Thread: The Challenge: Create Your Own

Originally Posted by Jacks0n

I want a challenge where the best competitors are pit against each other in elimination competitions. Here it would be a cash prize of whatever, just not split between first second and third, only first place girl and guy would get anything, hopefully eliminating any alliances. Because if its enough money and other than first place getting cash, competitors would only want weak players to stay. Thus, weekly challenge winner, power holder can choose two competitors to battle in the arena or whatever.

I absolutely love the format and the guys you cast. This would be the perfect format to have all the elite players though because you'd definitely get to see them go H2H as whomever won would send in the top two in order to guarantee one leaves. Evelyn, Laurel, Emily, Rachel, Theresa, Aneesa, Sarah and Camila would be my ideal. Again, love the format

I'm not sure how MTV would title this challenge without crushing a few people's souls, but a concept of great challengers vs bad challengers would be quite hilarious. Imagine Kenny having to to deal with Shavoun as his partner. :-P I'm not saying some of the "bad" contestants don't have their advantages or are completely worthless (Aneesa is a great elimination player, Casey won multiple running head to heads with Wes, Katie has actually won a challenge when some of the "good" haven't yet) but I feel casting sometimes stretches stories as well (Johnny and Camilla being exes, Camilla and Theresa being Rivals)

Kenny - Shavoun
Darell - Cameran
Evan - Katie or Priscilla
Frank - Aneesa
Tyler - Melinda
Landon - Casey

Laurel - Danny
Paula - Nate
Evelyn - Big Easy
Emily - Alex (Denver)
Diem - Tyrie
Kelly Anne - Preston

Each week the "Greats" compete in a challenge and the Guy and Girl winner can either give their pair immunity, or trade for a better partner by going into the elimination round with them. After that they play for power team, if the previous winners traded, then last place won't matter, and the power couple will chose someone to go in. Either 2 teams or three teams will go to the elimination round, but only one team leaves and goes home.

The final 3 teams do the final. The only rule is that you cannot carry your teammate on your back(to even the disadvantage the guy "greats" may use over the girl "greats"). Establish this beforehand so people are clear unlike what happened Gauntlet 3.

Originally Posted by SkylarGuy23

I'm not sure how MTV would title this challenge without crushing a few people's souls, but a concept of great challengers vs bad challengers would be quite hilarious. Imagine Kenny having to to deal with Shavoun as his partner. :-P I'm not saying some of the "bad" contestants don't have their advantages or are completely worthless (Aneesa is a great elimination player, Casey won multiple running head to heads with Wes, Katie has actually won a challenge when some of the "good" haven't yet) but I feel casting sometimes stretches stories as well (Johnny and Camilla being exes, Camilla and Theresa being Rivals)

Kenny - Shavoun
Darell - Cameran
Evan - Katie or Priscilla
Frank - Aneesa
Tyler - Melinda
Landon - Casey

Laurel - Danny
Paula - Nate
Evelyn - Big Easy
Emily - Alex (Denver)
Diem - Tyrie
Kelly Anne - Preston

Each week the "Greats" compete in a challenge and the Guy and Girl winner can either give their pair immunity, or trade for a better partner by going into the elimination round with them. After that they play for power team, if the previous winners traded, then last place won't matter, and the power couple will chose someone to go in. Either 2 teams or three teams will go to the elimination round, but only one team leaves and goes home.

The final 3 teams do the final. The only rule is that you cannot carry your teammate on your back(to even the disadvantage the guy "greats" may use over the girl "greats"). Establish this beforehand so people are clear unlike what happened Gauntlet 3.

Is this Road Rules X-Treme Danny or Real World Austin Danny? Because if it's Austin Danny, him and Laurel would probably win easily.

Originally Posted by Nightwolf

Is this Road Rules X-Treme Danny or Real World Austin Danny? Because if it's Austin Danny, him and Laurel would probably win easily.

I was actually going with Austin, however now that you mention it, it would make sense that he would be some pretty good competition. I was kind of going with the fact that he has yet to win an elimination. A lot of the girls however would probably trade to get him on their team, so his elimination record may scare them since they'd have to go in to the head to head to keep him(?) But perhaps to give some alternatives, Danny from Xteme, Donnell from South Pacific, Mike from Las Vegas, Lacey from Austin, Brooke from Denver (how on earth did I forget her?) Colie (sorry Colie's mom!). I'm not too familiar with Real world seasons after Brooklyn, so the people not on the challenges yet may also be good options.

I kinda just want to see the really good players blow some fuses. :devil2: As frustrating as it may seem, I enjoyed watching Casey try but fail on almost every challenge on the Ruins, it shows that some of these people really aren't superhuman.

Originally Posted by SkylarGuy23

I was actually going with Austin, however now that you mention it, it would make sense that he would be some pretty good competition. I was kind of going with the fact that he has yet to win an elimination. A lot of the girls however would probably trade to get him on their team, so his elimination record may scare them since they'd have to go in to the head to head to keep him(?) But perhaps to give some alternatives, Danny from Xteme, Donnell from South Pacific, Mike from Las Vegas, Lacey from Austin, Brooke from Denver (how on earth did I forget her?) Colie (sorry Colie's mom!). I'm not too familiar with Real world seasons after Brooklyn, so the people not on the challenges yet may also be good options.

I kinda just want to see the really good players blow some fuses. :devil2: As frustrating as it may seem, I enjoyed watching Casey try but fail on almost every challenge on the Ruins, it shows that some of these people really aren't superhuman.

You're forgiven.

Cut Throat 2

Old School(Seasons 1-15) vs New School(Seasons 16-22 + FM1 & 2) vs Rookies (23-27)

Old School
1. Adam (Paris)
2. Landon (Philly)
3. MJ (Philly)
4. Mark (USA Tour)
5. Darell (Campus Crawl)
6. Ruthie (Hawaii)
7. Aneesa (Chicago)
8. Trischelle (Las Vegas)
9. Robin (San Diego)
10. Jillian (Xtreme)

New School
11. Nehemiah (Austin)
12. Wes (Austin)
13. Johnny (Key West)
14. Cohutta (Sydney)
15. Chet (Brooklyn)
16. Paula (Key West)
17. Shauvon (Sydney)
18. Devyn(Brooklyn)
19. Jonna (Cancun)
20. Laurel (Fresh Meat 2)

Rookies
21. Ty (DC)
22. Dustin (Las Vegas 2)
23. Leroy (Las Vegas 2)
24. Frank (San Diego 2)
25. Zach (San Diego 2)
26. Ashlee (New Orleans 2)
27. Jemmye (New Orleans 2)
28. Cooke (Las Vegas 2)
29. Heather (Las Vegas 2)
30. Marie (St. Thomas)