The Challenge: This or That?

415 posts / 0 new
Last post
The Challenge: This or That?

Basically, this is a game where one member compares two things (whether it be cast members, seasons, teams, challenges, or eliminations) and the next member to comment quotes them to pick which they prefer of the two. Following this, the latter includes another comparison in their comment and the game continues.

I'll start.

Rivals 1 or Battle of the Exes 1?

Rivals 1 by default cause Exes 1 was trash

Nany or Theresa (if you chose Nany you're wrong)

Rivals 1 by default cause Exes 1 was trashNany or Theresa (if you chose Nany you're wrong)

Obivously, Queen Theresa! Shes everything in a competitor and drama! Nany is too overrated! 

X Battle or Handcuffs?

 

 X Battle or Handcuffs? 

Handcuffs because there are more rounds and it allows for people to wrestle around more.

The Duel format or Free Agents format?

rideordie95 wrote:

 X Battle or Handcuffs? 

Handcuffs because there are more rounds and it allows for people to wrestle around more.The Duel format or Free Agents format?

Free Agents format since it doesn't allow as much of an alliance on an individual game as the Duel did(especially the Duel2)

The Ruins (Champions vs Challengers) or Gauntlet 3 (Veterans vs Rookies)?

Rivals 1 by default cause Exes 1 was trashNany or Theresa (if you chose Nany you're wrong)

Nany on Battle of Seasons.

Theresa on Exes 2.

Other than that, neither.

AlwaysAMess wrote:

rideordie95 wrote: X Battle or Handcuffs? 

Handcuffs because there are more rounds and it allows for people to wrestle around more.The Duel format or Free Agents format?

Free Agents format since it doesn't allow as much of an alliance on an individual game as the Duel did(especially the Duel2)The Ruins (Champions vs Challengers) or Gauntlet 3 (Veterans vs Rookies)?

The Ruins. All day everyday. 

Kenny or Evan? 

How about Nia or Coral?

Nany or Theresa (if you chose Nany you're absolutely correct)

Fr. Who in the hell would choose that evil girl over Nany.

 

Evan.

Coral.

Casey or Jenna?

Shane or Preston?

Jamie or Vince?

nevidcm wrote:

Nany or Theresa (if you chose Nany you're absolutely correct)

Fr. Who in the hell would choose that evil girl over Nany. 

Oh no you did not just hate on Exes 1 they were both cool.

Evan.Coral.Casey or Jenna?Shane or Preston?Jamie or Vince?

Casey

Shane

Jamie

Who would you rather have on your team? 

Danny (X-treme) or Danny (Austin)

The Ruins. All day everyday. Kenny or Evan? 

kenny for sure.

most annoying couple: cara and abe or jenna and jay?

Danny X-treme

Who would you rather hook up with?

Melinda or Tina

badladjj wrote:

The Ruins. All day everyday. Kenny or Evan? 

kenny for sure.most annoying couple: cara and abe or jenna and jay?

Cara and Abe 

Who would you rather hook up with?Melinda or Tina

Easiest one. Melinda.

Would you rather listen to Cara Maria cry and whine or Paula cry and whine?

Would you rather listen to Cara Maria cry and whine or Paula cry and whine?

Paula!! I love the baby voice. 

Most Dysfunctional Couple(during their seasons):

Tony and Madison or Brian and Jenny

richjoe92 wrote:

Would you rather listen to Cara Maria cry and whine or Paula cry and whine?

Paula!! I love the baby voice. Most Dysfunctional Couple(during their seasons):Tony and Madison or Brian and Jenny

Brian and Jenny. 

Which Duel Season was better.

Duel 1 or Duel 2?

Which Duel Season was better. Duel 1 or Duel 2?

The Duel 1. I mean, it’s so obvious.

Cooke or Heather M. ?

Debut Album wrote:

Which Duel Season was better. Duel 1 or Duel 2?

The Duel 1. I mean, it’s so obvious.Cooke or Heather M. ?

Cooke. 

Battle of the Sexes 1 or Battle of the Sexes 2?

AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Which Duel Season was better. Duel 1 or Duel 2?

The Duel 1. I mean, it’s so obvious.Cooke or Heather M. ?

Cooke. Battle of the Sexes 1 or Battle of the Sexes 2?

Battle of Sexes 1. Kina or Jodi for a partner?

Debut Album wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Which Duel Season was better. Duel 1 or Duel 2?

The Duel 1. I mean, it’s so obvious.Cooke or Heather M. ?

Cooke. Battle of the Sexes 1 or Battle of the Sexes 2?

Battle of Sexes 1. Kina or Jodi for a partner?

Jodi by a longshot.

LaToya or Simone?

LaToya or Simone?

Queen LaToya! Smile

Hall Brawl or Oppenheimer?

Graphik wrote:

LaToya or Simone?

Queen LaToya! :)Hall Brawl or Oppenheimer?

Hall Brawl.

Cutthroat or The Ruins?

Cutthroat or The Ruins?

Cutthroat

Emily S. or Laurel? 

BTW: Thank you all for not letting my thread flop lmao. Smile

Debut Album wrote:

Cutthroat or The Ruins?

CutthroatEmily S. or Laurel?

Emily S. No Contest.

Battle of the Seasons(2002) or Battle of the Seasons(2012)?

AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Cutthroat or The Ruins?

CutthroatEmily S. or Laurel?

Emily S. No Contest.Battle of the Seasons(2002) or Battle of the Seasons(2012)?

BOTS 2002.

Paula or Svetlana for a partner?

Debut Album wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:

Debut Album wrote:Cutthroat or The Ruins?

CutthroatEmily S. or Laurel?

Emily S. No Contest.Battle of the Seasons(2002) or Battle of the Seasons(2012)?

BOTS 2002.Paula or Svetlana for a partner?

Svetlana. Loved her. 

Who would you rather see back?

Cara or Susie?

RobbKingo wrote:

Debut Album wrote:

AlwaysAMess wrote:
Debut Album wrote:Cutthroat or The Ruins?

CutthroatEmily S. or Laurel?

Emily S. No Contest.Battle of the Seasons(2002) or Battle of the Seasons(2012)?

BOTS 2002.Paula or Svetlana for a partner?

Svetlana. Loved her. Who would you rather see back?Cara or Susie?

Cara. Susie can stay home.

Inferno 1 or Inferno 2?

 

Pages