The Island: MTV - Speculation

**LilysMom** · #1 08-28-2008

**** MAY CONTAIN SPOILER INFORMATION********

It has been brought up by members and I that some people might have more than 1 key and how that might play out. TJ said that it would take 4 keys to open the box, but never did he say 4 people. I myself think that if they were smart enough to catch on to this it would be the way to go!

I thought It might be appropriate to start a thread we we could all speculate what we thought, and leave the spoilers to spoilers.

LivesToRun · #2 09-11-2008

So I paused the "This Season.." teaser with 55 seconds remaining. And it shows what I believe to be one of the finished boats? But the thing is there are only 3 people (that are seen) in it. 2 girls and one guy. It's hard to make it out, but the guy looks to be Kenny. And the girls look either to be Robin and KellyAnne or Johanna. (They are both brunette for sure, but more so brown than black, so I feel Johanna is out of the picture)

Take a look, if you want, and tell me what you think. Sorry I would post a screen cap, but my button doesn't work anymore.

**V1man** · #3 09-11-2008

Originally Posted by LivesToRun

So I paused the "This Season.." teaser with 55 seconds remaining. And it shows what I believe to be one of the finished boats? But the thing is there are only 3 people (that are seen) in it. 2 girls and one guy. It's hard to make it out, but the guy looks to be Kenny. And the girls look either to be Robin and KellyAnne or Johanna. (They are both brunette for sure, but more so brown than black, so I feel Johanna is out of the picture)

Take a look, if you want, and tell me what you think. Sorry I would post a screen cap, but my button doesn't work anymore.

Is there a sail on the boat you are looking at?

LivesToRun · #4 09-11-2008

Yes..

**V1man** · #5 09-11-2008

Originally Posted by LivesToRun

Yes..

Good, so you only have to narrow it down to eight people, and you think you have identified one person.

Do you know for a fact that the boat was never occupied by people who did not sail/row to the Island? Did that make you think? (It's not an original thought with me. My wife was watching over my shoulder when I viewed the trailer and it was her instant observation.)

I've been told by more than one cast member that I'm not going to believe the ending. I'm looking forward to the adventure and how, with no teams, eight people with keys divide into the two boats.

Dartagnan · #6 09-11-2008

Originally Posted by V1man

Good, so you only have to narrow it down to eight people, and you think you have identified one person.

Do you know for a fact that the boat was never occupied by people who did not sail/row to the Island? Did that make you think? (It's not an original thought with me. My wife was watching over my shoulder when I viewed the trailer and it was her instant observation.)

I've been told by more than one cast member that I'm not going to believe the ending. I'm looking forward to the adventure and how, with no teams, eight people with keys divide into the two boats.

I actually had the same thought run across my mind V1. I was also thinking, maybe it isn't just the people who have keys and are going to the Island on the boat. Its still kinda a foggy subject, but its interesting.

Oooh, and the ending sounds even juicier. I mean ever since i found out the rules, I have been thinking, how do they split up? Do they choose the boat and the other 3 they are with now become a team that they must stay with? Are they selected a boat by TJ and the producers? Do they just choose their own boats and it has no meaning which one they end up on?

Dartagnan · #7 09-15-2008

Okay two thoughts and observations came to mind.

One is that in one of the dailies, KellyAnne tells Robin that either she wins a key or she gives up.

Spoiler!

We know she did shockingly well, so does it mean she won a key, or simply decided to stay but made it to the end.

iLoVeVeVmo · #8 09-16-2008

Originally Posted by V1man

Is there a sail on the boat you are looking at?

ok i was looking at that in the supertease and have we ruled out colie and cohutta??? it seems painfully obvious that kelly ann is in that boat but if you look i feel that the guy is cohutta and the girl in the front is colie....maybe just me looking for someone other than the obvious but just my thoughts....