Thread: The Challenge: Create Your Own

Ive always liked this idea, but there is some problems with the cast. Pretty much all the Straight Edge guys are questionable with the exception of Evan and Cohutta and Jonna had a threesome with Pat and Ayiiia on Cancun so I guess that would put her on the LGBT team.

I definitely think this is the way to go though. We need teams that the viewers can really get behind, Gay vs Straight, Guys vs Girls, Brains vs Beauty, East Coast vs West Coast and even Black vs White although I know that one would be particular conversational.

Originally Posted by ILoveRW

Ive always liked this idea, but there is some problems with the cast. Pretty much all the Straight Edge guys are questionable with the exception of Evan and Cohutta and Jonna had a threesome with Pat and Ayiiia on Cancun so I guess that would put her on the LGBT team.

I definitely think this is the way to go though. We need teams that the viewers can really get behind, Gay vs Straight, Guys vs Girls, Brains vs Beauty, East Coast vs West Coast and even Black vs White although I know that one would be particular conversational.

My thoughts exactly when making the list! haha

I totally agree that this is the way to go for the future of the show, i.e. themed teams.

Two Ideas for Cutthroat:

Concept 1: Real World/Road Rules/Fresh Meat
Real World
Tyler
Trishelle
Frank
Emily
Cohutta
Kelly Anne
CT
Nany
Danny
Melinda

Road Rules
Derrick
Jillian
Abram
Tina
Rachel
Darrell
Adam (Quest)
Katie
Mark
Susie

Fresh Meat
Laurel
Noor
Cara Maria
Luke
Carley
Eric
Casey
Kenny
Ev
Evan


Concept 2: Winners vs Finalists vs Losers (or something more catchy :-P)
Winners (1 or 2 challenge wins)
Alton
Tyler
Evan
Nehemiah
Wes
Paula
Camilla
Coral
Katie
Susie

Alternates: Jillian, Johanna, Dunbar, Mark, Adam (Quest)

Finalists (made it to finals, never won a challenge)
CT
Adam
Luke
Leroy
Ty
Diem
Emily
Sarah
Laurel
Kelly Anne

Alternates: Jenn, Robin, Ryan, Ace, Ruthie

Losers (never made it to a final)
Eric
CJ
Zach
Trey
Frank
Beth
Kimberley
Marie
Laura
Jonna

Alternates: CJ, Brandon, Danny, Melinda, Nany (any player never casted)

The Duel 3 or some new individual concept.

If it was a Duel 3 the rules would work like this to change it up a bit and make it not so predictable

Rules: There would be 12 guys and 12 girls. They would all compete in challenges. After each challenge, each player will obtain points based on where they placed on the challenge.

Ex. First place gets 22 points, second gets 20 points, etc. and the last place person gets 0.

Now instead of this whole choosing people to be safe the last place person for each sex cumulatively will be sent into the duel. That one guy and one girl will then get to choose whoever they want to go against, except the person who won the challenge. Those players will go into the duel guy vs guy and girl vs girl. Both winners stay in the game and the losers go home. Also those winners will obtain half of the players points they just defeated. In the end there will be 2 guys and 2 girls left in the final and in some way those points will matte and help them out tremendously in the final so winning challenges is crucial. Points are cumulative so you keep them throughout the challenge and they add up.

The issue that I am not sure of though is if the winner of that days challenge is safe or if the person with the most points are safe. The reason why it's hard to determine is because sometimes the person with the most points will not win the challenge so they are now vulnerable and having the most points makes them a threat which will lead to them being chosen more for the duel. However is it fair that the person who doesn't have a lot of points but gets first place in the challenge, is still vulnerable to be chosen for the duel. I would probably go with whoever wins the challenge is safe because we all know that in mostly all challenges where it is individual or pairs the winner is safe so it would make sense to go with that. What do you think? I have no idea right now on a cast but it could be an epic battle with allstar players.

I want a challenge where the best competitors are pit against each other in elimination competitions. Here it would be a cash prize of whatever, just not split between first second and third, only first place girl and guy would get anything, hopefully eliminating any alliances. Because if its enough money and other than first place getting cash, competitors would only want weak players to stay. Thus, weekly challenge winner, power holder can choose two competitors to battle in the arena or whatever.

To make it interesting maybe have a life shield competition, like in the inferno, once a week after the nominations to be sent into the elimination are revealed. With, in case a nominated competitor wins, can send it whoever nominated him, or her, or can send in a strong competitor that threatens them.

This idea would bring into a weekly episode three challenges: the challenge, life shield, and elimination. Leaving out room from excess drama, or hopefully extending the time length of The Challenge. So with so many challenges on the table, less but the best competitors would be ideal (8) and most entertaining. Three in the final challenge. My picks would be...

Men

Landon (Philadelphia)
Brad or Derrick
Wes (Austin)
Darrell (Campus Crawl)
Mark (First Adventure)
Abram (South Pacific)
Leroy (Vegas)
Brandon (Fresh Meat 2)

Women

Camila (Spring Break)
Sarah (Brooklyn)
Melinda (Austin)
Susie (Road Rules)
Jemeye (New Orleans)
Nany (Vegas)
Aneesa (Chicago)
Kim (Hollywood)

I love thinking of thing like these hahaha. Let me know what you all think! And any ideas you may have to make it better!!

The Duel III

Male Cast:

1.) CT - RW Paris
2.) Landon - RW Philadelphia
3.) Alton - RW Las Vegas
4.) Frank - RW Las Vegas
5.) LeeRoy - RW Las Vegas 2
6.) Wes - RW Austin
7.) Derrick - RR Xtreme
8.) Johnny - RW Keywest
9.) Brad - RW San Diego
10.) Derek - RR Viewer's Revenge
11.) Chet - RW Brooklyn
12.) Theo - RR Maximum Velocity Tour

Female Cast:

1.) KellyAnne - RW Sydney
2.) Ruthie - RW Hawaii
3.) Evelyn - Fresh Meat
4.) Robin - RW San Diego
5.) Cara - RR South Pacific
6.) Jillian - RR Xtreme
7.) Rachel - RR Campus Crawl
8.) Diem - Fresh Meat
9.) Sarah - RW Brooklyn
10.) Laurel - Fresh Meat 2
11.) McKenzie - RW New Orleans 2
12.) Kendal - RR Campus Crawl

Just my personal favorite cast members based on personality and performance in the challenges. Not a list of the most elite competitors or anything.