The Island: Episode 3 - Discussion - Page 3

LivesToRun · #17 09-24-2008

I only started at G2, and saw only clips from older challenges. So I didn't grow into liking Rachel.

But me personally, I like the underdogs on the challenges, (ie. KellyAnne)

Dartagnan · #18 09-24-2008

Originally Posted by Insider

Ya.. she said that after Jen was listening.. Did she tell Jen she promised to vote for Kenny and Johnny over her?

Yeah, but how do you know it wasn't sincere? Sounded sincere to me. But they still keep in contact and everything today, so I don't think it is a lie.

Moonpaw · #19 09-24-2008

Originally Posted by Insider

Ya.. she said that after Jen was listening.. Did she tell Jen she promised to vote for Kenny and Johnny over her?

But did Jenn ever hear her tell Kenny and Johnny before the actual vote that she would choose them over her? As far as I saw, Jenn didn't know about the backroom deals Rachel made.

I wonder...if Rachel had been straight with Johnny and Kenny from the start, would they have voted to keep her?

And I can't believe how their "alliance" controls things. I hope Paula and Johanna know that at least one (and probably both) of them are not going to be on that boat, if Derrick and Dunbar both already have keys and, while not as deep into the alliance, are in cahoots with the other two.

**Bacchus** · #20 09-24-2008

Originally Posted by LivesToRun

I only started at G2, and saw only clips from older challenges. So I didn't grow into liking Rachel.

I liked Rachel on her Road Rules season, but once she got to the challenges I was not her biggest fan. I have always rooted for the underdog and don't like the "mean girl" mentality.

Actually, I did a quick interview with her a few years ago and she was pleasant.

Insider · #21 09-24-2008

Originally Posted by Dartagnan

Yeah, but how do you know it wasn't sincere? Sounded sincere to me. But they still keep in contact and everything today, so I don't think it is a lie.

It could have been. Something about it doesn't sit well with me. That's all.

Dartagnan · #22 09-24-2008

Originally Posted by Bacchus

I liked Rachel on her Road Rules season, but once she got to the challenges I was not her biggest fan. I have always rooted for the underdog and don't like the "mean girl" mentality.

Actually, I did a quick interview with her a few years ago and she was pleasant.

I have been talking to her over mySpace for the past 3 weeks now. She is very nice. I talked about the comment she made to Kenny about him not having a show. It was pretty funny.

I have always liked her.

So Bacchus, does this mean you don't like Coral?

I liked this episode. So far we have had three solid episodes, with three of the most disappointing eliminations.

Moonpaw · #23 09-24-2008

Originally Posted by Dartagnan

I liked this episode. So far we have had three solid episodes, with three of the most disappointing eliminations.

I'm with you on that one. I love how they edited the "Shut the F*ck up!" scene, and how they cut out the part were Ev gave away Kelly Ann's win.

**Bacchus** · #24 09-24-2008

Originally Posted by Dartagnan

So Bacchus, does this mean you don't like Coral?

Coral had her place in the scheme of things.

I just don't think Rachel offers anything these days on competitive level (made fully clear tonight) or an entertainment level (nothing she said made me even crack a smile.)

She is better off in LA hawking tee-shirts.