The Island: MTV - Tonya Cooley (Spoilers) - Page 6

Dartagnan · #41 08-20-2008

Originally Posted by LivesToRun

Thanks Dart.

Your welcome LTR. I think it is a great idea. But V1 did say he chooses his wording carefully. Maybe Tonya was just the first "eliminated", but Dave was the first off the Island.

TDMEL52 · #42 08-20-2008

This is unreal, I can't believe this, MTV treats its cast like crapt, for ratings, though I love it. For once, I feel bad for Tonya, and I hope she won't be portrayed in a bad way.

Dartagnan · #43 08-21-2008

Originally Posted by TDMEL52

This is unreal, I can't believe this, MTV treats its cast like crapt, for ratings, though I love it. For once, I feel bad for Tonya, and I hope she won't be portrayed in a bad way.

I have always felt bad for Tonya. She has never had it easy on these shows. She is always around people who pick on her and who don't like her. And now it seems that it is happening again.

Int he trailer, she also said "That girl had my back when no one else did." Poor Tonya.

love_kenny · #44 08-21-2008

Originally Posted by Dartagnan

I have always felt bad for Tonya. She has never had it easy on these shows. She is always around people who pick on her and who don't like her. And now it seems that it is happening again.

Int he trailer, she also said "That girl had my back when no one else did." Poor Tonya.

Maybe someone else got eliminated like that too? It seems like this is how all the elminations work. Not that I don't feel bad for her, because it really isn't fair to have to go up against two guys.

hpkhg45 · #45 08-21-2008

I'm a little confused...

But essentially Tonya wasn't eliminated by them as a team right? Because in the about the show on MTV.com it said that 3 people go in and one person wins. Then, the other 2 are voted on who is eliminated. But V1 says it was "2 vs 1". Didn't she still have to lose in a vote off with either Abe or Kenny? Can someone explain atleast to how much we know so far?

needsalife · #46 08-21-2008

At the end of that about the show it said that it could change at anytime. Maybe there was a way for them to change that process a bit? That if two of the three wanted to team up they could.

hpkhg45 · #47 08-21-2008

Originally Posted by needsalife

At the end of that about the show it said that it could change at anytime. Maybe there was a way for them to change that process a bit? That if two of the three wanted to team up they could.

But didn't V1 say that this was the first elimination. I assume the rules stated in the About the Show are the rules that the show starts with and then changes to others later.

Dartagnan · #48 08-21-2008

Originally Posted by hpkhg45

But didn't V1 say that this was the first elimination. I assume the rules stated in the About the Show are the rules that the show starts with and then changes to others later.

The rules must change very soon. We know that Rachel was taken out by KellyAnne and Tonya by Abram and Kenny. So there is something missing we need to know. I guess we have to wait for the show.