Thread: American Idol

Originally Posted by toenails

I have no idea who Keith Urban is. And I kinda feel bad for Randy because surely he must be getting bored of this job by now.

Do you know who Nicole Kidman is?

Originally Posted by r3iKo

She's ok at best? Please tell me five females who have a better voice.

1.Christina Aguilera
2.Celine Dion
3.Cher
4.Kelly Clarkson
5.Carrie Underwood


I could name more but then we would start getting into preference. Whereas these 5 women, I believe, are technically way better singers than Mariah.

Originally Posted by TSPKM2

1.Christina Aguilera
2.Celine Dion
3.Cher
4.Kelly Clarkson
5.Carrie Underwood


I could name more but then we would start getting into preference. Whereas these 5 women, I believe, are technically way better singers than Mariah.

Yeah, but the difference with them & Mariah is Mariah Carey has a more urban appeal. She has a soul that Celine Dion, Kelly, Carrie or Cher cannot match. Christina Aguilera definitely has that soul aspect to her voice though.

Originally Posted by Nostalgic

Maybe to you but Mariah is "not the best they've had." Besides her last two album I fell she is kinda sorry. She's ok at best. I just want her to have better music.

Keith is so lame. I wanted it to be Randy, Enrique, Nicki and Mariah.

Mariah is definitely more qualified than J.Lo, Paula Abdul, Ellen, Simon, Randy, Steven Tyler though. She's a great singer, period.

Just because she is a great singer doesn't mean that she will be good at this. She is way to much of a diva. She was hired based on drama not because of her voice.

Originally Posted by TSPKM2

1.Christina Aguilera
2.Celine Dion
3.Cher
4.Kelly Clarkson
5.Carrie Underwood


I could name more but then we would start getting into preference. Whereas these 5 women, I believe, are technically way better singers than Mariah.

Kelly and Carrie are good, but not on par with Mariah. They are too generic, they have only one range in their voice.