The Island: MTV - Spoiler Discussion - Page 4

Dartagnan · #25 09-16-2008

Originally Posted by iLoVeVeVmo

ok i was looking at that in the supertease and have we ruled out colie and cohutta??? it seems painfully obvious that kelly ann is in that boat but if you look i feel that the guy is cohutta and the girl in the front is colie....maybe just me looking for someone other than the obvious but just my thoughts....

Ummm, I guess I am going to be nice and not tell you to look through the 100 pages of the old spoiler threads.

Cohutta and Colie were both eliminated, but further along the line.

**V1man** · #26 09-17-2008

Originally Posted by Dartagnan

Maybe LM. But what I meant to do was connect Robin having sailing experience with her making it far. That much I don't think is speculation.

I think the point would be that while it is logical, it is speculation unless a source in the know says that it is a fact and played a role in the decision process and/or outcome.

Dartagnan · #27 09-17-2008

Originally Posted by V1man

I think the point would be that while it is logical, it is speculation unless a source in the know says that it is a fact and played a role in the decision process and/or outcome.

True. I see what she/you meant. Maybe thats a question you, or somebody could ask her. It would be itneresting to hear what she says on that matter.

Darock1713 · #28 09-24-2008

Are we sure that Kenny and Johnny are indeed 2 of the 4, or is this that of a misdirection play by Bacchus and V1?

JoshiK · #29 09-24-2008

Did we state in this thread that Bananas and Jersey Boy win? I must've missed it.

Insider · #30 09-24-2008

Originally Posted by JoshiK

Did we state in this thread that Bananas and Jersey Boy win? I must've missed it.

Look at the very first post.

JoshiK · #31 09-24-2008

*sigh*

I knew there was a reason I didn't bother to check the first few pages of this thread.

If I were one of them, I'd see if it's permissible in the rules to take someone else's key once you reach the island...

**V1man** · #32 09-24-2008

Originally Posted by Darock1713

Are we sure that Kenny and Johnny are indeed 2 of the 4, or is this that of a misdirection play by Bacchus and V1?

As I've written before, I do know who wins and have no intention of naming any of them. Bacchus named Kenny and Johnny. I have opted to neither confirm nor deny that he is correct. Only once has a spoiler I offered been wrong (Re: Tyrie) and I corrected the info as soon as I learned that I had misunderstood my sources. My technique is to ask questions of posters to see if they have examined the possible scenarios that may play out, and to occasionally point out that they are about to jump into the deep end of the pool without knowing how to swim... It's my personal version of the Socratic Method.