I agree with both of you. This is one of those times where I find a discrepancy between who SHOULD win (Cook) and who most likely WILL win (Archuletta).

But just for kicks -- here's some more motivation to call and vote for David Cook. Imagine this if you will --- Cook wins and Archuletta's Daddy Dearest loses his mind on live TV, jumps on stage, and starts to choke Simon Cowell. Paula starts to hysterically cry while Randy just yells, "Dog! Dog! Check it out!" And Ryan Seacrest, of course, laughs as he quickly segues to commercial.

Just a thought.....

LMAO, that is such a great scenario...I am going to try to remember to vote for Cook in hopes of it happening, it's just usually I don't watch, so don't know when or what number to text or call.

The only thing I don't like about David A. is that you always know what kind of song he is going to perform.... It is always going to be a slow song. He tried to do a fast song... but wasn't very successful at it. What I do like about him is his personality and he does have a really good voice.... But I agree that David C should win.

Am I the only one who doesn't like David C.??? I mean, I think he's kind of a (Daughtry wannabe)

I wouldn't say that, I like him a lot but I don't get "Daughtry" out of his performances.

I confess to not having watched an episode of Idol for nearly three seasons. Does this make me a bad person?

Nope not at all...it has kinda lost its appeal for most...I tune in when I have nothing better to do thoguh.

I agree with you Phoenix, he completley messed up his beatles number. The judges weren't even horribly mean to him, as they were to past contestants, who forgot their lines. Which leads me to believe the judges already have their winner picked. Not to mention that his Dad is a huge mistake behind the scenes, I even think the dad is the one making the song choices!! I would love to see him win, he has so much talent.

But...I would like to see some one with a little bit more diversity in their choices, and great stage presence Just like David cook. No matter what happens he is pretty much gauranteed a record deal.

I put spoilers around this for people who haven't seen the show yet.

Wow!!!!!!!!! (in the voice of flavor flav) Paula?!?!?!?!?!?
When she did that, I got so confused. I was really wondering what was going on- I thought I might have missed something. I've been thinking something hasn't been right with her for a while and I've read and heard people say that she's drunk all the time on the show. Now I'm really starting to think she's actually got some substance abuse problems and to be honest I wouldn't mind seeing her replaced.