat 2)
Ty (RW: DC)
Leroy (RW: B2 Las Vegas)
Zach (RW: B2 San Diego)
Frank (RW: B2 San Diego)
Brandon (FM2)
Jasmine (RW: Cancun)
Emily (RW: DC)
Laurel (FM2)
Cara Maria (FM2)
Mandi (FM2)

I like the cutoff being Fresh Meat/Austin and the final team starting with FM2/DC so I thought I'd make my Cutthroat II using that. One difference is I'm using teams of 12 instead of 10.

Old School
Guys: Landon (Philadelphia), CT (Paris), Brad (San Diego), Derrick (Xtreme), Mark (RR1) & Abram (South Pacific)
Girls: Rachel (Campus Crawl), Aneesa (Chicago), Trishelle (Vegas), Coral (BNY), Jillian (Xtreme) & Veronica (Semester at Sea)
Alternates: Alton (Vegas), Adam (Paris), Susie (Down Under), Katie (The Quest), Robin (San Diego) & Tina (South Pacific).
Note: I would have included Susie over Jillian if she wasn't pregnant/just had a kid.

Present
Guys: Johnny (Key West), Wes (Austin), Dunbar (Sydney), Tyler (Key West), CJ (Cancun) & Danny (Austin)
Girls: Evelyn (FM), KellyAnne (Sydney), Sarah (Brooklyn), Jonna (Cancun), Paula (Key West) & Melinda (Austin)
Alternates: Kenny & Evan (FM), Davis (Denver), Issac (Sydney), Chet (Brooklyn), Diem (FM), Tori (VR), Kimberly (Hollywood), Jasmine (Cancun) & Lacey (Austin)
Notes: If Evan & Kenny's situation involving Tonya is resolved I'd put them in over Danny & CJ. I would have included Tori over Paula or Melinda if she didn't just have a kid. I can't see her and Brad doing a challenge together unless they bring the kid with them like Belou did in the first Battle of the Seasons

New School
Guys: Zach (SD2), Leroy (Vegas), Ty (DC), Frank (SD2), Dustin (Vegas) & a Portland guy
Girls: Emily (DC), Laurel (FM2), Theresa (FM2), McKenzie (NOLA, Jemmye (NOLA) & a Portland girl
Alternates: Brandon (FM2), Trey (St. Thomas), Knight (NOLA), Camila (SB), Ashley (SD2), Cara Maria (FM2) & Mandi (FM2)
Note: I included 2 Portland people because I think they need to be eased in and this format would fit for that.

I tried to make the teams as even a possible. Having Emily & Laurel gives the New School team a huge advantage IMO. I think the "Present" team has the weakest guys but four of them have won before. I really don't think there's an "awful" player. Danny may be the weakest guy but he can still put up a fight even in a loss. We don't know a lot about Jemmye or McKenzie yet--if both turn out to be weak it would probably be good to replace one of them.

Also, it is kind of sad that Brandon is really the only Fresh Meat II guy that's even a possibility. Maybe Luke?

Gauntlet 4: Veterans vs. Rookies. New rule is that you must have done at least 3 seasons to be a veteran instead of 2.

Veterans:
- Abram
- Alton
- CT
- Derrick
- Dunbar
- Johnny
- Mark
- Wes

- Aneesa
- Camila
- Cara Maria
- Laurel
- Paula
- Rachel
- Sarah
- Trishelle

Rookies:
- CJ
- Derek
- Dustin
- Frank
- Knight
- Leroy
- Trey
- Zach

- Ashley
- Ayiiia
- Heather
- Jonna
- Laura
- Marie
- Nany
- Sam

I have no theme or concept.

Just to fix up the female side of these challenges, I'd really like to see the dynamic of:
Portland Girl, Ashley (DC), McKenzie, Laura, Marie, Jonna, Emily, KellyAnne, Laurel, Evelyn, Cara Maria, Trishelle, Coral, Rachel, and an unbanned Tina.

For males everyone is anticipating Johnny and Frank together with guys like CT, Wes, Derrick, Abram, Leroy, Dustin, Ty, CJ, Zach, Trey, Knight, Isaac and then a Portland guy thrown in there.

My realistic fantasy cast for next season will include 14 men and 14 women. 7 veteran men, 7 rookie men, 7 veteran women, 7 rookie women.

1 vet and 1 rookie will be a pair

1.Kenny (Fresh Meat) & Marie (St.Thomas)
2.Evan (Fresh Meat) & Jemmye (New Orleans)
3.Johnny (Key West) & Nany (Las Vegas)
4.CT (Paris) & McKenzie (New Orleans)
5.Wes (Austin) & Laura (St.Thomas)
6.Derrick (X-Treme) & LaToya (St.Thomas)
7.Mark (USA) & Ashley (San Diego)
8.Paula (Key West) & Frank (San Diego)
9.Laurel (Fresh Meat 2) & Trey (St.Thomas)
10.Sarah (Brooklyn) & Robb (St.Thomas)
11.Coral (B2NY) & Swift (St.Thomas)
12.Kelly Anne (Sydney) & Knight (New Orleans)
13.Trishelle (Las Vegas) & Nate (San Diego)
14.Susie (Down Under) & Zach (San Diego)

...or at least this is how I see next season looking, probably with a few different substitutions

Originally Posted by TSPKM2

My realistic fantasy cast for next season will include 14 men and 14 women. 7 veteran men, 7 rookie men, 7 veteran women, 7 rookie women.

1 vet and 1 rookie will be a pair

1.Kenny (Fresh Meat) & Marie (St.Thomas)
2.Evan (Fresh Meat) & Jemmye (New Orleans)
3.Johnny (Key West) & Nany (Las Vegas)
4.CT (Paris) & McKenzie (New Orleans)
5.Wes (Austin) & Laura (St.Thomas)
6.Derrick (X-Treme) & LaToya (St.Thomas)
7.Mark (USA) & Ashley (San Diego)
8.Paula (Key West) & Frank (San Diego)
9.Laurel (Fresh Meat 2) & Trey (St.Thomas)
10.Sarah (Brooklyn) & Robb (St.Thomas)
11.Coral (B2NY) & Swift (St.Thomas)
12.Kelly Anne (Sydney) & Knight (New Orleans)
13.Trishelle (Las Vegas) & Nate (San Diego)
14.Susie (Down Under) & Zach (San Diego)

...or at least this is how I see next season looking, probably with a few different substitutions

I like this idea so I made a cast of my own.

Teams:
Abram (RR: South Pacific) & Anastasia (RW: Portland)
Coral (RW: Back to New York) & Frank (RW: San Diego 2)
CT (RW: Paris) & Laurel (Fresh Meat II)
Derrick (RR: X-Treme) & Ashley (RW: San Diego 2)
Diem (Fresh Meat) & Leroy (RW: Las Vegas 2)
Dunbar (RW: Sydney) & Marie (RW: St. Thomas)
Janelle (RW: Key West) & Trey (RW: St. Thomas)
Johnny (RW: Key West) & Theresa (Fresh Meat II)
KellyAnne (RW: Sydney) & Zach (RW: San Diego 2)
Kenny (Fresh Meat) & Emily (RW: D.C.)
Paula (RW: Key West) & Ty (RW: D.C.)
Rachel (RR: Campus Crawl) & Swift (RW: St. Thomas)
Robin (RW: San Diego) & Jordan (RW: Portland)
Trishelle (RW: Las Vegas) & Nate (RW: San Diego 2)
Tyler (RW: Key West) & Jonna (RW: Cancun)
Tyrie (RW: Denver) & LaToya (RW: St. Thomas)

Old School- Any Real World season up through Sydney, Road Rules, and Fresh Meat
New School- Any Real World season from Hollywood-present and Fresh Meat II